Autentico

- 124 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

For New Yorkers seeking an authentic, memorable Italian dining experience without venturing into the city's hustle, look no further than Autentico in charming Oyster Bay, Long Island. This highly-regarded Italian restaurant has carved out a reputation for delivering exceptional cuisine that honors traditional Sicilian and Italian roots while embracing the freshness of local, seasonal ingredients.

Autentico, true to its name, aims to provide more than just a meal; it promises an authentic experience. Many patrons find themselves consistently "blown away" by the chef's dedication to originality, flavor, and beautiful presentation. It’s a place where you come to savor the food, the company, and the time spent, making it a perfect spot for celebrating special occasions, a delightful date night, or simply elevating a regular evening out with a truly memorable dinner.

The culinary philosophy at Autentico revolves around a commitment to farm-fresh, locally sourced ingredients. The menu is intentionally designed to change frequently, keeping in perfect synchronicity with the season and ensuring that every visit offers a chance to explore new, creative interpretations of Mediterranean-inspired Italian cuisine. This commitment to freshness and seasonality is a cornerstone of the dining experience, distinguishing Autentico from more static Italian menus across the New York region.

One dish that transcends the seasonal menu changes and garners consistent praise is the renowned Legendary Bolognese. This dish is frequently cited by patrons as a must-try, never failing to delight with its rich, deep flavors. Beyond the legendary pasta, the menu consistently showcases mastery, featuring dishes that customers rave about, such as branzino, spaghetti vongole, and unique appetizers like vegan zucchini polpette and eggplant parmigiana.

The attention to detail extends seamlessly into the dessert menu, which is often described as "fabulous" and visually stunning. Diners can complete their experience with treats like chocolate torte, raspberry tart, biscotti, and a truly unique item: the sfinci donut. Sfinci are traditional Sicilian fried ricotta donuts, often light and airy, providing a perfect sweet end to an authentic Italian meal.

Location and Accessibility

Autentico is conveniently located in the heart of Oyster Bay, offering a desirable Long Island destination for New York residents. Its address is 124 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771. The location provides a picturesque setting that complements the cozy and romantic interior ambiance, making the journey worthwhile for those seeking an escape from the city’s concrete landscape.

Accessibility is thoughtfully addressed, ensuring a comfortable experience for all guests:

• The premises include a wheelchair accessible restroom, demonstrating a commitment to customer comfort and convenience.
• Wheelchair accessible seating is provided to accommodate patrons who require it.
• For those driving, free street parking is available, which is a welcome amenity in the often-busy Long Island area.

Services Offered

Autentico provides a comprehensive range of service options designed for maximum flexibility and convenience, catering to various customer needs whether they wish to dine in or enjoy the cuisine at home:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the full, authentic experience with table service in a casual, cozy, and romantic atmosphere.
• Outdoor Seating: Perfect for warm evenings, the outdoor seating option allows patrons to enjoy their meal in the pleasant Oyster Bay environment.
• Takeout: Meals can be prepared for convenient pickup.
• Curbside Pickup: An efficient service allowing customers to retrieve their order without leaving their vehicle.
• Dinner Reservations: Reservations are accepted and recommended, especially given the restaurant’s popularity, to secure a table for your authentic dining experience.
• Private Events: While not explicitly detailed in the provided information, the ambiance and reputation suggest suitability for special, smaller private gatherings, though direct inquiry would be needed.

Features / Highlights

The following highlights solidify Autentico's status as a premier Italian dining spot in the New York metropolitan area:

• Great Wine List: A curated selection of wines is available to perfectly complement the Mediterranean-inspired Italian menu, enhancing the overall fine dining experience.
• Great Dessert: The dessert menu is a particular point of praise, known for being delicious and beautifully presented, featuring items like the highly-rated sfinci donut.
• Seasonal and Original Menu: The menu changes to reflect the freshest seasonal ingredients, showcasing the chef's creativity and commitment to authentic, quality cuisine.
• Atmosphere: The ambiance is described as a trifecta of casual, cozy, and romantic, making it suitable for both intimate dinners and relaxed gatherings.
• Offerings: The menu is diverse, including a full bar with alcohol, beer, and wine, alongside options for coffee, comforting food, and healthy selections.
• Crowd: The restaurant successfully attracts a mix of both appreciative locals and discerning tourists, suggesting broad appeal and consistent quality.

Contact Information

For New York residents planning a visit, here is the essential contact and location information:

• Address: 124 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771
• Phone: (516) 922-2212
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-922-2212
• Parking: Free street parking is available.
• Payments: The restaurant accepts Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for convenience.

What is Worth Choosing Autentico?

Autentico offers New York area residents a compelling reason to make the trip to Oyster Bay. It stands out by merging authentic, high-quality Italian cuisine—often with a Sicilian influence—with a dedicated, personalized service experience. The restaurant is not simply a place to eat; it’s an opportunity to truly “savor” the moment, as one customer eloquently put it. The chef’s dedication to a seasonal menu means that the food is always fresh, inventive, and tailored to the optimal ingredients available, ensuring repeat visits are always exciting.

For those looking to impress a date, celebrate a milestone, or simply treat themselves to comfort food executed with mastery, Autentico consistently delivers. The combination of its romantic, cozy atmosphere, the professional and courteous staff, the outstanding Legendary Bolognese, the deep wine selection, and the celebrated desserts—all accessible with convenient payment and parking options—make Autentico a top-tier choice for Italian dining on Long Island.

The fact that dinner reservations are recommended speaks to its popularity. If you are looking for an authentic and memorable Italian dinner, perhaps including a glass of fine wine and a signature sfinci donut for dessert, Autentico promises to provide an experience that is truly unforgettable.

Autentico

124 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA