Fortunato Brothers: A Brooklyn Institution for Italian Pastries and Gelato

Fortunato Brothers Introduce

For generations, Fortunato Brothers has been a staple of the Brooklyn community, offering a sweet taste of Italy right in the heart of Williamsburg. This family-owned bakery and dessert shop is more than just a place to grab a treat; it's an institution. As you step inside, you are transported into a world of traditional Italian sweets, from classic cannolis and sfogliatellas to rich, flavorful gelatos and elaborate cakes. The atmosphere is bustling and inviting, filled with the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and baked goods. Fortunato Brothers embodies the charm and authenticity that New Yorkers cherish in their local businesses, making it a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth.

Fortunato Brothers offers a vast and impressive menu that caters to every craving. It's a place where you can find a dessert for any occasion, whether it's a simple, perfect pastry to go with your morning coffee or a grand cake for a special celebration. Their commitment to classic recipes and high-quality ingredients is evident in every bite. The bakery’s extensive selection includes everything from individual pastries like the Lobster Tail and Cream Puff to a wide variety of cakes available both by the slice and as a whole. Beyond the baked goods, their gelato menu is a highlight, offering a refreshing and authentic experience with a range of flavors available by the scoop, pint, or quart. With so many options, Fortunato Brothers ensures that every visit is a new adventure, giving you a reason to come back again and again to explore their delicious offerings.

Location and Accessibility

Fortunato Brothers is centrally located in Brooklyn at 289 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA. This prime location places it in the vibrant and bustling neighborhood of Williamsburg, making it easily accessible for both locals and visitors exploring the area. The bakery is situated on a main thoroughfare, surrounded by a mix of residential buildings and other local businesses, contributing to the strong sense of community that defines this part of Brooklyn. For those traveling by car, there is a convenient benefit of free street parking available, which can be a significant plus in a busy New York neighborhood. Public transportation is also readily available, making it simple to reach Fortunato Brothers from various parts of the city. The bakery also prioritizes accessibility for all customers, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance. This commitment to convenience and inclusivity helps ensure that everyone can come and enjoy the classic Italian sweets that Fortunato Brothers has to offer.

Services Offered

Dine-In, Takeout, and Delivery: Fortunato Brothers provides multiple ways for customers to enjoy their products. You can choose to dine in and soak in the traditional bakery atmosphere, or you can opt for convenient takeout to enjoy your treats on the go. Additionally, for those who prefer the comfort of their home, the bakery offers delivery services, bringing their delicious items right to your doorstep.
In-Store Pickup: The bakery offers in-store pickup, making it easy to place an order ahead of time for special occasions or large quantities. This service is especially useful for those planning an event and wanting to ensure their favorite cakes or pastries are ready for a quick and easy collection.
On-Site Services: Fortunato Brothers’ welcoming environment and quick-visit-friendly nature make it a perfect spot for a spontaneous stop. Whether you need a morning coffee and pastry or a dessert after dinner, the bakery's on-site services are designed to be efficient and friendly.
Custom and Specialty Cakes: Beyond the individual pastries, Fortunato Brothers specializes in a wide range of custom and specialty cakes. The menu includes a variety of options, from classic Italian Cheesecake and Tiramisu to more unique creations like the Rainbow Cookie Cake and Pistachio Cheesecake. These cakes are perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, or any celebration.

Features and Highlights

Extensive Menu Variety: A key feature of Fortunato Brothers is its incredibly diverse menu. It goes far beyond a typical bakery, offering a wide array of items. From the large selection of pastries like the Cannoli and Lobster Tail to a full gelato menu, there is something to satisfy every craving. They also offer a variety of coffee and tea, and a selection of classic Italian beverages like Gassosa and Chinotto.
Authentic Italian Offerings: The bakery prides itself on its authentic Italian specialties. Customers can find traditional items like Torrone, Marzipan, and a vast selection of biscotti and cookies sold by weight. The commitment to traditional recipes and flavors gives the bakery a genuine, old-world charm that is a rare find in modern New York City.
High-Quality Ingredients: Fortunato Brothers uses high-quality ingredients, which is evident in the taste and texture of their products. From the fresh-made gelato to the perfectly crafted pastries, the focus on quality is a primary reason for its long-standing popularity in the community. Their retail selection of Miscela D'Oro and Lavazza espresso products also speaks to a dedication to authenticity.
Friendly and Professional Staff: The customer service at Fortunato Brothers is often a highlight for many visitors. Several reviews praise the staff for their friendly and welcoming demeanor, which contributes to a pleasant and enjoyable experience. A welcoming smile and helpful service can make a quick visit feel like a memorable one.

Contact Information

Address: 289 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA
Phone: (718) 387-2281

What is Worth Choosing?

Choosing Fortunato Brothers is about more than just grabbing a quick dessert; it's about experiencing a piece of Brooklyn's rich cultural and culinary history. The bakery’s extensive and authentic menu is a huge draw. For lovers of classic Italian sweets, the selection is unparalleled. You can find everything from a perfect cannoli with your coffee to an entire cake for a special event. The sheer variety, from a simple croissant to a complex Zuppetta, means there is always something new to try. The commitment to tradition and quality is what makes their offerings so consistently delicious.

Furthermore, the atmosphere and the service make it a genuinely pleasant place to visit. While some experiences may vary, the general consensus is that the staff is welcoming and the environment is a true neighborhood institution. It's a place that fosters a sense of community and provides a consistent, high-quality product. The ability to dine in, take out, or get delivery adds to its convenience, catering to all types of customers and occasions. For anyone in New York looking for an authentic and delicious bakery experience that feels like a true local find, Fortunato Brothers is an excellent choice. It's a spot where you can satisfy your sweet tooth while also connecting with the authentic, long-standing spirit of Brooklyn.

Fortunato Brothers Menu

All Day Menu - Gelato
2 Scoops Of Gelato $11.99
1 Scoop Of Gelato $5.99
Pint Of Gelato $23.99
Gelato Milkshake $9.99
Quart Of Gelato $32.99
3 Scoops Of Gelato $17.99

All Day Menu - Italian Specialties per Pound
Torrone $12.99
Bow Ties
Marzipan
All marzipan tastes the same regardless of design. Comes assorted in size.

All Day Menu - Cakes by the Slice
Cubano Cake Slice $6.99
Chocolate sponge cake with Lulu and Nutella, soaked in rum and covered in chocolate. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Italian Cheesecake Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Oreo Cheesecake Slice $8.99
American Cheesecake Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Blueberry Napoleon Cake Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Tiramisu Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Red Velvet Cheesecake Slice $6.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Rainbow Cookie W/ Cannoli $6.99
Rainbow cookie with cannoli cream in between topped with chocolate. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Red Velvet Cake Slice $6.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Strawberry Shortcake Slice $6.99
Strawberry and banana. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Black Forest Cake Slice $6.99
All chocolate!! Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.

All Day Menu - Beverages
Gassosa $4.99
Lemon-lime soda.
Bottled Water $3.99
Aranciata $4.99
Orange soda.
Coffee Soda $4.99
Espresso soda.
Limonata $4.99
Lemon soda.
Brooklyn Best Iced Tea $4.99
Acqua Mineral $3.99
Sparkling water.
Chinotto $4.99
Bitter $4.99
Pear Juice $4.99

All Day Menu - Caffe & Tea
Latte |
Espresso
Iced Cappuccino
Green Tea |
Iced Americano
Camomilla |
Peppermint |
Unsweetened Tea Over Ice
Caffe Granita |
Lipton Tea |
Americano |
Cappuccino |
Hot Chocolate |

All Day Menu - Pastries
Elephant Ear $5.99
Lulu
Puffed pastry filled with Lulu cream (a custard and whipped cream mixture).
Croissant $5.99
Frola $5.99
St. Joseph Zeppole $8.99
Cream Puff $3.99
Napolean
Zuppetta
Napoleon pastry with vanilla custard and lulu cream, soaked in rum with a powder sugar top.
Pistachio Mousse $3.99
Puff pastry filled with pistachio mousse covered in chocolate.
Eclair
Cannoli Shot $4.99
Cannoli cup with a chocolate base and a layer of Nutella, topped with cannoli cream.
Baba Rum W/ Cream $8.99
Sponge cake pastry soaked in rum with your choice of cream filling.
Deliziosa
Baba Rum
Sponge cake pastry soaked in rum.
Pasticciotto | Vanilla Cream $5.99
Filled with vanilla custard.
Swan $5.99
Filled with vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream.
Cannoli
Pistachio Cannoli $6.99
Pistachio infused chocolate encrusted in pistachios and filled with pistachio cannoli cream.
Pasticciotto | Cross
Filled with Ricotta cheese.
Lobster Tail
Filled with Lulu cream (a custard and whipped cream mixture).
Hazelnut Cannoli $6.99
Covered in chocolate and encrusted in hazelnuts filled with cannoli cream topped with a fresh strawberry.
Sfogliatella
Linzart Tart $5.99
Chocolate Covered Strawberry $5.99

All Day Menu - Assorted Biscotti | Cookies sold by weight
Mixed Cookies
1lb. Assorted cookies 20-25 per pound.
Pistachio Biscotti
1lb.
Sesame Biscotti
1lb.
Almond Biscotti
1lb.
Anisette Biscotti
1lb.
Rainbow Cookies
1lb. Between 12-15 cookies per pound.
Pistachio Cookies
1lb. Made with marzipan and pistachio. Between 18-20 cookies per pound.
Pignoli Cookies
1lb. About 22 cookies per pound.
Crocantini
1lb. Chocolate hazelnut.
Butter Cookies
1lb.

All Day Menu - Retail Espresso by Miscela D'Oro
Nespresso Capsules $57.99
100 count capsules for Nespresso machine.
Espresso Beans $40.99
1 kg bag.
Espresso Pods $57.99
150 count espresso paper pods.
Lavazza Capsules $57.99
100 count capsules for Lavazza machine.
Ground Espresso Stove Top $10.99
8.8 oz.

All Day Menu - Cakes
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Chocolate sponge with chocolate mousse covered in chocolate ganache with chocolate filled cream puffs around. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Red Velvet Cake $40.99
Serves 8 people. Filled with cream cheese frosting. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Mocha Mousse Cake $40.99
Serves 8-12 people. Vanilla sponge soaked in coffee liqueur filled with mocha mousse cream. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Oreo Cheesecake $34.99
Cassata Cake
Vanilla cake soaked in rum with cannoli cream fondant topped with dry fruit decoration. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Strawberry & Banana Vanilla Sponge Cake $36.99
Serves 8 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Tiramisu
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
American Cheesecake | Large $66.99
Serves 15-20 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Italian Cheesecake | Large $66.99
Serves 15-20 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Fruit Tart
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Rainbow Cookie Cake $56.99
Serves 10-15 people. Same as our award winning cookie in a giant cake form. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Strawberry & Banana Chocolate Sponge Cake $36.99
Serves 8 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Black Forrest Cake $40.99
Serves 8 people. All chocolate, no cherries inside. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Vanilla & Chocolate Cake
Yellow sponge with a layer of vanilla custard and chocolate cream finished in whipped cream. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Cubano Cake $55.99
Serves 10-15 people. Chocolate sponge cake with Lulu and Nutella soaked in rum and covered in chocolate. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Pistachio Cheesecake $53.99
Cannoli & Chocolate Cake
Yellow sponge with a layer of cannoli cream and chocolate cream finished in whipped cream. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Italian Cheesecake | Small $36.99
Serves 8-10 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Pistacchio Tiramisu
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
American Cheesecake | Small $36.99
Serves 8-10 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Limoncello Tiramisu
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.

weekend menu - Gelato
2 Scoops Of Gelato $11.99
1 Scoop Of Gelato $5.99
Pint Of Gelato $23.99
Gelato Milkshake $9.99
Quart Of Gelato $32.99
3 Scoops Of Gelato $17.99

weekend menu - Italian Specialties per Pound
Torrone $12.99
Bow Ties
Marzipan
All marzipan tastes the same regardless of design. Comes assorted in size.

weekend menu - Cakes by the Slice
Cubano Cake Slice $6.99
Chocolate sponge cake with Lulu and Nutella, soaked in rum and covered in chocolate. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Italian Cheesecake Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Oreo Cheesecake Slice $8.99
American Cheesecake Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Blueberry Napoleon Cake Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Tiramisu Slice $8.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Red Velvet Cheesecake Slice $6.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Rainbow Cookie W/ Cannoli $6.99
Rainbow cookie with cannoli cream in between topped with chocolate. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Red Velvet Cake Slice $6.99
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Strawberry Shortcake Slice $6.99
Strawberry and banana. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Black Forest Cake Slice $6.99
All chocolate!! Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.

weekend menu - Beverages
Gassosa $4.99
Lemon-lime soda.
Bottled Water $3.99
Aranciata $4.99
Orange soda.
Coffee Soda $4.99
Espresso soda.
Limonata $4.99
Lemon soda.
Brooklyn Best Iced Tea $4.99
Acqua Mineral $3.99
Sparkling water.
Chinotto $4.99
Bitter $4.99
Pear Juice $4.99

weekend menu - Caffe & Tea
Latte |
Espresso
Iced Cappuccino
Green Tea |
Iced Americano
Camomilla |
Peppermint |
Unsweetened Tea Over Ice
Caffe Granita |
Lipton Tea |
Americano |
Cappuccino |
Hot Chocolate |

weekend menu - Pastries
Elephant Ear $5.99
Lulu
Puffed pastry filled with Lulu cream (a custard and whipped cream mixture).
Croissant $5.99
Frola $5.99
St. Joseph Zeppole $8.99
Cream Puff $3.99
Napolean
Zuppetta
Napoleon pastry with vanilla custard and lulu cream, soaked in rum with a powder sugar top.
Pistachio Mousse $3.99
Puff pastry filled with pistachio mousse covered in chocolate.
Eclair
Cannoli Shot $4.99
Cannoli cup with a chocolate base and a layer of Nutella, topped with cannoli cream.
Baba Rum W/ Cream $8.99
Sponge cake pastry soaked in rum with your choice of cream filling.
Deliziosa
Baba Rum
Sponge cake pastry soaked in rum.
Pasticciotto | Vanilla Cream $5.99
Filled with vanilla custard.
Swan $5.99
Filled with vanilla custard and topped with whipped cream.
Cannoli
Pistachio Cannoli $6.99
Pistachio infused chocolate encrusted in pistachios and filled with pistachio cannoli cream.
Pasticciotto | Cross
Filled with Ricotta cheese.
Lobster Tail
Filled with Lulu cream (a custard and whipped cream mixture).
Hazelnut Cannoli $6.99
Covered in chocolate and encrusted in hazelnuts filled with cannoli cream topped with a fresh strawberry.
Sfogliatella
Linzart Tart $5.99
Chocolate Covered Strawberry $5.99

weekend menu - Assorted Biscotti | Cookies sold by weight
Mixed Cookies
1lb. Assorted cookies 20-25 per pound.
Pistachio Biscotti
1lb.
Sesame Biscotti
1lb.
Almond Biscotti
1lb.
Anisette Biscotti
1lb.
Rainbow Cookies
1lb. Between 12-15 cookies per pound.
Pistachio Cookies
1lb. Made with marzipan and pistachio. Between 18-20 cookies per pound.
Pignoli Cookies
1lb. About 22 cookies per pound.
Crocantini
1lb. Chocolate hazelnut.
Butter Cookies
1lb.

weekend menu - Retail Espresso by Miscela D'Oro
Nespresso Capsules $57.99
100 count capsules for Nespresso machine.
Espresso Beans $40.99
1 kg bag.
Espresso Pods $57.99
150 count espresso paper pods.
Lavazza Capsules $57.99
100 count capsules for Lavazza machine.
Ground Espresso Stove Top $10.99
8.8 oz.

weekend menu - Cakes
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Chocolate sponge with chocolate mousse covered in chocolate ganache with chocolate filled cream puffs around. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Red Velvet Cake $40.99
Serves 8 people. Filled with cream cheese frosting. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Mocha Mousse Cake $40.99
Serves 8-12 people. Vanilla sponge soaked in coffee liqueur filled with mocha mousse cream. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Oreo Cheesecake $34.99
Cassata Cake
Vanilla cake soaked in rum with cannoli cream fondant topped with dry fruit decoration. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Strawberry & Banana Vanilla Sponge Cake $36.99
Serves 8 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Tiramisu
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
American Cheesecake | Large $66.99
Serves 15-20 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Italian Cheesecake | Large $66.99
Serves 15-20 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Fruit Tart
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Rainbow Cookie Cake $56.99
Serves 10-15 people. Same as our award winning cookie in a giant cake form. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Strawberry & Banana Chocolate Sponge Cake $36.99
Serves 8 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Black Forrest Cake $40.99
Serves 8 people. All chocolate, no cherries inside. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Vanilla & Chocolate Cake
Yellow sponge with a layer of vanilla custard and chocolate cream finished in whipped cream. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Cubano Cake $55.99
Serves 10-15 people. Chocolate sponge cake with Lulu and Nutella soaked in rum and covered in chocolate. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Pistachio Cheesecake $53.99
Cannoli & Chocolate Cake
Yellow sponge with a layer of cannoli cream and chocolate cream finished in whipped cream. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Italian Cheesecake | Small $36.99
Serves 8-10 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Pistacchio Tiramisu
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
American Cheesecake | Small $36.99
Serves 8-10 people. Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.
Limoncello Tiramisu
Cakes are made fresh daily. Items may sell out without being updated.

Fortunato Brothers Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Amenities
Restroom

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free street parking

Fortunato Brothers Photos

Fortunato Brothers Location

Fortunato Brothers

New York Kings County Williamsburg Manhattan Avenue

289 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Fortunato Brothers Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 1749 user reviews.

italiancannoligelatorainbow cookiesespressolobstersfogliatellemarzipanpignoli cookieswhipped cream

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I am writing to express my disappointment with the cake I recently received from your store. I am not a first-time customer, which makes this experience even more frustrating.In the first picture (purple cake), the handwriting on the cake was extremely poorly done. It looked rushed and unprofessional, completely ruining the presentation. The words were slanted, “birthday” was missing the letter t, there was an odd scribble at the bottom of the “B,” and the “M” in “Maria” didn’t even resemble an M. Because of this, I wasn’t able to take proper pictures with the cake.For comparison, the second picture shows a cake I ordered just a month ago from your store, which looked clean, neat, and well-presented. The difference between the two is significant.When I addressed my concerns with the staff, the customer service I received was dismissive and unhelpful. I was told the handwriting was done by the owner himself and this was considered “fancy handwriting.” I never asked for fancy handwriting, and what I received was not neat or legible. Then when I showed him the photo of the cake he proceeded to tell me “That’s how all the handwritings on the cake look”. When I pointed out that this was untrue and showed them a photo of the previous cake I had ordered, which clearly had different, better handwriting, they had no response.I was told the owner would reach out to me the following day, but no one has contacted me. Instead, the only “solution” offered was that in the future I should order cakes without handwriting and have the writing done at pickup. This is not a reasonable solution.I expected much better quality and service, especially for an important occasion. Unfortunately, this experience has left me extremely dissatisfied, and I will not be returning.
August 23 · Britney Sotomayor
Fortunato Bros. is a true gem! The blonde girl with green eyes (i think her name was ariana or something) gave us top-tier service—so friendly and welcoming that she made us feel right at home. Her kindness and professionalism made our visit unforgettable. Can’t wait to come back!
September 05 · Mary Ann Llado
Such a great, timeless Italian bakery in the area for ages! Varieties of pastries, cookies, cakes, gelato, and seasonal specialties like St. Joseph’s pastry and a variety of things for Easter. They have pistachio sfogliatelle (lobster tail pastry) as well as other varieties, they have a cream puff shaped like a swan. Something many unique items that differentiate from other Italian bakeries.
April 05 · Mary Naughton
Ordered a cake for an early Father's Day surprise-and the real surprise was that it arrived completely smashed. When I called the bakery, I was told, "Well, we didn't give it to the driver like that," and that there was nothing they could do. This was ordered directly through their website.Unfortunately, this isn't the first time l've had issues. On several occasions, items were missing from my order, and when I called to report it, I was told they couldn't just send a driver out to fix it. One time, they even claimed a replacement item was sold out-only for me to place a new order under another name and suddenly it was back in stock.It's been one unprofessional experience after another, and I can no longer recommend this place in good faith.
June 12 · Dee
A friend of mine raved about this bakery, so we decided to check out their gelato. Their pistachio flavor was incredible and didn't disappoint! We enjoyed it in their sitting area with great company. If you're in the area, I highly recommend giving it a try.
August 16 · Joan L