Teddy's Bully Bar

- 46 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

For New York residents looking for a vibrant dining and social spot that perfectly blends classic American comfort food with a lively bar atmosphere, **Teddy's Bully Bar** in historic Oyster Bay is the destination. Situated in the town that was once home to Theodore Roosevelt's 'Summer White House' (Sagamore Hill), this establishment is a refined gastropub that celebrates the town's history with an inviting atmosphere, great eats, and specialty cocktails. It’s an ideal spot to stop by after touring the Roosevelt estate, serving as a “perfect way to wrap up the whole Teddy Roosevelt experience,” according to delighted customers.

Teddy's Bully Bar is more than just a restaurant; it’s a modern American culinary and cocktail experience. The concept of the 'Bully Bar' is inspired by Theodore Roosevelt's famous expression, "bully," meaning superb or excellent, and the menu lives up to the moniker. Guests are consistently impressed by the quality of the food—it is described as **fresh, flavorful, and absolutely hitting the spot**. The menu strikes a perfect balance between hearty, familiar American classics and refined gastropub fare, from delicious tacos and the **must-try** fish burger to high-quality raw bar selections.

Beyond the satisfying cuisine, the bar scene is a significant highlight. Teddy's boasts a **great beer selection** and **great cocktails**, with skilled staff like their fantastic bartender, Fran, mixing up a variety of delicious drinks, ensuring “every single one was a hit.” The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and trendy, designed to accommodate groups, solo diners, and families alike, often enhanced by the presence of **live music** which adds to the upbeat and friendly environment.

The combination of a beautifully designed space, **fantastic service**, and a diverse, high-quality menu makes Teddy's Bully Bar a premier choice for lunch, dinner, or just a round of happy hour drinks on Long Island's Gold Coast.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Teddy's Bully Bar is centrally located at **46 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771**. Oyster Bay is a historical and picturesque town on the North Shore of Long Island, accessible from various points across the New York metropolitan area.

This location is convenient for both local residents and visitors to historical sites in the area, such as Sagamore Hill National Historic Site. Accessibility for patrons is well-addressed, ensuring a comfortable visit for everyone:

• **Parking**: The venue offers the convenience of a **Free parking lot** as well as **Free street parking**, which is a significant amenity in a popular Long Island town.
• **Handicap Accessibility**: The establishment is fully accessible, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.
• **Transportation**: The Oyster Bay area is reachable via the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), providing an option for those commuting from Manhattan or other parts of Long Island, making the restaurant an excellent end-point for a day trip.

The location on Audrey Avenue places it near other local attractions, allowing guests to easily tie a meal at Teddy's in with other activities, such as tours of the Roosevelt estate or exploring the harbor.

---

## Services Offered

Teddy's Bully Bar offers a comprehensive range of dining and hospitality services to cater to various needs and occasions:

• **Dining Options**: Provides service for **Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert**, with ample **Table service** and **Seating** options available.
• **Bar Service**: Features a **Bar onsite** with **Hard liquor, Beer, Cocktails, and Wine**, specializing in a **Great cocktails** list and an excellent **Great beer selection**.
• **Convenience**: Offers multiple ways to enjoy the food, including **Dine-in**, **Takeout**, **Delivery**, and **No-contact delivery**.
• **Time-Sensitive Offerings**: Caters to various schedules with **Happy hour drinks**, **Happy hour food**, and **Late-night food** options.
• **Menu Variety**: Serves **Comfort food**, **Small plates**, and options for a **Quick bite**, ensuring there is something for every craving and appetite level.
• **Group Planning**: **Accepts reservations** and is a popular spot for **Groups**, with **High chairs** and a dedicated **Kids' menu** making it family-friendly.
• **Pet-Friendly**: Uniquely, **Dogs are allowed outside**, accommodating pet owners who wish to enjoy the patio space.

---

## Features / Highlights

The "bully" (excellent) features of this gastropub contribute significantly to its high reputation among New York diners:

• **Exceptional Bar Program**: The signature highlight is the robust drink menu, featuring expertly mixed classics like the **Old Fashion** and **Espresso Martini**, alongside creative fall selections like **The Bully Bramble** and **Teddy's Tea**.
• **Fresh Raw Bar**: Patrons praise the quality of the raw bar, with the **Oysters** being specifically highlighted as **fresh**. Offerings include Little Neck Clams and Oysters by the half-dozen or dozen, and unique items like **Grilled Oysters**.
• **Signature Sandwiches & Burgers**: The menu includes unique, hearty fare such as the **Bourbon BBQ Bison Burger**, the **Authentic Cuban Sandwich**, and the customer-recommended **fish burger**. Vegetarian options like the **Falafel Burger (V)** and **Vegetable Panini** are also available.
• **Fast and Friendly Service**: The service is a celebrated feature, described as **Fast service** with a **Friendly and outgoing staff**, ensuring a seamless and enjoyable experience from beginning to end.
• **Themed Atmosphere**: The sophisticated, history-inspired setting connected to Theodore Roosevelt's legacy in Oyster Bay makes the visit a unique and culturally engaging experience.
• **Live Entertainment**: The venue regularly hosts **Live music** and is an active participant in local events like the Oyster Bay Cruise Night, adding a vibrant energy to the dining experience.
• **Diverse Small Plates**: The wide array of appetizers, including **Rhode Island Calamari**, **Bully Wings**, **Mac & Cheese**, and a classic **Meat & Cheese Board**, are perfect for sharing or enjoying a quick bite.

---

## Contact Information

For New York locals planning a visit or seeking more information about the menu, events, or reservations, here is the essential contact information for Teddy's Bully Bar:

• **Address**: 46 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
• **Primary Phone**: (516) 408-5339
• **Mobile Phone**: +1 516-408-5339

Guests are encouraged to check the website or call directly for the most current live music schedule and happy hour specials before planning their visit.

---

## What Is Worth Choosing

Teddy's Bully Bar is definitively worth choosing for New Yorkers and Long Island residents who value a high-quality gastropub experience that is steeped in local history and delivers on every element of dining. You should choose this restaurant and bar because it seamlessly blends a historical, themed atmosphere with a contemporary and broadly appealing menu.

The sheer **variety and quality of the offerings** are unparalleled, making it suitable for almost any occasion. Whether you are craving light fare from the **fresh raw bar**, a hearty comfort meal like **Steak Frites** or **Shepherd's Pie**, or a gourmet sandwich like the **Authentic Cuban**, the menu delivers **fresh, flavorful** food that truly hits the spot. The dedication to quality extends to the beverage menu, which is famous for its **Great cocktails** and extensive beer list, including local specialties like Oyster Bay Brewing Co.'s Barn Rocker.

Furthermore, the experience is enhanced by the superb hospitality. The staff are described as **friendly and outgoing**, providing **fantastic service** that contributes to the venue's overall **casual, cozy, and trendy** atmosphere. With amenities like **free parking**, **live music**, and a full range of dining options from brunch to late-night food, Teddy's Bully Bar ensures every visit is convenient and memorable. It is the perfect place to gather with **Groups**, enjoy a solo lunch, or host a casual date night, making it an indispensable part of the Oyster Bay dining scene.

Teddy's Bully Bar

46 Audrey Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA