Island Shack

- 87 S Elliott Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11217

For New Yorkers craving the warm, vibrant flavors of the Caribbean, Island Shack stands out as a true culinary gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn. More than just a restaurant, it's a destination that transports you straight to the islands with every bite. Specializing in authentic Caribbean cuisine, Island Shack has quickly established itself as a beloved local spot in the Fort Greene neighborhood. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted with a cozy atmosphere and the intoxicating aromas of perfectly seasoned Jerk spices and slow-cooked stews, making it an essential experience for anyone seeking authentic island flavor in the city. The focus here is on delivering a quality dining experience that combines genuine hospitality with a menu full of comfort food favorites and inventive dishes, ensuring both regulars and newcomers feel right at home. It’s an ideal setting whether you’re planning a relaxed weekend meal or a quick, satisfying bite during a busy weekday.

The menu is a rich tapestry of island favorites, celebrated for their authentic preparation and generous portions. From the succulent Oxtail that falls off the bone to the spicy, smokey flavor of their signature Jerk Chicken, Island Shack ensures every dish is prepared with passion and a commitment to traditional recipes. Beyond the classics, you'll find creative interpretations like their popular Island Shack Pasta, which you can enjoy with protein options such as Jerk Shrimp or Jerk Salmon. This dedication to both traditional and modern Caribbean cooking is what makes Island Shack a standout establishment in the competitive New York food scene, cementing its reputation as a must-try local haunt. For those familiar with the cuisine, the offering of local specialty items like Bake & Shark and various Roti preparations provides a taste of home, while newcomers will find an accessible and exciting introduction to the diverse world of Caribbean flavors.

Island Shack is ideally situated at 87 S Elliott Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11217. This prime address places it firmly in the desirable and historic Fort Greene neighborhood, known for its tree-lined streets, brownstones, and vibrant cultural scene. The restaurant’s setting benefits from the area's lively atmosphere, providing a welcoming backdrop for dining. Its location on S Elliott Pl makes it easily accessible for Brooklyn residents and visitors alike.

For those traveling via public transit, the restaurant is conveniently located near several major subway lines, a key factor for accessibility in New York City. The proximity to transportation hubs makes it a hassle-free destination for lunch, dinner, or a casual weekend meal. Whether you’re coming from Manhattan or another borough, reaching this Fort Greene hotspot is straightforward, encouraging repeat visits from locals. Driving is also an option, though, as with any central Brooklyn location, street parking may require some patience. The neighborhood itself offers a pleasant walk, allowing diners to enjoy the local architecture and atmosphere before or after their meal. The mention of its location on a street with a "Square's open area out front," as one customer noted, further enhances its appeal as a pleasant spot to gather and dine, especially with the option of Outdoor seating when the weather is fine.

Island Shack is dedicated to serving the diverse needs of the New York community, offering a comprehensive range of service options designed for convenience and comfort.

• Dine-in: Enjoy the full, cozy, and trendy atmosphere with comfortable Seating and Table service. It’s a great spot for Groups to gather.
• Outdoor Seating: Perfect for enjoying a meal or a cocktail on a pleasant Brooklyn day, taking advantage of the lovely neighborhood setting.
• Takeout: Place your order and pick up your meal quickly and conveniently. Ideal for those who want to enjoy the flavors of Island Shack at home or on the go.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers reliable Delivery options, ensuring your favorite Caribbean dishes can be enjoyed without leaving your apartment or office.
• No-contact delivery: For maximum safety and convenience, this option is available to customers.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: Open for both major meals, making it a reliable spot for a midday break or an evening feast. Dessert options are also available to round out your meal.
• Bar Service: Features a fully stocked Bar onsite with a focus on great cocktails, beer, and hard liquor.
• NFC Mobile Payments: Easy and modern payment options are available, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Family Friendly: High chairs are available, making it suitable for families dining out.

What truly sets Island Shack apart and draws customers back time and again is its distinct combination of efficiency, quality, and genuine island charm.

• Fast Service: A noted highlight, ensuring that even during busy lunch or dinner rushes, your order is handled efficiently, making it perfect for a Quick bite.
• Great Cocktails & Happy Hour: The bar is a major draw. Customers rave about the expertly mixed Cocktails, making it an exciting spot for an evening out. The availability of Happy hour drinks adds even more incentive to visit. One review specifically praises the "delicious drinks" and the "excitement" of the bar area.
• Serves Local Specialty: Island Shack prides itself on offering authentic dishes that reflect the richness of Caribbean, and particularly Trinidadian (Trini), cuisine. The inclusion of items like Mini Bake & Shark, Doubles, and Trini Corn Soup showcases this commitment to authentic island fare. The customer who said, "That was the best Bake and Shark I’ve had in the city," confirms the authenticity and quality.
• Comfort Food: The menu is packed with satisfying, hearty Comfort food, including generous portions of Oxtail, Curry Goat, and the ever-popular Macaroni Pie side.
• Vegetarian Options: The inclusion of extensive Vegetarian options such as the Indian Rasta Bowl, Trini Sunday Bowl, and Vegetable Roti ensures a welcoming menu for all dietary preferences.
• Trendy and Casual Vibe: The Casual yet Trendy Atmosphere—described by one guest as having a "beautiful island vibe"—provides an inviting and enjoyable dining experience for all.

Here is how you can connect with the team at Island Shack to place an order, make a reservation, or simply inquire about the menu and services:

Address: 87 S Elliott Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA

Phone: (347) 987-4832

Mobile Phone: +1 347-987-4832

When deciding on your next dining spot in New York, particularly in the bustling area of Brooklyn, Island Shack provides compelling reasons to choose their authentic Caribbean experience. This is a place that excels in offering a complete, high-quality, and genuinely friendly service that resonates deeply with the local community.

For the uninitiated, the Entrées section is the perfect starting point. You cannot go wrong with the highly-rated Oxtail or the signature Jerk Chicken Meal, which encapsulates the true spirit of island cooking—smokey, tender, and expertly seasoned. Pair any of these with the essential side of Rice & Peas and a creamy, cheesy portion of Macaroni Pie for a truly satisfying and complete meal. The portions are substantial, providing excellent value for the quality of the food.

Adventurous diners or those familiar with the cuisine should explore the Roti and Appetizers. A Curry Goat Roti is a handheld masterpiece of tender meat, flavorful curry, and a soft, flaky wrapper. For an appetizer, the highly praised Mini Bake & Shark is a must-try. As one customer noted, the quality of this specific item is arguably the "best...in the city." Other traditional bites like Doubles and Aloo Pie offer small plates that are ideal for sharing or a Quick bite.

Beyond the food, a visit to Island Shack is as much about the environment as it is about the meal. The atmosphere is consistently described as a "beautiful island vibe" and a place where you "feel like you’re home with family." This friendly, welcoming service—highlighted by a reviewer who praised the staff for their "bubbly and beautiful" energy and excellent customer service—is a key element of the experience. It makes Island Shack a fantastic choice for Solo dining as well as for gatherings with Groups.

Finally, no trip to Island Shack is complete without sampling the drinks. The Great cocktails are a standout feature, with original options like the Ma Gloria and Duce Strong Juice. For a non-alcoholic taste of the islands, try a refreshing, house-made drink like the Sorrel or Ginger Beer. The full selection of Beer, including Caribbean favorites like Red Stripe and Carib, further complements the authentic flavors of the meal. In short, Island Shack is an essential Brooklyn experience, blending incredible, authentic food with a lively and welcoming island spirit.

Island Shack

87 S Elliott Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11217, USA