Gelateria Gentile: Authentic Italian Gelato on the Upper West Side

Gelateria Gentile Introduce

For New Yorkers with a craving for a sweet escape, Gelateria Gentile on the Upper West Side offers a truly authentic taste of Italy. This charming ice cream shop is more than just a place to get a scoop; it’s a destination for high-quality, artisanal gelato and a delightful array of traditional Italian pastries and desserts. Stepping inside Gelateria Gentile feels like a mini-vacation to an Italian café, with a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes it the perfect spot to slow down and savor a moment of indulgence. Unlike many commercial ice cream shops, Gelateria Gentile is dedicated to the craft of traditional gelato, ensuring a rich, creamy, and flavorful experience with every bite.

What sets Gelateria Gentile apart is its commitment to authenticity and quality. The gelato is made with care, offering a texture that is both dense and smooth, with flavors that are incredibly rich and true to their ingredients. Beyond the star attraction, the menu is a treasure trove of other Italian delights. From elegant Tiramisu' and Pistachio Tartufo to a variety of fresh pastries like Bocconotto and Cornetto, there's a treat for every palate. The café also serves a full range of high-quality coffee drinks, including classic Italian espresso and cappuccinos, making it a perfect all-day destination whether you're in the mood for a morning pick-me-up or an afternoon treat.

The atmosphere inside Gelateria Gentile is a major part of its charm. It's a casual, cozy, and trendy spot, with tasteful decor and a pleasant ambiance. With a lovely view of Amsterdam Avenue, it's an ideal place to sit and watch the world go by. This combination of a high-quality menu and a relaxing environment makes it a beloved spot for both locals and those just passing through, solidifying its place as a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth in New York City.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Gelateria Gentile is located at 498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024. Its position on the Upper West Side makes it a convenient stop for anyone in the neighborhood. Amsterdam Avenue is a lively street, and the shop is easily accessible on foot for residents and visitors exploring the area. The neighborhood is well-served by public transportation, including nearby subway and bus lines, making it an easy trip from other parts of Manhattan. For those who are simply looking for a quick and rewarding treat while out on a stroll, Gelateria Gentile’s location is ideal.

The shop also features a wheelchair accessible entrance, which is a thoughtful detail that ensures it is welcoming to all members of the community. This commitment to accessibility allows everyone to enjoy the delicious offerings and cozy atmosphere. For a quick visit, whether you're walking by or making a dedicated trip, the location and easy access make Gelateria Gentile a convenient choice.

---

## Services Offered

Takeout: Gelateria Gentile is primarily a takeout spot, with customers able to purchase gelato, pastries, and drinks to enjoy on the go.
Gelato Pints & Quarts: For those who want to bring the deliciousness home, the shop offers gelato in convenient pints and quarts, as well as fresh whipped cream (Panna) in the same sizes.
Dessert & Pastry Sales: The shop offers a wide selection of desserts, including Tiramisu' and various cakes (Torta), as well as pastries like Bocconotto and Cornetto.
Coffee Service: Gelateria Gentile serves a full coffee menu, including authentic Italian espresso, cappuccino, and latte, along with cold brew and iced drinks.
Crepes: The menu also includes a variety of crepes with different fillings like Nutella, pistachio, and custard cream.

---

## Features and Highlights

Authentic Italian Gelato: The main draw of Gelateria Gentile is its high-quality, authentic gelato. Customers rave about the creamy texture and rich flavors, which are a true testament to traditional Italian techniques. The Tartufo Pistachio is a standout favorite.
Diverse Menu of Italian Treats: The offerings extend far beyond gelato. The shop serves a variety of traditional Italian pastries, cakes, and crepes, providing a comprehensive taste of Italian dessert culture. Items like Pistachio Bocconotto and Torta Nera are great examples of their sweet specialties.
Cozy and Casual Atmosphere: The interior is described as warm and inviting, with a tasteful and trendy decor. It's a great place for a quick visit or a brief, relaxing break. The music selection is often noted as being particularly good, adding to the pleasant ambiance.
Full Coffee Menu: In addition to their desserts, the extensive coffee menu makes it a full-service café. The quality of their espresso and other coffee beverages is highly regarded.
Good for Kids: The shop is a great spot for families, offering a fun and delicious treat that kids will love. They even offer special kid’s cups.

---

## What is worth choosing

Choosing Gelateria Gentile is about opting for a truly authentic and high-quality Italian dessert experience. Unlike other generic ice cream shops, this establishment prides itself on the traditional art of gelato making, which results in a product that is denser, smoother, and more flavorful than typical ice cream. This dedication to craft is evident in every bite, making it a worthy indulgence. The pistachio flavor, in particular, has received high praise for its richness and authenticity. Beyond the gelato, the shop's diverse menu of other Italian pastries and desserts, like the delicious Tiramisu and various torta options, means there is always something new to discover and enjoy.

The atmosphere is a huge part of the appeal. It's a cozy and welcoming spot that provides a brief, delightful escape from the hustle and bustle of New York City life. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, people-watch, and enjoy a high-quality treat. The fact that they also serve excellent coffee means you can get your dessert and your caffeine fix all in one place. Whether you’re looking for a quick and simple gelato cone, a pint to take home, or a more elaborate pastry, Gelateria Gentile offers a superior and genuine taste of Italy on the Upper West Side.

---

## Contact Information

Address: 498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Phone: (646) 398-7171

Gelateria Gentile Menu

Gelato (Online)
Gelato Pint $20.00
Choose 1 or 2 of our top gelato or vegan sorbet flavors. Creamy, fresh, and made with the best ingredients for an authentic Italian treat!
Gelato Quart $40.00
Choose 1 to 3 of our top gelato or vegan sorbet flavors. Creamy, fresh, and made with the best ingredients for an authentic Italian treat!
Baby Cones (10 Pieces) $3.00
Mini crispy cones, perfect for creating bite-sized gelato treats at home with your favorite pint or quart
Frappe' (Italian Milkshake) $8.50
A rich and creamy blended drink made with our artisanal gelato and fresh milk for a perfectly smooth texture
Panna Pint (Fresh Whipped Cream) $21.00
Light, airy, and made fresh daily for the perfect finishing touch to any dessert
Panna Quart (Fresh Whipped Cream) $42.00
Light, airy, and made fresh daily for the perfect finishing touch to any dessert
Wafer Cone $0.75
Light, crispy, and delicately sweet, perfect for enjoying your gelato cones with your favorite pint or quart
Home Made Empty Cone $1.00
Our light, crispy homemade cone, perfect to pair with your favorite pint or quart

Dessert/Semifreddi (Online)
Tiramisu' $10.00
Classic Italian dessert served in a ready-to-enjoy cup. Made with the traditional recipe for a perfect balance of creamy mascarpone, espresso-soaked ladyfingers, and a dusting of cocoa
Coffee Tartufo $9.00
A ready-to-enjoy dessert with Coffee and Milk cream gelato, finished with a rich Nutella glaze
Pistachio Tartufo $9.00
A ready-to-enjoy dessert with Pistachio and Stracciatella gelato, coated in a rich pistachio glaze
Cassata Cake $9.00
A slice of cassata cake with Crema Antica and Chocolate gelato, sour cherries, sponge cake soaked in Strega liqueur, and cassata semifreddo with chocolate chips, candied fruits, and nuts
Torta Croccante $55.00
A dessert with an almond biscuit base, Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate mousse, Milk cream gelato, Macadamia nuts, and sour cherries. A frozen dessert, perfect to keep in your freezer and enjoy anytime
Torta Classica $55.00
A dessert with an almond biscuit base, Crema Antica mousse (vanilla with lemon zest), coffee gelato, and a crunchy coffee topping. A frozen dessert, perfect to keep in your freezer
Torta Leggera (Lactose-Free) $55.00
A lactose-free dessert with an almond biscuit base, Bourbon vanilla mousse, raspberry cremoso, and a pistachio crunch. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer.
Torta Straordinaria $60.00
A dessert with Gianduja chocolate mousse, chocolate biscuit, Valrhona Jivara (40%) milk chocolate mousse, butter salted caramel, and macadamia nuts. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer
Torta Luna Rossa $55.00
A dessert with an almond biscuit base, Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate and tonka bean mousse, and a mixed berries cremoso. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer
Torta 5 Sensi $60.00
A dessert featuring Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate mousse, Valrhona Jivara (40%) milk chocolate mousse, Valrhona Madagascar (74%) dark chocolate mousse, and Gianduja praliné. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer.
Torta Tradizionale $60.00
A dessert with a chocolate biscuit base, pistachio mousse, chocolate gelato, and a crunchy pistachio topping. A frozen dessert, perfect to keep in your freezer and enjoy anytime!
Limited Edition - Torta Solstizio D'Estate $60.00
Limited Edition special dessert with an almond biscuit base soaked with Pineapple juice, Valrhona Ivoire (35%) white chocolate and coconut from Sulu' Island mousse, and Mango and Passion Fruit cremoso. Perfect to enjoy from the fridge or freezer

Pastry/Dolci (Online)
Torta Nera – Italian Chocolate Cake $6.00
An indulgent slice of rich, velvety chocolate cake, crafted from a secret family recipe passed down for generations
Pistachio Bocconotto $4.75
A traditional cream-filled shortcrust pastry with rich pistachio cream for a perfectly nutty and flavorful bite.
Crema & Amarena Bocconotto $4.75
A traditional cream-filled shortcrust pastry with velvety custard and tart Amarena cherries, lightly dusted with powdered sugar for a perfect balance of sweetness and flavor
Salted Caramel Bocconotto $4.75
A traditional cream-filled chocolate shortcrust pastry with silky salted caramel cream for the perfect sweet-and-salty balance.
Bocconotto Pugliese - Coffee & Almond Cream $4.75
A traditional cream-filled shortcrust pastry with smooth coffee and almond cream for a rich, aromatic flavor
Gocciolato $4.50
Soft, fluffy brioche studded with Chocolate chips
Brioches $4.00
Soft, fluffy, house-made Brioches bun
Cornetto Empty $4.00
Flaky Italian croissant with a delicate, buttery texture, perfect on its own or paired with your favorite coffee
Chocolate Cornetto $4.00
Flaky Italian croissant filled with creamy chocolate
Pastry Cream Cornetto $4.00
Flaky Italian croissant filled with rich custard cream and topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar
Flan - Vanilla & Chocolate $4.75
Rich chocolate shortbread crust filled with smooth, creamy vanilla flan
Sporcamuss (Crispy Puff Pastry) $8.75
A traditional dessert from Bari (Italy), made with crispy puff pastry, filled with rich custard cream, and topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar. Warm it up briefly in the oven (Grill mode) for a softer, creamier filling and the best experience. A true taste of Apulian tradition!
Corona Pistachio & Raspberry $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with rich Pistachio cream and Raspberry jelly, topped with a luscious Pistachio glaze
Corona Tiramisu' $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with creamy tiramisu' filling and coffee sauce, finished with a dusting of cocoa powder
Corona Hazelnut $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with smooth Hazelnut cream and topped with a rich dark chocolate Macadamia glaze
Cuoricini Gift Box (20 Pcs) $19.00
A delightful box of 20 heart-shaped shortbread cookies, chocolate and vanilla. Perfect for sharing or gifting
Praline Gift Box (3 Pcs) $8.00
A trio of rich chocolate truffles infused with rhum, perfect for gifting or indulging
Pugliesini Cookies Gift Box (10 Pcs) $19.00
Apulian almond cookies with a delicate citrusy flavor
Baresini Cookies Gift Box (10 Pcs) $19.00
Apulian almond cookies made with fig Vincotto and dried figs for a rich, authentic Italian flavor
Corona Tropicale - Pineapple & Coconut Cream $7.50
Sourdough brioche bun filled with pineapple and coconut cream, glazed with white chocolate and topped with coconut flakes and dried pineapple

Crepes (Online)
Zucchero/Classic Crepes $8.00
Classic soft freshly made crepes topped with a light dusting of powdered sugar
Nutella Crepes $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with warm, creamy Nutella
Pistachio Crepes $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with warm, creamy pistachio spread
White Chocolate Crepes $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with warm, creamy white chocolate
Crema Gentile Crepes (Handmade Custard Cream) $10.00
Soft, freshly made crepes filled with our warm handmade Custard Cream

Savory (Online)
Focaccia $5.50
A classic Italian focaccia topped with ripe tomatoes, black olives, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil for a flavorful, rustic bite
Savory Bocconotto – Tomato & Parmigiano $4.75
A traditional savory shortcrust pastry filled with tomato jelly and creamy Parmigiano béchamel, for a rich and authentic Italian bite. Best enjoyed warm, heated in the oven or microwave.

Caffetteria (Online)
Hot Chocolate $5.50
Our homemade Italian-style hot chocolate, rich, velvety, and perfect for warming up your day
Latte $5.00
Espresso $3.75
Cappuccino $4.50
Macchiato $4.00
Americano $3.50
Cafe' Mocha $5.50
Chai Latte $5.00
Cold Brew Coffee $4.50
Double Espresso $4.50
Drip Coffee $3.00
Hot Tea $3.75
Iced Americano $4.00
Iced Espresso $4.25
Iced Latte $5.00
Iced Tea $4.00

Sodas (Online)
Water Bolle Lurisia $3.00
Water Stille Lurisia $3.00
Lurisia Chinotto $3.50
Lurisia Orange $3.50

Gelateria Gentile Details

Service options
Takeout
Delivery

Popular for
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Table service

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Planning
Quick visit

Children
Good for kids

Gelateria Gentile Photos

Gelateria Gentile Location

Gelateria Gentile

New York New York County New York Amsterdam Avenue

498 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, USA

Gelateria Gentile Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 129 user reviews.

pistachiopastriescoffeeconehazelnutcrepedark chocolateflavorflantartufo

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We stumbled upon this charming café and decided to try the Tartufo Pistachio—it was absolutely delicious! The gelato was incredibly creamy, rich in flavor, and a delightful treat. The café has a lovely view of the street, making it a great spot to relax and watch the world go by. Inside, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, with tasteful decor and well-arranged tables, creating the perfect setting for a leisurely afternoon. If you're looking for a cozy spot with high-quality gelato, this place is definitely worth a visit!
April 27 · Maryam Bojarian
The musics inside were nice. The gelato was creamy and flavorful. They have kid’s cup and classic cup. It’s just a few dollars different. They also have other pastries available. Lovely atmosphere. Whoever picked the musics has good taste too. :)The napkins are not very absorbent in my opinion.
April 13 · G Frye
This is my favorite Gelato spot!I visited Gentile today and it was such a pleasant surprise, the staff was really nice and kind, very gentile, they allowed me to try some of the flavors and that made my decision even harder. I got a wafer cone with fragola è stracciatella, very classic combo but really tasty. The cones are beautiful and they give you a small cute cone on top.
July 01 · Sophie Hill
A Disappointing Experience at Geltaria – Not Worth the HypeI had high hopes for this visit to Geltaria and even raved about it to an elder in my family, eager to share what I remembered as amazing service and delicious gelato. Unfortunately, today’s experience was a complete letdown.Despite four employees being within eyesight, only one was actively serving customers. Shockingly, this same employee wiped his eyes and nose with his service gloves—a major hygiene red flag. The staff seemed confused about basic operations, and no one appeared ready or willing to step in to assist.After waiting more than 15 minutes, we were finally served, but the interaction was awkward and frustrating. The employee acted as though he couldn’t understand my order, and when I raised my voice slightly to clarify, he became visibly offended. I asked for an additional cup to serve my elder, but was given one the exact same size as mine. I reminded him that I had already paid for a cup and was just asking for a second one for convenience. Rather than asking clarifying questions, he once again acted offended, claiming not to understand the request.I then asked about the remaining pastries. Instead of providing an answer or checking, the employee stated I would “just need to walk around and see for myself,” even as another customer with a stroller stood nearby waiting. Rather than offering help, he walked away without so much as a thank you.To top things off, when I asked another employee for the name of the person who served me, I was told, “I’m new, I don’t know his name.” When I asked how he could be working with a stranger, he simply replied, “Yes.”All in all, this visit was marked by poor hygiene, long wait times, and astonishingly bad customer service. The gelato melted quickly, and the entire interaction left a sour taste in my mouth.There are at least three other gelato or ice cream spots within a four-block radius. If you’re looking for sticky gloves, confusion, and rudeness—by all means, line up here. Otherwise, save your time and go elsewhere
May 03 · Creative Solutions
A great gelateria reminiscent of gelato places in Italy. Gelato flavors held in silver pots, and flavors listed in Italian. A wide variety of flavors both milk/cream based and fruit flavors. Lots of seating, a warm environment, and a tasty assortment of pastries that I'll have to try next time. My small cup of stracciatela was 8$.
March 14 · Joseph Hewes