Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge: Authentic Italian Panini, All-Day Brunch, and Gourmet Coffee in Brooklyn

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge Introduce

In the vibrant culinary landscape of Brooklyn, finding a restaurant that perfectly balances authentic Italian tradition with the modern demands of a New York lifestyle is a true find. Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge, located on the bustling 3rd Avenue, stands out as that essential neighborhood gem. While the name immediately conjures images of the classic Italian sandwich—and they certainly deliver on that promise—this establishment is much more than just a panini shop. It is a full-service, all-day Italian cafe and restaurant, perfectly suited for the Bay Ridge community, whether you’re rushing to grab a

Quick bite

or settling in for a cozy

Dinner

with friends.

Panino Rustico has cultivated a reputation for fresh, high-quality ingredients and a surprisingly diverse menu that caters to every craving from morning till evening. From the moment you step inside, the atmosphere is inviting, described by patrons as both

Casual

and

Trendy

, but with a comforting

Cozy

feel that makes everyone feel at home. It’s a place where the rich aromas of Italian espresso and savory grilled meats blend seamlessly.

The heart of the menu, the Panini, are elevated works of art, stuffed with gourmet meats, cheeses, and creative pairings, transforming a simple sandwich into a substantial meal. However, their culinary scope is truly impressive. They offer a comprehensive

All Day Breakfast

menu, perfect for New Yorkers who don't adhere to traditional breakfast hours, alongside a rich selection of

Antipasti

Salads

Homemade Soups

, and even specialized

Savory Crepes

and

Sweet Crepes

. This commitment to variety, coupled with their famous

Fast service

, solidifies their position as a versatile local favorite.

A significant highlight, and one that sets them apart from typical cafes, is their capacity for hosting special gatherings. As one satisfied customer noted, the dedicated

back room for any event

acts as a private, separate space, making Panino Rustico a 10/10 recommendation for everything from a bridal shower to a group celebration. Their ability to accommodate large groups with pre-fixed menus, fair pricing, and no pressure on time underscores a commitment to customer experience that goes above and beyond the daily service of a traditional restaurant.

The full bar, offering

Alcohol

Beer

Cocktails

, and

Wine

, also makes it a prime destination for an evening out or a weekend

Brunch

. For Brooklyn locals, this combination of versatile dining options, quality Italian cuisine, and exceptional service makes Panino Rustico a truly valuable asset to the Bay Ridge community. It’s the perfect place to get your fix of comforting, authentic, and satisfying food.

Location and Accessibility

Panino Rustico is perfectly situated at 8901 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA. This is a prime location in the heart of the Bay Ridge neighborhood, known for its extensive array of dining and retail options. The 3rd Avenue corridor is easily accessible and a central hub for residents and visitors alike.

The restaurant is dedicated to ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. Accessibility features include a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

and

Wheelchair accessible seating

, making it a welcoming dining environment. For planning your visit, the restaurant accepts

Reservations

, which is advisable for dinner or large

Groups

. Whether you prefer dining in, taking food to go, or having it delivered, Panino Rustico offers comprehensive service options:

Dine-in

Takeout

Delivery

, and

No-contact delivery

. Payments are convenient, accepting

Credit cards

Debit cards

, and

NFC mobile payments

Services Offered

Full-Service Dining: Available for
Breakfast
,
Brunch
,
Lunch
,
Dinner
, and
Dessert
with complete
Table service
.
Gourmet Panini and Italian Specialties: The core offering features an extensive menu of signature paninis, as well as
Antipasti
(like
Burrata Caprese
and
Eggplant Caponata
),
Pizza
, and
Philly Cheese Steak
variations.
All-Day Breakfast & Brunch: Providing traditional breakfast fare outside of typical morning hours, including various Omelettes (Western, Italian, Greek), Crepe and Pancrepe dishes, and specialty options like the
Breakfast Panini
.
Full Espresso and Beverage Bar: Serving a wide range of hot and iced coffee drinks, from
Americano
and
Hot Cappuccino
to unique offerings like
Hot Nutella Latte
,
Caffe Frappe
, and
Frozen Hot Chocolate
.
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
is also available.
Bar Service: Featuring a
Bar onsite
with a full menu of
Alcohol
,
Beer
,
Cocktails
, and
Wine
.
Private Event Hosting: Offers a separate, spacious back room that can be reserved for private events and parties, providing a secluded space for celebrations like bridal showers.
Convenient Takeaway Options: Providing
Takeout
,
Delivery
, and
No-contact delivery
for enjoying their
Comfort food
and
Small plates
at home.
Family-Friendly Options: Offers a dedicated
Kid's Menu
with popular selections like
Chicken Fingers
,
All Beef Hot Dog
, and
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
.

Features / Highlights

Authentic & Creative Panini Selection: Specializing in the Italian pressed sandwich with options like
Romanza Special
(Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers & Creamy Basil) and the massive
Fat Panino
(Chicken Tenders, French Fries, Porchetta, Bacon, Mozzarella & Chipotle Mayo).
Gourmet Burrata Dishes: A prominent selection of
Antipasti
featuring Burrata, paired with ingredients like Eggplant, Roasted Peppers, and Truffle Oil, highlighting their use of authentic, high-quality Italian cheeses.
Dedicated Event Space: A major advantage is the separate, large back room suitable for private events, noted for its fair pricing and accommodating service for group functions.
Exceptional Coffee and Desserts: Beyond the main course, they offer a full spectrum of espresso drinks and classic Italian
Desserts
like
Tiramisu Lady Fingers
,
Pistachio Tartufo
, and fresh
Mini Cannoli
, making it an ideal cafe spot.
Fast, Friendly, and Accommodating Service: Customer reviews consistently praise the
Great service
,
Sweet girls
on staff, and their commitment to efficiency, with food coming out
so quickly
.
Versatile Menu for All Day Dining: The ability to serve everything from
Bagel With Cream Cheese, Lox, Tomato & Red Onion
in the morning to a
Flank Steak Strips
wrap in the evening caters to the varied schedule of a New Yorker.

Contact Information

Address: 8901 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Phone: (718) 333-5144

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing what to order at Panino Rustico is half the fun, given the sheer depth of the menu. However, to truly appreciate this Bay Ridge gem, it’s best to sample the items that showcase their Italian roots and New York ingenuity.

First and foremost, you must try one of the namesake Panini. The

Romanza Special

is a highly recommended entry point, perfectly capturing the Italian spirit with Imported Prosciutto, Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers, and the house

Creamy Basil

dressing. For the local looking for a hearty, over-the-top indulgence, the

Fat Panino

—a decadent combination of Chicken Tenders, French Fries, Porchetta, Bacon, Mozzarella, and Chipotle Mayo—is a must-try, quintessential piece of New York comfort food. Its popularity is well-earned for its generous portions and flavor profile.

For those seeking an all-day brunch item, the

Breakfast Panini

with Fried Eggs, Cheddar, Avocado, Bacon & Chipotle Mayo is an excellent, modern twist on the classic morning sandwich, offering a satisfying blend of flavors that works at any hour. Alternatively, for a lighter, authentic Italian start, the

Bagel With Cream Cheese, Lox, Tomato & Red Onion

is their take on a New York deli staple, executed with fresh ingredients.

Beyond the Panini, their

Antipasti

are highly worth exploring. The restaurant is not afraid to feature high-quality cheese, and any of the Burrata-based dishes, such as

Burrata & Roasted Peppers

Burrata Caprese

, provide a fresh, creamy contrast to the rich sandwiches.

Finally, never skip the cafe side of the business. Treat yourself to a specialty coffee like the

Hot Nutella Latte

or the festive

Pumpkin Frozen Hot Chocolate

(when in season), and pair it with a mini

Cannoli

or a piece of their

Tiramisu Lady Fingers

. This Italian restaurant’s ability to satisfy a craving for a traditional Italian dinner, a gourmet sandwich, and a sophisticated coffee break all under one cozy roof is why Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge is worth choosing every time.

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge Food & drink

Coffee & Tea
Tea $1.99
Espresso $4.99
Iced Mocha $4.49
Hot Nutella Latte $5.29
Fresh Brewed Georgia Peach Iced Tea $4.69
NEW!!!!!!
Caffe Frappe $5.24
24oz
Fresh Brewed RASPBERRY Iced Tea $4.69
Caffe Mocha $4.49
Americano $2.99
Hot
Iced Americano $3.99
Macchiato $4.99
Hot Cappuccino $4.99
Affogato $6.99
Double shot of espresso with vanilla gelato.
Vanilla/Chocolate Tartufo $7.99
Pumpkin Frozen Hot Chocolate $5.99
American Coffee $2.49
Homemade Hershey Hot Chocolate $0.00
Unsweetened Iced Tea $3.29
Iced Latte $4.49
Frozen Hot Chocolate $0.00
Iced Nutella Latte $5.89
Hot Latte $4.49
Iced Cappuccino $4.49
Iced Coffee $4.49

Creamy Basil 12oz
12oz Creamy Basil Dressing $12.99
12oz Squeeze bottle of our Homemade creamy basil dressing

All Day Breakfast
Western Omelette $11.99
Ham, yellow American cheese, red bell peppers, white onions and your choice of toast ( specify in order instructions)
Eggs & Yellow Cheese On A Wrap $9.99
Bagel With Butter And Jelly $3.59
Eggs & Yellow Cheese On A Bagel $8.99
Bagel With Butter $3.29
3 Pancrepes With 2 Eggs Any Style $11.99
Crepe batter style pancakes with eggs. Served with a side of butter & maple syrup.
Eggs On A Crepe $9.99
Italian Omlette $11.99
Sausage, Peppers, Onions & Provolone ( please specify toast in order instructions)
Eggs On A Panini $9.88
Bagel With Cream Cheese And Jelly $3.99
Bagel With Cream Cheese $3.59
Eggs & Yellow Cheese On A Crepe $10.99
Eggs & Yellow Cheese On A Panini $10.88
Breakfast Panini- Fried Eggs, Cheddar, Avocado, Bacon & Chipotle Mayo $14.88
American Omlette $11.99
Avocado, yellow American, creamy basil dressing ( please specify toast in order instructions)
Greek Omlette $11.99
Spinach,red onion, tomato & feta cheese ( please specify toast in order instructions)
Bagel With Cream Cheese, Lox, Tomato & Red Onion $11.99
Eggs On A Bagel $7.99
Eggs On A Wrap $8.99

Soda/Water/Juice
Sprite $1.79
12oz Can
Ginger Ale $1.79
12oz Can
Poland Spring Water $1.69
Peach Snapple $2.79
Sparkling Water $2.29
Lemon Tea Snapple $2.79
Manhattan Special $2.99
espresso soda
Diet Peach Snapple $2.79
Coke $1.79
12oz Can
Apple Juice $2.99
Tropicana
Diet Lemon Snapple $2.79
Diet Coke $1.79
12oz Can
San Pellegrino $2.99
Italian Soda
Chocolate Milk $2.99

Philly Cheese Steak
C2 Cheesesteak Hoagie W/Yellow Cheese $13.99
Steak, pepper & onions with yellow cheese on an 10" Amoroso Hoagie roll.
C4 Philly Cheese Steak Hoagie W/Mozzarella Cheese $13.99
Steak, pepper & onions with mozzarella cheese on an 10" Amoroso Hoagie roll.
C1 Cheesesteak Hoagie W/Provolone Cheese $13.99
Steak, pepper & onions with provolone cheese on an 10" Amoroso Hoagie roll.
C3 Cheesesteak Hoagie W/Swiss Cheese $13.99
Steak, pepper & onions with swiss cheese on an 10" Amoroso Hoagie roll.

Homemade Soups
Cream Of Zucchini $8.99
Chicken Noodle $8.99
Potato & Leek Soup $8.99
Lentil Soup $7.99
Pasta Fagioli $7.99
Contains pork
New England Clam Chowder $9.99
New England style chowder. It is thick and creamy and loaded with diced potatoes and minced clams. Contains pancetta.
Italian Wedding Soup $8.49
Broccoli Cheddar Soup $7.99
Split Pea Soup W/Prosciutto $7.49
Cream Of Broccoli $8.99
Cream Of Tomato $8.99
With Chicken & Orzo
Sweet Corn Chowder W/Chicken $8.99

Sides
Parmesan Truffle Fries $8.99
Hot & Crispy
Side Of Grilled Veggies $7.99
Zucchini & Eggplant
Side Of Sautéed Broccoli Rabe $9.49
Homemade Potato Salad $6.99
New 12oz
French Fries $7.99
Hot & Crispy
Side Of Sautéed Spinach $7.59
Sauteed in garlic & olive oil

Bruschetta
B6 $0.00
Bruschetta with eggplant caponata & goat cheese.
B8 $0.00
Bruschetta with asparagus, parmigiana cheese & truffle oil
B1 $0.00
Bruschetta with grape tomato, red onion and fresh basil & extra virgin olive oil
B10 $0.00
Bruschetta with melted mozzarella, grape tomato & basil pesto
B7 $0.00
Bruschetta with melted mozzarella, grape tomato, fresh basil & extra virgin olive oil

Desserts
Vanilla Gelato $3.99
per scoop
Panini Nutella $6.99
Nutella Panini
Pistachio Tartufo $7.99
Mini Cannoli $1.99
7 Layer Cookie $1.49
French Cannoli $2.00
Flakey Cookie stuffed with Nutella
NY Cheese Cake $7.99
Large Cannoli $3.99
Chocolate Mousse $7.99
Raspberry Tart $2.99
Sprinkle Cookie $1.79
Chocolate dipped Sprinkle cookie stuffed with raspberry jam
Tiramisu Lady Fingers $7.99
Nutella Tart $2.99
Nutella stuffed tart
Linzer Tart $2.99

Pizza
Pizza $11.99
10" Margarita style pie.

Sweet Crepes
S12 $10.49
Fresh strawberry & smuckers strawberry preserve crepe
S8 $9.49
Reeses peanut butter & Welches grape jelly crepe
S7 $8.99
Butter & powdered sugar crepe
S13 $10.49
Fresh blueberry & smuckers blueberry preserve crepe
S11 $10.99
Nutella & fresh fruit crepe
S9 $10.99
Homemade apple cinnamon & nutmeg crepe
S6 $8.99
Lemon & powdered sugar crepe
S10 $9.99
Nutella Crepe
S14 $9.99
Butter, powdered sugar, maple syrup & cinnamon crepe
S15 $10.99
Cannoli cream, nutella & fresh strawberries

Panini
P35 $17.38
Turkey panini with fontina cheese, bacon, avocado & homemade creamy basil dressing
P43 $16.88
Sausage And Melted Provolone Cheese with Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
P37 $16.88
Grilled chicken panini with pepperjack cheese, bacon & ranch dressing
P54 Chicken Parmigiana $17.88
P48 $19.88
Flank Steak strips, melted Mozzarella with pepper & onions
P39 $15.38
Grilled Chicken & Melted Mozzarella
P49 $19.88
Flank Steak Strips, Provolone cheese with sauteed Broccoli rabe
P23 $16.88
Cured beef with grana cheese, baby arugula & extra virgin olive oil
P21 $14.88
Grana cheese, toscano cheese and fontina cheese panini with truffle oil
P8 $15.88
Grilled eggplant & zucchini panini with grana cheese, balsamic & extra virgin olive oil
P36 $16.88
Grilled chicken panini with goat cheese, avocado & balsamic glaze
P29. $16.38
Hot soppresata panini with smoked mozzarella & fire roasted red peppers
BLT Panini $13.88
(Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo)
P38 $18.38
Grilled chicken panini with fontina cheese, bacon, hot cherry peppers, avocado & honey mustard dressing
P22 $16.88
Porchetta panini with baby arugula, extra virgin olive oil & sea salt
P46 $16.88
Chicken tenders, American yellow cheese, pepper-jack cheese, bacon, red onion & chipotle mayonnaise
P52 Meatball Parmigiana $17.88
Contains pork
P24 $16.88
Prosciutto panini with smoked mozzarella, sun dried tomato and fresh basil leaves
Everything Pizza Panini $12.49
Melted fontina cheese, sun-dried tomato spread, fresh basil leaves and extra virgin olive oil all on an EVERYTHING PANINI!
P33 $17.88
Hot pastrami panini with swiss cheese, pickles & mustard
P31 $15.38
Genoa salami panini with provolone cheese & mustard
P17 $16.88
Prosciutto panini with fontina cheese, red onion, fresh basil leaves & extra virgin olive oil
P16 $18.38
Smoked salmon panini with goat cheese, red onion, avocado and truffle oil
P41 $16.88
Grilled chicken panini with fontina cheese, avocado & sun dried tomato
Earth Day Special $13.88
Avocado, sun dried tomato, red onion, arugula, sliced tomato, extra virgin olive oil & sea salt.
P25 $16.88
Grilled chicken panini with smoked mozzarella & sun dried tomato
P42 $16.88
Sausage, Melted Mozzarella & Sauteed Red Bell Peppers & Onions
P32 $15.38
Turkey panini with provolone cheese, tomato & mustard
Oceans 11- Italian Tuna , Avocado , Roasted Peppers, Arugula & Oil $15.88
P20 $17.88
Grilled chicken panini, melted mozzarella, roasted red peppers, arugula & basil pesto
P50 $20.88
Flank Steak Strips, Yellow American cheese, Pepper-jack cheese, Bacon, Red Onion & Chipotle mayo
Bensonhurst BLT - Grilled Chicken, Cheddar, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo & Balsamic Vinegar $16.38
P3 $15.88
Sopressata panini with fontina cheese & baby arugula
P30 $15.38
Ham panini with melted swiss, tomato, lettuce & mayonnaise
P9 $15.38
Prosciutto cotto panini with melted mozzarella, tomato & mayonaise
P45 Burrata, Tomato, Basil, Glaze $15.38
Burrata cheese, tomato, fresh basil leaves, extra virgin olive oil and balsamic glaze
Romanza Special- Imported Prosciutto , Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers & Creamy Basil $15.88
P15 $13.88
Melted mozzarella panini with tomato, fresh basil leaves & extra virgin olive oil
P51 $18.38
Flank Steak Strips and Melted Mozzarella
Fat Panino - Chicken Tenders, French Fries, Porchetta, Bacon, Mozzarella & Chipotle Mayo $17.49
Chicken tenders, french fries, porchetta, bacon, mozzarella & chipotle mayo
P44 Burrata & Prosciutto $18.38
Buratta cheese panini with prosciutto, fire roasted red peppers & truffle oil
P5 $15.88
Italian tuna panini with red onion, tomato & extra virgin olive oil
Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella & Roasted Peppers $15.88
P4 $15.88
Italian tuna panini with red onion & black olive spead
P26 $17.38
Grilled chicken panini with melted mozzarella & sauteed broccoli rabe
P40 $16.38
Grilled eggplant and zucchini panini with black olives, mozzarella, fire roasted red peppers, fresh basil and balsamic glaze
P18 $16.38
Prosciutto panini with melted mozzarella, tomato & basil pesto
P34 $16.88
Hot homemade roast beef with melted mozzarella & gravy
P28 $16.88
Hot roast beef panini with melted mozzarella, sun dried tomato & extra virgin olive oil
BKLYN Lent Special:Zucchini, Eggplant, Burrata, Roasted Peppers, Arugula & Balsamic GlaZe $14.99
P12 $15.88
Imported Mortadella panini with goat cheese, baby arugula & mayonnaise.
P11 $15.88
Turkey panini with fire roasted red pepper & fontina cheese
P27 $18.38
Porchetta panini with smoked mozzarella & sauteed broccoli rabe

Salads
E2 $0.00
Baby arugula, parmigiana cheese, cherry tomatoes, cranberries tossed in lemon & olive oil
E6 $0.00
Spring mix, granny smith apples, cranberries, walnuts mixed in balsamic fig glaze
E5 $0.00
Caesar Salad ( romaine lettuce, croutons, shaved parmigiana cheese and creamy Caesar dressing)
Summer Salad $0.00
Spring mix, Apples, Strawberries, Blueberries, Sun-dried Cranberries, Goat Cheese, Buratta with Fig Glaze
E8 $0.00
Spring mix, grape tomatoes, cranberries, walnuts, avocado tossed in balsamic vinegar & olive oil
E1 $0.00
Spring mix, strawberries, goat cheese, candied walnuts & balsamic fig glaze
E4 $0.00
Romaine lettuce, avocado, tomato tossed in homemade ginger dressing
E9 $0.00
Romaine lettuce, feta cheese, cucumber, green olives, red onions tossed with red wine vinegar & olive oil
Potato Salad $6.99
NEW!!!!! Homemade 12oz

Antipasti
A5 $11.99
Lioni Mozzarella, tomato, fresh basil leaves & fire roasted red peppers
A2 $11.99
Imported Prosciutto Di Parma, Colpi Dolce, & Sweet Soppresata
A1 $7.99
Mixed olives & bread ends
A7 Eggplant Caponata $8.49
Eggplant caponata
A4 $15.99
Prosciutto, colpi dolce, soppresata, mixed olives, fontina cheese, grana cheese & aged toscano cheese
A11 Burrata & Eggplant $14.49
Burrata cheese, eggplant caponata & fig glaze
A3 $11.99
Grana cheese, aged toscano cheese, fontina cheese & goat cheese
A8 Burrata & Truffle Oil, Cherry Tomato, Arugula & Mixed Olives $11.49
Burrata cheese with truffle oil, cherry tomato, baby arugula & mixed olives
A12 Burrata Caprese $14.49
Burrata Caprese. 3 pc Burrata over sliced tomato, fire roasted red peppers, fresh basil leaves and balsamic glaze.
A10 Burrata & Roasted Peppers, Cherry Tomato & Arugula $11.49
Burrata cheese, fire roasted red peppers, cherry tomatoes & baby arugula

Kid's Menu
All Beef Hot Dog $4.49
Chicken Fingers $11.99
6 piece
Pizza $11.99
10" margarita pie
Hot Dog & French Fries $11.99
Chicken Fingers & French Fries $11.99
4 pc chicken fingers
French Fries $7.99
Hot & Crispy
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $5.49

Wraps
W11 Flank Steak Strips, Pepper-Jack Cheese, Hot Peppers, Avocado, Red Onion, Chipotle Mayo $13.49
W10 Flank Steak Strips, Pepper-Jack Cheese, Red Onion & Chipotle Mayo $16.99
W4 $12.99
Hot roast beef, melted mozzarella, sun-dried tomato and mayonnaise
W5 $11.49
Ham wrap with provolone, tomato and mayonnaise
W6 $11.99
Genoa Salami Wrap With Swiss, lettuce, tomato and mustard.
W7 $12.99
Prosciutto Wrap With goat cheese, baby arugula and fig glaze.
W3 $11.49
Grilled Zucchini & Eggplant Vegetable Wrap With mozzarella balsamic vinegar & extra virgin olive oil
W9 Flank Steak Strips, Mozzarella Cheese, Red Onion & Ranch Dressing $15.99
W2 $11.49
Turkey Wrap With Melted Swiss & yellow American cheese, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
W1 $10.99
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
W8 $12.99
Grilled Chicken, pepper-jack cheese, bacon & ranch dressing

Fruit Smoothies
F6 $9.49
Mango
F2 $9.49
Strawberry and Banana Smoothie.
F10 $9.49
Peach Smoothie
F4 $9.49
Pina Colada
F1 $9.49
Strawberry Smoothie

Savory Crepes
S5 $11.99
Hot Turkey, Melted Fontina Cheese, Baby Arugula, Creamy Basil Dressing on a Crepe
S3 $12.99
Prosciutto, Melted Mozzarella, Arugula and Balsamic Glaze on a Crepe
S2 $10.49
Cherry Tomato, Melted Mozzarella, Basil Pesto on a Crepe
S4 $10.49
Fire roasted red peppers, goat cheese and black olive spread on a crepe
S17 Steak, Pepper-Jack Cheese, Bacon, Red Onions & Chipotle Mayo $16.99
NEW & SPICY!!! Flank Steak Strips
S1 $11.99
Mortadella, Fontina Cheese, Baby Arugula on a Crepe

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Children
Good for kids

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge Photos

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge Location

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge

New York Kings County Fort Hamilton 3rd Avenue

8901 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Panino Rustico of Bay Ridge Reviews

An average rating of ★4.5 from 117 user reviews.

sandwichespricescrepesatmospheretruffle friesservercoffeetablelemongrilled chicken

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This is my third time here and it’s absolutely amazing. Food… delicious. Great service such sweet girls. Everything so fresh and so good. And great price!!! All the food comes out so quickly, one of my favorite sandwiches in Bay Ridge.
June 15 · Arinessa Valley
I recently booked this place for a bridal shower and the experience was amazing at every step. From inquiring availability and discussing food and drink menu to the day of, everything was so accommodating.They had the back room for any event and that space was big and was so separate from the front of the restaurant, it was like your own private room. Time wise, they did not rush us. Gave us adequate amount of time to set up and clean up our decorations.Pricing was so fair , including open bar. 10/10 recommend having your event here!Food was pre fixed but it was so much food!! And for a good price !Such a great experience !
May 06 · Nicole Lin
I came here with my cousins and we were not only impressed with the service and food, but the prices were very affordable. The coffee looked very light but did not taste light. Had a good ratio of coffee and cream. 2 of us got sweet crepes, and the fruit was very fresh and overall very delicious. 1 of us got a panini with bologna and goat cheese. It was also very tasty and the portion size was great. The truffle fries were very crispy, hot, and seasoned perfectly. The atmosphere is chill and family friendly. Overall the price was $60 for everything we got, which was pleasantly surprising considering how much we ordered. Definitely will go back as much as I can.
August 27 · Nico Archambault
Eaten here numerous times and we know we are in for a great meal and friendly inattentive service. Guess that's a unique way describing the waitstaff's performance. And that's the rub of what otherwise would be a fantastic dining experience...whether it's brunch, lunch or dinner you can count on the service by the waitstaff to be lacking. They are very friendly so it's kind of hard to be mad at their lousy service. However, it's the food that keeps us coming back. Their crepes are to die for. Salads are great as are their panni's, but it's the crepes that keeps us coming back. Absolutely delicious and a generous size to boot. Usually wind up taking a portion home with us. Everything we've ever ordered is presented nicely and is cooked just right. The dining area is intimate (which is good since you don't have far to go to track down waitstaff...there we go again with the crappy service). Never been disappointed with any of the meals and it is amazingly inexpensive given the portion sizes. Deserts are really good, especially the chocolate mouse and cannoli's. Here's a tip for the waitstaff or owner if you read this. Don't have conversations with your back turned to the dining area. Face the dining area and read the room. Last time we were there our server never came by to ask how the meal was and two tables next to us had to get up to find their server for their check. Sigh, so close to being perfect.
October 07 · mimi tann
Love this place. Visited it twice in one week. Their panini’s are beyond delicious, especially if you order it on an everything panini. Won’t disappoint, trust me.The 1st time we visited, I ordered a P.37 & P.50 - I wasn’t too impressed with the P.37 which was chicken, pepper jack cheese, and ranch dressing ( got avocado instead ). It was good but bland. Now, the P.50 whew, this is a MUST. it’s steak strip, cheese, bacon, lettuce, onions on an everything panini. Each bite is juicy and flavorful. Ppl were ordering it after seeing it on our table lol. Just fyi it’s addictive and will make you want to come back. We paired this with truffle fries.On our 2nd visit we ordered drinks; frozen pina colada and a mojito. Do not recommend alcoholic drinks. The “frozen “ pina colada was not at all frozen. Looked more like milk in a mason jar. And the mojito did not have any mint - idk if that’s what made it taste bad but I just wasn’t a fan of the drinks. StickTo the panini’s.
May 28 · Josenny Torres