Buttercup Bake Shop

- 167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016

For New Yorkers with a sweet tooth, there's a certain comfort in knowing where to find a classic, satisfying dessert. Buttercup Bake Shop, located at 167 Madison Ave, has been a beloved fixture in Midtown Manhattan, serving up a slice of nostalgic Americana with every treat. This isn't just a bakery; it's a destination for anyone craving traditional, homemade-style desserts. From its famous cupcakes to its specialty puddings, the shop is a celebration of simple, well-crafted sweets that have won over the hearts of locals and visitors alike. The shop's reputation is built on providing moist, flavorful, and not-too-sweet baked goods that remind many of the best homemade treats.

The essence of Buttercup Bake Shop is its focus on quality and tradition. The menu features an extensive variety of baked goods, including an impressive selection of cupcakes, cookies, and bars. What makes this bakery stand out is its commitment to variety, catering to different tastes and dietary needs, as seen in their popular gluten-free offerings. Whether you're in the mood for a rich chocolate cupcake or a classic lemon square, Buttercup has something to satisfy every craving. It is the perfect spot for a quick visit, allowing busy New Yorkers to grab a delicious treat on the go or plan ahead for a special occasion.

Buttercup Bake Shop is perfectly situated at 167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016. This prime Midtown location makes it a convenient and accessible spot for a vast number of people. Whether you're working in a nearby office, exploring the neighborhood, or simply passing through, the bakery is an easy stop. For accessibility, the shop is equipped with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that all customers can come in and enjoy the offerings. The bakery is designed for a quick visit, with a small storefront that is packed with options, making it ideal for those who are short on time but big on cravings. Its central address makes it a sweet retreat in a bustling urban environment.

Buttercup Bake Shop provides a focused and delicious range of services and products, specializing in classic baked goods that are crafted to perfection. Their menu is thoughtfully organized to highlight a wide variety of treats, ensuring there’s always something new and exciting to try, or an old favorite to return to. The services are also designed for modern convenience, catering to the busy lifestyle of New Yorkers.

• Cupcakes: The cornerstone of the bakery's menu. Customers can choose from a variety of flavors, including traditional assortments and special gluten-free options. The cupcakes are praised for their moist texture and balanced frosting, which many find to be perfectly sweet without being overpowering. The premium cupcakes, such as the Ube and Red Velvet, are often noted as standout flavors.

• Bars and Squares: A fan-favorite category, featuring gooey and decadent treats like the Fudge Brownie, Lemon Square, and the Gooey Chocolate Chip Bar. The "staff favorite," the Peanut Butter Jelly Bar, is a must-try for those looking for something unique and comforting.

• Puddings: For a different kind of sweet treat, the bakery offers specialty puddings. The Banana Pudding, Triple Chocolate Trifle, and Cookies and Cream Pudding are rich, creamy, and satisfyingly decadent, offering a fantastic alternative to cake or cookies.

• Cookies and Bundt Slices: The menu also includes classic cookies like the Chocolate Chip Cookie and Snickerdoodle, as well as unique options like the Bestest Oatmeal Cinnamon Chocolate Cookie. For a hearty slice of cake, the Bundt slices, including Lemon Vanilla and Maple Cinnamon, are a popular choice.

• Convenient Services: Buttercup Bake Shop offers three primary service options: takeout, in-store pickup, and delivery. This flexibility allows customers to enjoy their treats on the go, pick up pre-orders, or have them conveniently delivered to their home or office in Manhattan.

• Coffee: To perfectly complement the sweet treats, the bakery also offers coffee, providing a complete snack or dessert experience.

Buttercup Bake Shop's reputation is built on several key features and highlights that set it apart from other bakeries in the city. These attributes are what turn first-time visitors into loyal customers and make the shop a true standout in the New York dessert scene.

• Quality of Baked Goods: The consistent quality of the baked goods is a major highlight. Reviewers often mention the moistness of the cakes and the deliciousness of the frostings, particularly the cream cheese-based ones. The focus on rich flavors and moist textures ensures a high-quality product every time.

• Gluten-Free Options: A significant highlight is the dedicated selection of gluten-free cupcakes and bars. This inclusion makes the bakery accessible to a wider audience and shows a commitment to providing delicious options for those with dietary restrictions.

• Famous Staff Favorites: The menu's special designation of a "Staff Favorite" like the Peanut Butter Jelly Bar or a "NEW BAR ALERT" like the Butter Cake Bar creates a sense of discovery and encourages customers to try new and exciting items that are beloved by the people who make them. The Banana Pudding is also a standout, often hailed as a must-try.

• Variety of Products: The bakery offers more than just cupcakes. The diverse selection of cookies, bars, and specialty puddings provides a reason to return again and again. Customers appreciate the wide array of choices, ensuring they can find the perfect treat for any craving.

• Efficiency and Convenience: The shop is designed for a quick visit, and the availability of credit card, debit card, and NFC mobile payments streamlines the process. This efficiency is highly valued by New Yorkers who are always on the move.

You can find Buttercup Bake Shop at the following location and contact them using the provided information:

Address: 167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016

Phone: (212) 350-4144

So, why should you choose Buttercup Bake Shop over the countless other bakeries in New York City? For local users, it's a matter of trust and consistent quality. While some customers have noted that the prices have gone up and sizes may have changed over time, the overwhelming feedback is that the quality remains high. The moist, tasty cakes and flavorful frostings are a reliable and delicious treat that many find superior to other options in the city. The famous lemon Bundt cake, for example, has been called "the best… ever" by a customer, which is a powerful testament to the bakery's skill.

What truly makes Buttercup Bake Shop worth choosing is its blend of classic, comforting flavors with modern convenience. The availability of delivery, in-store pickup, and a variety of payment methods means you can get your fix of their delicious treats no matter your schedule. The inclusion of specialty items like their renowned banana pudding and a wide range of gluten-free options also demonstrates a commitment to catering to a diverse customer base. Ultimately, Buttercup Bake Shop is more than just a place to buy a cupcake; it's a reliable, high-quality bakery that offers a taste of simple perfection. It’s the kind of place that becomes a part of your routine—a little slice of sweetness that you know you can always count on.

Buttercup Bake Shop

167 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016, USA