Bagelicious Cafe

- 1026 Broadway, Thornwood, NY 10594

For Westchester County locals and New York-area bagel aficionados, finding that perfect, fresh, chewy bagel is a daily quest. Bagelicious Cafe, situated right in Thornwood, stands as a highly-regarded and long-standing answer to that search. This is not just a place for a quick bite; it is a quintessential New York bagel shop that prides itself on delivering high-quality, authentic boiled bagels, generously portioned sandwiches, and great value. As one customer noted, the quality remains "just as amazing" even after years away, a testament to the consistency that busy New Yorkers rely on.

Bagelicious Cafe operates as a full-service bagel shop and deli, focusing on all-day breakfast options and a vast selection of homemade spreads, fresh deli meats, and pre-prepared salads. The atmosphere is casual and often bustling—a sure sign of fresh food and fantastic prices. Whether you're in a hurry to grab a coffee and a bagel for your commute or you have time to sit down for a hearty breakfast sandwich, Bagelicious Cafe offers a welcoming environment where the quality of the food speaks for itself. The popularity of the shop means it is often packed, but for many, the great taste and excellent value are well worth the hustle and bustle.

Bagelicious Cafe is conveniently located at 1026 Broadway, Thornwood, NY 10594, USA, making it a central and easily accessible hub for the Thornwood community and surrounding Westchester towns like Pleasantville. The location on Broadway (Route 141) is excellent for both local traffic and those running errands nearby.

Recognizing the needs of its diverse clientele, the shop offers solid accessibility features:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance for easy entry and exit.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot, eliminating the stress of finding convenient parking.
• Free parking lot, a major convenience for customers driving to pick up their orders.

The store is designed for a quick visit, ensuring efficiency even when busy. The operating hours for their famous breakfast sandwiches run everyday from 6:00 am to 1:30 pm, providing a wide window to enjoy their extensive morning menu.

Bagelicious Cafe offers flexibility in how you enjoy your food, catering to every schedule from morning commuters to weekend brunch seekers.

• Delivery: Enjoy their full menu brought right to your home or office.
• In-store pickup: Ideal for quick orders placed ahead of time, minimizing your wait during peak hours.
• Takeout: Fast and efficient service for quick grab-and-go meals.
• Dine-in: A casual setting to enjoy your breakfast or lunch on-site, with a restroom amenity available.
• NFC Mobile Payments: Accepts credit cards, debit cards, and mobile payments for swift and modern transactions.
• Breakfast Service: Catering specifically to the most important meal of the day with hearty, fresh options available from 6:00 am.

The expansive menu at Bagelicious Cafe is the heart of its appeal, showcasing a true commitment to a variety of fresh foods, from the namesake bagels to specialty deli items.

• Affordable, Hearty Breakfast Sandwiches: A key highlight is the incredible value and generous portions of their morning offerings. A two-egg breakfast sandwich starts at just $1.99, making it one of the most cost-effective, high-quality starts to your day in the region. Their loaded sandwiches, such as the famous BX Bomber (with two fried eggs, bacon, ham, sausage, onions, Pepper Jack cheese, and hot sauce), or the simple yet satisfying 2 Eggs with Protein & Cheese ($3.49) are celebrated for being full, flavorful, and budget-friendly. They still offer a beloved bacon, egg, and cheese that is highly praised for its quality and price point.

• A True New York Deli Experience: The menu extends far beyond bagels. You can order Mini Sandwiches perfect for a lighter lunch, or opt for a substantial Bagel Sandwich featuring premium meats and salads. The deli counter offers meats and cheeses by the Lb., including Roast Beef, Ham, and Turkey, making it a great stop for weekly meal prep or catering.

• Specialty Salmon and Fish: For a classic New York experience, the shop features an impressive selection of smoked fish and salad options. Choose from the Bagel Smoked Atlantic Nova Salmon Sandwich, Bagel Premium Whole Whitefish Sandwich, or the more unique Bagel Baked Kippered Salmon Sandwich. These high-end offerings are available for sandwiches or by the pound.

• Homemade Cream Cheese Variety: The shop is serious about its spreads, offering not only Plain and Light Plain, but also flavorful options like Lox Scallion, Walnut Raisin, Jalapeño, and Sun-Dried Tomato Cream Cheese. They even include Tofu-based spreads for dairy-free alternatives. These spreads are available on regular bagels, mini bagels, or the flattened Flagel, and can be purchased by the pound.

• Lunch Wraps and Salads: For a midday meal, the menu features a selection of specialty wraps ($6.50), such as the Philly Cheesesteak Wrap, the local favorite The Thornwood Wrap (Tuna with cranberries, apples, and walnuts), and the savory The Wall Street Wrap (Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo). Fresh salads and sides like house-made Potato Salad, Macaroni Salad, and Cole Slaw are also available by the pound.

• Coffee Bar and Baked Goods: Complementing the food is a full coffee bar offering hot and iced beverages, including Espresso, Latte, Cappuccino, and Mocha, alongside fresh baked goods like Cinnamon Rolls, Muffins, Croissants, and the classic New York Black & White Cookie.

For those planning a visit, placing a phone order, or arranging a delivery, here is the necessary contact information:

• Address: 1026 Broadway, Thornwood, NY 10594, USA

• Phone: (914) 239-8448

• Breakfast Sandwich Hours: Available everyday from 6:00 am – 1:30 pm (Note: General store hours may extend beyond this for other items).

For New Yorkers in Westchester, Bagelicious Cafe is worth choosing primarily because it nails the trifecta of a great local spot: authentic quality, exceptional value, and broad selection.

Authentic Quality and Freshness: The most significant draw is the consistent quality of the bagels themselves. Customer reviews highlight that the bagels are reliably fresh, with one person specifically noting their poppy seed bagels are always fresh and generously coated. For bagel purists, this consistency is paramount. The house-made salads and variety of fresh cream cheese spreads also contribute to a product that tastes homemade and high-quality.

Unbeatable Value: In the New York Metro area, it is increasingly difficult to find a hearty, satisfying breakfast at a great price. Bagelicious Cafe offers incredible value, with some breakfast sandwiches starting under $2 and the more complex protein and cheese options staying highly affordable. This commitment to maintaining great prices, even for a bacon, egg, and cheese, makes it a financial relief for daily customers compared to many other spots.

Extensive Menu Variety: The ability to function as a specialty bagel shop, a full-service deli, and a coffee bar makes it a one-stop-shop. Customers aren't limited to just a bagel and cream cheese; they can grab a gourmet lox sandwich, a healthy vanilla yogurt parfait, a classic deli lunch wrap, or even stock up on deli meats and spreads by the pound. The inclusion of Tofu spreads, Light cream cheese options, and unique specialty wraps like the Pleasantville Wrap (Chicken salad with grapes, raisins, apple and walnuts) ensures that nearly every taste and dietary preference is catered to. For a quick visit that consistently delivers on taste, price, and selection, Bagelicious Cafe at 1026 Broadway in Thornwood is a local essential.

Bagelicious Cafe

1026 Broadway, Thornwood, NY 10594, USA