Yella's

- 1103 Goffle Rd, Hawthorne, NJ 07506

If you're looking for an authentic taste of American classics delivered with New Jersey flair, look no further than Yella's in Hawthorne. More than just a sandwich shop or burger joint, Yella's is a family-owned establishment built on generations of food industry experience, offering high-quality, hand-crafted food in a fun, nostalgic atmosphere. It's a place where every meal is designed to be "food worth screaming about," a motto that honors the owner's grandfather, Frank, whose nickname "Yella" came from his days as a spirited dance caller in the 1930s and 40s.

Yella's has established itself as a local favorite, blending the comfort of old-school deli classics with modern, gourmet takes on burgers and chicken sandwiches. Their commitment is simple: exceptional quality, fresh ingredients, and friendly, family-focused service that makes every customer feel welcome.

—

The family story behind Yella's dates back to 1967 when the family first entered the food industry as a deli meat and cheese distributor. This long-standing commitment to quality ingredients is evident in every item on the menu. From the generously portioned sandwiches named after family members to the famous hand-spun milkshakes, Yella's delivers a meal experience that is both satisfying and memorable. The restaurant has successfully cultivated a local following in New Jersey, with its Hawthorne location becoming a go-to spot for both quick lunches and family dinners.

—

Yella's has a particularly strong connection to the local community, as evidenced by glowing customer testimonials. One review highlights the business's exceptional community spirit, recounting a visit to a local school to lead a free "sandwich lesson" for students with special needs. The customer noted, "The staff are consistently kind, patient, and welcoming, and our students always enjoy the delicious sandwiches." Finding a local business dedicated to giving back and making meaningful connections is a rare and wonderful thing, and Yella's clearly strives to be that kind of partner to the New Jersey community.

—

The atmosphere itself is a key part of the Yella's experience. It’s often described as a mix of old-school retro with a modern twist, evoking the fun and energy of a classic 50's diner. The dining area is clean, spacious, and features an open-concept assembly line where you can watch your food being prepared fresh. The decor is designed to be inviting and photo-worthy, complete with real family photos of 'Grandpa Yella' and those who inspired the signature sandwich names, adding a layer of personal charm and nostalgia to your visit.

—

Another customer review mentioned driving by countless times without realizing the gem hidden within, only to be drawn in by an Instagram post about the milkshakes. This speaks volumes about the quality of the food—it looks and smells so great that even a simple stop for a shake can leave you "very tempted to order their loaded fries" for next time. Yella's is a delightful local discovery that turns first-time visitors into enthusiastic regulars.

—

Location and Accessibility

Yella's is conveniently located in Passaic County, making it an easy stop for residents and visitors throughout the North Jersey area. Its prime spot is ideal for a quick takeout order, a comfortable dine-in meal, or an easy pick-up for a catering order for your next local event.

Contact Information

P 1103 Goffle Rd, Hawthorne, NJ 07506, USA

P Phone: (973) 840-2279

—

Services Offered

• Dine-In Service: The restaurant offers a comfortable, clean, and spacious dining area with a classic, retro-inspired atmosphere that seats around 25 guests.
• Takeout: All menu options are family-friendly and easily portable for grabbing a bite to go.
• Delivery: Yella's partners with various delivery services to bring their food right to your door in the Hawthorne area and surrounding communities.
• Catering: They offer extensive catering options perfect for events of any size, including Sandwich Platters, Burger/Chicken Platters, Jumbo Wings & Tenders Boxes, and custom Boxed Lunches for individual meals.
• Special Accommodations: They accept reservations and offer both Gluten-free and Vegetarian options, and can make most menu items suitable for these preferences.

—

Features / Highlights

• Signature Sandwiches and Subs: The menu features unique hot and cold deli sandwiches and subs, many of which are named after family members and people from the old neighborhood, such as the famous The Uncle Charlie (a take on the New Jersey sloppy Joe) and The Yella Submarine (prosciuttini, hot ham, salami, provolone).
• Gourmet Burgers: Hand-crafted burgers use Yella's signature blend, with popular options like the Jersey Smash (shaved sweet onions, white American cheese, pickles, secret sauce) and the Cowboy Burger (double patties, bacon, cheddar, onion rings, banana peppers, BBQ sauce).
• Legendary Milkshakes: Their hand-spun milkshakes are a true highlight. They blend high-quality ice cream and natural syrups, with signature varieties like Chocolate Chip Brownie and sometimes feature a whole cannoli or brownie on top, making them highly Instagram-worthy.
• Commitment to Quality: Everything is made from scratch and in-house, using only the best natural, high-quality ingredients, ensuring that everything is 100% fresh and delicious.
• Jumbo Wings & Tenders: Crispy, jumbo-sized wings and hand-breaded tenders are available in six flavors: Plain, Buffalo, Nashville Hot, Sweet BBQ, Garlic Parmesan, or Lemon Pepper Dry Rub.

—

What is Worth Choosing

When you visit Yella's, you're choosing an American classic experience rooted in family tradition and a genuine dedication to quality. The menu is diverse enough to satisfy any craving, but a few items consistently stand out for those looking for a truly authentic Yella's experience. You absolutely must try one of their signature, over-the-top Hand-Spun Milkshakes—they are the perfect end to any meal and a major draw for the local community. For the sandwich aficionado, the Hot Pastrami with Swiss cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on sliced rye is highly recommended for its classic deli flavor, or try one of the hot subs like The Benny Brown, featuring sliced steak, sautéed onions, fresh mozzarella, and rich brown gravy. Their side game is strong, too; the Loaded Fries (crispy fries topped with cheddar cheese sauce, gravy, crumbled bacon, and banana peppers) and their crispy Onion Rings are consistently praised by locals. Choosing Yella's means choosing a place where every item, from the "Nuclear Sub" to the "Crispy Chicken Sandwich," is prepared with pride, ensuring a meal that is, without a doubt, food worth screaming about.

Yella's

1103 Goffle Rd, Hawthorne, NJ 07506, USA