Isabella's Prime Pizza

- 1875 Ocean Blvd, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers looking for a genuine taste of Italy without leaving Long Island, Isabella's Prime Pizza stands out as a must-visit local establishment. Located right in the beautiful beach community of Atlantic Beach, NY, this spot is more than just a pizza shop—it is a full-fledged Italian restaurant committed to serving authentic Italian flavors with a modern sensibility. From traditional pasta dishes to signature specialty pizzas, Isabella’s Prime Pizza offers a comprehensive menu that appeals to families, beachgoers, and local residents alike.

The philosophy at Isabella's Prime Pizza centers on quality ingredients and exceptional, friendly service. Customer reviews frequently highlight the excellent food, with some patrons even comparing the quality favorably to dishes they’ve enjoyed in Italy. The atmosphere is often described as great, welcoming, and the staff is consistently noted as friendly and respectful. Whether you're craving a classic cheese slice or a hearty hero, Isabella's is dedicated to providing a satisfying culinary experience. It’s a great place to stop by after a day enjoying the pristine beaches and low-key atmosphere that Atlantic Beach is known for.

Location and Accessibility

Isabella's Prime Pizza is perfectly situated to serve the Atlantic Beach and greater Long Island communities. You can find this authentic Italian spot right on Ocean Boulevard, making it a convenient destination for both locals and those visiting the scenic barrier island. The specific address is 1875 Ocean Blvd, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509, USA. Being in Atlantic Beach, it’s easily accessible from neighboring areas like Long Beach, Lido Beach, and the Five Towns via the Atlantic Beach Bridge.

The restaurant's location on Ocean Blvd places it close to the various private beach clubs and the boardwalk, making it a natural choice for a delicious meal or a quick, satisfying slice. While Atlantic Beach is primarily a residential community, its quiet charm and easy connection to Nassau County make it a desirable spot. For those driving, the location is simple to find, and being on a major local thoroughfare enhances its accessibility. Patrons have noted the ease of service, which extends to their convenient options for picking up orders. The combination of a prime location and easy accessibility ensures that getting your Italian fix at Isabella's Prime Pizza is never a hassle.

Services Offered

Isabella's Prime Pizza offers several service options designed for maximum customer convenience, catering to a variety of dining preferences. Whether you prefer to sit down for a relaxing meal, grab a quick bite to enjoy at home, or have your order brought right to your car, the restaurant is set up to accommodate your needs.

• Curbside Pickup: An excellent option for customers on the go, allowing you to quickly collect your order without having to leave your vehicle.
• Takeout: Perfect for those who want to grab their favorite Italian dishes and enjoy them at home or at one of Atlantic Beach's beautiful spots.
• Dine-in: A comfortable and welcoming environment for those who wish to enjoy their meal right at the restaurant, offering a chance to experience the 'great atmosphere' that customers often mention.
• Accepts Reservations: For those planning a dinner or a larger gathering, the option to reserve a table is available, ensuring a smooth and stress-free dining experience.

Features / Highlights

Isabella's Prime Pizza sets itself apart with several key features that make it a favorite among New York diners seeking quality Italian fare and pizza. The menu is diverse, moving beyond standard offerings to include specialty items that have garnered high praise from the community.

• Authentic Italian Cuisine: The restaurant is passionate about serving authentic Italian dishes, ensuring a true taste of Italy in every bite.
• Diverse Pizza Selection: They offer a wide range of pizza styles including Regular Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, and Grandma Pizza, alongside unique specialty pies like Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Chicken Parm Pizza, and the noted Vegetable Pizza.
• Signature Specialty Pies: The menu features creative and highly-rated options like the 'Thai' pizza and the 'Isabella' pizza, which customers have called "A+."
• Comprehensive Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu includes classic Italian staples such as a variety of Pasta dishes (Penne Alla Vodka, Baked Lasagna, Linguini With Shrimp & Broccoli), classic Heros (Shrimp Parm, Chicken Parm, Meatball Parm), appetizers (Fried Ravioli, Mozzarella Sticks), and main courses like Chicken Marsala and Chicken Francese.
• Friendly and Experienced Staff: Many reviews praise the 'great people,' 'very friendly staff,' and the 'respectful staff.' One review specifically mentions the owner having been in the business for 40 years, highlighting a long-standing commitment to quality and service.

Contact Information

Reaching out to Isabella's Prime Pizza is easy for New York residents looking to place an order, make a reservation, or inquire about the menu. The restaurant offers both a standard phone line and a mobile contact number.

Address: 1875 Ocean Blvd, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509, USA

Phone: (516) 906-9639

Mobile Phone: +1 516-906-9639

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Isabella's Prime Pizza is choosing a high-quality Italian and pizza experience rooted in tradition and exceptional customer care. The restaurant’s dedication to using quality ingredients and providing a menu with both beloved classics and exciting new flavors makes it a standout dining option in the Atlantic Beach area. While one customer noted the price of a slice, the general consensus across multiple reviews is overwhelmingly positive regarding the value, service, and, most importantly, the taste.

The pizza selection is undoubtedly a primary draw. Options like the simple yet satisfying Regular Pizza, the hearty Sicilian Slice, or the upscale specialty pies demonstrate the range of skill in the kitchen. For those seeking something heartier, the extensive pasta menu, featuring classics like Baked Ziti and the rich Fettuccine Alfredo, provides a complete Italian dining experience. The Heros are also a fantastic option for lunch or a quick dinner, with options like the Chicken Parm and Eggplant Parm heroes offering savory comfort.

Furthermore, the customer experience at Isabella's is consistently top-tier. Diners report "great service" and a "friendly staff," contributing to a "great atmosphere." This is a place where staff takes the time to engage with patrons, creating a welcoming, neighborhood feel that is highly valued. For a dependable, delicious, and friendly Italian dining spot in the Nassau County area, Isabella's Prime Pizza delivers on all fronts, offering authentic Italian dishes with a smile. It is an ideal local choice for your next pizza night or Italian feast.

Isabella's Prime Pizza

1875 Ocean Blvd, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509, USA