Holy Pita

- 263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers seeking a genuine taste of the Middle East, specifically the vibrant and soulful experience of Israeli street food, Holy Pita Prospect Park stands out as a true culinary gem in Brooklyn. Located conveniently near the sprawling green space of Prospect Park, this spot is much more than just a sandwich shop; it’s a destination for authentic, multi-generational recipes brought to life with fresh, quality ingredients. From the moment you step in, the welcoming atmosphere—often described by customers as cozy and full of charm—sets the stage for a delightful, casual dining experience.

Holy Pita has successfully carved out a reputation for serving some of the best falafel and shawarma in Brooklyn, impressing locals with generous portions and a focus on profound, authentic flavors. The cuisine is rooted in Mediterranean and Middle Eastern traditions, offering a diverse menu that caters to a wide array of preferences and dietary needs, including robust vegan and vegetarian selections that are clearly marked. Whether you are craving a quick, satisfying lunch, a hearty dinner, or a flavorful brunch, Holy Pita delivers a consistent, high-quality meal every time. Their commitment to authenticity is evident in their use of spices sourced from the markets of origin and their dedication to time-honored cooking techniques.

Beyond the traditional pita sandwiches—which customers rave are "probably the best pita in Brooklyn"—the menu features substantial main courses, refreshing salads, and delicious Malawach, a delightfully flaky, traditional Yemenite flatbread. This dedication to diverse and expertly prepared dishes is what makes Holy Pita a popular choice in the Prospect Park and surrounding Brooklyn neighborhoods.

Location and Accessibility

The Prospect Park location of Holy Pita makes it an ideal spot for Brooklyn residents and visitors looking for authentic Mediterranean food. Situated at 263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA, the restaurant is perfectly positioned to serve the community, whether you're finishing a run around the park or looking for a casual meal with family and friends.

This location offers an inviting atmosphere with seating available for dine-in customers. It's known for having a casual vibe, welcoming families and individuals alike, and is noted as being an LGBTQ+ friendly establishment. For those who enjoy dining al fresco, Holy Pita is equipped with Outdoor Seating. A major bonus, especially in an urban environment like Brooklyn, is that the location is pet-friendly, with a policy of Dogs Allowed both outside and inside, making it an easy stop for dog-owners.

While specific architectural accessibility details are not fully public, the restaurant’s business listing notes a focus on general Accessibility to ensure a broad welcome to the community. For those driving, Paid Street Parking is available nearby. The central location provides easy access for quick pickups and deliveries throughout the area.

Services Offered

Holy Pita Prospect Park provides a variety of convenient services to ensure a fantastic dining experience, regardless of how you choose to enjoy your meal.

• Dine-in Seating: Enjoy a casual meal inside the cozy restaurant or take advantage of the outdoor seating.
• Takeout and Curbside Pickup: Convenient options for grabbing your meal on the go.
• Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Full delivery service to bring the flavors of Holy Pita directly to your home or office.
• Catering: Services available for events and larger gatherings, perfect for office lunch or a family celebration.
• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, making planning for a small group easier.
• Dining Times: Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and general Solo Dining, also serving Brunch and late-night food options.
• Payment Options: Accepts a wide range of payment methods including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

Holy Pita's commitment to quality and diverse offerings makes it a standout choice for Mediterranean cuisine in New York City.

• Authentic Middle Eastern & Israeli Street Food: The menu is inspired by the owner's travels and features authentic spices and time-honored recipes, ensuring a world-class taste experience.
• Vegan and Vegetarian Excellence: Holy Pita excels in offering clearly marked and highly-rated plant-based dishes, including the acclaimed Vegan Shawarma (made with jackfruit) and the Falafel Pita Sandwich, which is frequently praised as some of the best falafel in NYC.
• Signature Malawach Dishes: Experience the delicious, flaky traditional Yemenite bread with savory fillings like the Iraqi Malawach (grilled eggplant, hardboiled egg, hummus) or sweet options like the LAWO Malawach (Nutella spread and bananas).
• Must-Try Menu Items: Customer favorites include the juicy Chicken Shawarma Pita Sandwich (often called the best pita in Brooklyn), the flavorful Sabich (a vegetarian delight with eggplant and egg), and the popular Coffee Tahini Shake.
• Health-Conscious Offerings: The menu prominently features Healthy Options and Organic Dishes alongside their comforting staples, all made with fresh, locally sourced produce whenever possible.
• Unique Dessert and Sides: Beyond the main dishes, Holy Pita offers unique sides like Sumac Fries and the traditional Middle Eastern dessert, Baklava.
• Family and Community Focus: The casual, family-friendly atmosphere welcomes all. The team is known for being super friendly, helpful, and creating a genuine, welcoming environment for the local community.

What is Worth Choosing

If you're making your first trip to Holy Pita, the range of excellent choices can be exciting. The restaurant is a specialist, operating across multiple types including Falafel, Shawarma, and Middle Eastern cuisine, which means you can trust the quality of their signature dishes.

For a classic, highly recommended choice, you simply must try one of the Holy Pita Sandwiches. The Chicken Shawarma is consistently a top favorite, described by patrons as juicy, perfectly spiced, and served on a soft, warm pita. It’s a substantial meal that perfectly captures the heart of Israeli street food. The Falafel Pita Sandwich is also a must-have, with reviewers calling the falafel "crunchy outside n moist interior" and arguably the best falafel sandwich in New York.

Vegetarians and vegans have exceptional choices, moving well beyond basic options. The Vegan Shawarma Pita, utilizing seasoned jackfruit, is a powerful choice that provides a deeply satisfying, savory experience, or you can opt for the highly-rated Sabich Pita Sandwich, a vegetarian masterpiece with grilled eggplant, hard-boiled egg, and tangy amba sauce.

If you are dining in and looking for something more substantial, consider a Main Event plate, such as That - Chicken Shawarma, which features the famous shawarma served with Persian basmati rice, hummus, and a selection of fresh salads. This is a great way to sample a variety of textures and flavors.

Finally, don't overlook the unique dessert offerings. The Baklava is a wonderful, traditional finish, and the Tahini Shakes (especially the Coffee Tahini Shake) are a distinct and delicious treat that customers often mention as a highlight of their visit. Holy Pita is not just about a quick bite; it's about an experience of authentic, fresh, and soul-satisfying food. The genuine passion that the owner and staff put into their food is clear in every dish, making it a truly 'holy' grail of Middle Eastern dining in Brooklyn.

Contact Information

For more information or to place an order, please use the following details:

Address: 263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (646) 323-3170

Holy Pita

263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA