Carlotto

- 100 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003

Introduction / Overview

In the bustling culinary landscape of New York City, Carlotto emerges as a true gem, offering a refined and intimate Italian dining experience. Located just north of Union Square at 100 E 19th St, this restaurant seamlessly blends the warmth of a classic trattoria with the chic, trendy elegance of a modern New York establishment. As a fine dining Italian restaurant, Carlotto is celebrated for its commitment to tradition and quality, with a menu that features pastas made daily and honors Italy's most celebrated regions. The ambiance is a highlight in itself, described as cozy, romantic, and trendy, making it an ideal destination for a special date night, a celebratory dinner, or even a sophisticated solo dining experience. The space, designed by the award-winning Rockwell Group, features a beautiful bar and warm interiors, creating a setting that is both stylish and welcoming. The restaurant also functions as a cocktail bar, wine bar, and pasta shop, showcasing a comprehensive beverage program that includes an extensive Italian-focused wine list, a curated cocktail menu, and one of the largest selections of vintage and modern amaro in the city. The service is consistently praised as "top-notch" and "wonderful," with a staff that is attentive and knowledgeable, ensuring every guest feels well cared for. Carlotto is known for its fast service and an atmosphere that manages to be both upscale and genuinely comfortable. It is a popular choice for lunch and dinner, drawing a diverse crowd, including families, groups, and the LGBTQ+ community, and is recognized as a transgender safespace, reinforcing its inclusive and welcoming spirit.

The culinary journey at Carlotto is a delightful one, with standout dishes that have garnered high praise from patrons and professional foodies alike. The menu is a mix of classic Italian favorites and modern interpretations, with the "rich, flavorful, and comforting" ragu being a particular highlight. Other must-try dishes include the sweet corn agnolotti and the slow roasted lamb ribs, which a professional chef friend recommended. While some experiences may be "hit or miss," as noted by one reviewer, the overall impression is that of a high-quality establishment dedicated to crafting delicious and authentic Italian food. The attention to detail extends to their a variety of offerings, including happy hour food and drinks, a three-course prix fixe menu, and options for private dining. Carlotto's ability to create a memorable experience, from its stunning plating to its impeccable service, solidifies its position as a go-to spot for a high-quality Italian meal in the heart of New York City.

Location and Accessibility

Carlotto is centrally located at 100 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003, placing it in the vibrant Gramercy neighborhood, just a short walk from Union Square. This prime location makes it easily accessible for both locals and visitors. The area is well-served by an extensive public transportation network, including several subway lines and bus routes, which makes getting to the restaurant a breeze. For those who choose to drive, the restaurant offers several parking options, including free street parking, paid street parking, and access to a paid parking garage, a significant convenience in a dense urban area. Carlotto is also committed to ensuring an inclusive dining experience for all guests. It features a "wheelchair accessible entrance," "wheelchair accessible restroom," and "wheelchair accessible seating," making it a comfortable and welcoming space for individuals with mobility challenges. The restaurant's well-established presence in this bustling area means it is easy to find and serves as an excellent destination for a night out in the city. Its location contributes to its appeal as a central spot for both casual and special-occasion dining, attracting a wide-ranging clientele.

Services Offered

• Onsite services: A full-service dining experience with attentive table service.
• Takeout: Place an order and pick it up to enjoy Carlotto's cuisine at home.
• Dine-in: Enjoy the full experience of dining in the restaurant's cozy and romantic setting.
• Accepts reservations: Recommended for planning your visit, especially for dinner.
• Private dining room: Perfect for hosting private events and large groups.

Features / Highlights

• Expertly crafted Italian cuisine with a menu that honors celebrated regions of Italy and features fresh, housemade pastas.
• Offers a comprehensive beverage program with "great cocktails," a "great wine list," and a large selection of amaro.
• Known for "fast service," "great dessert," and a generally high level of hospitality.
• Provides a three-course prix fixe menu for a set price, offering a curated dining experience.
• The atmosphere is a blend of cozy, romantic, and trendy, making it suitable for a wide range of occasions.
• Caters to a diverse crowd, including families (with high chairs and a kids' menu), groups, and the LGBTQ+ community.
• Offers happy hour specials on both drinks and food.
• Amenities include a bar on-site, gender-neutral restrooms, and private dining options.
• Provides a variety of offerings, including comfort food, organic dishes, and vegetarian options.

Contact Information

Address: 100 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003, USA

Phone: (212) 209-1054

Mobile Phone: +1 212-209-1054

What is worth choosing

Choosing Carlotto is a choice for an authentic and high-quality Italian dining experience that stands out in New York. The restaurant's commitment to using housemade pastas and fresh ingredients is evident in every dish. The menu, while offering traditional favorites, also includes some true standouts. The sweet corn agnolotti is a "highly recommended" dish, praised for its incredible flavor profile. Another highlight is the lamb ribs, which are "simply amazing" and have been endorsed by a professional chef. The rich and flavorful ragu is noted as a "highlight," providing a comforting and delicious experience. The attention to detail in the food is matched by the impressive beverage program. The extensive wine list is a major draw for wine lovers, and the bar's focus on Italian cocktails and a vast collection of amaro provides a unique and sophisticated way to start or end a meal. The availability of happy hour specials on both food and drinks makes this fine dining experience more accessible and is a great way to sample some of their popular dishes. While some dishes might be "hit or miss" for some palates, the overall quality and creativity are consistently high.

Beyond the food and drinks, the atmosphere and service at Carlotto make it a worthwhile destination. The space is beautifully designed, creating a romantic and upscale yet comfortable setting. The staff, like the "wonderful" server Kim, are consistently praised for their top-notch service and hospitality. They are attentive without being intrusive, which enhances the overall dining experience. The restaurant is a great option for a wide variety of occasions, whether it's a romantic dinner for two, a family meal, or a larger group gathering in their private dining room. The fact that it is family-friendly and offers high chairs and a kids' menu shows its versatility. In a city with countless Italian restaurants, Carlotto distinguishes itself by delivering a full sensory experience—from the delicious food and curated drinks to the beautiful ambiance and impeccable service. It’s a place that promises a memorable and satisfying evening, making it a destination you will want to return to and recommend to others.

Carlotto

100 E 19th St, New York, NY 10003, USA