Benjamin Steakhouse Prime

- 23 E 40th St, Between Madison &, Park Ave, New York, NY 10016

In a city famed for its steakhouses, Benjamin Steakhouse Prime stands out as a distinguished destination that embodies the classic New York steakhouse tradition with a touch of modern elegance. Located at 23 E 40th St, between Madison and Park Avenues, it is a prime spot for anyone seeking an unforgettable dining experience. The restaurant's reputation is built on its commitment to serving the highest quality USDA prime dry-aged steaks, which are meticulously aged in-house to achieve a rich, distinctive flavor and a tender texture. This dedication to craft is what draws both locals and tourists, providing a dining experience that is both luxurious and deeply satisfying.

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is more than just a place for great steak; it is a full-service culinary destination. The menu extends far beyond the signature beef, offering a wide array of appetizers, fresh seafood, and classic steakhouse sides. From the sizzling Canadian bacon to the exquisite lobster mac and cheese, every dish is prepared with the same level of care and precision. The atmosphere is upscale yet cozy, with a sophisticated ambiance that makes it an ideal setting for any occasion, be it a business dinner, a family celebration, or a romantic date night. The professional and attentive service ensures that every guest is treated like a VIP, making the entire experience feel special.

The restaurant’s design is as impressive as its menu, blending traditional steakhouse décor with contemporary accents. The spacious dining room, accented with classic features, creates an environment that feels both grand and inviting. The extensive wine wall is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to providing the perfect pairing for every meal. For those looking for a truly quintessential New York dining experience, Benjamin Steakhouse Prime delivers on all fronts, combining exceptional food, impeccable service, and a timeless atmosphere.

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is conveniently situated in Midtown East at 23 E 40th St, New York, NY 10016, making it easily accessible from all parts of the city. Its proximity to major landmarks like Grand Central Terminal and Bryant Park makes it an excellent choice for a pre-theater dinner or a post-work gathering. The central location is a major advantage for both locals and tourists, with numerous subway lines and bus routes just a short walk away.

The restaurant is highly accessible, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating. For guests arriving by car, there are options for paid parking garage and paid street parking in the vicinity, which is a great convenience in this busy part of the city. The restaurant's amenities also cater to families, with high chairs and a changing table available, ensuring a comfortable experience for all.

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime offers a range of services designed for a premium dining experience.

• Dine-in: The primary service is dine-in, with a focus on elegant table service in a beautiful, upscale setting.

• Reservations: Reservations are highly recommended for both lunch and dinner, especially on weekends, to secure a table and ensure a seamless visit. The restaurant accepts reservations, making it easy to plan your special occasion in advance.

• Takeout, Curbside Pickup & Delivery: For those who want to enjoy the steakhouse experience at home or the office, the restaurant offers convenient takeout and delivery options, as well as curbside pickup for added ease.

• Private Dining: The restaurant has a private dining room, perfect for corporate events, family celebrations, or any large group that requires an exclusive and customizable space.

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is celebrated for a number of standout features that make it a favorite among New York's top steakhouses.

• Great Steak & Chops: The star of the menu is undoubtedly the USDA prime dry-aged steaks. The Porterhouse for 2, 3, or 4 is a popular choice, praised in customer reviews for being juicy, perfectly seasoned, and a true standout.

• Exceptional Seafood: The restaurant, from the Benjamin Restaurant Group which also has a well-regarded seafood restaurant, offers a fantastic selection of seafood, including a raw bar with chilled lobster and colossal shrimp. The Duo Tartare, which combines Scottish salmon and yellowfin tuna, is also a highly praised appetizer.

• Great Wine List & Cocktails: The extensive wine list is curated to perfectly complement the rich flavors of the menu. The bar also serves a selection of great cocktails, making it a perfect spot for a pre-dinner drink or a nightcap.

• Delicious Sides and Desserts: Sides are ordered à la carte, allowing for customization. Popular choices include the Creamed Spinach and the Lobster Mac And Cheese. For dessert, the Chocolate Mousse Cake and New York Cheesecake are highly recommended, offering a perfect end to the meal.

• Upscale & Cozy Atmosphere: The restaurant’s ambiance is a key highlight. It manages to feel both luxurious and welcoming, making it an excellent spot for both a formal business lunch and a relaxed evening with family or friends.

To make a reservation or for more information about the menu, you can contact the restaurant directly.

• Address: 23 E 40th St, New York, NY 10016

• Phone: (212) 338-0818

Choosing Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is a decision to embrace a quintessential New York dining experience that is both classic and contemporary. The most compelling reason to visit is, of course, the steaks. Their commitment to in-house dry-aging and their mastery of the grill results in a product that is juicy, flavorful, and truly memorable. The Porterhouse, in particular, is a must-try, offering a perfect blend of tenderness and robust flavor.

Beyond the steaks, the restaurant’s versatility is a major draw. It's a place where you can enjoy a hearty lunch, an intimate dinner, or a large group celebration. The menu’s breadth, including fresh seafood and a variety of delicious sides, ensures that there is something for everyone, even for non-steak lovers. The a la carte side dishes allow for a truly personalized meal. While a few customer reviews may note that some dishes are good but not "standout," the overall consensus is that the restaurant is a "solid steakhouse" that consistently delivers on its promise of quality.

Ultimately, Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is worth choosing because it provides a reliable, high-quality, and luxurious experience in the heart of New York City. It is a place that honors the tradition of the great American steakhouse while providing all the modern comforts and services expected of a top-tier restaurant. For anyone looking for a truly satisfying steak dinner in a beautiful setting, Benjamin Steakhouse Prime is a stellar choice.

Benjamin Steakhouse Prime

23 E 40th St, Between Madison &, Park Ave, New York, NY 10016, USA