The Cookie House

- 5100 Kings Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11234

For discerning dessert lovers across New York, a trip to the Kings Plaza Mall in Brooklyn is incomplete without a stop at The Cookie House. This is not just any bakery; it is a highly-rated, specialized Cookie Shop that has earned a reputation for excellence among local patrons. For many Brooklynites, The Cookie House is more than a store—it’s a destination, with numerous customers attesting that the promise of its treats is the main reason they visit the entire mall. This strong local endorsement speaks volumes about the quality and appeal of its baked goods.

The core philosophy of The Cookie House centers on delivering delicious, high-quality, and satisfying treats with exceptional speed. The atmosphere is designed for a convenient and highly enjoyable "quick visit," perfect for shoppers and local residents grabbing a decadent snack or a dessert for home. The store is well-organized and staffed to ensure rapid service, a major highlight for New Yorkers who appreciate efficiency and minimal wait times.

The signature offering is, naturally, the cookies, which are often purchased by the pound, encouraging customers to explore the vast array of flavors available. The selection is a comforting mix of beloved classics and exciting, contemporary creations. Must-try traditional options include the perfectly baked Chocolate Chip, the deeply indulgent Double Chocolate Chip (listed at $0.00 to indicate price by weight), the hearty Oatmeal Raisin, and the richly textured Macadamia Nut and Chocolate Pecan. The shop also thoughtfully caters to various needs with delicious Sugar Free Cookies and the vibrant, classic Rainbow Cookies.

However, The Cookie House offers much more than just cookies. Its brownies are celebrated just as much as its namesake product, known for their rich, moist, and satisfying textures. Popular brownie varieties include the luxurious Cheesecake Brownie ($5.00), the nutty Pecan Brownie ($5.00), the childhood favorite Oreo Brownies ($5.99), and the dependable Chocolate Chip Brownie ($5.00). In a delightful twist, the shop also features imaginative, filled cookies such as the one-of-a-kind Peanut Butter FILLED WITH GRAPE JELLY ($5.00) and the colorful Birthday Cake FILLED WITH VANILLA AND SPRINKLES ($5.00).

Adding to the unexpected variety, The Cookie House features a comprehensive menu of soft, warm pretzels and pretzel bites. This is a perfect savory counterpoint to the sweetness, with options like the fiery Jalapeño Pretzel ($9.00), the protein-packed Pepperoni Pretzel ($9.00), and the sweet Cinnamon Pretzel ($8.00). Complementing this robust food menu is a full beverage selection, including fresh-squeezed Lemonades Fresh Squeezed ($6.99), creamy frappes like Cookies & Cream ($9.99), and refreshing slushes such as the Blue Raspberry Slush ($7.99).

Situated in one of Brooklyn’s most active shopping centers, The Cookie House benefits from a high-traffic, central location that is easy for New Yorkers to reach.

Address: 5100 Kings Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11234, USA

The store is conveniently positioned on the first level, towards the back of the Kings Plaza Mall, making it a clear landmark for shoppers seeking a high-quality treat. The facility has taken steps to ensure comfort and ease of access for all patrons:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance is provided, welcoming every member of the community to enjoy their famous desserts.

Given its location inside the mall, ample public parking is typically available for those driving to the location.

The Cookie House is designed to accommodate the fast-paced life of its New York customers through multiple streamlined service options.

• In-store Shopping: Encourages customers to personally select and purchase a custom assortment of cookies by the pound.
• Takeout: Efficient service for grab-and-go orders, whether for a quick snack or desserts for a gathering at home.
• Delivery: Offering the ultimate convenience of receiving your favorite cookies, brownies, and pretzels without leaving your door.
• Specialty Desserts and Coffee: Focusing on Dessert as its primary dining option, the shop also offers a selection of Coffee to pair perfectly with its baked goods.
• Flexible Payments: Accepts modern and traditional payment methods for a smooth transaction, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Retail Accessories: The availability of the Cookie House Reusable Bag ($1.99) allows customers to easily transport their purchases and promote sustainability.

Beyond its core products, several key features contribute to The Cookie House's standing as a highly regarded local business.

• Cookies Sold by the Pound: This unique retail model allows customers maximum flexibility, enabling them to curate a perfect selection of flavors at a competitive price point.
• Gourmet Brownie Selection: The extensive variety of brownies, from Cheesecake Brownie to Pecan Brownie, offers an alternative indulgence for those who prefer fudge and cakey textures.
• Diverse Pretzel Menu: The addition of fresh, hot pretzels—ranging from plain and salted to unique options like Almond Pretzel ($9.00) and the classic Pretzel Dog ($8.00)—makes it a versatile snack destination.
• Seasonal & Gifting Items: The regular release of holiday-specific items like the HOLIDAY COOKIE TIN ($40.00) and themed platters for Mother’s Day and Valentine’s Day makes the shop a reliable source for gifting.
• Exceptional Speed and Service: Highlighted by customers, the Fast service provided by the well-managed staff ensures that even during busy times, the wait is minimal.
• Creative Beverages: The robust drink menu, featuring specialty frappes and slushes, positions it as a complete refreshment stop in addition to a dessert provider.

For general questions, details on large custom orders, or current holiday specials, New York customers are encouraged to reach out directly to the store.

Address: 5100 Kings Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11234, USA
Phone: (718) 252-6483

The Cookie House is unequivocally worth choosing for any New Yorker in the vicinity of Kings Plaza for a few compelling reasons. First and foremost is the undisputed quality of their primary product—the cookies. Customer reviews consistently highlight them as the "best," signifying a level of taste and freshness that rises above generic mall offerings. The unique ability to mix and match your preferred flavors and purchase them by the pound provides an excellent customized value proposition that a pre-packaged box cannot match.

Secondly, the store's dedication to variety ensures there is a treat for every craving. Whether you desire a savory, warm Salt Pretzel ($8.00), a refreshing Mocha Chocolate Frappe ($9.99), or a celebratory Birthday Cake FILLED WITH VANILLA AND SPRINKLES cookie, The Cookie House is a one-stop shop. This versatile menu, combined with the fast and efficient service, makes it an ideal spot for satisfying sudden cravings, picking up a quick dessert on the way home, or gathering a stunning platter of treats for an unexpected party. For the best cookies and a diverse, high-quality snack menu in the Kings Plaza area of Brooklyn, The Cookie House is the definitive choice.

The Cookie House

5100 Kings Plz, Brooklyn, NY 11234, USA