Johnny's Pizzeria

- 5806 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220

Johnny's Pizzeria: Serving Generations of Authentic Brooklyn Pizza on 5th Avenue

For New Yorkers seeking the quintessential "old-school" Brooklyn pizza experience, Johnny's Pizzeria on 5th Avenue in Sunset Park is a time-tested institution. This is more than just a slice shop; it is a full-service Italian and Pizza restaurant that has become a foundational piece of the local culinary landscape. Johnny's has earned its reputation through decades of dedication to fresh ingredients, soft yet crisp dough, and a bright, flavorful sauce that defines quality New York-style pizza.

The establishment is highly regarded for its authentic, no-frills approach to dining—a classic counter-serve experience where the focus remains strictly on the excellence of the food. While the name is synonymous with phenomenal pizza, the menu extends far beyond, incorporating a wide array of Italian American comfort foods, including fully composed Pasta Dishes, classic Hot Hero sandwiches, and various appetizers designed to satisfy a demanding New York clientele.

What truly sets Johnny's Pizzeria apart, according to loyal patrons, is the personal touch and genuine care from the ownership. The long-standing, family-style operation fosters a relationship of trust with the community, particularly regarding customer needs like dietary restrictions and allergies. This dedication to serving everyone with attention and respect solidifies Johnny's status as a top-tier neighborhood fixture and a must-visit destination for anyone craving "the real deal" Brooklyn pizza.

Whether you're stopping by for a quick, affordable Slice during your Lunch break or ordering a full spread of Italian dinner and specialty pies for a family gathering, Johnny's Pizzeria is committed to delivering quality, authentic food that tastes of traditional New York.

Location and Accessibility

Johnny's Pizzeria is conveniently situated in the heart of Sunset Park, Brooklyn, a vibrant and easily accessible neighborhood:

5806 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA

Located on the heavily trafficked 5th Avenue, the pizzeria is easy to reach via public transportation and serves as a natural stop for locals and those passing through. The surrounding area offers the characteristic energy of a Brooklyn neighborhood, and the establishment’s reputation is a beacon for authentic Italian food lovers. Given that the experience is an old-school counter-serve environment, most transactions are focused on Takeout, Delivery, or quick Lunch service.

Contact Information

For placing orders for Delivery, arranging a large Catering job, or making an inquiry, Johnny's Pizzeria can be reached using the following numbers:

Phone: (718) 492-9735

Mobile Phone: +1 718-492-9735

Services Offered

Johnny's Pizzeria focuses on maximum convenience and extensive menu variety, ensuring they can serve individuals, families, and large events across the New York region:

• Full Pizza Delivery Service: Functions primarily as a Pizza delivery provider, offering quick service across the local area.
• Multiple Service Options: Provides easy access with standard Delivery, Takeout, and an option for No-contact delivery.
• Comprehensive Catering: Officially operates as a Caterer, specializing in large orders of pizza, pasta trays, and appetizers for parties and events.
• Lunch Service: A dedicated Dining option for Lunch, accommodating the needs of the working day with fast service and slices.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts all modern payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for seamless transactions.
• Reservation Acceptance: Uniquely, the establishment Accepts reservations, a helpful feature when planning a larger gathering or mealtime at the venue.
• Vegetarian Inclusivity: Offers extensive Vegetarian options across the menu, ensuring non-meat eaters have a variety of choices beyond the classic cheese pie.

Features / Highlights

The long-standing reputation of Johnny's Pizzeria is built on a range of authentic Italian and New York-centric features and menu items that stand out in a competitive food city:

• The Famous Square Pie and Grandma Slice: The pizzeria is particularly famous for its Square Pie ($18.00) and the thick, crispy-crusted Sicilian Slice ($2.50). The Grandma Pie ($18.00) and its corresponding Grandma Slice ($2.25) are also celebrated highlights, representing true old-school Brooklyn styles.
• Specialty Pizza Pies: The menu features inventive specialty pies that merge Italian classics with pizza, such as the hearty Lasagna Pie ($14.00) and the comforting Baked Ziti Pie ($17.00). The Fresh Mozzarella Pie ($18.00) speaks to the quality of ingredients used.
• Deep-Dive Italian Entrees: Beyond pizza, Johnny’s provides a full Italian dinner experience. The expansive Pasta Dishes menu includes classics like Baked Ziti, Lasagna, Stuffed Shells, and Ravioli (all starting at $8.00), with the option to add Meatballs, Sausage, or Chicken for a complete, affordable meal.
• Signature Hot Heroes and Rolls: The Famous Hot Heros section features traditional, substantial choices like Chicken Parmigiana and Meatball, all available for under $7.50. The Rolls and Calzones—including the satisfying Chicken Parmigiana Roll ($5.50)—offer great grab-and-go meal options.
• Customer-Centric Service: The owner’s personal attentiveness to customer needs, especially regarding food allergies, is a major highlight, instilling a high level of trust and loyalty among the New York community.
• Excellent Value for Money: The pricing structure is incredibly competitive for New York City, with the basic Slice at $2.50, and a Pizza Pie starting around $14.00 for a small, making it a very affordable daily lunch or dinner spot.
• Extensive Appetizer Selection: The Appetizers menu is comprehensive, featuring all the essential sides from Garlic Knots (5 for $2.00) and Mozzarella Sticks (4 for $2.25) to Buffalo Wings (8 for $7.00) and Beef Patties, providing options for any size of appetite or party.

What is Worth Choosing

For a New York user looking to experience the best of Johnny's Pizzeria, the choice should focus on their iconic staples and highly praised comfort foods that reflect the establishment's deep Brooklyn roots.

The most recommended choice is their celebrated Square Pie or Sicilian Slice. This is the item that has historically brought them fame and is often cited as a benchmark for quality in the area. For those seeking an inventive meal-on-a-pie, the Lasagna Pie ($14.00) or the Baked Ziti Pie ($17.00) are unique, hearty options that combine two beloved Italian dishes into one satisfying format.

When looking for a full dinner without committing to a whole pie, selecting one of the Pasta Dishes is an excellent value proposition. A plate of Spaghetti w/Meatballs or Sausage ($11.00), or the Baked Ziti ($8.00), offers a generous portion of authentic Italian comfort food at a very appealing price point, especially when upgraded to a Plate for $1 extra.

Finally, for a quick and satisfying lunch, opt for one of the specialty slices like the Fresh Mozzarella Slice ($3.00) or a classic Chicken Parmigiana Roll ($5.50). With convenient options for Delivery and Takeout, and an unwavering commitment to quality ingredients, Johnny's Pizzeria is the reliable Brooklyn institution for satisfying any New York pizza craving, whether you are dining solo or catering an entire event.

Johnny's Pizzeria

5806 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11220, USA