Utica Pie Co.

- 594 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains, NY 10605

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in the Westchester area searching for a genuinely unique pizza experience, Utica Pie Co. on Mamaroneck Avenue in White Plains stands out as a must-try local spot. While the New York metropolitan area boasts a variety of traditional pizza styles, this establishment brings a distinct flavor profile and style that originates further upstate in New York—specifically, the Utica region. It is a welcoming and casual pizza restaurant that has quickly become a local favorite, known not just for its pies but for fast, friendly service and a full menu of comfort food and traditional Upstate New York specialties.

Utica Pie Co. expertly bridges the gap between classic regional styles, offering options ranging from a crisp thin crust to a more substantial deep crust. The star of the show for many patrons is the famous ‘Upside Down Pie,’ a unique creation where the rich, house-made sauce is layered over the cheese, offering a taste experience that is both unconventional and deeply satisfying. This commitment to traditional regional techniques and quality ingredients is evident in every dish, from their signature pizzas to the widely praised Utica Style Greens and savory wings.

Whether you are looking for a quick bite for solo dining, a relaxed dinner for the family, or a catered meal for an event, Utica Pie Co. provides a professional yet family-friendly atmosphere that makes every visit a pleasant experience. It’s a place where both new and regular customers, affectionately known as 'Locals,' feel right at home.

Location and Accessibility

Utica Pie Co. is conveniently located at 594 Mamaroneck Ave in the heart of White Plains, NY 10605, USA. This highly accessible location in Westchester County makes it an easy destination for residents and visitors alike. White Plains is a central hub in the region, providing straightforward access via major roadways, making it a simple trip from various surrounding towns and neighborhoods. For those relying on public transportation, the Mamaroneck Avenue corridor is well-served, putting this top-rated pizza restaurant within easy reach.

The restaurant prides itself on prioritizing customer accessibility. Notably, the establishment features a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all community members can comfortably visit and enjoy their meal. The bustling location and the availability of multiple service options mean that whether you are stopping by for a dine-in experience or a swift pickup, the location is designed to accommodate a seamless and efficient transaction, reflecting their commitment to ‘Fast service.’

Services Offered

The services provided by Utica Pie Co. are designed to be flexible and convenient for the busy New York lifestyle, catering to various dining preferences and current needs. The comprehensive list of options includes:

• Dine-in: Available seating for a casual, enjoyable meal in a family-friendly atmosphere.
• Takeout: Fast and efficient service for customers picking up orders to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Delivery: Reliable service to bring their signature pizzas and full menu directly to your door.
• No-contact delivery: An option for maximum safety and convenience, allowing for contactless drop-off.
• Curbside pickup: A convenient alternative to traditional takeout, minimizing time spent inside the premises.
• Catering: Providing options for larger orders and events, including popular items like the large pies and wings.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, making it easier to plan a guaranteed dinner, although they are noted as ‘Reservations required’ for certain times or parties, so calling ahead is recommended.

Features / Highlights

Utica Pie Co. distinguishes itself in the competitive Westchester dining scene through a variety of unique offerings and customer-focused features that elevate the overall experience:

• Signature ‘Upside Down’ Pizza: A unique specialty pie where the sauce is layered on top of the cheese, offering a distinct flavor and texture profile, often available in both small and large sizes.
• Variety of Crusts: Patrons can choose between the classic thin crust and a deep crust option, satisfying a range of textural preferences.
• Upstate Comfort Food: The menu extends beyond pizza to include regional favorites such as the renowned 'Utica Greens' (escarole sautéed with oil, garlic, and prosciutto/salami) and generous portions of 'Chicken Riggies' (rigatoni pasta with chicken and peppers in a savory cream and tomato sauce).
• Fast Service: A key highlight for busy individuals and families, ensuring minimal wait times for orders.
• Comprehensive Offerings: The full menu includes pizza, specialty pies, buffalo wings, various sides like garlic cheese bread and garlic knots, subs, salads, and dinner items, providing a complete meal solution.
• Drinks & Libations: The restaurant offers Alcohol, Beer (including mentions of unique upstate brews), and Wine, perfect for pairing with a classic pie.
• Amenity and Atmosphere: Provides complimentary Wi-Fi and maintains a Casual, Family-friendly environment, and also allows ‘Dogs allowed outside’ for outdoor seating.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Ideal for Dinner and Solo Dining: The atmosphere and service model make it a great choice for both a planned dinner with friends or a simple, quick meal alone.

Contact Information

For placing an order, making a reservation, or inquiring about catering, you can reach Utica Pie Co. at the following contact points:

Address: 594 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains, NY 10605, USA

Phone: (914) 948-5600

Mobile Phone: +1 914-948-5600

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Utica Pie Co. is an excellent decision for New Yorkers looking to explore a style of pizza that is distinct from the typical slice shop fare. What truly makes this restaurant worth choosing is the combination of its unique regional focus and its commitment to quality and service. The establishment successfully delivers an authentic taste of Upstate New York, which is a significant draw in the Downstate area. Customers consistently rave about the unique cheese blend used on their traditional pies, describing it as 'absolutely wonderful,' and they highly recommend trying both the thin crust and the substantial deep crust variations to experience the full range of what the restaurant offers.

The ‘Upside Down Pie’ is arguably the centerpiece of the menu—a rich, flavorful experience that, according to satisfied patrons, holds up even as leftovers. Beyond the pizza, the inclusion of authentic regional dishes like Utica Greens and large, varied wings solidify its standing as a superior comfort food destination. With its reliable fast service, multiple convenient service options (delivery, takeout, curbside pickup), and a welcoming, casual setting that is perfect for families and locals, Utica Pie Co. is more than just a pizza joint; it’s a dedicated purveyor of high-quality New York regional cuisine right here in Westchester.

Utica Pie Co.

594 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains, NY 10605, USA