Pumpernickel's

- 640 Main St, Northport, NY 11768

Nestled on the picturesque Main Street of Northport, Long Island, Pumpernickel's is more than just a restaurant; it is a cherished local landmark that has been serving the New York region since 1973. Specializing in authentic German fare and classic Continental cuisine, this establishment offers a truly unique and immersive dining experience. It provides a taste of old-world charm and traditional German hospitality, which is increasingly rare to find in the hustle of modern Long Island dining.

The menu at Pumpernickel's is a testament to the rich, hearty flavors of both German and broader European cooking. Diners are invited to explore a vast selection of dishes, from traditional German "House Specials" to refined "Continental" entrees and fresh seafood. The restaurant is celebrated for providing generous portion sizes, ensuring a satisfying and memorable meal that often results in leftovers to enjoy the next day. The food quality is consistently praised by patrons for its outstanding and authentic preparation, with sauces described as superbly made.

Walking into Pumpernickel's is often compared to stepping into a cozy, historic corner of Germany itself. The atmosphere is casual, cozy, and distinctly historic, enhanced by staff who sometimes wear traditional German attire and German music playing softly in the background. It’s a place where families, groups, and solo diners can find comfort and high-quality food, perfect for both a special occasion dinner or a relaxing mid-week lunch. The establishment has been recognized by the Northport Historical Society, celebrating its long-standing presence and unique contribution to the local community's culture and commerce.

Pumpernickel's is ideally located at 640 Main St, Northport, NY 11768. Main Street is a central artery in Northport, making the restaurant highly visible and accessible to anyone visiting or residing in the area. Its location in this historic village adds to the overall dining atmosphere.

Accessibility is a key convenience for all patrons. The establishment features wheelchair-accessible seating, making it welcoming for guests with mobility needs. Furthermore, parking is exceptionally convenient in this area of Long Island. The restaurant offers a free, ample parking lot for its guests, a significant advantage in a busy village center. For overflow or for those who prefer it, free street parking is also available nearby. This eliminates the common New York stress of finding a spot, allowing diners to transition smoothly from arrival to enjoying their meal.

Pumpernickel's offers a comprehensive range of services tailored to meet the needs of its diverse clientele in the New York market.

• Dine-in Table Service: Offering a full-service experience with seating available in the cozy main dining areas.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts and recommends dinner reservations, especially on weekends, due to its popularity.
• Takeout: All menu items are available for takeout, allowing guests to enjoy their favorite German and Continental dishes at home.
• Full Bar Service: A bar is onsite, serving a great selection of beer (including imported German varieties), cocktails, hard liquor, and wine, complementing the authentic German dining experience.
• Catering: On and off-premise catering services are available for private parties and events, leveraging their extensive menu of hearty, crowd-pleasing dishes.
• Private Party Room: An additional dining room located upstairs is available for booking private parties and events.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is good for kids and provides high chairs and a specific kids' menu, making it a comfortable choice for family outings.
• Payment Options: Accepts all major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for convenience.

Several standout features make Pumpernickel's a beloved culinary institution on Long Island, attracting loyal customers from across the New York metropolitan area.

• Authentic German Cuisine: The primary highlight is the dedication to classic German dishes, executed with rich and flavorful authenticity. Menu highlights include the famous Sauerbraten, a truly tender pot roast served with potato dumplings and red cabbage, and various Schnitzel preparations like Wiener Schnitzel and Jaeger Schnitzel.
• Cozy, Historic Atmosphere: The interior features Tiffany-style light fixtures, comfortable booths, and historic elements like a classic phone cabinet and upstairs bathrooms, creating a "cozy, historic" and "old-world charm" ambiance.
• Exceptional Beverage Program: Patrons consistently highlight the "Great beer selection" and "Great cocktails," making the bar a central feature of the dining experience. The ample beer selection is especially crucial for a German restaurant.
• Diverse Menu Offering: While rooted in German food, the menu extends to "Continental" fare, including high-quality steaks (New York Cut Sirloin, Filet Mignon), fresh seafood (Broiled Salmon, Imported Lobster Tails), and Long Island Clams, ensuring options for all tastes.
• Fast and Expert Service: Despite the focus on quality and a seated dining experience, the service is known to be prompt and professional. The wait staff is often described as expert, attentive, friendly, and in some cases, German-speaking, which adds an authentic touch.
• Generous Portions: Patrons consistently note the "very generous portion sizes," which significantly contribute to the restaurant's value proposition.

For general inquiries, to confirm operating hours, or to make the recommended dinner reservations, please contact Pumpernickel's directly.

Address: 640 Main St, Northport, NY 11768
Phone: (631) 757-7959
Mobile Phone: +1 631-757-7959

Pumpernickel's in Northport is an essential dining experience for New York residents seeking truly authentic German comfort food in an environment brimming with old-world charm and history. What is most worth choosing is the restaurant's famous Sauerbraten—the dish is consistently highlighted by customers as fork-tender, swimming in a rich gravy, and served with traditional potato dumplings and red cabbage, a perfect embodiment of German culinary tradition.

Beyond the German specialties, the inclusion of local specialties, such as the Long Island Clams on the Half Shell, connects the Continental side of the menu to the restaurant's Long Island home. The overall value provided by the quality of the food, the generous portions, and the immersive, cozy atmosphere makes it an excellent choice for a satisfying and substantial meal. Whether you are craving a Wiener Schnitzel, a hearty bowl of Hungarian Beef Goulash, or a perfectly cooked steak, Pumpernickel's delivers a fast, friendly, and deeply flavorful experience. The restaurant is a beloved fixture of the community, evidenced by its "historic" classification and the Northport Historical Society's recognition, assuring diners they are visiting a place of genuine local significance and enduring culinary excellence.

Pumpernickel's

640 Main St, Northport, NY 11768, USA