Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown

- 47 Main St # 1F, Tarrytown, NY 10591

Introduction / Overview: Your Tarrytown Pizza Destination

For New Yorkers in the know, especially those residing in or passing through the charming village of Tarrytown in Westchester County, the search for authentic, high-quality pizza and Italian fare often leads straight to Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown. This local establishment has carved out a reputation as a community staple, offering a vibrant, classic pizzeria experience that perfectly blends old-school charm with a diverse, modern menu. It is more than just a place to grab a slice; it’s a full-service Italian restaurant that caters to nearly every craving, from comforting classics to creative specialty dishes.

Located conveniently on the village’s main thoroughfare, Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown is renowned for preparing its food using quality ingredients, with dough and sauce often made from scratch, which is a key component of that true New York-area pizza taste. Whether you're a long-time resident or a tourist exploring the Hudson Valley, this spot offers a reliable and satisfying meal. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual and cozy, making it an excellent choice for solo dining, a family lunch, or a dinner outing with a group of friends or college students from the local area. Customer feedback frequently highlights the perfect combination of a crispy crust, generous toppings, and an overall delicious, memorable pie—with particular praise for their signature specialty pizzas and high-quality gluten-free options.

The menu is expansive, moving beyond standard cheese and pepperoni to include an incredible array of specialty pies, classic Italian pasta dishes, fresh salads, hearty wedges, and grilled entrées. It truly is a comprehensive Italian kitchen offering comfort food and quick bites for lunch and dinner, making it a pivotal dining option for the local New York community.

Location and Accessibility for the New York User

Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown is strategically located at 47 Main St # 1F, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA. This address places it right in the heart of Tarrytown’s bustling downtown area. The Main Street location ensures high visibility and ease of access for anyone traveling through this part of Westchester County, whether they are local commuters or weekend visitors.

Accessibility is an important consideration for any local business in the New York metropolitan area. The restaurant features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that it is welcoming to all members of the community. For those driving, paid street parking is available nearby, which is typical for a prime location in a vibrant New York village center. The central location also makes it highly accessible for pedestrians and those utilizing public transportation in the Tarrytown area.

Services Offered

Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown provides a variety of service options designed for maximum convenience and enjoyment for the New York consumer:

• Dine-in Seating: Enjoy the casual and cozy atmosphere for a relaxing lunch or dinner. The space is equipped with seating and a restroom amenity.
• Delivery (Including No-Contact): For those evenings or afternoons when staying in is preferred, the restaurant offers robust delivery services, including a no-contact option for safety and convenience.
• Takeout: Ideal for commuters or locals grabbing a meal on the go. Customers can easily pick up their orders for a quick bite at home or the office.
• Catering: The extensive menu of pizzas, pasta, entrées, and salads makes this an excellent choice for catering events, meetings, or large family gatherings in the Tarrytown area.
• Reservations Accepted: The restaurant is known to accept reservations, which is particularly helpful for groups planning a dinner outing during peak hours.
• Accepts NFC Mobile Payments: Along with credit cards and debit cards, the convenience of NFC mobile payments is available for swift, modern transactions.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown apart from other dining options in the region is its commitment to variety and quality. Here are some of the establishment's key features:

• Extensive Pizza Selection: The menu is a pizza lover’s dream, offering classic Cheese Pizza, an 18-inch Large Sicilian Pizza, and a huge range of Specialty Pies like Vodka Sauce Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, and the crowd-pleasing Meat Lovers Pizza. They also feature Pizza by the Slice for a quick and satisfying meal.
• The Grandma Pizza Experience: A celebrated feature is the 18-inch Grandma Pizza, a thin-crust Sicilian style. The menu offers creative variations such as Grandma's Fig Pizza, Grandma Philly Cheese Pizza, and Grandma Lasagna Pizza, showcasing an innovative approach to a New York-area classic.
• Accommodation for Dietary Needs: The restaurant is highly accommodating with options like the 12-inch Gluten Free Pizza and the 10-inch Cauliflower Crust, ensuring that nearly everyone can enjoy a delicious Italian meal.
• Full Italian Kitchen: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a wide range of authentic Italian fare, including Pasta dishes (with options like Bolognese, Vodka Sauce, and Clam Sauce), Entrées (such as Marsala, Parmigiana, and Grilled Salmon), and hearty Wedges (Hero sandwiches) and Wraps.
• Family and Crowd Friendly: Known for being a good spot for kids, complete with high chairs, and popular with groups, college students, and tourists, the restaurant fosters a lively and welcoming atmosphere.
• Popular Appetizers: The 6 Pieces Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, and Fried Calamari are essential Italian appetizers and quick bites that are frequently ordered by patrons.
• Desserts: The meal can be capped off with delightful homemade desserts, including Tiramisu, NY Cheesecake, and a unique Nutella Pizza.

Contact Information

To place an order for delivery or takeout, or for general inquiries, New York patrons can reach Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown using the following information:

• Address: 47 Main St # 1F, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA
• Phone: (914) 631-3300 or +1 914-631-3300 (Mobile)

What is Worth Choosing

When navigating the extensive menu at this Tarrytown gem, several categories and specific dishes truly stand out for a local New York user seeking the best experience.

For the Pizza Connoisseur: The Grandma Pizza selection is arguably the crown jewel. Opting for the classic Grandma Pizza with its thin crust and quality sauce, or perhaps the indulgent Grandma Chicken Scarpiello Pizza for a unique twist, is highly recommended. The popularity of the Specialty Pizza Slice is noted in customer feedback, offering a convenient way to sample unique creations like the Philly Cheesesteak pizza or Chicken Parm Pizza without committing to a whole pie. Don't forget their reliable White Pizza or a fully customizable Build Your Own Pizza starting with the excellent Cheese Pizza.

For the Hearty Appetite: The Entrées and Wedges provide substantial and comforting meals. Favorites like Chicken Parmigiana or Veal Hero are a taste of classic Italian-American dining. The pasta section is strong, with the Pasta With Vodka Sauce being a perpetual favorite and the various Italian Pasta Specials offering fantastic value and flavor, such as the Homemade Lasagna Special. The appetizer of 3 Homemade Rice Balls is a must-try for a truly satisfying start.

For Lighter Fare and Sides: Main Street Pizza’s commitment to quality extends to its lighter options. The salads are far from an afterthought, with the Main Street Salad, Cobb Salad, and Arugula Salad providing fresh, full-sized options. On the side, the perfectly cooked Sautéed Broccoli Rabe or the popular 10 Buffalo Wings (a New York-area staple) are perfect complements to any pizza or pasta dish.

In short, Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown has earned its place as a top-tier local pizza and Italian restaurant. It’s a place that understands the New York palate, offering a massive menu of high-quality comfort food with the convenience options of modern dining, ensuring that whether you're dining in or ordering delivery, you're getting a slice of authentic Westchester flavor.

Main Street Pizza of Tarrytown

47 Main St # 1F, Tarrytown, NY 10591, USA