TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Yonkers: Your Local Destination for Delicious Sandwiches, Coffee, and Comfort Food

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Introduce

Welcome to TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP, a beloved local spot nestled right in Yonkers, New York. More than just a place to grab a quick bite, this establishment has quickly become a community hub for delicious, expertly-crafted sandwiches, hearty all-day breakfast, and a welcoming, casual atmosphere. Identifying proudly as a Latino-owned business, TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP is on a mission to bring high-quality, specialty meats and cheeses together to create flavor combinations that truly stand out in the competitive New York food scene. Since opening its doors in 2022, it has solidified its reputation as the home of some of the "best sandwiches in all of Yonkers," a testament to the care and passion that goes into every order.

The shop's diverse menu offerings mean it serves multiple roles for the local community—functioning expertly as a sandwich shop, a cozy café, a vibrant brunch restaurant, and a reliable fast food and lunch spot. Whether you're an early bird looking for a satisfying breakfast, seeking a midday meal, or in need of a late-night bite, TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP is ready to serve. From gourmet toasted sandwiches and classic Boar's Head selections to fresh smoothies, comforting sides, and a full range of hot and cold coffee drinks, this Yonkers gem offers something to satisfy nearly every craving at any time of day.

The friendly and professional team ensures a welcoming experience, whether you're dining in, grabbing a takeout order, or utilizing their convenient delivery and curbside pickup options. The emphasis on high-quality ingredients and a dedication to the community makes it a standout choice for Yonkers residents and visitors alike.

Location and Accessibility

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP is conveniently located at 132 Gavin St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA. This accessible location makes it a great spot for neighborhood residents and those passing through the area, such as visitors to nearby attractions like Untermyer Gardens Conservancy.

For customers driving to the shop, free street parking is available, making it easier to stop in and grab your order. The business also boasts a commitment to inclusivity with a wheelchair-accessible entrance. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual, family-friendly, and a safe space, being noted as LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace, welcoming all members of the community.

Operating hours are generous, catering to both the early morning and late-night crowd throughout the week. The general hours of operation are:

LI Monday to Saturday: 7:00 AM – 9:00 PM

LI Sunday: 9:00 AM – 9:00 PM

/UL

Services Offered

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP provides a wide array of services and dining options to meet the needs of every customer in Yonkers:

LI Onsite Dining: Comfortable seating is available for customers who wish to dine in, with a casual atmosphere perfect for solo dining or small groups.

LI Takeout and Curbside Pickup: Quick and efficient service for those on the go, including convenient curbside pickup.

LI Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Partnering with various services to bring their delicious food right to your door in the New York area.

LI All-Day Meal Service: Offering full menus for Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner.

LI Catering: Providing food options for larger events and gatherings.

LI Beverage Service: Serving a full line of hot and iced coffee drinks, teas, and fresh, made-to-order smoothies.

LI Payment Options: Accepting Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments for customer convenience.

/UL

Features / Highlights

What truly sets TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP apart is its dedication to quality and its distinctive offerings.

LI Signature Toasted Sandwiches: Famous for "The toastiest and most delicious" sandwiches in the area, including the highly-praised Magic Chopped Cheese.

LI Great Coffee: Offering a strong selection of coffee and espresso drinks, from a simple Fresh Brewed Coffee to specialty items like the Iced Caramel Latte.

LI All-Day Breakfast: Serving a comprehensive breakfast menu from open until close, featuring favorites like the SNOOZE AM WRAP and the FREAKING FRENCH TOAST SANDWICH.

LI Diverse Menu Categories: Beyond sandwiches, the menu includes Toasty Special Fries (like the Buffalo Chicken Cheese Fries), Munchie'z (like Mozzarella Sticks and Crispy Chicken Wings), fresh Salads, and Signature Omelettes.

LI Health-Conscious and Dietary Options: Offering healthy choices such as the Daily Detox and Green Machine Smoothies, along with a variety of Vegetarian options and organic dishes.

LI Community and Atmosphere: Known for its casual and friendly atmosphere, being a designated transgender safespace and LGBTQ+ friendly, and a favorite spot for locals. Dogs are also allowed both inside and outside.

LI Happy Hour and Late-Night Food: Providing options for a quick bite or comfort food throughout the evening hours.

/UL

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or just get in touch, use the following contact details:

Address: 132 Gavin St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

Phone: (914) 457-8509

What is Worth Choosing

For New York locals searching for a meal that blends comfort, quality, and bold flavor, TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP is a must-visit. While the entire menu is crafted with care, a few items stand out as local favorites and are certainly worth trying on your first visit.

The Toasted Sandwiches section, available on a Roll Bread or a larger Hero Bread, is the heart of the menu. Customers frequently rave about the expertly-prepared toasted bread that gives the shop its name.

LI The Lady Lover: A customer favorite, this sandwich is a delicious combination of Grilled Chicken, creamy Mozzarella Cheese, fresh Avocado, Onions, Green Peppers, all finished with a bright Vinaigrette. It's a fresh, yet satisfying, choice.

LI El Dictador: For a savory and sweet kick, try this signature sandwich which features Honey Turkey, Crispy Bacon, Provolone Cheese, and a drizzle of Honey Mustard. The blend of textures and flavors is a clear winner.

LI Magic Chopped Cheese: A New York sandwich staple, their version features Melted American Cheese, Ground Beef, Onions, Roasted Peppers, Mayonnaise, and Ketchup—a highly-rated take on the classic.

LI TOASTY SUPREME: For those with a big appetite, this colossal sandwich includes Crispy Fried Chicken, Bacon, French Fries (yes, right in the sandwich!), Smoked Gouda Cheese, and Chipotle Sauce.

/UL

Beyond the signature sandwiches, don't overlook their unique "Munchie'z" section for a perfect side, particularly the loaded Chopped Cheese Fries or the Bacon Supreme Fries with melted smoked gouda cheese. If you're starting your day here, the SNOOZE AM WRAP (Scrambled Eggs, Sausage, Hash Brown, American Cheese, Secret Sauce) is a comforting and filling choice, or for a lighter start, pair a signature sandwich with one of their vibrant, fresh smoothies like the CARRIBEAN BREEZE (Mango, Strawberry, Pineapple) or the GREEN MACHINE (Green Apples, Kiwi, Spinach).

Ultimately, TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP delivers on its promise of delicious, quality food made with care. It’s an ideal destination in Yonkers for locals who value great taste, a friendly environment, and a menu that covers everything from a quick coffee run to a full, satisfying meal. Stop by 132 Gavin St and see why this Latino-owned local business has earned its title as one of the best sandwich spots in Yonkers, NY.

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Menu

Snacks
BAKED AFTER MIDNIGHT $4.95

HOT DRINK'S
ADD ON - WHIP CREAM $0.99
WHIP CREAM
BLENDED BEAN COFFEE ☕ $3.25
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE
CARAMEL LATTE $4.50
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE, CARAMEL
CREAMY CAPPUCCINO☕ $4.50
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED CAPPUCCINO
FRENCH VANILLA $4.50
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE, FRENCH VANILLA
FRESH BREWED COFFEE $2.80
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE
HOT CHOCOLATE $4.80
12 OZ , HOT CHOCOLATE
MOCHA LATTE☕ $4.50
12 OZ , FRESH BREWED COFFEE, MOCHA
ROASTED ESPRESSO $3.25
ESPRESSO
VARIETY OF TEA $3.50
GREY EARL PEPPERMINT LEMON GREEN TEA

COLD DRINK'S
ADD WHIPPED CREAM $0.99
WHIP CREAM
COLD SODA $3.25
COCA COLA PEPSI GINGER ALE SPRITE FANTA SELTZER
COLD WATER $2.50
POLAND SPRING
ICED CARAMEL LATTE $4.50
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, CARAMEL
ICED COFFEE $3.50
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, MILK OR HALF & HALF
ICED HAZELNUT LATTE $4.50
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, HAZELNUT
ICED MOCHA LATTE❄☕ $4.50
16 OZ, FRESH BREWED COFFEE, MOCHA
SNAPPLE $3.25
KIWI STRAWBERRY ORANGE ICED TEA PEACH

SMOOTHIE'S
BANANA SUNSHINE $8.32
FRESH BANANA, HONEY, WHOLE MILK
BLUE'S CLUE $8.00
BLUEBERRY, APPLE, BANANA, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
CARRIBEAN BREEZE $8.32
MANGO, STRAWBERRY, PINEAPPLE, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
DAILY DETOX $8.32
GREEN APPLE, SPINACH, PINEAPPLE, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
GREEN MACHINE $8.32
GREEN APPLE, KIWI, SPINACH, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
HEALTHYHOLIC $8.32
GREEN APPLE, HONEY, PINEAPPLE, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
CREATE YOUR OWN SMOOTHIE
3 FRUITS IN TOTAL STRAWBERRY, MANGO, PINEAAPPLE, SPINACH, KIWI, RASPBERRY, BLUEBERRY CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
TROPICAL SUN $8.32
STRAWBERRY, BANANA, MANGO, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK
WILDBERRY $8.32
STRAWBERRY, BLUEBERRY, RASPBERRY, CHOICE OF WATER OR MILK

SALADS
BASIC SALAD $6.99
LETTUCE, TOMATOES, ONIONS, DRESSING OF CHOICE
CHICKEN CEASER SALAD $9.00
GRILLED CHICKEN, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CROUTONS, CEASER DRESSING
CRISPY CHICKEN SALAD $8.99
CHICKEN CUTLET, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, PARMESAN, CROUTONS, RANCH DRESSING
APPLE CRISP CHICKEN SALAD $9.99
GRILLED CHICKEN, GREEN APPLE, LETTUCE, TONATOES, CROUTONS, VINAGRRETTE
B.L.T SALAD $7.99
CRISPY BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CROUTONS, ITALIAN DRESSING

BOARS HEAD - WRAP'S
CALIFORNIA TURKEY $10.50
OVEN GOLD TURKEY, MUENSTER CHEESE, AVOCADO, LETTUCE, TOMATO, SUNDRIED TOMATO PESTO MAYO
CRISP & SWEET $9.50
Maple Honey Turkey Mozzarella, apple & Honey Mustard MAPLE HONEY TURKEY, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, SLICED APPLE, HONEY MUSTARD
HOT & SPICY $11.50
BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN, BACON, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
SMOKE MASTER $9.50
SMOKE MASTER, BLACK FOREST HAM, SWISS CHEESE, ROASTED PEPPERS, MUSTARD SAUCE
THE RUSSIAN $9.50
DELUXE ROAST BEEF, COLESLAW, RUSSIAN DRESSING
TURKEY CLUB $9.50
PITCRAFT TURKEY, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO
WRAP CHICKEN CEASER $10.50
GRILLED CHICKEN, PARMESAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, CROUTONS, CEASER DRESSING

BOARS HEAD - SANDWICHE'S
HONEY BEE $10.50
MAPLE HONEY TURKEY, DELUXE HAM, MUENSTER CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, HONEY MUSTARD SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
SOUTHERN STYLE $10.50
ROAST BEEF, CHEDDAR CHEESE, GRILLED ONIONS, HORSERADISH SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
THE CLASSIC $9.50
OVEN GOLD TURKEY, CHEDDAR CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHOICE OF DRESSING, TOASTED HERO
CHOPPED CHIPOTLE CHEESE $11.50
CHIPOTLE CHICKEN, MELTED PEPPER JACK CHEESE, PEPPERS, ONIONS, TOASTED HERO
SANTA FE $11.50
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
THE NEW YORKER $9.50
PASTRAMI, SWISS CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MUSTARD

BOARS HEAD - BREAKFAST
BOARS HEAD BLT $6.50
BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, TOASTED ROLL
BOARS HEAD - EGG & CHEESE ON A ROLL $5.50
TOASTED ROLL, EGGS, AMERICAN CHEESE
BOARS HEAD - EGG ON A ROLL $4.50
TOASTED ROLL , EGGS
BOARS HEAD - EGG WHITE'S ON A ROLL $4.50
TOASTED ROLL, EGG WHITE'S
BOARS HEAD - GRILLED CHEESE $4.50
WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST, AMERICAN CHEESE, BUTTER
BOARS HEAD - HUNGRY MAN $12.00
3 EGGS, BACON, HAM, SAUSAGE, AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES

TOASTY SPECIAL FRIES
BACON SUPREME FRIES LARGE $10.40
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BACON SUPREME FRIES SMALL $7.99
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES SMALL $8.99
CHICKEN CUTLET, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, RANCH, BUFFALO SAUCE
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES LARGE $11.44
GROUND BEEF, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, KETCHUP, MAYO
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES SMALL $7.99
GROUND BEEF, AMERICAN CHEESE, KETCHUP, MAYO
PEPPERONI FRIES LARGE $8.99
FRESH PEPPERONI, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE
PEPPERONI FRIES SMALL $5.99
FRESH PEPPERONI, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE

MUNCHIE'Z
BACON SUPREME FRIES LARGE $10.40
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BACON SUPREME FRIES LARGE $10.99
CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, CHIPOTLE SAUCE
BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES LARGE $11.99
CRISPY CHICKEN, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, BUFFALO SAUCE, RANCH SAUCE
BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE FRIES LARGE $11.99
CHICKEN CUTLET, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, RANCH, BUFFALO SAUCE
CHEESY QUESADILLA $8.99
FRESH TORTILLA, AMERICAN CHEESE, MOZZARELLA CHEESE
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES LARGE $11.44
GROUND BEEF, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, AMERICAN CHEESE, FRENCH FRIES, KETCHUP, MAYO
CHOPPED CHEESE FRIES LARGE $10.99
GROUND BEEF, AMERICAN CHEESE, KETCHUP, MAYO
CRISPY CHICKEN TENDERS (6)
CRISPY CHICKEN TENDERS (6) $10.40
BUFFALO, PARMESAN, BBQ, OR REGULAR
CRISPY CHICKEN WINGS (6)
CRISPY CHICKEN WINGS (6) $9.36
BUFFALO, PARMESAN, BBQ, OR REGULAR
CRISPY ONION RINGS $7.99
CRISPY ONION RINGS $8.32
BEER BATTERED ONION RINGS
MELTED CHEESE FRIES LARGE $7.28
FRENCH FRIES, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE
MELTED MOZZARELLA STICKS (6) $8.99
MELTED MOZZARELLA STICKS (6) $8.32
MARINARA SAUCE
ORIGINAL FRENCH FRIES $5.25
GOLDEN FRENCH FRIES
PEPPERONI FRIES LARGE $9.36
MELTED MOZZARELLA CHEESE, PEPPERONIS, FRENCH FRIES, MARINARA SAUCE
PEPPERONI FRIES LARGE $8.99
FRESH PEPPERONI, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE

TOASTY BAGEL'S
BAGEL MANIA $6.99
CREAM CHEESE, EGGS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, CRISPY BACON
BAGEL WITH BACON & CHEESE $5.99
TOASTED BAGEL, BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE
BAGEL WITH BUTTER AND JELLY $3.50
BAGEL WITH CREAM CHEESE $4.16
TOASTED BAGEL, CREAM CHEESE
BAGEL WITH MELTED BUTTER $3.12
TOASTED BAGEL, MELTED BUTTER
TOASTED PLAIN BAGEL $2.08
TOASTED PLAIN BAGEL

TOASTY BURGER'S
PIKEN BURGER + FRIES $13.99
DOUBLE MEAT, BACON, AVOCADO CHEDDAR CHEESE & CHIPOTLE SAUCE + FRENCH FRIES
SPICY CHICKEN SANDWICH + FRIES $10.99
CHICKEN CUTLET, MUENSTER CHEESE, RANCH & BUFFALO SAUCE + FRENCH FRIES
TOASTY BURGER + FRIES $11.99
SMASHED PATTY, AMERICAN CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, MAYO KETCHUP + FRENCH FRIES
CHEESE BURGER + FRIES + CAN SODA $11.99

TOASTY WRAP'S
BACON RANCH WRAP $10.99
GRILLED CHICKEN, CRISPY BACON, AMERICAN CHEESE, RANCH SAUCE, TORTILLA WRAP
BBQ CRUNCH WRAP $8.99
GROUND BEEF, FRIES, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, AMERICAN CHEESE, BBQ SAUCE, TORTILLA WRAP
FIRE WRAP $9.99
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TORTILLA WRAP
GO GREEN WRAP $8.99
AVOCADO, SPINACH, TOMATOES, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, BALSAMIC SAUCE, GREEN TORTILLA WRAP

TOASTED SANDWICHE'S ( HERO BREAD )
BUFFALO SOLDIER
BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN, BACON, MUENSTER CHEESE, BUFFALO, RANCH, TOASTED HERO BREAD
CALIFORNIA LOVE
OVEN GOLD TURKEY, CRISPY BACON, AVOCADO, AMERICAN CHEESE, RANCH, TOASTED HERO BREAD
CREATE YOUR OWN SANDWICH $0.00
CRUSHED MAN
PIT CRAFT TURKEY, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, HASH BROWN, BBQ SAUCE, TOASTED HERO BREAD
EL DICTADOR
HONEY TURKEY, CRISPY BACON, PROVOLONE CHEESE, HONEY MUSTARD, TOASTED HERO BREAD
HERO JACK
SMOKED PIT TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, BBQ SAUCE, TOASTED HERO BREAD
ITALIAN BOY
TURKEY, HAM, PROVOLONE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, ITALIAN SAUCE, COLD SANDWICH
LADY LOVER
GRILLED CHICKEN, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, AVOCADO, ONIONS, PEPPERS, VINAIGRETTE DRESSING, TOASTED HERO BREAD
MAGIC CHOPPED CHEESE
MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, BEEF, ONIONS, ROASTED PEPPERS, MAYONNAISE, KETCHUP, TOASTED HERO BREAD
PARMIGIANO SANDWICH
CHICKEN CUTLET, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE, TOASTED HERO
PASTRAMI MELT
SLICED PASTRAMI, MELTED CHEDDAR CHEESE, ONIONS, ROASTED PEPPERS, MAYO, TOASTED HERO BREAD
ROASTED MELT
ROAST BEEF, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, MAYO, TOASTED HERO BREAD
THE GARDEN
AVOCADO, ROASTED PEPPERS, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED HERO BREAD
THE MIDNIGHT
CHICKEN CUTLET, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, CHEDDAR CHEESE, AOLI SAUCE, TOASTED HERO BREAD
TOASTY SUPREME $13.99
CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN, BACON, FRENCH FRIES, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TOASTED HERO BREAD
TOP SHELF $13.52
GRILLED CHICKEN, CHEDDAR CHEESE, BACON, MOZZARELLA STICKS, CHIPOTLE & RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED HERO BREAD
TUNA MELT
FRESH TUNA, ONIONS, TOMATOES, AMERICAN CHEESE, TOASTED HERO

TOASTED SANDWICHE'S ( ROLL BREAD )
BUFFALO SOLDIER $8.99
BLAZING BUFFALO CHICKEN, BACON, MUENSTER CHEESE, BUFFALO SAUCE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
CALIFORNIA LOVE $8.99
TURKEY, CRISPY BACON, AVOCADO, AMERICAN CHEESE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
CRUSHED MAN $8.99
PIT CRAFT TURKEY, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, HASH BROWN, BBQ SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
EL DICTADOR $7.99
HONEY TURKEY, CRISPY BACON, PROVOLONE CHEESE, HONEY MUSTARD, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
HERO JACK $8.99
SMOKED PIT TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, BBQ SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
ITALIAN BOY $7.99
TURKEY, HAM, PROVOLONE CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, ITALIAN SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
LADY LOVER $8.99
GRILLED CHICKEN, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, AVOCADO, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, VINAIGRETTE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
MAGIC CHOPPED CHEESE $9.99
MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, GROUND BEEF, ONIONS, ROASTED PEPPERS, MAYONNAISE, KETCHUP, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
PARMIGIANO SANDWICH $7.99
CHICKEN CUTLET, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, MARINARA SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL
PASTRAMI MELT $9.99
SLICED PASTRAMI, MELTED CHEDDAR CHEESE, ONIONS, ROASTED PEPPERS, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
ROASTED MELT $8.99
ROAST BEEF, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
THE GARDEN $7.99
AVOCADO, ROASTED PEPPERS, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
THE MIDNIGHT $9.99
CHICKEN CUTLET, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, CHEDDAR CHEESE, AOLI SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
TOASTY SUPREME $10.99
CRISPY FRIED CHICKEN, BACON, FRIENCH FRIES, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
TOP SHELF $9.99
GRILLED CHICKEN, CHEDDAR CHEESE, BACON, MOZZARELLA STICKS, CHIPOTLE SAUCE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL BREAD
TUNA MELT $6.99
FRESH TUNA, ONIONS, TOMATOES, AMERICAN CHEESE, TOASTED ROLL

SIGNATURE OMELETTE'S
CHESSY OMELETTE $8.99
EGGS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, MOZARELLA CHEESE, MUENSTER CHEESE
CREATE YOUR OWN $7.99
MUSCLE MAKER OMELETTE $9.99
EGG WHITES, TURKEY, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, SPINACH, ONIONS, GREEN PEPPERS, WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST
SIGNATURE OMELETTE $11.99
SAUSAGE, CRISPY BACON, HAM, MUENSTER CHEESE, ONIONS PEPPERS, WHITE TOAST
SUPREME OMELETTE $10.99
CRISPY BACON, HAM, AMERICAN CHEESE, GREEN PEPPERS, ONIONS, TOMATOES, WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST
VEGGIE OMELETTE $8.99
GREEN PEPPERS, SPINACH, ONIONS, WHITE OR WHEAT TOAST

ALL DAY BREAKFAST
BACON & EGG $4.99
BACON + EGGS, TOASTED ROLL
BACON EGG & CHEESE ROLL $6.25
BACON, EGGS, MELTED AMERICAN CHEESE, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL
BUTTER ROLL COLD $2.50
TOASTED BUTTER ROLL $2.50
FRESH BUTTER, TOASTED ROLL
FREAKING FRENCH TOAST SANDWICH $10.40
TEXAS STYLE BREAD, FOREST HAM, FRIED EGGS, CHEDDAR CHEESE, MAPLE SYRUP
MASTER BLT MELT $8.32
BACON, MUENSTER CHEESE, LETTUCE, CHIPOTLE MAYO, TOMATOES, TOASTED ROLL
MC LOVIN SANDWICH $9.36
EGG WHITES, CRISPY BACON, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, SPINACH, MAYO, TOASTED ROLL
NYC STYLE GRILLED CHEESE $4.99
TEXAS STYLE BREAD ; AMERICAN CHEESE ; BUTTER ; BACON ; GRILLED
CINNAMON FRENCH TOAST $7.99
CINNAMON DIPPED FRENCH TOAST, POWDER SUGAR
TOASTED BLT ROLL $4.99
BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, TOASTED ROLL
SAUSAGE - EGG - CHEESE $6.25
SAUSAGE, AMERICAN CHEESE, EGGS, MAYO
SNOOZE AM WRAP $9.36
SCRAMBLED EGGS, SAUSAGE, HASH BROWN, AMERICAN CHEESE, SECRET SAUCE
THE HASHTAG $9.36
CRISPY HASH BROWN, CRISPY BACON, SMOKED GOUDA CHEESE, RANCH SAUCE, TOASTED ROLL
TOASTY AVOCADO MELT $8.32
TOASTED MULTICRAIN, FRESH AVOCADO, PROVOLONE CHEESE, BUTTER
TOP OF THE MORNING $8.32
SALSALITO TURKEY, PEPPER JACK CHEESE, LETTUCE, TOMATOES, KETCHUP, MAYONNAISE, TOASTED ROLL
TURKEY BACON + EGG + CHEESE $6.99
TURKEY BACON, EGG, CHEESE, TOASTED ROLL

UNCATEGORIZED
Delivery Order $0.00
EDAMAME FALAFEL BOWL $12.00
Crispy edamame falafel, cucumber namasu, roasted corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, seed blend, your choice of grains with our greens blend and Tzatziki dressing (served on side).
PLANT BASED BOWL ( VEGAN ) $12.00
Plant-based tenders, cucumber namasu, roasted cauliflower, black beans, tofu, roasted broccoli, seed blend, your choice of grains with our greens blend and Sesame dressing (served on side).
FRIED CHICKEN BOWL $12.00
Fried chicken tenders, avocado, roasted corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, cucumber namasu, cheddar cheese, crispy onions, your choice of grains with our greens blend and BBQ Ranch (served on side).
BUFFALO CHICKEN BOWL
Fried chicken tenderloins, avocado, roasted cauliflower, celery, marinated cherry tomatoes, seed mix, blue cheese crumbles, Frank's Hot Sauce, your choice of grains with our greens blend and BBQ ranch (served on side).
EDAMAME FALAFEL SALAD $11.99
Crispy edamame falafel, cucumber namasu, roasted corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, seed blend, salad greens blend and Tzatziki dressing (served on side).
PLANT BASED SALAD ( VEGAN ) $11.99
Plant-based tenders, cucumber namasu, roasted cauliflower, roasted broccoli, black beans, firm tofu, seed blend, our greens blend and Sesame Dressing (served on side).
FRIED CHICKEN SALAD $11.99
Fried chicken tenders, avocado, corn, marinated cherry tomatoes, black beans, cucumber namasu, cheddar cheese, crispy onions, our greens blend and BBQ Ranch (served on side).
BUFFALO CHICKEN SALAD $11.99
Fried chicken tenders, avocado, roasted cauliflower, celery, marinated cherry tomatoes, seed mix, blue cheese crumbles, Frank's Hot Sauce, our greens blend and BBQ Ranch (served on side).

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Details

From the business
Identifies as Latino-owned

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Great coffee
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour food
Late-night food
Organic dishes
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Locals
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed
Dogs allowed inside
Dogs allowed outside

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Photos

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Location

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP

New York Westchester County Yonkers Bryn Mawr Park Gavin Street

132 Gavin St, Yonkers, NY 10701, USA

TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP Reviews

An average rating of ★4.7 from 331 user reviews.

chopped cheesesmoothiecoffeeatmospherebaconwraplunchenvironmentparkingfrench toast sandwich

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Stopped here on our way to Untermeyer Gardens. This is a neighborhood spot. Street parking was easy. Limited seating inside-we sat at the counter. We got the Lady Lover and El Dictador sandwiches. Both perfectly Toasty and filled with yummy ingredients. Definitely made w care and not “fast-food””.
August 04 · D C
Arguably the best sandwiches in all of Yonkers, including the chopped cheese! The toastiest and most delicious hands down.
August 20 · Franjez
I will list each criteria individually since some people rank them by importance differently.Food- By far their strongest attribute, everything I ate was delicious and flavorful. Everything that I saw others eating looked like it was delicious as well.Price- Very reasonable by today’s standards.Decor- The interior has a very modern design, the ambience is pleasant.Staff- Nice people, very accommodating.Service- The one outlier in the experience is that it’s extremely slow. I walked in to place a to-go order for 3 items and it took over a half hour. I was told by seated customers that this is a typical issue which is why they chose to call in their order ahead of time even though they were eating inside.Bottom line: Good help is hard to come by these days, especially for small businesses. I would absolutely recommend this place to anyone searching locally for an excellent sandwich or wrap. Just make sure that you either have plenty of time to spare or phone in your order ahead of time.
March 09 · John Connelly
I came to this location for the first time and read such great reviews with high hopes. Unfortunately it was NOT good. I ordered my food to go. As I waited, a ROACH flew on the table and i told the host. I didn’t make a big deal of it, she thanked me. But when I got my food! I ordered “The midnight”. My sandwich was soggy! and messy! And I didn’t wait an hour later to eat my sandwich, It was ten minutes after getting it to go I opened it. I also ordered fries. It was stale and it was obviously burnt. But to add on to this, why did I find a piece of bacon in my regular fries.
February 17 · Zelina B
A solid sandwich shop with friendly staff for reasonable price. We dine-in and got the Toasty Supreme, Sausage egg & cheese, and Bacon Supreme fries. There’s hot and cold beverage options such as iced coffee, smoothies - as well as bottled/can options like soda and tea. The food took a bit longer than expected though given how busy they are with take outs and dine-in order, it is understandable. Portion is adequate and there are counter seatings along perimeter of store.Call out is there is only 1 table available for seating so you have to bet on having that 1 table being available when you come in.
March 30 · Nat T.