My Pie Pizzeria Romana

- 690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022

In a city where pizza is a way of life, finding a slice that stands out from the crowd is a true accomplishment. My Pie Pizzeria Romana does just that by bringing the distinct, delicious style of Roman pizza to the bustling streets of New York. Unlike the thin, foldable New York slice, Roman-style pizza is known for its light, crispy, and airy crust. This unique approach, combined with a commitment to fresh, quality ingredients and a wide variety of toppings, has made My Pie a beloved spot for a quick bite or a satisfying meal. It is a place that successfully blends the casual, grab-and-go nature of a slice shop with the authentic flavors of an Italian restaurant. Whether you're a local on a lunch break or a tourist exploring the area, this pizzeria offers a memorable culinary experience that is both authentic and approachable.

The menu at My Pie Pizzeria Romana is an impressive showcase of creativity and tradition. It features a wide array of pizzas, each one handcrafted with care. You’ll find classic options like the Margherita and Pepperoni, but the true magic lies in their inventive combinations. Fan favorites include the Truffle Oil and Mushroom, which offers a decadent and earthy flavor, and the Buffalo Chicken, which provides a spicy kick. The menu also caters to a variety of dietary preferences, with an extensive selection of vegan options, including the Vegan Seasonal Veggie and the Vegan Eggplant Pizza, making it a truly inclusive spot for everyone. This dedication to variety and quality is a key reason why many consider it their "favorite spot to grab a slice of pizza in NY." The generosity with toppings and the perfectly crispy crust are consistent points of praise from patrons, proving that the team at My Pie is committed to delivering excellence with every pie.

The atmosphere at My Pie Pizzeria Romana is best described as casual and friendly. It is the kind of place where you feel instantly welcomed, and the staff is noted for their friendliness and willingness to go the extra mile. One reviewer highlighted the staff's impressive ability to remember them even after a long absence, a detail that speaks volumes about the personalized service they provide. While the interior seating is limited to about five small tables, which can get crowded during peak hours, this simply adds to its cozy, authentic vibe. The focus on takeout and delivery is a testament to its understanding of the New York lifestyle. The convenient to-go boxes allow customers to enjoy their slices on the go or in one of the many beautiful nearby parks, which is a perfect solution for the busy city environment. The clientele is a mix of college students and tourists, all drawn in by the promise of a great slice in a relaxed setting.

The quality of the food is a recurring theme in reviews, with many praising the crispy and airy crust, which is a hallmark of authentic Roman-style pizza. The slices are large and filling, offering excellent value for the price. While some reviews mention issues with delivery timing or food arriving cold, these are often attributed to third-party delivery services and not the quality of the food itself. The dedication of the staff is evident in stories from customers, such as the time they offered to make a fresh pie when a favorite flavor had run out. This kind of customer service is rare and makes a lasting impression. Beyond the pizza, the restaurant also offers a selection of Italian desserts imported from Milan, such as Coppa Tiramisu and Coppa 3 Chocolate, providing a perfect way to finish off a delicious meal.

My Pie Pizzeria Romana is centrally located at 690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA, placing it in a prime spot in Midtown. Its location makes it a highly convenient option for anyone working or visiting the area, with easy access to various subway lines and major streets. The proximity to landmarks and office buildings means it's a popular choice for a quick and satisfying lunch. The ease of getting there and the fast service make it an ideal spot for a quick bite on a busy day. While there are no specific accessibility notes provided beyond the restaurant's type, its focus on takeout and quick service makes it an efficient option for all.

My Pie Pizzeria Romana offers a variety of services designed for maximum convenience and enjoyment.

• Customers can choose from delivery, takeout, and dine-in options.
• It is a popular spot for lunch and dinner, as well as a great option for solo dining.
• The menu includes offerings such as comfort food, organic dishes, and vegetarian and vegan options.
• It is an excellent choice for a quick bite, with fast service and ready-to-go slices.
• Payments are made easy with the acceptance of credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• The restaurant is noted as being good for kids, with a casual and family-friendly atmosphere.

Several features and highlights make My Pie Pizzeria Romana a standout choice for pizza lovers in New York.

• The unique Roman-style pizza, with its crispy, airy crust, sets it apart from traditional New York slices.
• The wide variety of flavors and generous toppings are a key highlight.
• The extensive vegan menu makes it a rare and appealing option for those with plant-based diets.
• The staff is consistently praised for their friendliness and excellent customer service.
• The casual and chill atmosphere makes it a great spot for a relaxed meal.
• The convenient location and fast service are perfect for the fast-paced life in Midtown.

For more information, here is the essential contact information for My Pie Pizzeria Romana.

Address: 690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA

Phone: (212) 317-1850 or +1 212-317-1850

What is worth choosing at My Pie Pizzeria Romana? The real answer is the pizza itself. The unique Roman style is a must-try for anyone who appreciates a different kind of crust. The Buffalo Chicken and Truffle Oil and Mushroom pizzas are highly recommended for their exceptional flavor profiles. For a classic taste, the Grandma Nonnina Pizza and Mozzarella di Buffalo Cheese Pizza are excellent choices. Vegetarians and vegans will appreciate the dedicated and delicious vegan options, which are a testament to the restaurant's commitment to quality for all customers. Beyond the food, what is truly worth choosing is the experience. It’s the combination of the high-quality, flavorful slices, the fast and friendly service, and the chill atmosphere that makes it a favorite spot for so many. Whether you're a long-time resident or just passing through, My Pie Pizzeria Romana offers a slice of Italian authenticity that is hard to beat in the city.

My Pie Pizzeria Romana

690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, USA