Bagel Boss Hicksville: Your Essential Kosher Bagel & Deli Destination in New York

Bagel Boss Hicksville Introduce

For many New Yorkers, the search for the perfect bagel is a lifelong pursuit, and a genuinely great local bagel shop is a cornerstone of the community. Bagel Boss Hicksville stands out as a true Long Island institution, offering not just the quintessential New York bagel experience but an extensive kosher deli and catering service that caters to every meal and special occasion. This establishment has earned a loyal following for its commitment to freshness, quality ingredients, and a truly impressive menu that extends far beyond a simple 'bagel with a schmear.'

What distinguishes Bagel Boss Hicksville is its dedication to tradition combined with modern convenience. As a certified kosher restaurant, it provides a crucial and reliable dining option for the local community, ensuring quality and adherence to dietary laws. From a quick, comforting breakfast to elaborate catering for a large event, this shop is designed to be a one-stop culinary destination for residents across the New York metro area who find themselves on Long Island.

The shop's impressive operating hours—reportedly 24 hours—make it an essential spot for early risers, late-night workers, and anyone needing a quality bite at any time of day. This round-the-clock availability is a significant convenience factor that truly serves the fast-paced lifestyle of New York.

Location and Accessibility

Bagel Boss Hicksville is conveniently situated at 432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801. This location makes it easily accessible for customers throughout Hicksville and the surrounding Long Island neighborhoods. Its presence on a main thoroughfare provides excellent visibility and ease of access whether you're starting your morning commute or making a dedicated stop.

Accessibility is a key priority for this location, ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. The establishment provides a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated Wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a Wheelchair accessible restroom. Parking is convenient, with both a Free parking lot and Free street parking available, making it simple for New York drivers to stop in quickly.

Patrons planning a visit will appreciate the available amenities, including a clean Restroom and Wi-Fi. The setup is designed for a Quick visit, perfect for those on the go, but comfortable enough to linger over a coffee and one of their famous bagels. The shop accepts multiple payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Services Offered

Bagel Boss Hicksville offers a comprehensive array of dining and specialty services tailored to the needs of the Long Island community:

Full-Service Bagel and Deli Counter: Offering freshly baked bagels, bialys, and flagels with a wide variety of homemade cream cheeses, butter, and spreads like Lox Spread and Walnut Raisin.
On-Premise Dining: Patrons can enjoy their breakfast, lunch, or snack within the shop with comfortable Dine-in options.
Convenient Takeout and Pickup: Essential services for the busy New Yorker, including Takeout and In-store pickup for orders placed in advance.
Delivery Services: Bringing the full menu of fresh bagels, smoked fish, and hot entrees directly to your home or office.
Comprehensive Catering: Extensive catering options for all occasions, ranging from Continental Breakfast Buffets and Smoked Nova Scotia Salmon Platters to full-scale hot food catering with choices like Penne alla Vodka, Eggplant Rollatini, and professional Onsite services.
Specialty Holiday Items: Seasonal offerings such as DOZEN POTATO PANCAKES and MINI POTATO PANCAKES for holidays.
Hot and Cold Beverages: A full Coffee Bar serving hot coffee, tea, hot chocolate, and iced coffee or iced tea, available for self-service to control your perfect cup.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Bagel Boss Hicksville apart is the sheer breadth and quality of its food offerings, which combine classic deli fare with full kosher restaurant capabilities:

24-Hour Service: The notable operating schedule makes this one of the most dependable spots in the area for a high-quality meal at any hour.
Authentic Kosher Certification: The entire establishment and its menu adhere to strict kosher guidelines, making it a reliable resource for the New York Jewish community. This includes the notable absence of meat items like bacon, which should be considered when ordering egg and cheese items.
Exceptional Homemade Spreads: Featuring a highly-praised lineup of spreads, including flavors like Walnut Raisin, Scallion, Jalapeno, and Chocolate Chip cream cheese, available by the pound.
Extensive Smoked Fish Menu: Offering premium selections like Smoked Nova Salmon, Baked Kippered Salmon, Smoked Sable Plate, and Whitefish Fillet, available as sandwiches, platters, or by the pound.
Full Hot Food and Chef Specialties: Beyond breakfast, the menu includes significant lunch and dinner options such as Lasagna, Flounder Florentine, Honey Balsamic Glazed Salmon, and classic comfort food sides like Homemade Soups, Knishes, and Potato Latkes.
Specialty Bakery: An in-house bakery featuring a massive variety of fresh pastries, cakes, and cookies, including Challah, Rainbow Bagels, Black and White Cookies, Babka, and various pies.
Customizable Catering Packages: Highlighted by the 'Gold Package,' which offers a vast, customizable menu that can include Assorted Smoked Fish, Hot Pasta Stations, Sushi Bar, and an Ice Cream Bar for large events.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or confirm service details, you can reach Bagel Boss Hicksville using the following information:

Address: 432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801

Phone: (516) 681-1856

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers seeking a high-quality, reliable, and authentic kosher deli and bagel experience on Long Island, Bagel Boss Hicksville is an exceptional choice. The depth of the menu means it can satisfy cravings ranging from a simple Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese (the Walnut Raisin often receives high praise) to a full Smoked Nova Salmon Sandwich. The ability to grab Mini Bagels for a party, an Impossible Burger for a hearty lunch, or a whole Chocolate Babka makes it a multipurpose food resource.

Customers consistently highlight the delicious cream cheese and the good variety of fresh bagels. While wait times can occasionally be long—a testament to its popularity—the quality is widely considered worth it. For those planning a road trip or an early start, the 24-hour convenience is unparalleled. If you are hosting an event, the comprehensive catering options, especially the large platters like the Smoked Fish Medley and the Wrap & Bagel Platters, ensure you can feed a crowd with authentic New York-style fare. It truly serves as a central point for quality food, whether you are passing through or live locally.

Bagel Boss Hicksville Food & drink

Breakfast
Continental Breakfast Buffet
GREAT FOR CORPORATE MEETINGS OR CASUAL GET TOGETHERSAssorted fresh bagels, bialys and flagels(r) * Assorted pastry platter * Variety of cream cheeses, butter & jelly * Coffee, premium orange juice * Complete paper and cutlery
Hot Breakfast
PERFECT FOR BRUNCHES, MEETINGS, AND ENTERTAININGFarm fresh scrambled eggs * Old Fashioned challah french toast or fluffy buttermilk pancakes * Morningstar Farms vegetable links * Home fries * Assorted fresh bagels, bialys and flagels(r) * Variety of cream cheeses, butter and jelly * Coffee, premium orange juice * Complete paper and cutlery * Chafing dishes and sterno racks
Optional Addition to Hot Breakfast
OMELETTE STATIONAny style omelette includes mushrooms, onions, spinach, cheese, broccoli and more
Cream Cheese Platters
ASSORTED SPREADS INCLUDING:Plain * Everything * Veggie * Nova spread * Scallion * Olive * Walnut Raisin * Lite cream cheeses available * Butter * Assorted bagels, bialys and flagels(r)
Smoked Nova Scotia Salmon Platter $95.00
1 Lb. of the finest smoked salmon beautifully decorated on a platter.A delicious addition to a Cream Cheese Platter or Breakfast Buffet.Serves 8-10 guests.

Snacks
A Great Mid-Afternoon Snack
Regular & Decaf Coffee, cut up fresh fruit, an assortment of cubed cheeses and crackers, and a delicious platter of our fine pastries and cookies
Vegetable Crudite
ASSORTMENT OF CRISP JULIENNE VEGETABLESFlorets of broccoli and cauliflower * Ripe cherry tomatoes * Celery * Carrots * Holland pepper spears * Home-made garlic ranch dip
Cheese Platter
SLICED OR CUBED, A PERFECT ADDITION TO ANY MENUAssortment of fine kosher cheeses * Bagel chips
Fresh Fruit
Cantaloupe * Honeydew * Watermelon * Pineapple * Strawberries * Red and green grapes * Seasonal specialties

Specialty Salads
CHOICE OF 2 DRESSINGS:French * Caesar * Thousand island * Balsamic vinaigrette * Creamy Italian * Yogurt dill * Fat-free ranch * Fat-free Italian * Fat-free French * Fat-free honey mustard * Fat-free raspberry vinaigrettePetite (10 -15 p): $65.00 | Grande (20 -25 p): $90.00
Tossed Garden Salad
Lettuce * Cucumber slices * Diced red Holland peppers * Radishes * Broccoli florets * Julienne of carrot and celery * Ripe cherry tomatoes * Homemade croutons * Your choice of salad dressing on the side
Caesar Salad $0.00
Crisp romaine lettuce * Bermuda onions * Red Holland peppers * Grated Parmesan cheese * Homemade croutons * Garlic parmesan dressing on the side
Classic Spinach Salad
Fresh tender leaf lettuce * Sliced hard boiled eggs * Mushrooms * Diced Swiss Cheese * Soy bacon bits * Sliced Bermuda onion * Bagel chips * Balsamic vinaigrette on the side
Greek Salad
Crisp romaine and green leaf lettuce * Tomato wedges * Bermuda onion * Cucumber slices * Imported greek olives * Crumbled feta cheese * Balsamic vinaigrette on the side
California Spring Mix
Mesculin lettuce * Plum tomatoes * Red onion * Cucumber * Walnuts * Mandarin oranges * Feta cheese * Raspberry vinaigrette on the side

Pastries & Cakes
Patisserie Platters
Cream Puffs * Eclairs * Brownie Bites * Napoleons * Chocolate Dipped Strawberries
Gift Baskets
GREAT FOR ANY OCCASIONCookies * Candy * Coffee * Whole fruit, etc.(Speak to a specialist to design your basket)

Platters
Bagel Boss Salad Medley
GARNISHED PLATTERS - CHOICE OF 3Classic tuna * Low-fat honey mustard tuna * Low-fat veggie tuna * Cranberry apple tuna * Egg-white spinach tuna * Baked salmon salad * Whitefish salad * Egg salad * Low-fat egg white vegetable salad * Low-fat egg white spinach salad * Mushroom egg and onionSALAD ACCOMPANIMENTS - CHOICE OF 2Pasta primavera * Sun-dried tomato pasta * Israeli * Red bliss potato * Cole slaw * Macaroni * Health * Garbanzo bean * Broccoli * Cucumber and onion with dill * Cucumber and tomato * Tortellini * Inquire for additional side salad choices Lettuce, tomato and onion platter * Assorted bagels, bialys & flagels(r)
Wrap & Bagel Platters
OVERSTUFFED SANDWICHES PREPARED ON BAGELS, WRAPS, KAISER ROLLS, EGG TWIST ROLLS, BIALYS AND FLAGELS(r)Classic tuna * Low-fat honey mustard tuna * Low-fat veggie tuna * Cranberry apple tuna * Egg-white spinach tuna * Baked salmon salad * Whitefish salad * Egg salad * Low-fat egg white vegetable salad * Low-fat egg white spinach salad * Mushroom egg and onionSALAD ACCOMPANIMENTS - CHOICE OF 2Pasta primavera * Sun-dried tomato pasta * Israeli * Red bliss potato * Cole slaw * Macaroni * Health * Garbanzo bean * Broccoli * Cucumber and onion with dill * Cucumber and tomato * Tortellini * Inquire for additional side salad choicesTray of assorted pickles and olives * Complete paper and cutlery
Smoked Fish Medley
ALL TIME FAVORITE, PERFECT FOR ANY OCCASIONSliced smoked Nova Scotia salmon and/or belly lox * Fillet or stuffed whitefish * Bowl of tender marinated herring fillets in classic cream or wine sauce * Kippered baked salmon * Assortment of bagels, bialys and flagels(r) * Choice of three homemade cream cheese spreads and butter * Lettuce, tomato and Bermuda onion platter
Bagel Boss Nosh
Sliced smoked Nova Scotia salmon and/or belly lox * Assortment of bagels, bialys and flagels(r) * Choice of three homemade cream cheese spreads and butter * Sliced tomato and Bermuda onion
Any Occasion Platter
Sliced smoked Nova Scotia salmon and/or belly lox * Tuna Salad * Egg Salad * Sliced tomato and onion * Choice of two homemade cream cheeses * Assortment of bagels, bialys and flagels(r)

Hot Food Favorites
INCLUDES CHAFING DISHES & STERNO RACKS(Half trays 6 - 8 p, Full trays 12 - 15 p)
Steamed Vegetables
Rice Pilaf
Grilled Vegetables in Balsamic Glaze
Pasta Primavera
Lasagna
Vegetable or Spinach
Fettuccine Alfredo
Penne alla Vodka
Baked Ziti
Eggplant Rollatini
Eggplant Parmigiana

Chef Specialties
Fish Entrees (serves 12 Guests)Includes serving utensils and egg twist rolls
Honey Balsamic Glazed Salmon $165.00
Blackened Cajun Style Salmon $165.00
Salmon Primavera $165.00
Flounder Florentine $165.00
Flounder Marsala $165.00
Flounder Parmigiana $165.00
Honey Lime Salmon $165.00
Orange Salmon $165.00
Raspberry Salmon $165.00
Teriyaki Salmon $165.00

Soups & Sides
Homemade Soups & Chili
SERVED WITH BAGEL CHIPSMatzah ball * Tomato bisque with swiss chard and orzo * Nineteen vegetable * Split pea with roasted peppers and spinach * Lentil * Mushroom barley * Cream of mushroom * Spicy vegetable chili * Cream of potato and broccoli * Boston potato corn chowder * New Orleans seafood gumbo * Cuban black bean * White bean cassoulet
Knishes
Potato * Spinach * Kasha
Blitzes
SERVED WITH SOUR CREAMCheese * Blueberry * Cherry
Potato Pierogies $0.00
SERVED WITH SAUTEED ONIONS
Potato Latkes $0.00
SERVED WITH APPLESAUCE
Noodle Pudding
With raisins
Blintzes
SERVED WITH SOUR CREAMCheese * Blueberry * Cherry

Gold Package
Includes ceremonial challah bread, bagels, bialys and flagels(r), buffet table clothes and complete cutleryWait Staff 200 p.s.$100.00 pp (35 people minimum - sales tax and gratuity additional)Gold Package can be customized to meet personal preference
Assorted Smoked Fish
Nova Scotia * Whitefish fillet * Kippered baked salmon * Sable plate * Marinated herring fillets in cream sauce or wine sauce
Hors D'oeuvres
Gourmet Salads - Choice of 3
Classic tuna * Low-fat honey mustard tuna * Low-fat veggie tuna * Cranberry apple tuna * Egg-white spinach tuna * Baked salmon salad * Whitefish salad * Egg salad * Low-fat egg white vegetable salad * Low-fat egg white spinach salad * Mushroom egg and onion
Hot Pasta Station
Choice of three types of pasta with sauces
Green Salad - Choice of 1
Spinach * California spring mix * Greek * Caesar
Sushi Bar
Priced according to market
Accompaniments - Choice of 2
Pasta primavera * Sun-dried tomato pasta * Israeli * Red bliss potato * Cole slaw * Macaroni * Health * Garbanzo bean * Broccoli * Cucumber and onion with dill * Cucumber and tomato * Tortellini * Inquire for additional side salad choices
Children's Candy Bar
Cream Cheese Assortment
Plain * Everything * Veggie * Nova spread * Scallion * Olive * Walnut raisin * Lite cream cheeses available * ButterLettuce, tomato & onion platter
Ice Cream Bar
Fresh Fruit Salad
Cantaloupe * Honeydew * Watermelon * Pineapple * Strawberries * Grapes
Assorted Desserts
Demi danish * Cookies * Rugalach * Fresh berries (upon availability)
Hot & Cold Beverages
Assorted soda & juice * Regular & decaf coffee * Assorted fine teas

Holiday Treats
DOZEN POTATO PANCAKES $40.56
One dozen potato pancakes. Includes apple sauce and sour cream.
DOZEN MINI POTATO PANCAKES $28.80
Mini potato pancakes. Includes apple sauce and sour cream.
Potato Pancakes(EACH) $4.16
MINI POTATO PANCAKE (EACH) $2.34

Bagels With A Schmear
Bagel With Butter $3.38
Your choice of bagel with butter.
Flagel With Butter $4.42
Your choice of Flagel with butter.
Bagel with Cream Cheese $4.68
Your choice of bagel with plain regular or lite cream cheese.
Flagel with Cream Cheese $5.72
Your choice of Flagel with regular or lite cream cheese.
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese $5.72
Your choice of bagel with your choice of flavored cream cheese.
Flagel with Flavored Cream Cheese. $6.76
Your choice of Flagel with your choice of flavored cream cheese.
Bagel With Lox Spread $6.24
Your choice of bagel with Lox Spread cream cheese.
Flagel With Lox Spread $7.28
Your choice of Flagel with Lox Spread cream cheese.

Oven Fresh
Bagels only. Please see Cream Cheese And Butter By The Pound section to add spreads to order.
Dozen Bagels / Bialys $22.88
Pick & Choose 13 bagels from our many different bagel choices.
Bagels / Bialys $2.80
Order by single bagels.
Dozen Bialys $22.88
Our famous Old World Recipe handed down through generations!
Bialys $2.80
Our famous Old World Recipe handed down through generations!
Mini Bagels (Single)
$1.30 per mini bagel
Mini Bagels (Dozen) $14.56
Mini Bialys (Single) $1.30
Mini Bialys (Dozen) $14.56
Flagels (Single)
$2.86 per flagel
Flagels (Dozen) $34.32
Challah $7.25
Rainbow Bagel $2.86
Our famous Tie-Dye Rainbow bagel.
Challah Rolls (6) $8.30
Package of 6

Cream Cheese And Butter By The Pound
Our homemade cream cheese and butter by the pound.
Plain
Lite Plain
Vegetable
Lite Vegetable
Scallion
Lite Scallion
Walnut Raisin
Cinnamon Raisin
Olive
Lox Spread
Lite Lox Spread
Chocolate Chip
Jalapeno
Everything Seed
Butter
Sliced Tomatoes
Sliced tomatoes in a container
Sliced Onions
Sliced onions in a container
1/2 Lb Plain Cream Chees $6.50

Breakfast Menu
All omelettes come with your choice of a bagel with butter on the side. Served with Salt, Pepper, and Ketchup on the side.
Bagel Boss Plate $13.51
2 eggs any style, bagel, coffee, juice and home fries
3 Egg Omelette $13.51
Choice of 4 veggies
Leo Omelette $17.67
3 eggs, lox and onions
Greek Omelette $15.59
3 eggs, peppers, onions, spinach, and feta
Spanish Omelette $13.51
3 eggs, tomatoes, onions, peppers and jalapenos
Egg White Omelette $13.97
Egg white omelette. Build your own with your choice of fillings.
Chili Omelette $15.59
3 eggs, chili, and cheddar cheese
Challah French Toast $13.51
Served with a small coffee or juice. Please choose one.
Pancakes $13.51
Served with a small coffee or juice
Hard Boiled Eggs $0.78
Each

Breakfast Wraps
Egg White Wrap $14.55
With spinach, mushrooms & sauteed onions
Classic Egg Wrap $14.55
With sauteed onions, mushrooms & cheese
Wrap It Your Way $14.55
Eggs or egg whites with choice of veggie & cheese
Veggie Wrap $14.55
Eggs with broccoli, peppers, onions and mushrooms
Bagel Boss Favorite Wrap $14.55
Eggs with potato & onions
Healthy Start Wrap $14.55
Eggs or egg whites with spinach & cheese
Farmers Wrap $14.55
Eggs with veggie sausage, soy bacon & cheese

From the Grill
One Egg (On a Bagel or Roll) $5.20
One Egg (On a Flagel) $5.20
Two Eggs (On a Bagel or Roll) $6.24
Two Eggs (On a Flagel) $6.75
Grilled Cheese $7.28
3 slices of any cheese with a side and a pickle

Coffee Bar
Coffee Tea or Hot Chocolate
Iced Coffee or Iced Tea
Ground Coffee $16.99
Sold by the pound
Box of Joe $28.70
Box of Joe contains 12 eight ounce cups. Complete with sugar, sweet n Low, milk, cups and stirrers.
12 Ounce Hot Coffee or Tea

Overstuffed Sandwiches
All sandwiches can be made on a bagel, roll or wrap. All sandwiches include a crisp pickle and a choice of side salad.
Classic Egg Salad (Bagel or Wrap) $14.30
Classic Egg Salad (Flagel) $15.52
Egg Mushroom Onion (Bagel or Wrap) $14.56
Comes with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
Egg Mushroom Onion (Flagel) $14.56
Comes with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
All Tuna Salads (Bagel or Wrap) $14.30
Your choice of Tuna Salad served with a side. Tuna Salads: Classic, Light Vegetable, Light Tuna, Spicy Tuna, Honey Dijon, Spinach Egg White Onion, Mediterranean, and Cranapple.
All Tuna Salads (Flagel) $16.12
Your choice of Tuna Salad served with a side. Tuna Salads: Classic, Light Vegetable, Light Tuna, Spicy Tuna, Honey Dijon, Spinach Egg White Onion, Mediterranean, and Cranapple.
Flounder Fillet (Bagel or Wrap) $11.44
Flounder Fillet (Flagel) $12.48
Toasted Tuna Melt (Bagel or Wrap) $14.56
With tomato
Toasted Tuna Melt (Flagel) $17.16
With Tomato
Seafood Salad (Bagel or Wrap) $12.48
Seafood Salad (Flagel) $15.80
Whitefish or Baked Salmon Salad (Bagel or Wrap) $16.12
Whitefish or Baked Salmon Salad (Flagel) $18.20
Egg White Spinach (Bagel or Wrap) $14.55
Comes with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
Egg White Spinach (Flagel) $17.42
Comes with a pickle and your choice of side salad.
Lettuce & Tomato Sandwich (bagel or wrap) $6.99

Salad Platters
All platters come with a bagel or roll, a crisp pickle and a choice of 2 side salads.
Tuna Salad Platter $15.60
All platters come with your choice of tuna, a bagel or roll, a crisp pickle and a choice of 2 side salads.
Egg Salad Platter $15.34
All platters come with your choice of a bagel or roll, a crisp pickle and a choice of 2 side salads
Whitefish Salad Platter $17.68
All platters come with your choice of a bagel or roll, a crisp pickle and a choice of 2 side salads
Baked Salmon Salad Platter $17.68
All platters come with your choice of a bagel or roll, a crisp pickle and a choice of 2 side salads
Seafood Salad Platter $15.60
All platters come with your choice of a bagel or roll, a crisp pickle and a choice of 2 side salads

Fish Du Jour
Today's fish special served with your choice of two side salads. Changes daily. Grilled Salmon, Grilled Tuna Teriyaki, Seafood Stuffed Flounder and more.
Grilled Tuna Teriyaki Special $16.63
Grilled Tuna Teriyaki served with rice and mixed vegertables.
Grilled Salmon Special $16.63
Grilled Norwegian Salmon served with rice and vegetable.
Seafood Stuffed Flounder $16.63
Seafood Stuffed Flounder

Smoked Fish Sandwiches
All smoked fish sandwiches come with lettuce, tomato, onion & capers. All sandwiches can be made on a wrap or bread. All sandwiches include a crisp pickle and a choice of side salad (potato, macaroni, cole slaw, or health)
Premium Whitefish Fillet (Bagel) $18.71
Premium Whitefish Fillet (Flagel) $19.75
Baked Kippered Salmon (Bagel) $18.71
Baked Kippered Salmon (Flagel) $19.75
Smoked Nova Salmon (Bagel) $18.71
Smoked Nova Salmon (Flagel) $19.75
Smoked Belly Lox (Bagel) $18.71
Smoked Belly Lox (Flagel) $19.75
Smoked Sable Plate (Bagel) $18.71
Smoked Sable Plate (Flagel) $19.75

Homemade Specialty Salads
Our homemade salads by the pound.
Classic Tuna Salad
Light Tuna
Light Vegetable Tuna
Honey Dijon Tuna
Mediterranean Tuna
Classic Egg Salad
Egg Salad No Celery
Spinach Egg White Salad
Mushroom Onion Egg Salad
Spinach, Egg White & Red Onion Tuna
Whitefish Salad
Baked Salmon Salad
Seafood Salad
Spinach, Eggwhite & Red Onion Tuna Salad

Smoked Fish By The Pound
The finest smoked fish available.
Smoked Nova Salmon
Hand sliced Nova Scotia Smoked Salmon
Belly Lox
Hand sliced belly lox
Baked Kippered Salmon
Baked Kippered Salmon custom sliced to order.
Smoked Sable Plate
Smoked Sable hand sliced to order.
Smoked Whitefish
Fresh smoked Whitefish fileted to order.
Pickled Herring In Cream Sauce
Pickled herring filet in cream sauce with onions.

Chopped Salads
Salads are served with your choice of bagel.
Romaine Salad (Small) $9.00
Served with your choice of bagel.
Romaine Salad (Large) $12.00
Served with your choice of bagel.
Spring Mix Salad (Small) $9.00
Served with your choice of bagel.
Spring Mix Salad (Large) $12.00
Served with your choice of bagel.
Iceberg Salad (Small) $9.00
Served with your choice of bagel.
Iceberg Salad (Large) $12.00
Served with your choice of bagel.

Burgers
All burgers come with lettuce, tomato, onion, a pickle, and a side
Impossible Burger $18.71
Veggie Burger $12.47
Spicy Black Bean Burger $12.47

Soup
6 homemade soups daily. Small & medium include your choice of 1 bagel.Large includes your choice of 2 bagels.
Matzo Ball Soup
19 Vegetable
Tomato Bisque
Tomato bisque with Swiss Chard and Orzo
Vegetarian Chili

Beverages
Snapple 16 Ounce
Choose your flavor
Tropicana Juice
Poland Spring Sport Bottle $2.86
20 Ounce Soda
Choose Type
Stewarts 12 Ounce Glass Bottle $2.34
Choose Your Flavor
Dr. Brown 12 Ounce Cans $1.92
Choose Flavor
Martinelli's Apple Juice $3.38

Large Bakery Items
Rainbow Square $4.16
Apple Strudel $4.16
Apple Turnovers $4.16
Banana Nut Muffin $4.16
Black and White Cookies $4.16
Blueberry Danish $4.16
Blueberry Muffin $4.16
Cappuccino Muffin $4.16
Cheese Danish $4.16
Cherry Danish $4.16
Chocolate Chip Brownies $4.16
Chocolate Chip Muffin $4.16
Chocolate Cigars $4.16
Cinnamon Crumb Muffin $4.16
Cinnamon Rolls $4.16
Corn Muffin $4.16
Croissants $4.16
Double Chocolate Muffin $4.16
Linzer Tarts $4.16
M&M Brownies $4.16
Oreo Muffin $4.16
Pineapple Danish $4.16
Pistachio Muffin $4.16
Raisin Bran Muffin $4.16
Blueberry Crumb Ring $12.48
Pecan Danish Ring $12.48
Walnut Danish Ring $12.48
Oreo Crumb Ring $12.48
Chocolate Covered Philly Fluff $12.48
Chocolate Babka $12.48
Apple Pie $21.83
10 Inch Pie
Blueberry Pie $21.83
10 Inch Pie
Cherry Pie $19.75
10 Inch
Pumpkin Pie $19.75
10 Inch
Pecan Pie $21.83
10 Inch Pie
Mini Apple Pie $11.43
Mini Blueberry Pie $10.39
6 Inch
Mini Cherry Pie $11.43
6 Inch
Irish Soda Bread $8.31
Fresh home made! Large 18 oz

Small Bakery Items
Mini Black and White Cookies $2.86
Mini Chinese Cookies $2.86
Mini Hamantaschen $2.86
Prune, Apricot, Raspberry, Cherry, and Strawberry flavors
Mini Marble Cookies $2.86
Chocolate Rugelach
Cinnamon Rugelach

Chef Specialties
Knishes $4.16
Square fried potato
Blintzes
Noodle Pudding
Pizza Bagel $7.80
Served on a plain bagel
Macaroni and Cheese $6.76
Baked Ziti $12.47
Comes with a challah roll with butter
Eggplant Parmesan $13.51
Comes with a challah roll with butter
Flounder Fillet $18.72
Lb
1 piece Grilled Teriyaki Salmon $9.00

Side Salads
Red Bliss Potato
Macaroni
Cole Slaw
Health
Quinoa Salad
Cucumber Red Onion and Dill
Cucumber and Tomato
Broccoli Salad
Garbanzo Bean
Israeli
Kale
Pasta Primavera
Sun-Dried Tomato Pasta
Tortellini

Desserts
Yogurt Parfait $4.68
Vanilla Pudding $4.68
Chocolate Pudding $4.68
Rice Pudding $4.68
Fresh Fruit Salad $6.24
Pineapple $6.24
Strawberries $6.24
Grapes $6.24

Chips & Snacks
Wise Potato Chips $2.58

Miscellaneous
Paper Goods $0.35
Paper goods per person includes: Forks, spoons, knives, cold cup and napkins.
Sour Pickles $0.78
Sour pickles sold by the piece.
Milk
Whole milk
Half & Half
Dozen Eggs $6.23
Breakstone's Salted (Blue) Butter $5.75
Banana $1.00
1 Banana
Bagel Boss Travel Mug $12.99
Insulated travel mug for hot or cold use.Includes a free fill up!

Packages
Package 1 $316.30
Serves up to 8 guests.Incudes: Your choice of smoked Nova salmon or Belly Lox, your choice of tuna, White fish and egg salad. Sliced tomato and onion. Your choice of plain or lite cream cheese. An assortment of bagels and bialys (not sliced). A ceremonial challah and your choice of honey or marble cake.
Package 2 $564.83
Serves up to 12 guests.Incudes: Your choice of smoked Nova salmon or Belly Lox, fileted or stuffed Whitefish, smoked baked kippered salmon, your choice of tuna and egg salad. Pickled herring in cream or wine sauce. A platter of lettuce, sliced tomato and onion. Your choice of plain or lite cream cheese. An assortment of bagels and bialys (not sliced). A ceremonial challah and your choice of honey or marble cake.
Package 3 $734.29
Serves up to 18 guests.Incudes: Your choice of smoked Nova salmon or Belly Lox, fileted or stuffed Whitefish, smoked baked kippered salmon, your choice of tuna and egg salad. Pickled herring in cream or wine sauce. A platter of lettuce, sliced tomato and onion. Your choice of plain or lite cream cheese. An assortment of bagels and bialys (not sliced). A ceremonial challah and your choice of honey or marble cake.

Accompaniments
Customize your order by adding any of the following items.
Smoked Nova Salmon
Hand sliced Nova Scotia Smoked Salmon
Belly Lox
Hand sliced belly lox
Whole Whitefish $72.80
1 Whole smoked Whitefish
Half Smoked Whitefish $41.60
Baked Kippered Salmon
Baked Kippered Salmon custom sliced to order.
Smoked Sable Plate
Smoked Sable hand sliced to order.
Pickled Herring Fillet
In cream or wine sauce
Pickled Lox
Pickled Lox in cream sauce or wine sauce with onions
Chopped Herring Salad
Classic Tuna Salad
Lite Tuna
Egg White Spinach Salad
Light Vegetable Tuna
Mushroom Onion Egg Salad
Whitefish Salad
Bakeed Salmon Salad
Macaroni
Red Bliss Potato
Cole Slaw
Health
Israeli
Sun-Dried Tomato Pasta
Pasta Primavera
Gefilte Fish $4.99
by the piece
Noodle Kugel
Tray serves 8 guests
Potato Kugel
Tray serves 8 guests
Blintzes
Honey Cake $8.32
Homemade Honey Cake
Sponge Cake $8.32
Babka $12.50
Mandel Bread $12.48
Chocolate Rugelach
Cinnamon Rugelach
Teiglach $20.79
Hamentashen
Jelly Roll
Chocolate Dipped Macaroons $2.25
Gourmet Cookie
3 Lb Sweet Ending $71.76
5 Lb Sweet Ending $119.60
Cheese Platter
SLICED OR CUBED, A PERFECT ADDITION TO ANY MENUAssortment of fine kosher cheeses * Bagel chips
Round Challah $8.32
Dozen Bagels / Bialys $22.88
Round Raisin Challah $8.32
Bagels / Bialys $2.80
$1.82 per bagel
Dozen Bialy $22.88
Our famous Old World Recipe handed down through generations!
Bialys $2.80
Our famous Old World Recipe handed down through generations!
Mini Bagels (Dozen) $14.56
Mini Bagels (Single)
$1.30 per mini bagel
Flagels (Dozen) $34.32
Flagels (Single)
$2.86 per flagel

Bagel Boss Hicksville Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Amenities
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Bagel Boss Hicksville Photos

Bagel Boss Hicksville Location

Bagel Boss Hicksville

New York Nassau County Hicksville South Oyster Bay Road

432 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA

Bagel Boss Hicksville Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 1197 user reviews.

koshersaladseverything bagelspreadtunacookiesislandwhitefish saladvegan bacondairy

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Stopped by as we headed to our long road trip. I said we didn't get bagels and that was on my NY list. When I saw "24 hours" we headed there! Large shop, good variety of bagels! The cream cheese was absolutely delicious! Would certainly come again. The wait was a little long, but worth it!
June 30 · Karen Pierre-Louis
Having heard a lot of buzz about Bagel Boss, and being a Queens native, I decided to check it out.The bagels themselves were decent, but the standout was definitely the exceptional walnut raisin cream cheese.It's worth noting that because it's a kosher establishment, you won't find options like bacon to go with your egg, and cheese.While the staff provided attentive service, the system for ordering and waiting for pickup could be more streamlined.Both hot and iced coffee is on the side for diy.It's a little expensive, Manhattan price for long Island...
May 23 · Thomas Wang (tomtom)
We could not have found a better place, on every level, than Bagel Boss Hicksville, for a family gathering for a lite bite together last Sunday. Through the kindness of Terri, who we were working with, we secured the back dining room for our group. The "buffet" of bagel sandwiches, salads, fruit and cookies, was perfect. The platters were decorated beautifully and the food plentiful. Thanks to the good care of Terri and Delaney (forgive if misspelled), throughout the time we were there, helping, refilling, accommodating every request and assisting in packing up what was leftover, for all of us to take, made our time there just perfect. Everyone enjoyed fully. On behalf of our family, a sincere thank you Bagel Boss. Thank you Terri and Delaney for your kindness to our family and your exceptional service and attention to us throughout.
September 14 · Rachel Epstein
Not sure of the reason but this place is it the best it’s ever been. Came in today and had a warm sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese, tomato and nova and it was simply sensational. Freshness matched customer service! I will be returning soon. Whether you ask for Scott or not…you are in the best possible hands SOOOOOO if you’re looking for a great place for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner or a late night snack…this Kosher 24 hour bagel place will definitely make you happy! SIMPLY DELICIOUS!
March 29 · Kimberly Faraci
Horrible customer sevice.Inspite of ordering online way ahead of time,the staff had no idea of what was ordered and the big guy at the counter hasn't even checked the orders when we reached there.Literally no rush at the store and they are just too lazy to work.He finally managed to pick up my order and was slower than a snail packing the order of a few buttered bagels!; and guess what he even messed up my order by not giving me the custom ordered items on top of all this! The Bagels are okay but honestly lost my appetite just by seeing their subpar attitude to customers.Pathetic customer service!! A complete waste of time and money.Would not recommend buying from here or even worth visiting!
June 22 · Dr.Anju Nair