Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Mahopac: Local Italian & Pizza Destination in NY

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Introduce

For residents and visitors in the **New York** area looking for a reliable, authentic, and delicious dining experience, **Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant** in Mahopac stands out as a local gem. More than just a pizza place, this establishment has cemented its reputation as a full-service **Italian restaurant** and bar, offering an extensive menu that caters to a diverse array of tastes and occasions. From classic mozzarella pizza to sophisticated seafood dishes and savory steaks, Four Brothers provides a cozy and welcoming atmosphere that embodies the spirit of local, quality dining.

The commitment to fresh, well-prepared food is evident across their comprehensive menu. Whether you're in the mood for a quick, satisfying lunch or a full, multi-course dinner, Four Brothers has carefully curated options. Patrons can explore traditional Italian favorites like **Spaghetti with Meatballs** or **Penne Ala Vodka**, alongside robust meat and seafood selections such as the **NY Strip Steak Campagnola** and **Grilled Salmon**. The offerings ensure that whether you're seeking comfort food or a more adventurous culinary journey, you'll find an exceptional dish prepared with care.

---

### Location and Accessibility

Located conveniently in the Mahopac area, **Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant** serves as an easily accessible dining spot for the local **New York** community. Its address is **654 US-6, Mahopac, NY 10541, USA**. The restaurant is specifically noted for its charming setting, which, as one customer highlights, is "set alongside Mahopac lake," adding a unique scenic element to the dining experience.

The facility is designed with **accessibility** in mind, a crucial factor for a community-focused establishment. It offers:

**Wheelchair accessible entrance**
**Wheelchair accessible parking lot** (including free parking in a lot and on the street)
**Wheelchair accessible restroom**
**Wheelchair accessible seating**

The generous provision of **free parking**, both in a dedicated lot and on the street, removes the common urban hassle of finding a spot, making it an excellent choice for individuals, couples, and large groups arriving by car.

---

### Services Offered

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant provides a variety of service options to meet the needs of today's busy local New Yorkers. You can enjoy their excellent food in several convenient ways:

**Dine-in:** Enjoy the full restaurant experience with comfortable seating, a welcoming atmosphere (described as Casual, Cozy, Quiet, and Trendy), and table service. Reservations are accepted, making it easy to plan for peak times or larger groups.
**Delivery:** Get your favorite Italian and pizza dishes brought right to your home or office.
**Takeout & Curbside Pickup:** For those on the go, placing an order for pickup is a fast and efficient option, with the added convenience of curbside service.
**Catering:** The restaurant offers catering services, making it a perfect choice for local events, parties, and business meetings in the Mahopac region.
**Private Dining Room:** An ideal amenity for private parties, large gatherings, and special occasions, ensuring a dedicated and intimate space.

---

### Features / Highlights

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant is celebrated for numerous features that enhance the customer experience, distinguishing it within the **New York** dining scene:

**Full-Service Bar:** A major draw is the impressive array of beverages, including a **Great beer selection**, **Great cocktails**, and a **Great wine list**. Patrons can enjoy hard liquor, beer, and wine from a bar located on-site.
**Exceptional Menu Variety:** The menu goes far beyond typical pizza offerings, featuring **Healthy options**, **Vegetarian options**, **Comfort food**, and even a full **Children's Menu** with items like **Kids Chicken Parmigiana With Pasta** and **Kids Mac N Cheese**.
**Specialty Dishes:** Highlights from the menu include the signature **Four Brothers Special Pizza**, the extensive selection of **Gourmet Pizzas** (like **Broccoli Rabe Pizza** and **Buffalo Chicken Pizza**), and hearty entrees like **Pork Chops Scarpariello** and **Zuppa Di Pesce**.
**Focus on Speed and Quality:** Customers consistently praise the **Fast service**, ensuring that meals are delivered promptly without compromising quality. The restaurant also serves local specialties, adding a unique regional flavor to its offerings.
**Dessert & Coffee:** Concluding your meal is a treat with their famous dessert menu, which offers a **Great dessert** selection, including **Oreo Cookie Bash**, **Tiramisu**, and the expansive **Big Chocolate Cake**. They also serve **Great coffee**.
**Family-Friendly Environment:** The restaurant is known to be **Good for kids**, including offering **High chairs** and being suitable for **kids' birthday** celebrations.
**Atmosphere:** The vibe is described as overall excellent, being simultaneously **Casual** and **Cozy**, attracting both **Groups** and **Tourists**.

---

### Contact Information

For inquiries, reservations, or to place an order, you can contact Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant using the details below:

Address: 654 US-6, Mahopac, NY 10541, USA

Phone: (845) 628-4404

Mobile Phone: +1 845-628-4404

---

### What is Worth Choosing

Choosing **Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant** means opting for a comprehensive and high-quality dining experience right here in the **New York** region. It’s an ideal choice for several compelling reasons:

**Authentic Italian and Gourmet Pizza:** The dual focus on being a superb Italian restaurant (offering classic pasta, parmigiana, and casseroles) and a top-tier pizza parlor (with **Mozzarella Pizza** and a dozen gourmet options) means you never have to compromise. The addition of **Gluten Free Pizza** ensures they accommodate various dietary needs.
**High-End Dinner Options:** The presence of impressive main courses, particularly in the **Meats** and **Seafood** categories—like the premium **NY Strip Steak Campagnola** and **Stuffed Filet Of Sole**—positions it as a destination for celebrating special occasions or enjoying a sophisticated dinner out.
**Unmatched Convenience and Comfort:** With the combination of **outdoor seating**, every service option from **delivery** to **dine-in**, extensive **wheelchair accessibility**, and **plenty of free parking**, the experience is frictionless. The staff, noted by patrons as "friendly" and in some cases "bilingual," further enhances the comfortable and excellent vibe.
**An All-Day Destination:** The restaurant is popular for both **Lunch** and **Dinner**, with a wide array of choices suitable for either time. From robust **Grinders** and **Wraps** to substantial **Burgers** and full pasta dishes, it can satisfy any craving at any time of day.
**Perfect for Groups and Private Events:** Its capacity to handle large gatherings, the option of a private dining room, and its appealing atmosphere make it a standout venue for family get-togethers, couples, and local community events. The fact that the establishment accepts **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments** adds a final layer of modern convenience.

In essence, Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant offers the best of both worlds: the casual comfort of a local pizza spot merged with the quality and extensive menu of a fine Italian establishment. It’s a dedicated and reliable staple for Mahopac and the surrounding **New York** area.

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Menu

Appetizers
Nacho Platter $13.50
Crispy tortilla chips covered with melted cheese, served with jalapeno peppers, chopped tomatoes, olives & scallions with salsa & sour cream.
Nacho Platter With Chicken $17.00
Chips with cheese and a variety of toppings.
Coconut Shrimp $13.95
Coconut breaded shrimp served with orange marmalade.
Hot Antipasto $21.95
Clams casino, stuffed mushrooms & fried calamari.
Bruschetta $10.50
Grilled bread topped with fresh chopped tomatoes, garlic, basil and olive oil.
Mozzarella Sticks $11.95
Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried. Served with marinara sauce.
Baked Potato Skins $12.95
Topped with melted cheese & bacon.
Clams Casino $13.95
Pimentos, garlic butter sauce & bacon.
Zuppa Di Mussels $16.90
Served in red or white sauce.
Zuppa Di Clams $19.15
Served in red or white sauce.
Hot Spinach & Artichoke Dip $13.95
Served with tortilla chips & garlic bread.
Buffalo Wings $13.50
Spicy wings served with bleu cheese & celery sticks.
Fried Calalmari $16.50
Cooked in oil.
Zucchini Sticks $11.95
Garlic Bread $6.95
Buttery bread that is topped with garlic.
Garlic Bread With Cheese $7.95
Mozzarella Caprese $14.95
Fresh mozzarella layered with fresh tomatoes, prosciutto, roasted peppers, drizzled with extra virgin olive oil.
Broccoli Rabe, Sausage & Potatoes With Garlic & Oil $18.95
Cheeseburger Sliders $14.50
Sauteed onions.
Fried Mac N Cheese $15.95
Hand-rolled & crusted with panko & Parmesan.
Appetizer Sampler $18.05
Mozzarella sticks, Buffalo wings & zucchini sticks.

Soup
French Onion Soup $7.50
Soup that is made with stock, onions, and covered with either cheese, bread, or croutons.

Salads
Individual Tossed Salad $5.60
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & cucumbers.
Small Tossed Salad $10.25
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & cucumbers.
Large Tossed Salad $12.80
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions & cucumbers.
Individual Greek Salad $6.75
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, peppers & feta cheese.
Small Greek Salad $13.25
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, peppers & feta cheese.
Large Greek Salad $16.25
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, Kalamata olives, peppers & feta cheese.
Small Antipasto Salad $14.25
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, peppers, Kalamata olives, cucumbers, mozzarella cheese, ham, salami, egg with anchovies.
Large Antipasto Salad $17.25
Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, peppers, Kalamata olives, cucumbers, mozzarella cheese, ham, salami, egg with anchovies.
Small Caesar Salad $10.25
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese & croutons tossed in our homemade Caesar dressing.
Large Caesar Salad $12.75
Romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese & croutons tosses in our homemade Caesar dressing.
Cobb Salad $19.15
Lettuce, tomatoes, bacon, Gorgonzola, egg, avocado & grilled chicken, with our homemade balsamic vinaigrette.
Tuscan Chicken Salad $19.15
Grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mushrooms, penne pasta, fresh tomatoes & Parmesan cheese served over lettuce with our Tuscan vinaigrette.
Thai Chicken Salad $17.50
Romaine lettuce, onions, tomatoes & Cajun grilled chicken topped with cherry peppers & toasted peppers, served in a tortilla shell with Caesar dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Salad $19.15
Lettuce, onions, tomatoes, gorgonzola & shredded cheddar topped with breaded Buffalo chicken strips.
Santa Fe Chicken Salad $19.15
Lettuce, tomatoes, corn, black beans & cheddar cheese topped with grilled chicken & tri-colored tortilla chips, served with ranch dressing.
Grilled Salmon Salad $21.95
Baby mixed greens, red onions, roasted almonds & cranberries with orange vinaigrette.
Fried Goat Cheese Salad $19.15
Mixed greens, beets, red onions & almonds with homemade vinaigrette.
Caprese Salad $17.50
Mixed greens, fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, roasted peppers & basil with our balsamic vinaigrette.
Lakeside Salad $19.15
Mixed greens, cranberries, Gorgonzola, sliced almonds and grilled chicken with balsamic vinaigrette.

Sandwiches
Chicken Sorrentino Sandwich $15.75
Grilled chicken with roasted peppers, eggplant & melted mozzarella cheese on a roll.
Diparma Sandwich $16.50
Crispy chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, mixed greens & balsamic vinaigrette on a toasted Ciabatta roll.
Greek Gyro $15.75
Served with grilled chicken or beef, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & tzatziki sauce in a pita.

Grinders
Steak Grinder $15.50
NY strip with mayo, melted cheese & sauteed onions & peppers.
Cheeseburger Grinder $14.50
Served with melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & mayo.
Grilled Chicken Grinder $13.50
Served with melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & our own special dressing.
Italian Combo Grinder $13.50
Pepperoni, salami, ham, served with melted cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & our own special dressing.
Chicken Parm Grinder $12.75
Breaded chicken, tomato sauce, and cheese grinder.
Sausage Parm Grinder $13.50
Served with peppers & onions.
Meatball Parm Grinder $11.95
Grinder with seasoned meat that has been rolled into a ball topped with tomato sauce and cheese.
Eggplant Parm Grinder $12.50
Eggplant topped with cheese and tomato sauce.

Wraps
Chicken Caesar Wrap $15.75
Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken & onions with Caesar dressing.
Four Brothers Wrap $15.75
Chicken with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, bacon, Russian dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Wrap $15.75
Buffalo chicken with lettuce & tomatoes.
Philly Cheesesteak Wrap $16.50
Sauteed onions, peppers & American cheese.
The Farmhouse Wrap $15.75
Fried goat cheese, roasted peppers & mixed greens with balsamic vinaigrette.

Burgers
Hamburger $15.25
Grilled or fried patty on a bun.
Cheeseburger $16.40
Grilled or fried patty with cheese on a bun.
California Burger $18.05
Avocado, bacon & red onions.
Four Brothers Burger $19.15
Bacon, mushrooms, onions & American cheese.
Turkey Burger $17.50
Swiss cheese & sauteed mushrooms.

Pizzas
Mozzarella Pizza
Four Brothers Special Pizza
Pepperoni, onions, peppers, mushrooms, meatballs & sausage.

Gourmet Pizzas
Clam Pizza
Clams, garlic, spices, ricotta & mozzarella cheese.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni, meatballs, ham & bacon.
Hawaiian Pizza
Ham, sliced pineapple & mozzarella cheese.
Salad Pizza
Lettuce, fresh tomatoes, red onions, sliced olives & mozzarella cheese.
Tuscany Pizza
Spinach & breaded chicken.
Vegetarian Pizza
Onions, peppers, mushrooms, eggplant, artichoke hearts, fresh tomatoes & mozzarella cheese.
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo chicken strips with Buffalo sauce, with or without tomato sauce.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Breaded chicken with crispy bacon & mozzarella, drizzled with ranch dressing.
Broccoli Rabe Pizza
Broccoli rabe, sliced sausage, garlic, olive oil, mozzarella cheese & hot cherry peppers.
Small Gluten Free Pizza $13.50

Pastas
Spaghetti With Meatballs $19.15
Long thing pasta.
Spaghetti With Sausage $19.15
Long thing pasta.
Cheese Tortellini In Meat Sauce $21.50
Ring shaped pasta.
Cheese Ravioli In Marinara Sauce $19.25
Stuffed pasta.
Fettuccine Alfredo $21.50
Served in cream sauce with parmesan cheese.
Penne Ala Vodka $21.50
Marinara sauce with a touch of cream & vodka.
Linguine Bolognese $23.70
Sauteed ground pork, beef & veal in a marinara with a touch of cream.
Penne Napolitano $23.70
Penne pasta tossed with fresh tomatoes, grilled chicken & fresh mozzarella in garlic parmesan sauce.
Vegetarian Pasta $22.55
Spinach, pea, mushrooms & roasted peppers with roasted garlic & charred tomatoes.
Pasta Bella $23.70
Fettuccine tossed with chicken, tomatoes, basil, garlic & olive oil, topped with mozzarella cheese.
Penne & Broccoli Rabe $21.40
Garlic & olive oil.
Tortellini Papalino $23.70
Peas, proscuitto, garlic and Alfredo sauce.
Pasta Basilico $20.30
Plum tomatoes, basil, garlic and olive oil with pecorino Romano tossed with angel hair.

Parmigiana
Eggplant Parmigiana $20.90
Chicken Parmigiana $22.50

Parmesan Casserole
Meat Lasagna $18.25
Layered dish with wide flat pasta.
Baked Ziti $18.25
Smooth tube shaped pasta.
Eggplant Casserole $18.25
Served with mozzarella, ricotta & tomato sauce.

Meats
NY Strip Steak Campagnola $36.50
16 oz. Sauteed with peppers, onions & potatoes.
Steak Madiera $36.50
16 oz. New York strip with sauteed onions, mushrooms and Madiera wine.
Pork Chops Campagnola $28.50
Sauteed with peppers, onions & pan fried potatoes.
Pork Chops Scarpariello $28.50
Center cut pork chops broiled & topped with hot cherry peppers, garlic & pan fried potatoes.

Seafood
Linguine With Clam Sauce $24.50
Ribbon pasta with red or white. Substitute whole wheat penne for additional charge.
Stuffed Filet Of Sole $27.10
Stuffed with crab meat.
Filet Of Sole Francaise $25.95
Egg-dipped, sauteed with white wine, butter, lemon & shallots.
Mussels Marinara $23.50
Seved over linguine. Substitute whole wheat penne for additional charge.
Calamari Marinara $24.50
Served over linguine. Substitute whole wheat penne for additional charge.
Zuppa Di Pesce $39.99
Clams, shrimp, calamari & mussels in a marinara sauce over linguine. Substitute whole wheat penne for an additional charge.
Shrimp Scampi $26.95
Sauteed in garlic butter, olive oil & white wine sauce over linguine. Substitute whole wheat penne for an additional charge.
Grilled Salmon $27.10
Grilled salmon served over a bed of sauteed spinach.
Shrimp Diablo $26.50
Sauteed shrimp with garlic in a spicy marinara sauce, served over angel hair pasta. Substitute whole wheat penne for an additional charge.

Children's Menu
Kids Cheeseburger Sliders $11.75
Served with fries.
Kids Pasta With Meatball $10.25
Ball of seasoned meat.
Kids Pasta With Sausage $10.25
Finely chopped or ground meat mixed with seasoning.
Kids Pasta With Tomato Sauce $8.25
Kids Chicken Fingers & Fries $11.25
Breaded or battered crispy chicken.
Kids Cheese Ravioli $10.25
Stuffed pasta.
Kids Chicken Parmigiana With Pasta $11.95
Made or covered with Parmesan cheese.
Kids Mac N Cheese $10.25
Macaroni pasta in a cheese sauce.

Sides
French Fries $5.75
Fried potatoes.
Sweet Potato Fries $6.75
Fried sweet potatoes.
Side Of Sauteed Broccoli $6.75
Cooked in oil or fat over heat.
Side Of Sauteed Spinach $6.75
Cooked in oil or fat over heat.
Side Of Broccoli Rabe $8.25
Side Of Meatballs $6.95
Ball of seasoned meat.
Side Of Sausage $6.95
Finely chopped or ground meat mixed with seasoning.

Desserts
Big Chocolate Cake $11.50
Raspberry White Chocolate Cheese Brulee $8.50
A silken smooth white chocolate cheese, all a-swirl with vibrant red raspberry. Hand-fired and glazed in simple elegance.
Oreo Cookie Bash $8.50
An Oreo cookie universe of white 'n' milk chocolate cream. starry with Oreo chunks and showered with dark chocolate drizzle.
Toasted Almond Cream Cake $8.50
Ladyfingers are delicately soaked in amaretto syrup, layered with imported mascarpone cream, and topped with Italian amaretti cookies and roasted almonds.
Tiramisu $8.50
Clouds of light mascarpone cream on pillows of coffee and rum-soaked lady fingers finished with imported cocoa.This exquisite Tiramisu is a crave-able "pick-me-up".
Big Carrot Cake $11.50
6 layers of incredibly moist carrot cake, sandwiched with our smooth cream cheese icing, all studded with pecans and shards of freshly toasted coconut.
Traditional Apple Pie $7.25
Baked in house. An all time favorite.
Big Cannoli $8.25
Pastry shell internally coated in chocolate and filled with ricotta, candied fruit and chocolate chips.
Bomba $10.50
Classic vanilla and chocolate gelato separated by a cherry and sliced almonds covered in cinnamon, finished with a chocolate coating.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie $8.50

Beverages
Canned Soda $1.90
Choice of flavor.
2 Liter Canned Soda $3.95
Choice of flavor.
Bottled Water $2.50

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Private dining room
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Quiet
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Good for kids birthday
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Photos

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 1

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 2

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 3

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 4

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 5

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 6

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 7

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 8

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Picture 9

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Location

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant

New York Putnam County Mahopac U.S. 6

654 US-6, Mahopac, NY 10541, USA

Four Brothers Pizza Restaurant Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 891 user reviews.

lakepartyfood and serviceroompatiocalamarimusicchicken parmfuneralappetizers

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This is the ninth and final branch of Four Brothers which I review. By far this is one of the most charming locations, set alongside Mahopac lake. The food is exquisite, and the waitstaff friendly. The bathrooms are clean, and there is a full bar with about three beers on draft. In July 2025, former candidate for NY Governor Larry Sharpe appeared at this location.
July 05 · Daniel Donnelly
Preparation is essential to determine if food is delicious in a restaurant. This gorgeous Italian restaurant & bar has plenty of free parking, no reserved, wheelchair accessibility, and restroom. Excellent for large gatherings, couples, and private parties. Excellent bilingual staff, accommodations seating booth or table, overall an excellent vibe. Depending on the meal, all dishes come in medium to small portions. Dessert menus has plenty of options. Highly recommend.
March 09 · Zafiro Acevedo
Atmosphere excellent, beautiful visual and live music. Relaxed friendly patrons. The food was okay, not great, but not bad. The service was not strong. Wasn't crowded and plenty of staff but not available nor looking at tables to see if anyone needed attention. Id still return for scenery and music.... I'll push for service, and I'll try diff food.
September 19 · Manuel Velez
I paid a longoverdue visit to the Four Brothers Pizza Restauranttoday (10-12-2025) and ordereda half-meatball, and half-susageWedge. All I can say, is they are still the best Italian restaurant in Westchester County. Five Stars.I was so happy to see my pal John. My condolence goes out to his father, who I remembered, was a very nice gentleman.
October 12 · Bruce Newkirk
Tonight was a great dining experience. We were very fortunate to get Michelle as our server. She was attentive, precise and warm. I enjoyed the fresh ravioli and the homemade Russian dressing. The place had an excellent energy. Two thumbs up. We will be back.
May 01 · nicholas yannaco