Stella Maris Restaurant, Brooklyn: A Taste of Authentic Caribbean Seafood and Cuisine on Atlantic Avenue

Stella Maris Restaurant Introduce

For New Yorkers in search of an authentic and vibrant culinary experience,

Stella Maris Restaurant

stands out as a true local gem in the heart of Brooklyn. While classified as a seafood restaurant, its true identity lies in its flavorful and deeply satisfying Caribbean cuisine, particularly its Jamaican-inspired dishes and abundant seafood offerings. Located in the bustling East New York section of Brooklyn, Stella Maris—often referred to simply as "Stella's" by locals—provides a warm, casual, and inviting atmosphere where the rich, bold flavors of the Caribbean islands come alive. The restaurant has garnered a reputation as a neighborhood favorite, known for serving up generously portioned, authentically spiced meals that transport diners far from the concrete jungle.

The core of Stella Maris's appeal is its ability to seamlessly blend the fresh bounty of the sea with the robust, aromatic spices of the Caribbean, creating a menu that is both exciting and comforting. Diners appreciate the playful and creative menu, which offers a wide spectrum of traditional dishes. While the focus is heavily on island flavors, the restaurant ensures that seafood enthusiasts have an extensive selection to choose from. Popular choices range from the perfectly seasoned

Jerk Salmon

to the spectacular

Snapper Escovitch

, a classic preparation of deep-fried snapper topped with pickled vegetables. It is this dedication to authenticity and quality that has earned Stella Maris a dedicated following among Brooklyn residents looking for real West Indian food.

Beyond the seafood, Stella Maris is celebrated for its Caribbean classics. Customers frequently rave about the tenderness and flavor of the

Braised Oxtail with Lima Beans

, a dish that consistently receives high marks from reviewers for its richness. The legendary

Jerk Chicken

is a testament to the kitchen's mastery of Caribbean seasoning, often marinated overnight to ensure maximum flavor penetration. For those who enjoy the warmth of curry, the

Curry Goat Roti

and

Curry Chicken

are prepared with bone-in cuts to maximize succulence, all served alongside the essential

jasmine rice or rice and peas

. These items cement Stella Maris’s reputation as a purveyor of "authentic greater and lesser antilles cuisine," as one happy patron put it.

The atmosphere at Stella Maris is intentionally

Casual

, making it an excellent spot for everything from a family dinner to a relaxed date night. It is a place where you can feel immediately comfortable, focusing entirely on the delicious food in front of you. Customers consistently praise the food quality, noting that meals are often delivered hot and prepared nicely. Although some reviewers occasionally mention that the food can be “overpriced,” the overwhelming consensus points to the food being “absolutely delicious” and “always fresh and delicious all the time,” suggesting the quality justifies the price point for loyal patrons.

Seafood lovers will find their true calling in the restaurant's signature multi-seafood dishes. The

Stella's Seafood Pot

is an epicurean delight, featuring a generous combination of

lobster, shrimp, salmon, and mussels

simmered in a rich, flavorful seafood broth. For a shared experience, the

Jerk Bacchanal

platter allows two diners to sample a quartet of jerk-seasoned specialties: jerk chicken, jerk salmon, jerk shrimp, and jerk mussels. Other standout seafood items include

Coconut Salmon

, prepared in a tomato-based coconut sauce, and

Curry Shrimp

, providing a creamy, spiced shellfish option.

***

Location and Accessibility

Stella Maris Restaurant is conveniently located on a major thoroughfare in the East New York/Cypress Hills area of Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for residents across the borough and beyond.

The address is:

3386 Atlantic Ave #2fl, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA

Situated on Atlantic Avenue, the restaurant benefits from high visibility and excellent transportation links. New Yorkers utilizing public transport will find it is situated near subway and bus stops, with the J train line being a particularly convenient route for access. The location within the 11208 zip code positions it as a prime dining destination for the surrounding residential and commercial areas.

Services Offered

The primary service model for Stella Maris Restaurant is focused on creating an enjoyable, complete dining experience:

Dine-in Service:
Enjoy the casual and inviting atmosphere of the restaurant with attentive service.
Caribbean Specialty Drinks:
An array of homemade juices and sodas are available, including
Homemade Ginger Beer
and
Homemade Sorrel
, alongside Caribbean cocktails like the
Rum Punch
and
Old Gangalee
(must be 21 to purchase).
Brunch Service:
Offering a distinct weekend menu with breakfast-inspired Caribbean favorites like
Jamaican Breakfast
(Ackee & Saltfish) and
Jerk Chicken Hash
.
Dessert Specialties:
Classic sweet endings such as
Brioche Bread Pudding
served with a rich rum sauce, and
Banana Bread Loaf
.

Features / Highlights

What makes Stella Maris Restaurant a standout choice for Brooklyn diners:

Authentic Caribbean Cuisine:
Specializes in a wide range of Jamaican-style dishes, ensuring an authentic taste of the islands right here in New York.
Signature Seafood Selection:
A rich variety of fresh seafood preparations, including
Snapper Escovitch
,
Jerk Salmon
, and the must-try
Stella's Seafood Pot
(lobster, shrimp, salmon, and mussels).
Highly Praised Classics:
Consistently lauded customer favorites include the flavorful
Braised Oxtail with Lima Beans
,
Fried Chicken
, and
Codfish Fritters
.
Welcoming Casual Atmosphere:
The
Casual
setting provides a comfortable and relaxed environment for all guests, perfect for unwinding after a long day.
Flavorful Sides and Appetizers:
Essential Caribbean sides like
Fried Sweet Plantains
,
Rice & Peas
, and
Mac n' Cheese
that perfectly complement the main dishes.
Handcrafted Beverages:
Offerings like
Passion Fruit Lemonade
and
Homemade Ginger Beer
provide a refreshing counterpoint to the spiced food.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries about the menu, or current hours of operation, New York locals can reach Stella Maris Restaurant using the following information. Note that public phone information varies, so customers should confirm by checking current listings.

Address: 3386 Atlantic Ave #2fl, Brooklyn, NY 11208, USA

Phone Number: (Please search for the latest verified contact number for 'Stella Maris Restaurant 3386 Atlantic Ave Brooklyn NY' to ensure accuracy.)

What is Worth Choosing at Stella Maris Restaurant

Choosing Stella Maris is choosing a true culinary journey through the Caribbean right here in Brooklyn. For the ultimate dining experience, start your meal with the highly recommended

Codfish Fritters

or a soothing bowl of

Pumpkin Corn Soup

For the main course, New Yorkers looking for a quintessential Caribbean experience must try the

Braised Oxtail with Lima Beans

. It is consistently reviewed as one of the best dishes on the menu, known for its rich gravy and falling-off-the-bone tenderness. If your craving is for seafood, elevate your choice with the

Snapper Escovitch

for its incredible combination of deep-fried fish and tangy, vinegary pickled vegetables, or opt for the ultimate indulgence: the

Stella's Seafood Pot

. The combination of

lobster, shrimp, salmon, and mussels

in a flavorful broth represents the pinnacle of their seafood offerings.

To round out your plate, ensure you pair your main dish with the savory

Rice & Peas

and a side of

Fried Sweet Plantains

, a favorite among nearly all returning customers. Finish with the warm, rum-laced

Brioche Bread Pudding

and a glass of

Homemade Ginger Beer

. Stella Maris provides more than just a meal—it delivers a rich, flavorful slice of Caribbean culture in a relaxed, Brooklyn setting, making it an essential destination for any New York food lover.