Temptations Cafe

- 80 Main St, Nyack, NY 10960

Introduction / Overview

For residents and visitors in the New York region looking for a dining destination that is deeply rooted in local history while offering a thoroughly modern and exciting menu, Temptations Cafe in Nyack, NY, stands out as a true culinary staple. Located in the heart of Rockland County, this establishment is far more than a typical American restaurant; it’s a delightful fusion of an eclectic eatery, a gourmet hamburger spot, a health-conscious salad shop, and a long-standing ice cream parlor. Having been an ice cream destination on Nyack's Main Street for over 40 years, Temptations Cafe has evolved significantly under the current ownership of John Blanco and the innovative culinary direction of his son-in-law, Chef Jeremy Rose.

Since their complete makeover in August 2010, the mission has been to elevate the dining experience without sacrificing the casual, friendly atmosphere that makes local spots so cherished. Chef Rose, a Pastry graduate of the French Culinary Institute who trained under acclaimed chefs, brings a "fresh is best" scratch-kitchen mentality directly from his experience in New York City corporate dining. This commitment translates into a menu that is at once familiar and adventurous. Patrons can indulge in top-tier American comfort food, such as specialty burgers made with premium Pat LaFrieda meats, fresh-cut French fries, and house-made pickles. Simultaneously, the menu caters to diverse dietary needs, proudly offering healthy, vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options.

Temptations Cafe’s identity is uniquely split between savory and sweet. Its long heritage as an ice cream shop is maintained with a delicious selection of sundaes, pints, and quarts, including classic flavors and specialty creations. Furthermore, the venue is a full-service destination, offering a full bar that includes beer, wine, hard liquor, and the famous liquor-infused "Adult Shakes" concocted by Chef Jeremy. This dual focus on high-quality, fresh-made meals and decadent desserts, all served in a casual, cozy, and family-friendly atmosphere, is precisely why Temptations Cafe is considered an iconic and must-visit spot in the Nyack community. It is a welcoming space for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, catering to solo diners, groups, and families alike.

Location and Accessibility

Temptations Cafe is ideally located for local New York users, situated right on the main thoroughfare of Nyack, a vibrant river town known for its unique shops and artistic flair in Rockland County.

Address: 80 Main St, Nyack, NY 10960, USA.

Hours of Operation:

The cafe is open daily, offering convenient hours for all meals of the day, including breakfast/brunch on weekends.

• Monday - Friday: 11:30 AM – 9:00 PM (Kitchen Hours)
• Saturday - Sunday (Breakfast/Brunch): 8:00 AM – 12:00 PM
• Saturday - Sunday (Lunch/Dinner): 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM

Accessibility:

The establishment is committed to full accessibility, which is a major convenience for all patrons.

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating
• Street parking is generally available in the area for customers.

Services Offered

Temptations Cafe provides a comprehensive range of dining services designed to meet the diverse needs of the modern New York diner.

• Dine-in: Enjoy the cozy and casual indoor atmosphere with full table service.
• Outdoor Seating: Guests can enjoy their meals and desserts outdoors, adding to the Nyack dining experience.
• Takeout: All menu items, from burgers to ice cream, are available for convenient takeout.
• Delivery: The cafe partners with delivery services, ensuring your favorite meals can be enjoyed at home.
• Onsite Services: Features a full bar and a dedicated dessert and ice cream counter.
• Reservations: The cafe accepts reservations, which is advisable for groups or peak dining times.

Features / Highlights

The unique features and highlights of Temptations Cafe are a testament to the dedication of its owners and chef, setting it apart as a multi-faceted dining destination.

• Innovative Culinary Program: Led by Chef Jeremy Rose, the kitchen is known for its scratch-made menu items, including house-made salad dressings, soups, and daily specials that offer adventurous takes on world cuisines (e.g., Soft Shell Crab sandwiches, Korean Rack of Lamb).
• Gourmet Burgers and Sandwiches: Features premium meats from Pat LaFrieda, alongside specialties like the CRISPY FALAFEL BURGER and gourmet sandwiches on daily-delivered fresh bread.
• Signature Desserts and Shakes: Famous for its ice cream parlor heritage and selection of decadent desserts, including Chocolate Brownie Ala Mode and the specialty liquor-infused Adult Shakes (like the Banana Foster Shake with spiced rum).
• Extensive Menu Options: Offers a variety of healthy options, including gourmet salads (e.g., TACO SALAD, TEMPTATIONS SALAD) and numerous choices for Vegetarian options, Vegan options, and Gluten-free needs.
• Full Bar Service: Serves Alcohol, Beer, Wine, Cocktails, and Hard liquor—perfect for a full dining experience.
• Atmosphere and Hospitality: Praised for its casual, cozy, and trendy vibe, and the warm, family-style hospitality extended by owners John Blanco and Chef Jeremy Rose.

Contact Information

For reservations, takeout orders, or general inquiries, please use the following contact details for Temptations Cafe:

Address: 80 Main St, Nyack, NY 10960, USA

Phone: (845) 353-3355

What is Worth Choosing

Temptations Cafe is a must-choose destination in the New York area, particularly for those in Rockland County, because it successfully marries nostalgia with modern culinary excellence. It is worth choosing for the sheer diversity and quality that can satisfy any craving at any time of day.

For a complete savory experience, one should choose from the fresh, high-quality offerings. The HOUSE GROUND BEEF BURGER (priced at $11.25) or the GRILLED CHCIKEN SANDWICH (at $11.25) provides an excellent representation of their commitment to fresh ingredients and gourmet preparation. The generous portion sizes and use of premium ingredients like Pat LaFrieda beef offer superb value for the quality. Don't forget to pair your meal with a side of their SWEET POTATO WAFFEL FRIES or the unique FRIZZLED GREEN BEANS (both $7.00).

However, what truly makes Temptations Cafe unique and highly worth choosing is its dessert and drink selection. You must try one of their legendary Adult Shakes, such as the Peanutbutter Oreo Shake ($11.00) or the Cherry Vanilla Shake ($11.00), a creative and popular treat that showcases the chef’s pastry expertise with an adult twist. For a family-friendly choice, the classic sundaes or a quart of their ice cream ($19.00) for a group offers a delicious way to enjoy a true Nyack tradition. The ability to move from a scratch-kitchen gourmet meal to a full-bar cocktail or a decadent ice cream treat, all in one friendly location with fast service, makes Temptations Cafe an indispensable choice for a complete and satisfying dining experience.

Temptations Cafe

80 Main St, Nyack, NY 10960, USA