Sweet Tomato Oyster Bay, NY: Your Destination for Fresh Soups, Paninis, and Healthy Eats on Long Island

Sweet Tomato Introduce

Sweet Tomato, nestled on Audrey Avenue in the historic and charming town of Oyster Bay, New York, is a premier local establishment that has carved out a unique niche in the Long Island dining scene. More than just a simple restaurant, Sweet Tomato operates as a multifaceted culinary destination, combining the best features of a health food store, a gourmet sandwich shop, and a specialist soup restaurant. This family-owned business, reportedly founded in 2004, is run by multiple generations, bringing a personal, engaging, and dedicated approach to customer service that resonates deeply with the local community.

The core philosophy of Sweet Tomato revolves around providing a wide variety of fresh, delicious, and healthy options for every meal of the day—Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner. Their menu is thoughtfully designed to cater to diverse dietary needs, featuring extensive offerings that include healthy options, organic dishes, vegan options, and vegetarian options. Whether a New Yorker is looking for a quick bite, a satisfying comfort food classic, or a nutrient-packed meal, Sweet Tomato is equipped to deliver.

The restaurant’s reputation is built on its outstanding and ever-changing selection of homemade soups. On any given day, patrons can choose from a robust list that often includes favorites like the rich Tomato Bisque Soup, classic Chicken Noodle Soup, hearty Turkey Chili (which is often gluten-free), and specialty items such as Lobster Chowder or Hungarian Mushroom Soup. This dedication to soups has made the establishment a true local specialty, especially during the cooler months on Long Island.

Beyond the soup, the menu boasts a diverse and creative array of gourmet Panini’s and Signature Wraps. The Panini selection, served hot on savory rosemary focaccia, includes unique combinations like the Paduli, the Frost Hall Panini, and the Tuscan Focaccia, each offering a satisfying mix of fresh ingredients. The Hand Helds—Signature Wraps—feature popular choices like The Oyster Bay, the Cajun Ranch, and the nutritious Grilled Veggie wrap, which is perfect for vegetarians.

Sweet Tomato also excels in catering to the health-conscious market with a vibrant array of Sensational Salads and Hot Bowls. Salad options range from the classic Caesar and Greek Salads to specialty creations like the Waldorf Salad (gluten-free) and the Valley Salad. The Hot Bowls, such as the popular Turkey Rice Bowl (Turkey Chili over brown rice) and the Greek Quinoa Bowl, provide warm, wholesome, and nutritious meal options. Furthermore, their extensive Smoothies menu features options like The Workout, The High Protein Smoothie, and The Very Skinny Smoothie, all available for customization with the Build Your Own Smoothie option.

Sweet Tomato is also a favored spot for breakfast on Long Island, serving morning classics until 11:30 AM. Their breakfast menu includes comforting items like French Toast and a variety of Pancakes (Nutella, Chocolate Chip, Oreo, Very Berry), as well as savory options such as the Breakfast Quesadilla, the Champion Wrap, and the protein-packed Power Bowl. This comprehensive menu structure allows the restaurant to serve the community throughout the day, ensuring there's always a fresh option available.

Location and Accessibility

Sweet Tomato is located in the heart of Oyster Bay, a picturesque waterfront community in Nassau County, Long Island, making it an easy-to-reach spot for local residents and visitors exploring the area.

The official address is: 91 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771.

Accessibility is a key priority at Sweet Tomato, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The establishment is well-equipped with full wheelchair accessibility, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, designated parking lot spots, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and accessible seating. For patrons driving in, the restaurant offers multiple convenient parking options, including a free parking garage, a free parking lot, and free street parking, which is a significant advantage in a busy Long Island town center.

Services Offered

Sweet Tomato provides numerous convenient services designed to accommodate all dining preferences, whether you prefer to enjoy your meal on-site or take it to go.

Outdoor seating, including a dedicated adjacent seating area, for enjoying meals in the charming Oyster Bay atmosphere. Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.
Full Dine-in service with seating available inside in a casual, cozy, and quiet atmosphere.
Takeout and Curbside Pickup options for quick and easy ordering and retrieval.
Delivery and No-contact delivery options for those who prefer to have their meals brought directly to their home or office.
Extensive Catering services, offering Family Dinner Specials like the soup and wraps package, making it easy to feed groups with high-quality, healthy food.
Full Counter service for streamlined order placement and pickup.
Dining available throughout the day: Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.

Features / Highlights

The restaurant’s distinguishing features reflect its commitment to quality, diversity, and community.

Large and Varied Daily Soup Selection, which is their local specialty, featuring classics and rotating seasonal options.
Comprehensive Menu with an emphasis on Healthy Options, including numerous Organic, Vegan, and Vegetarian dishes.
Extensive options for all dietary needs, including gluten-free items such as the Turkey Chili, and salads like the Cobb and Waldorf.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere, offering high chairs and a dedicated Kids Menu with simple, satisfying options like Turkey Sandwich and PB & J.
Diverse Customer Crowd, catering to families, solo diners, and is noted as LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace.
Generous and Convenient Parking, offering free access to both a parking garage and a parking lot, plus free street parking.
All-Day Dining, serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with a great selection of coffee and cold beverages, including Nitro Cold Brew Coffee.
Accepts various modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Contact Information

For placing orders, catering inquiries, or general questions, please contact Sweet Tomato at their Oyster Bay location:

Address: 91 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
Phone: (516) 802-5353
Mobile Phone: +1 516-802-5353

What is Worth Choosing Sweet Tomato

For Long Island residents and New York visitors, choosing Sweet Tomato in Oyster Bay offers a refreshing and reliable dining experience centered on quality ingredients and menu diversity. The restaurant addresses the modern diner's need for both comfort food and healthy, clean eating options, often within the same meal—for instance, pairing a classic Panini with a nutrient-rich Veggie Quinoa Soup. The ability to dine at a single location that seamlessly blends a soup shop, sandwich deli, and health-focused kitchen is highly valuable.

While the majority of customer feedback highlights the excellent food, the freshness of ingredients, and the convenience of service, the most compelling reason to visit is the dedication to being an accessible and inclusive local hub. The presence of numerous accommodations, from wheelchair accessibility to a variety of seating and a welcoming atmosphere for all crowds, makes it a genuine neighborhood cornerstone. For those looking for fantastic, homemade soup, a hearty panini, a custom-blended smoothie, or a satisfying healthy bowl in a friendly, local setting on Long Island, Sweet Tomato provides a quality and value proposition that is hard to beat. Its longevity in the community is a testament to its consistent delivery of great food and dedicated service.

Sweet Tomato Food & drink

Panini's
Paduli $14.70
prosciutto, turkey, mozzarella, roasted red peppers with basil & sun-dried tomato pesto
Frost Hall Panini $14.70
Fresh mozzarella, basil pesto and juicy tomato
Sicilian Panini $14.70
Marinated grilled chicken, thinly sliced prosciutto provolone, sliced tomato and sun-dried tomato pesto
Crazy $14.70
grilled chicken, mozzarella, bacon, tomato & basil pesto
Blue Panini $14.70
Grilled chicken, crumbled blue cheese, caramelized onions and dijon mustard
Tuscan Focaccia $14.70
Chicken, portabello mushrooms, sautéed onions, roasted red peppers and fresh mozzarella
Hammerhead Panini $14.70
Thinly sliced turkey with melted mozzarella, tomato and basil pesto
Rosemary Focaccia $14.70
Honey grilled chicken with melted brie and juicy tomato slices
Vegetable Panini $14.70
Vegetarian. Grilled eggplant, yellow squash, zucchini, red and green peppers, carrots and homemade mozzarella with pesto dressing
Capri $14.70
Ham, turkey, mozzarella with sun-dried pesto

Hand Helds - Signature Wraps
Turkey Muenster $13.75
Turkey, muenster cheese, lettuce, tomato and honey mustard dressing
Cajun Ranch $13.75
Cajun marinated chicken, lettuce, tomato and cheddar cheese with ranch
Soup & Half Wrap Special $16.99
With 12-oz soup from group I or II
The Cali $13.75
Sesame chicken, tomato, lettuce, bacon, avocado, melted swiss cheese and ranch.
The Port $13.75
Vegetarian. Marinated grilled portabello mushroom, tomato, roasted pepper, sautéed onions topped with mixed greens, mozzarella and drizzled with balsamic
The Vodka $13.75
Grilled chicken, penne, homemade mozzarella with ala vodka sauce
The Oyster Bay $13.75
Turkey, our mozzarella, fire-roasted peppers dressing and honey mustard dressing
Turkey Club $13.75
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato and swiss cheese
Grilled Veggie $13.75
Vegetarian. Marinated zucchini, peppers, carrots and broccoli with feta cheese
Tuna Club $13.75
Tuna salad, bacon, lettuce, tomato and swiss cheese and mayo
The Caesar $13.75
Grilled chicken, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, garlic croutons, and caesar dressing.

Smoothies
The Workout $9.75
Strawberry, banana, protein, and fat-free milk.
The High Protein Smoothie $9.75
Peanut butter, banana, chocolate protein, and fat-free milk.
Build Your Own Smoothie $9.75
Choice of 2 fruits, yogurt powder, choice of milk or juice and ice
The Very Skinny Smoothie $9.75
Banana, strawberry, fat-free yogurt, and fat-free milk.
Belly Blasting $9.75
Yogurt powder, fat-free milk, peanut butter, frozen fruit, and protein.
Healthy Breakfast $9.75
Oatmeal, banana, orange juice, milk, and honey.
Energize Me $9.75
Banana, yogurt, raw maca powder, pineapple, milk, choice of orange juice or apple juice
The Pre Workout $9.75
Protein, banana, peanut butter, oatmeal, and fat-free milk.
The Brain Booster $9.75
Banana, blueberries, apple juice, and rhodiola.
The Post Workout $9.75
Protein, banana, blueberries, yogurt powder, and fat-free milk

Breakfast
Breakfast Quesadilla $13.45
2 eggs scrambled meat, scallions, mixed cheese, pico de gallo.
French Toast (3) $12.20
3 Delicious slices of French toast with powdered sugar and syrup and butter yummy!
Nutella Pancakes $15.25
3 buttermilk pancakes topped with Nutella and powdered sugar and comes with syrup and butter yummy !
Cinnamon Raisin $12.20
3 Delicious slices of Cinnamon Raisin French toast with powdered sugar and syrup sand butter yummy !
Avocado Toast $12.75
Smashed avocado , hard boiled eggs and scallions on rye or sourdough toast
Champion Wrap $12.20
3 egg whites, scrambled steamed vegetables, chopped chicken, home fries, jalapeños on a wrap.
Chocolate Chip Pancakes $14.00
3 Delicious buttermilk pancakes sprinkled with chocolate chips and powdered sugar . They come with syrup and butter . Yummy !
Oreo Pancakes $14.00
3 buttermilk pancakes with crumbled Oreo cookies sprinkled on top and powdered sugar comes with syrup and butter yummy !
Ranchero Wrap $12.00
Two scrambled eggs with fresh tomato, mushrooms, onion, choice of bacon, ham or sausage on a wrap .(Jalapeños optional)
Avocado Toast $14.00
Smashed avocado, hard boiled eggs and scallions on rye or sourdough toast
Very Berry Pancakes $14.00
3 buttermilk pancakes with blueberries and strawberries onto with powdered sugar with syrup and butter yummy !
Hungry Man And Woman $12.00
Eggs, bacon, ham and sausage with cheese on a wrap
Who's Counting $12.00
3 scrambled egg whites, veggies, turkey, sprinkled with parmesan on a plate or a wrap.
Two Eggs $8.74
bacon, ham or sausage a roll.
Oatmeal Loaded $10.95
A Delicious bowl of oatmeal with bananas raisins brown sugar topped with hemp seeds and chia seeds
Omelettes $13.45
Served with home fries and toast.
Pancakes (3) $12.00
Plain buttermilk pancakes with syrup
Chocolate Almond $12.20
3 Delicious slices of French toast with roasted coconut and almonds sprinkled on top and powdered sugar with syrup and butter yummy !
Power Bowl $13.45
Protein infused quinoa, crumbled bacon, roast portobello mushrooms, tomato, spinach, parmesan, extra virgin olive oil, with choice of cage free egg or grilled chicken on top.
Santa Maria Burrito $13.45
2 eggs, bacon, rice, beans, cheese on a wrap.
The Waterfront $13.50
2 eggs, choice of bacon, ham or sausage with 2 pancakes.

Cold Beverages
Snapple Lemon $2.50
Iced Coffee/Tea 24o/Z $4.99
24/oz
Snapple Rasberry $2.50
Coke $2.25
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Poland Spring Sport $3.45
Snapple Diet Lemon $2.50
Diet Coke $2.00
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Snapple Peach $2.50
Snapple Peach Diet $2.50
Iced Coffee/Tea 32o/Z $5.75
32o/z
Nitro Cold Brew Coffee $6.25
10o/z
Iced Coffee/Tea 16o/Z $4.00
16o/z
Tropicana Orange Juice $3.45

Gourmet
Turkey Brie $14.75
Turkey and brie cheese with bartlett pears, mixed greens and dijon mustard
The Miami $14.00
Thinly sciced ham with melted swiss , sliced tomato . jalapeños and mayo in a wrap
Mexican Lobster Tacos $14.30
Sweet Tomato's famous lobster salad with lettuce , topped with avocado and sprinkled pico
Fish Tacos $15.00
Fried flounder with coleslaw and chipotle drizzle
Fish Sandwich $14.70
Sautéed flounder with lettuce, tomato and chipotle mayo on a wrap or kaiser roll
Greek Wrap $14.10
Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, olives, feta, peppers, greek dressing
The Roosevelt $13.20
(Salad or wrap) . Egg salad with bacon, lettuce and tomato
Chicken Salad Wrap $14.00
Our cranberry chicken salad with field greens
Veggie Hummus $14.00
Vegan. Marinated grilled veggies with garlic hummus
The Waldorf $14.70
(Salad or wrap) . Cubed chicken tossed with toasted walnuts, granny smith apple slices, celery, red grapes and mayo
Grilled Cheese Classic $13.20
Vegetarian. A favorite with tomato on rye or sourdough
Sweet Grilled Cheese Classic $12.75
Made with brie , on multi grain bread with strawberry jam
Bombay $15.49
Melted brie , sliced turkey ,with apple and walnut chutney
The Baltz $14.00
Bacon , lettuce , tomato and avocado with chipotle dressing on sour dough bread
Lobster Roll $15.95
Our famous lobster salad on a bun with mesclun
Chesapeake Crab Cake $15.95
Lettuce, tomato, onion and muenster cheese, served with horseradish on a kaiser roll
Avocado Toast $13.80
Smashed avocado , hard boiled eggs and scallions on rye or sour dough bread
Buffalo Wrap $14.00
Spicy chicken , lettuce and blue cheese

Kids Menu
Turkey Sandwich $8.75
With lettuce on white or whole wheat
PB & J $8.75
On white or whole wheat
Kids Grilled Cheese $8.75
On white or whole wheat

Cold Beverages
Nitro Cold Brew Coffee $6.25
10o/z
Snapple Peach Diet $2.50
Coke $1.85
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Iced Coffee/Tea 24o/Z $4.35
24/oz
Snapple Lemon $2.50
Iced Coffee/Tea 32o/Z $5.60
32o/z
Diet Coke $1.85
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Hals Seltzer $2.00
Snapple Rasberry $2.50
Diet Coke $1.50
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Tropicana Orange Juice $3.45
Snapple Peach $2.50
Hals Seltzer $2.50
Arizona Cold Brew $3.45
Poland Spring Water 16.9 $1.85
Snapple Diet Lemon $2.50
Iced Coffee/Tea 16o/Z $3.10
16o/z
Poland Spring Sport $3.45

Soups
Tomato Bisque Soup $9.75
Thick and creamy soup.
Split Pea Soup $9.75
Thick soup made from peas that have been dried and split.
Italian Wedding Soup $9.75
Greens and meat in a broth base.
Lobster Chowder $9.75
Thick and creamy soup.
Turkey Chili $8.75
Gluten Free
Chicken Noodle Soup $9.75
Soup that is made with chicken broth noodles and vegetables.
Veggie Quinoa Soup $9.75
Vegetarian & Gluten Free.
Caribbean Red Lentil Soup $9.75
Vegetarian & Gluten Free.
Hungarian Mushroom Soup $9.75
Hearty creamy brown mushroom soup
New England Clam Chowder Soup $9.75
A thick creamy soup.

Hot Bowls
Turkey Rice Bowl $13.95
Turkey chili over brown rice with shredded cheese, sour cream
Greek Quinoa Bowl $14.10
Chicken, tomato, cucumber, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, red onion, chopped romaine and organic quinoa
Rainbow $14.10
Chicken, corn, tomato, cucumber, brown rice drizzled with chipotle and sprinkled with organic
Brown Rice Bowl $13.75
Add chicken, turkey chili (gluten free) or veggies (Vegan). Black beans, caramelized onions, fresh pico, shredded cheese
Mykonos $14.10
Gyro meat over chopped lettuce and tomato over brown rice with tzatziki sauce

Family Dinner Special
48oz Soup $64.95
Choice of chicken noodle, split pea, veggie quinoa (vegan & gluten free), caribbean red lentil (vegan & gluten free)
(4) Wraps $64.95
Choices of the oyster Bay, turkey muenster , the cali, the caesar cajun ranch , turkey club, grilled veggie (vegetarian)
1/2 Tray Salad $64.95
Choice of caesar and house

Hot Beverages
Hot Tea Large $3.00
Coffee Medium $2.49
Hot Tea Medium $2.50
Hot Tea Small $2.00
Nitro Brew $6.25
We brew 4Jacks for twenty-one hours to achieve an exceptionally smooth, subtly sweet Nitro Cold Brew with a touch of chocolate at the finish. Coffee

Sensational Salads
Cobb Salad $13.95
Gluten Free. Organic field greens, bacon, tomato, hard-boiled egg and drizzled with avocado
Mandarin Salad $14.95
Marinated chicken, mandarin orange slices, croutons, roasted walnuts and fresh cilantro on romaine with mandarin dressing
Cove Salad $14.95
Spicy cajun chicken, chickpeas, tomato, black olives and homemade croutons on romaine with balsamic dressing
Greek Salad $12.95
Vegetarian & Gluten Free. Romaine, cucumbers, tomato, onion, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, grape leaf, feta and greek dressing
Grilled Portobello Mushroom $12.45
Vegetarian & Gluten Free. Organic field greens, grilled portobello, tomato, sweet red onion, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella with balsamic
Fajita Salad $14.95
Gluten Free. Chicken breast, sautéed peppers and onions, tomato, salsa, blended cheese and low fat yogurt
Valley Salad $13.95
Gluten Free. Balsamic grilled chicken, avocado, tomato, cucumber and roasted red peppers on organic greens with our balsamic
Ensalada Balsamica $12.95
Vegetarian & Gluten Free. Baby organic greens, fresh mozzarella, tomato, red onion, roasted red peppers, olives and our balsamic dressing
Garden Salad $12.95
Vegetarian & Gluten Free. Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers and onion with balsamic
Health Salad $14.95
Vegetarian. Corn, dried cranberries, tomato, toasted silvered almonds and gorgonzola on romaine with balsamic.
Caesar Salad $12.95
Vegetarian. Romaine, tomato wedges, garlic croutons, parmesan cheese and caesar
Lobster Salad $15.95
Scoop of our famous lobster salad over field greens with cubed tomatoes
Waldorf Salad $14.95
Gluten Free. Cubed chicken tossed with walnuts, granny smith apples, celery, grapes and mayo on organic greens

Hot Beverages
Hot Tea Medium $2.50
Hot Tea Small $2.00
Nitro Brew $6.25
We brew 4Jacks for twenty-one hours to achieve an exceptionally smooth, subtly sweet Nitro Cold Brew with a touch of chocolate at the finish. Coffee
Coffee Large $3.00

Fajitas & Quesadillas
Grilled Chicken Fajita $14.95
Grilled chicken with sautéed onions, peppers, tomato, salsa, cheddar cheese and sour cream

Sweet Tomato Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Salad bar
Small plates
Vegan options
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking garage
Free parking lot
Free street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed
Dogs allowed outside

Sweet Tomato Photos

Sweet Tomato Location

Sweet Tomato

New York Nassau County Oyster Bay Audrey Avenue

91 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA

Sweet Tomato Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 210 user reviews.

wrapbreakfastpaninipricelobster bisquebowlselectionsoups and sandwichesto gosplit pea soup

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This is a nice breakfast lunch spot in town. Not fancy. They had lots of soups that looked great. I got an egg wrap which was very good. Full breakfast and lunch menu. They stop serving breakfast at 11:30 but were kind enough to make eggs and omelettes a few minutes after. Regular iced tea, sweet tea and iced coffee available. The paninis looked fresh too. They have outdoor seating plus another adjacent seating area in front of the next building. I would go back
May 19 · aaron grotas
I called in a pickup order and when I got home, I realized they gave me the wrong wrap. I called to let them know and they were polite, told me to come back and they’d replace it. When I went back, the older woman at the counter accused me of lying and said I already got the correct wrap plus another one … which was absolutely not true. I drove back and forth twice just to be told I was trying to “get something free.” Incredibly rude and unprofessional, especially since this was my first time there. I definitely won’t be going back!
October 10 · Costanza Intranova
Sweet Tomato has a small town feel to it. I enjoyed the welcoming vibes and was greeted upon entering. The rainbow bowl had immersive flavors that were delicious upon tasting. Pretty good value for the portion size. I would recommend for some lunch and taste of Oyster Bay.
February 04 · Emeli Galvez
Adorable little place in Oyster Bay village. Very limited seating inside and avail seating outside. Large selection of wraps, paninnis, salads, soup and breakfast (in the am). Went for lunch got a egg salad wrap w bacon that was amazing. My mom got a turkey brie wrap that she loved. The people that work there are super nice and helpful. When I'm in the area again, I'll go back and try something else. Highly recommend.
August 21 · Amy Lee
Made a pit stop here to refuel with a group. The veggie panini was toasty & tasty. Took a while to come out.Iced coffee hit the spot on a warm day. Ideal rest stop for cyclists with a restroom. Outdoor seating nearby in the shade next to trees.12/29/24 update:Service has improved 👍👍.Prices are now listed on menu 🙏🏻12/31/24Great service!Jessica brought the sandwiches to us while we were seated outside. 🙏🏻
December 31 · Frugal Cyclist