Prince Umberto Pizzeria

- 1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793

For residents across the New York region, specifically those on Long Island, Prince Umberto Pizzeria in Wantagh is a name synonymous with authentic, old-school New York-style pizza. Located at 1910 Wantagh Ave, this establishment is far more than just a typical local pizza joint; it’s a fully-fledged Italian restaurant, caterer, and a beloved local institution dedicated to serving comfort food classics. Operating as a dependable source for both quick bites and full family meals, Prince Umberto Pizzeria offers a refreshingly unpretentious and consistently reliable dining experience.

The atmosphere is decidedly casual and local, perfectly embodying the spirit of a true "New York hole-in-the-wall pizza joint," as described by devoted customers. The focus here is on quality, flavorful food made from traditional recipes, without the distraction of trying to be a trendy or upscale locale. While the regular cheese pie is a staple—available at an excellent value—the menu boasts a deep selection of specialty pizzas, heroes, pasta, and classic Italian entrees, making it a versatile option for lunch, dinner, or satisfying solo dining.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria proudly serves the Wantagh community and surrounding areas, ensuring that the essence of traditional Italian-American comfort food is always within reach. Their commitment extends beyond the counter, offering robust delivery and an extensive catering service that can bring their delicious offerings to any event, from a small gathering to a large banquet. This comprehensive approach to dining and service solidifies its reputation as a core business in the Wantagh, NY area.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria is conveniently situated at 1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, placing it in a prime, accessible spot within Nassau County on Long Island. The location is easily reachable from the surrounding suburban communities, making it a go-to spot for locals.

For diners driving in, accessibility and parking are made simple. Customers benefit from both Free Parking Lot access and Free Street Parking nearby. This ease of parking is a significant advantage in the heavily populated New York suburban region. Furthermore, the restaurant is committed to welcoming all members of the community by ensuring comprehensive accessibility features. These amenities include a Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot, a Wheelchair Accessible Restroom, and designated Wheelchair Accessible Seating, making it a comfortable destination for everyone.

The restaurant provides a full range of service options designed to meet the dynamic needs of the local New York clientele:

• Dine-in: Available seating in a casual atmosphere, good for kids, and includes amenities like high chairs and a clean restroom.
• Takeout: Quick service for individuals and families picking up orders.
• Delivery: Reliable delivery services, ensuring hot, fresh food arrives at your door.
• No-Contact Delivery: An option for safe, convenient ordering and receipt of food.
• Catering: Comprehensive catering services for parties and events, offering competitively priced trays of Italian specialties, pasta, and entrees, often serving 8 to 18 people per tray.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria is celebrated by its patrons for several key offerings that distinguish it from the competition:

• Authentic NY Pizza Experience: Delivers a classic, crispy New York-style pizza slice, which loyal customers attest is the best local "regular slice." A regular pie is reasonably priced, such as $19.00.
• Deep Menu of Italian Comfort Food: Extends far beyond pizza, offering a wide selection of appetizers, rolls, classic hero sandwiches, full Italian entrees (like Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Marsala, and Shrimp dishes), and pasta.
• Specialty Appetizers: Known for beloved side items such as Fried Capellini, large Rice Balls, Chicken Rolls, Pinwheels, and Garlic Knots, which are all highly praised by customers.
• Catering Breadth: Offers extensive catering menus, including Italian specialties like Baked Ziti, Lasagna, Eggplant Parmigiana, and a variety of Veal and Chicken entrees by the half or full tray.
• Traditional Atmosphere: Maintains a casual, no-fuss environment that focuses entirely on great food and dependable service, staying true to its roots as a classic neighborhood pizzeria.
• Inclusive Offerings: Serves dessert and coffee, making it a complete dining option for lunch and dinner.
• Modern Payment Options: Accepts NFC mobile payments for a quick and modern checkout process.

To place an order, inquire about catering, or for general questions, please use the contact information below:

• Address: 1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793
• Phone: (516) 221-7823
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-221-7823

For Long Islanders and New York residents in search of a genuinely authentic and dependable Italian-American meal, Prince Umberto Pizzeria is worth choosing for several compelling reasons. The primary draw is its unyielding commitment to delivering the Quintessential New York Pizza Slice. Customers frequently highlight the crispy texture and the simple, satisfying taste of their regular and Sicilian slices, affirming that this is the real deal—classic New York pizza without the gourmet price tag. At a value price for a regular slice, it represents the heart of local, accessible New York dining.

Beyond the pizza, the establishment’s strength lies in its Expansive, High-Quality Italian Menu. Unlike many pizzerias that only offer pizza and a handful of sides, Prince Umberto provides a full selection of hearty comfort foods. Items like the lauded Fried Capellini, a unique and flavorful appetizer, along with their rice balls, chicken rolls, and baked pasta dishes, ensure that there is a full Italian meal for every preference. This makes it an ideal spot for a family dinner where tastes might differ, as everyone can find their favorite classic Italian dish, from Baked Ziti to Chicken Parmigiana.

The third key factor is the Reliable Full-Service Catering. Prince Umberto Pizzeria is a trusted local caterer, offering large and half trays of all their Italian specialties at competitive prices. For planning a New York event, be it a small family party or a large business function, the ability to order massive trays of Veal Marsala, Chicken Francese, or Penne ala Vodka, along with large salads and appetizers, positions them as a highly valuable and convenient local resource. Their proven track record in serving high-quality food for larger groups ensures a successful and delicious event.

Finally, the consistent and casual atmosphere, backed by a staff that is described as "wonderful," ensures that the overall experience is comfortable and familiar—exactly what you expect from a long-standing, community-focused Long Island pizzeria.

Prince Umberto Pizzeria

1910 Wantagh Ave, Wantagh, NY 11793, USA