Experience an Authentic Irish Pub at The Perfect Pint in NYC

The Perfect Pint Introduce

In the vibrant and fast-paced landscape of Midtown Manhattan, The Perfect Pint stands out as a genuine Irish pub offering a welcoming and authentic atmosphere. Located just steps from the bright lights of Broadway, this multi-level establishment is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike who are looking for a true pub experience without the typical Times Square chaos. With its classic dark wood interiors, warm decor, and a wide array of beers on tap, The Perfect Pint successfully transports you to a cozy, traditional Irish setting. It's a place where you can find a comfortable nook to relax with friends, catch the big game on one of the many large-screen TVs, or simply enjoy a quiet moment with a pint of your favorite brew.

The pub is particularly well-regarded for its traditional fare and impressive drink selection. A customer review highlighted the "great food" and "good enough" drinks, pointing to the overall positive experience. The atmosphere is often described as a trip back in time "in the best way possible," suggesting a classic charm that is hard to find in modern establishments. While there have been a few negative reviews, particularly concerning service, the positive feedback on the food, drinks, and unique atmosphere indicates that for many, the overall experience is one worth having. The rooftop bar is a notable highlight, offering a unique setting to enjoy the city's energy from above.

Location and Accessibility

The Perfect Pint is centrally located at 123 West 45th Street, nestled between 6th Avenue and Broadway. This prime location in the heart of Midtown West makes it incredibly accessible and a perfect meeting spot for any occasion. It is just a short walk from major transportation hubs like Times Square-42nd Street, which serves the N, Q, R, W, S, 1, 2, 3, 7, and A, C, E subway lines. This makes it a convenient stop for a pre-theater dinner, a post-work happy hour, or a weekend outing with friends. Its proximity to countless office buildings, hotels, and attractions ensures a steady stream of patrons, contributing to the lively atmosphere. For those visiting from out of town, its central location makes it an easy find and a quintessential New York City experience.

The pub's multi-level structure is also a key part of its accessibility and appeal. While the ground floor offers a traditional bar setting, the upper floors and especially the rooftop provide different vibes to suit different moods. The rooftop bar, which is a major draw, is an experience in itself, offering a chance to escape the street-level crowds and enjoy the open air, weather permitting. This variety of spaces ensures that you can find the right spot whether you are looking for a bustling environment or something more laid-back.

Services Offered

Full Bar Service: The Perfect Pint boasts an impressive selection of over 40 beers on tap, including a variety of local, domestic, and international brews. The menu also features a wide array of cocktails and other spirits to suit every preference.
Dine-In and Takeout: The pub offers a full menu of hearty Irish and American pub fare. Whether you want to sit down for a meal or grab something to go, their kitchen is ready to serve.
Event Hosting: With its three floors, The Perfect Pint is an ideal venue for private events. It can accommodate parties ranging from 15 to 350 people, making it a great choice for happy hours, business functions, family gatherings, and alumni reunions.
Sports Viewing: The pub is a popular destination for sports fans, with large TV screens strategically placed throughout the venue, showing every major sporting event.
Outdoor Rooftop Seating: The unique rooftop bar is a major highlight, offering a rare outdoor dining and drinking experience in Midtown Manhattan, with a view of the street below.

Features / Highlights

Authentic Irish Pub Atmosphere: The interior is designed to mimic a classic Irish pub, with dark wood, gold lettering, and beer-themed decor. The overall vibe is cozy and traditional, providing a comfortable and inviting setting.
The Rooftop Bar: This is arguably the most unique feature of The Perfect Pint. It offers a great way to enjoy the bustling city from a peaceful, elevated vantage point. Even without a traditional skyline view, the "interesting" atmosphere is a major plus for patrons looking for a different kind of experience.
Extensive Beer Selection: With a rotating selection of more than 40 beers on tap, there is always something new to try. The variety ensures that every beer lover, from those who prefer classic lagers to those who seek out craft IPAs, will find something to enjoy.
Hearty Pub Food: The menu features classic pub staples like Harp Fish and Chips, Bangers and Mash, and Shepherd's Pie. These dishes are consistently praised for their quality and flavor, providing a satisfying complement to the drinks.
Versatile Spaces: The pub's multi-level layout allows it to cater to different needs and crowds. The ground floor can be a lively bar scene, while the upper floors and rooftop can be more relaxed, providing options for everyone.

Contact Information

Address: 123 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (212) 354-1099

What is Worth Choosing?

Choosing The Perfect Pint for your next outing in New York City means opting for a pub that offers more than just a drink. It's a place that provides a classic, comfortable, and lively experience in one of the city's most exciting neighborhoods. The pub's a great choice for its unique rooftop, which offers a different kind of urban escape, and its commitment to offering a wide variety of both food and drinks. While some customer experiences have been less than perfect, the positive feedback on the atmosphere, food, and the overall "can't miss" potential of the place suggests that it's a worthwhile destination. The combination of a traditional Irish ambiance, a large and varied selection of beers, and a location that can't be beaten makes The Perfect Pint a solid choice for a night out in Midtown. It’s a place that, despite any issues, still manages to captivate and charm its guests, making it a memorable spot for a drink or a meal.

The Perfect Pint Photos

The Perfect Pint Location

The Perfect Pint

New York New York County New York West 45th Street

123 W 45th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

The Perfect Pint Reviews

We’ve been loyal patrons of The Perfect Pint in Midtown East for some time, which led us to try their Midtown West location. On this occasion, the three of us arrived just after 6 PM for beers and fries, ordering a total of 15 or 16 beers. When the bill arrived, the waitress presented us with a charge for 21 beers. The receipt was not itemized, and when we requested a detailed breakdown, she falsely claimed we ordered more, including asserting that I had two Delirium Tremens when I only ordered one (evidence of this is in the attached video and photos l). Her response escalated to threats when we pressed for clarification.We simply wanted an accurate, itemized account of our order, not fabricated charges.The manager, Ernesto, intervened but only compounded the issue. He first falsely stated we had been there since 3 PM, which we corrected, then insisted that a typical person consumes two beers per hour, a baseless assertion that didn’t align with our consumption. He then again refused to provide an itemized receipt, claiming that it is too much work to keep track of what beers everyone drinks(an illegal practice)We captured this exchange on video - see the attached footage, along with photos and our bill.Ultimately, to avoid further confrontation, we paid the inflated total, which added approximately $20 per person to our bill, but it left us deeply unsettled.This was not a simple mistake - it felt like deliberate overcharging, supported by lies and intimidation.We will be uploading additional video evidence showing the waitress’s condescending and potentially racist demeanor, as well as her conversation with the manager, both of whom seemed complicit in this practice. We intend to dispute the charge with our credit card companies and urge others to approach this location with caution.The Perfect Pint in Midtown West appears to engage in deceptive and possibly criminal practices, preying on customers who trust they’ll be billed fairly. Save yourself the trouble and steer clear.
March 23 · Sasha
This was a really cool Irish Bar, situated right in the middle of downtown Manhattan. We sat on the rooftop, which despite not having a great view, was very interesting! The food was great, the drinks were good enough, and the staff was alright. This restaurant took me back in time a little bit, which I mean in the best way possible. If they can get the service part down a little bit better, it'd be a can't miss place! Would recommend.
October 11 · John Doe
While on vacation in NYC, we ate dinner at The Perfect Pint in Times Square. This is a really cool Irish Pub with three floors. We went to the third floor, and we were lucky to have Freddy as our server. He was fun and gave us great service. My son and I split the Reuben and the Cheese Steak. They were both so good, and the fries were outstanding. My daughter had the Portobello sandwich, and she said it was very good. The Perfect Pint also has a fantastic selection of beer on tap. If you are in Times Square, this is a good place to eat and have a few beers.
July 20 · Jim Secker
Good basic, solid Irish pub in Midtown near Grand Central Station. Food is OK but very pricey. I’d walk two blocks to Malones for good Irish pub fare. A local standby and an enjoyable place to come in and get a beer. Bartenders are efficient and that’s about all..
August 12 · John Mason
We ate on the fourth floor and we enjoyed our experience. They were one of the few restaurants with room, as they had many floors of seating. The food was cheaper than most places and they've got most of the usual drink options.
January 04 · Isaac Archuleta