Stefano's Pizzeria

- 569 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444

For New Jersey locals seeking an exceptional blend of classic Italian-American cuisine, standout pizza, and truly memorable desserts, Stefano's Pizzeria in Pompton Plains is a must-visit destination. More than just a simple pizza place, Stefano's is a full-service Pizza restaurant and Dessert shop that has earned a reputation for quality and variety in the Northern New Jersey dining scene. It serves as a comfortable, cozy hub for families, groups, and solo diners looking for fresh, thoughtfully prepared meals.

Stefano's Pizzeria distinguishes itself by offering a menu that covers the breadth of Italian and American comfort food while specializing in signature items. Customers frequently highlight the impressive freshness and quality of the ingredients, a detail that elevates even simple dishes. For lunch, the "sandwiches are loaded with freshness," featuring "fresh bread, lettuce, cutlet, aioli"—making it a favorite new lunch spot for many. The extensive menu ensures that whether you’re craving a classic specialty pizza like the unique DOLCE Pizza, a refreshing FIG Salad, or a hearty main course, you’ll find a high-quality option.

One of the true highlights of Stefano's is its renown as a Dessert shop. Patrons "highly recommend" the restaurant specifically for its variety of desserts, making it the perfect choice for satisfying a sweet tooth after dinner or simply stopping in for a coffee and treat. With excellent service options including Dine-in, Curbside pickup, and No-contact delivery, Stefano's is perfectly set up to serve the fast-paced life of New Jersey residents, offering convenience without compromising on the quality and cozy atmosphere that makes dining there so enjoyable.

---

Stefano's Pizzeria is conveniently located at 569 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444. Its position right on Route 23 in Pompton Plains makes it easily accessible for residents across Pequannock Township and surrounding communities. The address is central and highly visible, providing a simple and straightforward destination for quick meals or planned dinners.

The restaurant is committed to ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests through thoughtful accessibility features. These include a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and appropriate Wheelchair accessible seating within the dining area. For those driving, finding a spot is easy thanks to the availability of a Free parking lot and On-site parking, with the added benefit of potential Free street parking nearby. This convenience allows for a stress-free experience, whether you are dining in or utilizing their popular pickup services.

---

Stefano's Pizzeria offers a wide and flexible range of services tailored to meet the needs of the busy New Jersey customer, ensuring their delicious food is available wherever and whenever you need it:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the Casual and Cozy atmosphere with comfortable Seating and Table service for Lunch and Dinner.
• Takeout: Quick and easy pickup service for all menu items.
• Delivery & No-Contact Delivery: Reliable Delivery service, including a No-contact delivery option for maximum safety and convenience.
• Curbside Pickup: Offers quick and convenient Curbside pickup for those who prefer to remain in their vehicle.
• Outdoor Seating: Available for patrons who wish to enjoy their meal outside, weather permitting.
• Catering: Extensive Catering options available for parties, family gatherings, or business events.
• Planning Ahead: Accepts reservations for planned visits, although Counter service is also available for quick orders.
• Payments: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for fast, modern transactions.

---

Stefano's Pizzeria stands out in the competitive New Jersey dining landscape due to several key features and menu specialties:

• Exceptional Desserts: A major highlight, the restaurant is known as a high-quality Dessert shop offering a wide variety, including Homeade cannoli.
• Comprehensive Menu: Far more than just pizza, the menu includes Appetizers (like Stuffed Artichoke), Salads (e.g., FIG Salad), Subs, Wraps, Soups, Pasta, Seafood, Veal, Steak, and Chicken dishes.
• Quality Ingredients: Noted by customers for using "fresh bread, lettuce, cutlet, aioli" and emphasizing the quality and freshness of all ingredients.
• Dietary Options: Offers excellent choices for diverse dietary needs, including Vegan options, Vegetarian options, and Organic dishes.
• Family-Friendly Environment: The restaurant is Good for kids, providing High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu.
• Comfort & Atmosphere: Provides a Casual and Cozy atmosphere that is also surprisingly Quiet and perfect for Solo dining or groups.
• Specialty Offerings: Serves both Comfort food and Small plates, ensuring options for light bites or hearty meals.
• Amenities: Includes a Restroom and complimentary Wi-Fi for customer convenience.

---

To place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about catering services, Stefano's Pizzeria can be reached using the following details:

Physical Address: 569 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444

Primary Phone: (973) 616-6620

---

For New Jersey users, Stefano's Pizzeria is the ideal choice when seeking a reliable, high-quality Italian meal that goes above and beyond the standard pizza fare. What makes this establishment particularly worth choosing is its dual commitment to savory, satisfying entrees and truly exceptional baked goods. It’s rare to find a Pizza restaurant that excels equally as a Dessert shop, but Stefano's pulls it off, providing the perfect solution for a complete meal and sweet finish.

The dedication to using Fresh ingredients, as noted in customer reviews of their handhelds, is a significant draw. Whether you're ordering a simple sub or a full seafood platter, patrons can expect superior quality. The availability of Vegan options and Vegetarian options ensures that Stefano's is an inclusive choice for every member of the family or group, making meal planning much easier for hosts.

The convenience offered by Stefano's also makes it stand out among local options. The full range of service options, from traditional Dine-in and Takeout to the modern necessity of Curbside pickup and No-contact delivery, demonstrates a commitment to serving the community on their terms. With its accessible location on Route 23, ample Free parking, and an environment that is both Family-friendly and suitable for a Quiet solo meal, Stefano's Pizzeria is a high-value, high-quality, and deeply appreciated local resource for great Italian cuisine in Pompton Plains, NJ.

Stefano's Pizzeria

569 NJ-23, Pompton Plains, NJ 07444, USA