Brennan & Carr

- 3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229

For New Yorkers, a roast beef sandwich is not just a meal; it’s a matter of civic pride, and for over 85 years, **Brennan & Carr** has been the undisputed answer to where to find the absolute best. Since opening its doors in 1938, this legendary **Sandwich shop** and **Restaurant** in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, has specialized in one thing: the hot roast beef sandwich. It is an enduring Brooklyn institution, a place where time seems to have stood still, offering a unique blend of history, tradition, and pure, messy deliciousness.

Brennan & Carr has been celebrated as having one of the “23 Iconic Dishes to Try in New York,” and it serves as the city's quintessential answer to the French dip style. The secret lies not only in the succulent, slow-cooked, thinly sliced roast beef, but in the signature beef broth—the heated drippings from the oven-roasted beef—which is poured or dipped with the sandwich. This commitment to the original recipe and the "old school" experience is why Brennan & Carr maintains a fiercely loyal following of locals, **College students**, **Groups**, and **Tourists** alike. It's an authentic slice of Brooklyn history, served up fresh and hot for **Lunch**, **Dinner**, and even **Late-night food**.

## Location and Accessibility

Brennan & Carr holds its original and historic location in the Sheepshead Bay neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it a true neighborhood staple and a destination for food pilgrims from across the city.

The exact address is:

3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

The restaurant offers excellent accessibility and parking options, which are major benefits in a busy urban environment like New York:

• Ample Parking: The location features a **Free parking lot** and **On-site parking**, in addition to **Free street parking**, making a visit hassle-free for drivers.
• Physical Accessibility: The restaurant is committed to serving all guests, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible parking lot**, **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, and **Wheelchair accessible seating**.
• Dual Service Options: The establishment has both a traditional dine-in area with **Table service** and a walk-up window for customers seeking a true **Quick bite** on the go.

## Services Offered

The services at Brennan & Carr are distinctly "old school," focusing on the dining-in experience and efficient counter service, while still providing the flexibility demanded by modern New Yorkers.

The core services and amenities you can expect include:

• Dine-in and Table Service: Guests can enjoy the historic, **Cozy, Historic** atmosphere with full **Table service** from attentive staff, often noted for their friendly and professional demeanor.
• Takeout and Onsite Services: Customers can order at the walk-up window or counter for swift **Takeout**, making it an ideal option for a **Quick bite**.
• All-Day and Late-Night Availability: Serving food for **Lunch**, **Dinner**, and offering **Late-night food**, catering to various schedules.
• Beverage Options: Offering beverages including **Coffee**, **Beer**, and **Alcohol** to complement the hearty menu.
• Family-Friendly Environment: The restaurant is **Good for kids** and provides **High chairs**, welcoming the entire **Family-friendly** crowd.
• Service Simplicity: Emphasizing efficiency with options like **Counter service** and **Fast service**.
• Payment Requirement: Note that this is a traditional, **Cash-only** establishment, maintaining its decades-old practices.

## Features / Highlights

Brennan & Carr's highlights are centered around its single, signature dish and the unique, historic process used to prepare it. This focus allows them to proudly **Serves local specialty** that is recognized across New York City and beyond.

Key features and unique highlights that define the Brennan & Carr experience:

• The Iconic Roast Beef Sandwich: The star of the menu, featuring thinly sliced, slightly pink and tender roast beef that is famous for its melt-in-your-mouth texture.
• Broth 101 – The Broth Variations: The essential, signature house-made beef broth (leftover oven drippings) is the key to the flavor. Regular customers know the three ways to order the sandwich:
  • DINGLE DANGLE: Dipping only the beef into the broth, leaving the roll dry.
  • DOUBLE DIP: The entire sandwich—meat and both sides of the bun—is plunged into the broth, resulting in a supremely juicy, messy meal.
  • KFJ ("Knife Fork Job"): Broth is poured generously over the entire sandwich, requiring it to be eaten with cutlery.
• The Gargiulo Burger: While roast beef is the delicacy, the **Gargiulo Burger** is another legendary item, noted as a specialty that rivals the beef itself.
• Classic Comfort Sides: The menu features essential sides, including **French Fries**, **Cheese Fries** (often praised as the ideal crispy balance to the sandwich), **Onion Rings**, **Corn Fritters**, and **Mozzarella Sticks**.
• Traditional Desserts: The dessert menu features old-school favorites, notably the **Apple Pie or Blueberry Pie Ala Mode**, which customers describe as incredible, not too sweet, and super rich.
• Historic, Unchanged Atmosphere: The restaurant maintains a classic 1930s-era feel; patrons feel like they are stepping back in time, adding to the singular dining experience.

## Contact Information

To call ahead with a question, inquire about the menu, or confirm operating hours for this traditional institution, please use the following contact details:

Address: 3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

Phone: (718) 769-1254

Mobile Phone: +1 718-769-1254

## What is Worth Choosing

For New York residents, choosing Brennan & Carr is a choice for history, tradition, and the best **comfort food** Brooklyn has to offer. This is a pilgrimage every local should make, and there is one mandatory choice: the roast beef sandwich.

For your first visit, the recommendation is to order the classic **Roast Beef Sandwich** prepared in the **DOUBLE DIP** style, and always add cheese (which is often described as a heavy-duty, cheese-wiz style smear). This preparation method is the original and most famous, guaranteeing a soft, intensely flavored, and deliciously messy experience that requires you to "dig right in."

To complement the richness of the sandwich, you should absolutely order the **Cheese Fries**. The crispy, hand-cut fries smothered in cheese provide the perfect textural balance to the broth-soaked sandwich.

Do not miss the desserts, which are often overlooked but are genuinely high-quality; the **Apple Pie Ala Mode** is a fantastic, rich, and not-too-sweet finish to the meal. Remember that for the best, most traditional experience, many long-time customers recommend dining inside at a table, rather than taking the notoriously messy sandwich to go. Finally, always remember to bring cash, as this legendary institution stays true to its "old school" traditions.

Brennan & Carr

3432 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA