Cafe On The Hill

- 153 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11223

When New Yorkers talk about great local eats, especially those comforting neighborhood spots in Brooklyn that feel like a second home, the conversation invariably turns to places like Cafe On The Hill. Located on Avenue U, this establishment is a staple in the local dining scene, known for serving up a diverse menu that firmly grounds itself in Italian tradition while offering plenty of American and cafe-style favorites. It's the kind of spot where you can settle in for a relaxed dinner or grab a satisfying, quick lunch. Cafe On The Hill provides a casual and cozy atmosphere that has earned it a loyal following among families, local groups, and even solo diners looking for quality comfort food.

More than just a restaurant, Cafe On The Hill is celebrated for its commitment to classic, satisfying meals, ranging from hearty pasta dishes to fully-loaded heroes and paninis, all served with genuinely fast and friendly service. The establishment has been highlighted by customers for its welcoming vibe and its late-night food options, making it a reliable choice no matter the time of day. Whether you’re stopping by for a strong cup of coffee and dessert, or sitting down to enjoy a full plate of classic Italian comfort food, this Brooklyn gem aims to deliver.

The menu selection is thoughtfully designed to cater to all tastes and occasions, blending Italian specialties with staple American fare. Diners can explore traditional Italian favorites like various pasta dishes, parmigiana heroes, and an array of appealing appetizers. Additionally, the menu features classic American options such as Hill Burgers, various salads, and a full range of entrées including steaks and chops. This variety, paired with a full bar offering, ensures that Cafe On The Hill is ready to meet the needs of nearly any hungry patron in the Gravesend neighborhood and beyond.

For New Yorkers in the know, finding a reliable local spot that checks all the boxes—quality food, great service, and a comfortable setting—is a major win. Cafe On The Hill consistently shows up as a local favorite, recognized for its great coffee and desserts, and providing a space where everyone, from families to groups of friends, feels right at home. It’s an authentic slice of Brooklyn dining that prides itself on delicious, no-fuss meals made with care.

Location and Accessibility

Cafe On The Hill is conveniently situated in the heart of Brooklyn, providing an accessible dining option for those in the Gravesend and surrounding neighborhoods. Its address, 153 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11223, places it in a well-trafficked area, making it easy to find whether you are arriving by public transit or driving. The restaurant aims to be welcoming to all members of the community, offering wheelchair accessible seating to ensure a comfortable experience for every guest. The neighborhood setting contributes to the restaurant's casual and cozy atmosphere, making it a true local hangout.

Services Offered

• Dine-in Service: Enjoy a meal in the casual and cozy restaurant atmosphere with comfortable seating and table service.
• Takeout: Convenient options for picking up your meal to enjoy at home or on the go.
• Outdoor Seating: A great option for enjoying your meal outside when the weather in New York permits.
• Catering: Although not explicitly detailed on all platforms, the restaurant offers catering services, suggesting that their popular dishes can be scaled up for events and parties.
• Alcoholic Beverages: A full bar is available, serving Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine.
• Non-Alcoholic Drinks: Excellent Coffee and Espresso options are available.
• Full Meal Service: Serving lunch and dinner, as well as dessert.
• Quick Bites and Late-Night Food: Perfect for those needing a fast meal or a satisfying bite during late hours.
• Accommodations for Children: The atmosphere is considered good for kids and family-friendly.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts major Credit cards and Debit cards for easy payment.

Features / Highlights

• Great Coffee and Dessert: Highly praised by customers, making it an excellent stop for a quick pick-me-up or a sweet ending to a meal.
• Fast Service: Noted for its quick and efficient service, ideal for lunch breaks or busy evenings.
• Full Bar Offering: A complete selection of alcoholic beverages including cocktails, beer, hard liquor, and wine, enhancing the dining experience.
• Comfort Food Focused: The menu emphasizes satisfying, comforting, and classic dishes from Italian and American cuisines, such as pasta, heroes, and burgers.
• Cozy and Casual Atmosphere: The environment is welcoming and relaxed, perfect for groups, families, or solo diners.
• Diverse Menu Selection: Offers a wide variety, including healthy options, small plates (Appetizers), and substantial Entrées and Paninis.
• Late-Night Availability: A great option for those looking for a meal after standard dining hours.
• Customer Favorite Dishes: Highly reviewed items include the grilled calamari, which one customer called "probably the best grilled calamari I've ever had in my life," as well as other popular items like their hot tortellini soup and rockin' riceballs.

What is Worth Choosing

Cafe On The Hill offers a true taste of New York's casual Italian and cafe dining, with several menu categories that stand out. For those craving a satisfying classic, the Pasta selection is a must-try, featuring comforting dishes like Spaghetti with Meatballs ($7.00), Penne Alla Vodka ($6.00), and Baked Ziti (available through the full menu mentioned in other search snippets). These dishes exemplify the restaurant's focus on hearty, delicious Italian fare.

The Heroes section offers quick, filling, and classic Italian-American sandwiches, all priced at a modest $7.00. Favorites like the Chicken Parmigiana Hero or the Philly Cheese Steak are perfect for a robust lunch. The Panini options are also a highlight, each priced at $8.00, including delicious, substantial combinations such as the Grilled Chicken, Roasted Peppers, Mozzarella panini, and the Prosciutto Tomato & Mozzarella Panini, which showcase fresh ingredients.

For appetizers, the customer-raved Grilled Calamari (priced at $25.00 for the special mentioned in a review, but Crispy Calamari is listed at $9.00 on the bar menu) is a clear recommendation, along with other popular small plates like Spicy Wings ($7.00) and Mozzarella Sticks ($7.00). The full bar, combined with the excellent Coffee selection—featuring Espresso ($2.00) and Cappuccino ($3.00)—ensures your meal begins and ends on a high note. Lastly, don't overlook the main Entrée offerings, such as Rib Steak ($15.00) and Chicken Parmigiana ($9.00), which are served with a side salad and vegetable, offering a great value. The variety and accessible price points across the menu solidify Cafe On The Hill as an excellent choice for any occasion.

Contact Information

Address: 153 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA

Phone: (718) 266-0107

Cafe On The Hill

153 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11223, USA