Pantano's Eatery: Your Top Sandwich Shop & Deli Destination in Plainview, NY

Pantano's Eatery Introduce

For those living in and around **Plainview, New York**, and the greater **Long Island** area, finding a truly exceptional sandwich shop and deli is often a top priority. Look no further than **Pantano's Eatery**, a local favorite that consistently delivers not just great sandwiches, but a full-spectrum culinary experience. Positioned as a premier spot for everything from a hearty breakfast to a satisfying dinner, Pantano's has earned a stellar reputation for its quality ingredients, impressive variety, and friendly, top-notch customer service. While the name suggests a focus on quick and casual dining—a role it certainly fills with excellence—Pantano's Eatery elevates the concept of a local deli, offering extensive menus that rival full-service restaurants.

The vibe at Pantano's is best described as **casual and cozy**, creating a welcoming atmosphere that feels inherently **family-friendly**. It’s the kind of place where you can quickly grab a lunch-to-go or settle in for a relaxed, delicious meal. New Yorkers with high standards for their Italian-American deli fare will appreciate the attention to detail and authenticity. One customer, claiming to be "SUPER picky" about Italian food, even hailed it as the **"Best deli on Long Island,"** a testament to the quality and care put into their extensive offerings, particularly the Italian-inspired heroes and pasta dishes.

Location and Accessibility

Pantano's Eatery is conveniently located at **347 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803**. This address places it squarely in the heart of a vibrant Long Island community, making it an easy stop for local residents, commuters, and those passing through the Plainview area. Its placement ensures it is a fantastic option for a mid-day lunch break or a weekend family meal. The location is easily reachable by car, and accessibility is a key focus for the establishment, ensuring a smooth experience for all customers.

The shop is committed to providing an accessible environment for everyone. Specifically, the following **accessibility features** are provided, making the deli a comfortable choice for a diverse clientele:

**Wheelchair accessible entrance**
**Wheelchair accessible parking lot**
**Wheelchair accessible restroom**
**Wheelchair accessible seating**

For those driving, finding a spot is never an issue, as Pantano's offers both a **free parking lot** and the option of **free street parking**, which is a significant amenity in the bustling Long Island area.

Services Offered

Pantano's Eatery offers a wide array of services designed to meet various customer needs, whether you're looking for a quick meal, a seated dining experience, or food for a large event. They cater to all dining occasions, from your morning caffeine fix to feeding an entire office.

**Dine-in and Seating:** Enjoy a relaxing meal in the cozy atmosphere with dedicated seating.
**Takeout:** Perfect for busy locals who want to grab their order and go.
**Delivery:** Convenient service for homes and offices in the local Plainview region, making it simple to enjoy their food without leaving your location.
**Outdoor Seating:** An option for enjoying your meal outside when the weather is nice.
**Catering:** They offer extensive catering services, as evidenced by a customer who noted their office utilizes their daily specials menu and large-order delivery service, making Pantano's a reliable choice for workplace meals and events.
**Payment Flexibility:** They accept various payment methods for ease of transaction, including **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Pantano's Eatery apart is the sheer variety and quality of its menu, going far beyond the typical sandwich shop fare. They offer comfort food, healthy options, and quick bites, truly catering to every preference and dietary need. Their menu is so expansive that many customers find their portions to be quite generous—often described as "huge," with most sandwiches and meals easily becoming "2 day meals."

Key highlights and features of Pantano's menu and experience include:

**P-licious Paninis and Signature Specialties:** The menu boasts creative and popular items like the **The Anderson**, **The Larry**, and the local favorite **The Pantano Special**. Other signature heroes include the classic **Philly Cheese Steak Hero** and the well-regarded **Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero**.
**All-Day Dining:** They are a popular choice for all three main meals, with special recognition for **Breakfast** and **Lunch**. The breakfast menu is robust, featuring items like the **Sunrise Quesadilla**, the hearty **The Big Boy**, and various omelets from the **Omelette Station**, alongside classic **Bagels** and options from **On the Griddle** like **Homemade Golden Brown French Toast**.
**Authentic Italian and Comfort Food:** Beyond the cold cuts, they offer a vast selection of homemade Italian-American dishes, including the acclaimed **Chicken Vodka Parm** and a range of **Signature Pastas** like **Penne Alla Vodka** and **Rigatoni Bolognese**. The **Baked Pastas**, such as **Baked Ziti** and **Meat Baked Lasagna**, are popular comfort food choices.
**Diverse Offerings:** The menu extends to include modern trends like **Acai Bowls**, a full selection of **Wraps**, and various **Smashed Burgers** and classic **Burgers**. They even feature a separate **Kid's Menu** with items like **Mac & Cheese Junior** and **Grilled Cheese Junior**, solidifying their reputation as **good for kids**.
**Baked Goods and Coffee:** For a sweet treat, they offer fresh options like **Rainbow Cookies** and **Fresh Baked Cookies**, paired perfectly with their **Iced Coffee (24 Oz)**.

Contact Information

For placing an order, inquiring about catering, or checking on the daily specials menu that they fax to local offices, Pantano's Eatery can be reached using the following details:

Address: 347 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803

Phone: (516) 931-8800

Mobile Phone: +1 516-931-8800

What Is Worth Choosing?

If you’re in the New York area, particularly near Plainview, **Pantano's Eatery** is worth choosing for several compelling reasons. They are more than just a place to grab a sandwich; they are a comprehensive local deli and eatery built on quality and variety. The size and scope of their menu mean there is literally something for everyone, making it the perfect spot to satisfy a group with diverse tastes. Whether you're craving a simple deli sandwich (where you can **Build Your Deli Sandwich** with options like **Roast Beef** or **Homemade Chicken Salad**), a hearty, authentic Italian hero, or a satisfying breakfast to start your day, Pantano's delivers.

Specifically, the consistent praise for their Italian food, such as the customer who raved about the **twice fried chicken parm ala vodka** special, suggests that diving into their hot heroes and baked pasta sections will yield some of the most memorable meals. Their reputation for large portions offers incredible value, ensuring your lunch might cover your dinner, too. For local businesses, their efficient delivery and catering services make them an invaluable partner for feeding teams. Ultimately, Pantano's Eatery stands out on Long Island as a **must-try local institution** where quality food, a friendly atmosphere, and extensive choice come together seamlessly.

Pantano's Eatery Vibe

Hot Stuff
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero $17.95
Fried Eggplant w/ mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce.
Meatball Parmigiana Hero $17.95
Meatballs w/ mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce.
Chicken Quesadilla $19.99
With peppers, onions, sour cream and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of French fries.
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Hero $18.95
Chicken Cutlet w/ mozzarella cheese, marinara sauce.
Beef Quesadilla $16.99
With peppers, onions, sour cream and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of rice or regular fries.
Chicken Vodka Parm $18.95
Chicken cutlet w/ mozzarella cheese, vodka sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
Philly Cheese Steak Hero $17.95
Sliced Philly steak with peppers, onions, cheddar cheese and mayo.

Breakfast Sides
Homefries $7.99
Side order of Homemade Homefries

P-licious Paninis
The Anderson $18.95
Mini crab cakes, Asian slaw, goat cheese with southwest mayonnaise. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Larry $18.95
Grilled cajun shrimp, avocado, applewood bacon, romaine and tomatoes with 1000 island dressing Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Cathy $17.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with American cheese, lettuce, tomato and 1000 island dressing. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Peter $18.95
Imported prosciutto with fresh mozzarella, baby arugula and sliced tomatoes with balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Turnpike $17.95
Grilled pastrami with swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes and mustard. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Francisco $18.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with breaded eggplant, mozzarella and vodka sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Carlo $17.95
Grilled chicken with onions, provolone cheese and pesto mayonnaise. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Nonna Rosa $16.95
Grilled chicken with roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella and balsamic vinaigrette. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Griller $17.95
Grilled Roast Beef with mozzarella cheese and brown gravy. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Gianluca (John Luca) $17.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, bleu cheese. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Marco $17.95
Fried raviolis, sundried tomatoes, marinara sauce with mozzarella cheese. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

Baked Goods
Rainbow Cookies $6.99
Yogurt Muffins $4.99
Choose from: Corn, Blueberry, Banana Nut, Banana Chip, Cappuccino, Cinnamuffin, Chocolate or Vanilla Chip and more.
Fresh Baked Cookies $3.99
Fresh Baked Daily

Bagels
Individual Bagel $2.99
Plain, everything, sesame, poppy, cinnamon raisin, egg, garlic, pumpernickel, whole wheat, whole wheat everything.
Bagel With Butter $5.95
Plain Bagel with Butter ( While supplies are available )

Appetizers
Mozzarella Sticks (6) $11.99
Served with a side of marinara sauce.
Mini Crab Cakes (6) $14.95
Served with a side of Asian slaw and chipotle sauce.
Homemade Soup (16 Oz) $8.99
Made fresh daily.
Chicken Tenders (4) $12.95
Served with a side of honey mustard.
Fried Ravioli $14.95
Served with a side of marinara sauce.
Creamed Homemade Spinach Dip $16.99
Served with a side of pita chips and homemade nacho chips.
Sampler $14.99
Two pieces potato skins, four pieces mozzarella sticks and four pieces buffalo wings.
Garlic Mozzarella Bread $9.99
Garlic bread with melted mozzarella cheese and a side of marinara sauce.
Chicken Wings (12) $16.99
Plain, Buffalo,Honey BBQ.

Signature Pastas
Gnocchi (Full) $11.99
Fresh potato pasta topped with sauce, fresh mozzarella and basil.
Rigatoni Bolognese $19.99
Fresh ground meat with garlic and pomodoro sauce.
Spaghetti Calamari Marinara (Full) $14.99
Fresh calamari sautéed in a traditional garlic and herb plum tomato sauce.
Penne Caprese $19.99
Penne pasta topped with fresh homemade mozzarella cheese and sautéed in plum tomato and basil sauce.
Bow Tie Delite $16.99
Bowtie pasta with grilled chicken, broccoli rabe with sundried tomato, all sautéed in garlic and oil.
Spaghetti Pomodoro $7.99
Pantano's homemade tomato sauce served over spaghetti.
Vegetable Ravioli Primavera (Full) $16.99
Cheese ravioli in a light primavera sauce mixed with fresh grilled vegetables.
Rigatoni Fiorentina $18.99
Fresh chicken medallions with spinach and mozzarella cheese, sautéed in a creamy pink sauce.
Penne Al Pesto $19.99
Penne pasta with homemade pesto sauce.
Penne Alla Vodka $19.99
Imported prosciutto sautéed in a creamy pink vodka sauce.
Spaghetti Pomodoro With Italian Sausage $9.99
Pantano's homemade tomato sauce served over spaghetti.
Tortellini Alfredo $19.99
Our classic light cream sauce topped with parmigiano reggiano.
Spaghetti Pomodoro With Meatballs $9.99
Pantano's homemade tomato sauce served over spaghetti.
Rigatoni Alla Siciliana $16.99
Fresh battered eggplant, basil, garlic parmigiana and our traditional pomodoro sauce, topped with fresh mozzarella.

Baked Pastas
Baked Ziti $19.99
With seasoned ricotta cheese, pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.
Vegetable Baked Lasagna (Full) $10.99
Traditional classic lasagna with seasoned ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella and pomodoro sauce.
Meat Baked Lasagna (Full) $10.99
Traditional classic lasagna with seasoned ricotta cheese, melted mozzarella and pomodoro sauce.
Baked Ravioli (Full) $10.99
Filled with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.
Baked Manicotti (Full) $10.99
Fresh pasta stuffed with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.
Baked Stuffed Shells (Full) $10.99
Jumbo pasta shells stuffed with seasoned ricotta cheese, topped with fresh pomodoro sauce and melted mozzarella.

Wraps
The Megan $17.95
Penne alla vodka with crispy chicken cutlet stuffed in a Wrap. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Broadway $17.95
Balsamic grilled chicken, and fresh grilled vegetables Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Terrific Teriyaki $17.95
Teriyaki chicken and rice. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Ruth's $17.95
Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Gittleson $16.59
Grilled chicken with homemade creamed spinach. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Mezz $17.95
Grilled chicken, feta cheese, lettuce, tomato and Italian dressing. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Gabby $17.95
Crispy chicken, mac n cheese, bacon bits and mozzarella sticks. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Rob $17.95
Boneless buffalo crispy chicken with jalapeños, fresh mozzarella, lettuce and bleu cheese. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Stoner $17.95
Baked chicken cutlet parmigiana with side of marinara sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $17.95
Grilled chicken Caesar.
The Big John $17.95
Crispy chicken fingers, mozzarella, brown gravy and French fries (Inside). Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Amigo $17.95
Pesto grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, and tomato. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Crazy Rich $17.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with cheddar, bacon, ranch, and French fries (Inside). Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Tater $17.95
Crispy Chicken, Spicy Tater Tots, Pepper Jack Cheese, Ranch. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Max $17.95
Breaded eggplant, fresh mozzarella with a creamy vodka sauce. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Nico $17.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with peppers, onions, cheddar cheese and sour cream. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day
The Mia $17.95
Grilled chicken with avocado, gorgonzola, mixed greens and raspberry vinaigrette. Served with Homemade Pasta Salad of the day

Breakfast
Grilled Cheese Special $13.95
Grilled American cheese with crispy bacon and tomato, served with French fries.
Sausage Egg Cheese $9.99
Sausage (Patty) Egg Cheese served on a Roll
Ham Egg Cheese $9.99
Ham Egg Cheese served on a Roll
Egg White Special $10.99
Four fresh egg whites with feta cheese and tomatoes in a wrap.
The Big Boy $13.95
4 Eggs with bacon, sausage, ham and American cheese served on a hero.
Bacon Egg Cheese $9.99
Bacon Egg Cheese served on a Roll
Sunrise Quesadilla $13.95
Grilled steak with scrambled eggs and mozzarella cheese quesadilla style.
Egg Cheese $8.99
Egg Cheese served on a Roll
Classic BLT Sandwich $12.95
Bacon, lettuce and tomato with mayonnaise.

On the Griddle
Belgiun Waffle $9.99
Served with powdered sugar butter and syrup.
Panwich $4.99
Two farm fresh eggs sandwiched between two mini buttermilk pancakes.
Breakfast Combo # 2 $12.99
Buttermilk Pancakes served with Eggwhites and Turkey-Bacon
Breakfast Combo # 1 $12.99
French Toast served with eggs, Bacon strips, Sausage Links
Homemade Golden Brown French Toast (3 Pc) $11.99
Homemade French Toast Served with powdered sugar Side Butter and Syrup.
Heavenly French Toast $14.99
With syrup pre-poured. French toast topped with warm strawberries, sliced bananas and chocolate chips.
Homemade Buttermilk Pancakes (3 Pc) $11.99
Served with powdered sugar with Side Butter and Syrup.
Western Omelette Platter $14.99
(4) Eggs with diced ham, onions and peppers. Platter choice served with homefries and white toast.
Banana Stack $13.99
(3) Buttermilk pancakes topped with fresh bananas, pecans and caramel.
Western Sandwich $9.99
Three eggs with diced ham, onions and peppers.
Ultimate Stack $12.99
Buttermilk pancakes two pieces served with bacon, 3 eggs and American cheese.

Smashed Burgers
(2) Smashed Burgers With Side Fries $10.99
(2) Smashed Burgers with American cheese, pickles, onions, house Russian dressing on a Potato Bun
Smashed Burger Box Deal $19.99
4 x Single Smashed Burgers ( patty/American, pickles, secret sauce )
Triple Smashed Burger $13.00
3 Smashed Patties, American Cheese, pickles, secret sauce on a potato bun
(2) Double Smashed Burger With Side Fries $12.99
(2) Double Smashed Burgers with American cheese, pickles, onions, house Russian dressing on a Potato Bun
Double Smashed Burger $10.00
2 Smashed Patties, American cheese, pickles, Secret sauce on potato bun
Double Double Fatty Melt $10.99
(2) Smashed Burger Patties with onions, American on an Upside down Potato Bun ( Grilled )
Jalapeno Smashed Double $16.00
Double smashed Patties, Swiss cheese, caramelized onion, homemade chipotle sauce, jalapeños on a Potato Bun
Single Smashed Burger $7.00
Smashed Patty, American cheese, pickles, Secret sauce
Filthy Fries $11.50
French Fries topped with American Cheese, caramelized onions, Homemade Chipotle sauce, smashed patty

Fries and Sides
Onion Rings $7.99
Battered.
Disco Fries $10.99
Regular fries with melted mozzarella and (Side) Brown gravy.
Chili Cheese Fries $11.99
Regular fries with American cheese and chili.
Willie Fries $11.99
French fries topped with bacon bits and cheddar cheese.

Signature Entrees
Eggplant Rollatini $13.99
Fresh battered eggplant rolled with seasoned ricotta, baked parmigiana style with tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese, served over penne pasta.
Chicken Francese $12.99
Fresh egg Battered breast of chicken sautéed in a classic white wine, lemon and butter sauce.
Chicken Alla Matteo $10.99
Fresh grilled chicken breast topped with fresh bruschetta. Served over rice.
Balsamic Chicken $12.99
Fresh chicken breast marinated in balsamic vinegar and topped with a mit medley of sautéed fresh garden vegetables. Served over vegetable rice.

Omelette Station
Greek Omelette $13.95
Farm fresh eggs with feta cheese, red onions and black olives.
Create Your Own Omelette $12.95
Omelettes are prepared with three eggs and includes two complimentary fillings.
Spanish Omelette $13.95
Farm fresh eggs with jalapeños, onions, diced ham and salsa.

Signature Specialties
The Classic American $17.95
Roast beef, turkey, ham, American, swiss, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise.
The Il Bacio $8.99
Grilled marinated chicken with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.
The Phil Special $13.99
Grilled roast beef on garlic bread with mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, and Italian dressing.
The Duke's Dip $19.95
Thinly sliced beef or grilled chicken covered with mozzarella cheese garlic mayonnaise on a brick oven hero. Served with au jus sauce and creamy mashed potatoes on the side.
The Burnside $17.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with melted mozzarella and honey mustard.
The Italiano $13.99
Crispy chicken cutlet on garlic bread with grilled ham cappy and mozzarella.
The Rueben Classic $12.99
Grilled pastrami, swiss cheese, coleslaw, russian dressing on toasted rye.
The Jenny $17.95
Crispy chicken cutlet with melted American, lettuce and mayonnaise.
The Delivery Boy Special $8.49
Balsamic grilled chicken, melted swiss, lettuce and tomato.
The Guido $16.99
Crispy chicken cutlet with melted American, bacon and 1000 island dressing.
The Pantano Special $17.95
Genoa salami, mortadella, ham cappy, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato with Italian dressing.
The Pesci $17.95
Grilled roast beef with melted American, onion and 1000 island dressing.
The Michelangelo $17.95
Grilled corned beef with melted swiss, sauerkraut and mustard.

Acai Bowls
Acai Bowl ( 2 Scoops ) $16.95
Topped with Banana | Strawberry | Drizzle Honey | Granola | Coconut Flakes
Acai Bowl (1 Scoop) $9.99
Topped with Banana | Strawberry | Drizzle Honey | Granola | Coconut Flakes

Kid's Menu
Chicken Tender Junior $10.99
Includes side french fries.
Junior House Salad $9.99
Includes side french fries.
Mac & Cheese Junior $10.99
Includes side french fries.
Grilled Cheese Junior $10.99
Includes side french fries.

Build Your Deli Sandwich
Salami $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Ham $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Pepper Turkey $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Homemade Tuna Salad $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Turkey $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Pastrami $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Roast Beef $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Homemade Egg Salad $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Grilled Chicken $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Homemade Chicken Salad $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Salami $11.99
Served with side homemade pasta salad
Buffalo Crispy Chicken $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Bologna $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Honey Turkey $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad
Crispy Chicken Cutlet $11.99
Served with Side Homemade Pasta Salad

Signature Salads
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $18.95
Served mixed with homemade Caesar dressing.
Pantano Salad $16.99
Baby mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers and carrots topped with bbq grilled chicken.
Summer Salad $18.95
Mixed greens, apples, goat cheese, shaved almonds, dried cranberries and chick peas. Chopped.
Spinach Delite $18.95
Spinach leaves, tomatoes, bacon, crumbled egg and grilled chicken.
Sunrise Salad $18.95
Crispy buffalo chicken strips served over romaine hearts with tomatoes and shredded cheddar cheese.
Greek Salad $16.99
Tossed salad, feta cheese, red onions and black olives.
Classic Chef's Salad $16.99
Tossed salad with turkey, ham, American cheese and boiled eggs.
BBQ Popcorn Shrimp $21.95
Served over Caesar salad.
Friedman Salad $18.95
Tossed salad with grilled chicken, and dried cranberries. Chopped.
Diet Delite $18.95
Tossed salad with honey turkey and alpine lace swiss.
Pesto Grilled Chicken Salad $18.95
Served over a tossed salad and pesto marinara on the side.
Warm Salad $18.95
Baby mixed greens, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers with balsamic honey mustard chicken.
Alyssa Salad $16.99
Mixed greens, tomatoes, olives, roasted peppers, gorgonzola and roasted pecans. Chopped.

Burgers
The Cajun Burger $16.99
Cajun cheeseburger with sautéed onions, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, tomato and side onion rings.
Chicken Burger Deluxe $14.99
Homemade Chicken Burger topped with cheddar, lettuce, tomato, Avocado Side Sweet Potato Fries
The Philly Burger $16.99
Cheeseburger topped with Philly steak, cheddar, onion rings two and side mashed potatoes.
Classic Cheese Burger Deluxe $14.99
6oz CheeseBurger with Lettuce, tomato served side Fries

Coffee & Tea
Iced Coffee (24 Oz) $4.99
Regular, Decaf, Decaf Hazelnut, Cappuccino, Caramel, Crumb Cake, French Vanilla, Toasted Marshmallow.

Smashed Meatballs
Sloppy Italian $14.95
Smashed Meatballs, prosciutto, burrata, pesto vodka sauce on toasted bun
Sloppy Drunk $13.95
Smashed Meatballs, sautéed onions, pepperoni, mozzarella, vodka saut on toasted bun
Sloppy Mess $12.95
Smashed Meatballs, French fries, Onion Rings, mozzarella, gravy on garlic Toasted Bun

Pantano's Eatery Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite

Dining options
Breakfast
Lunch
Catering
Dessert
Seating

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Family-friendly

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Pantano's Eatery Photos

Pantano's Eatery Location

Pantano's Eatery

New York Nassau County Plainview South Oyster Bay Road

347 S Oyster Bay Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA

Pantano's Eatery Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 233 user reviews.

priceswrapsbreakfastdeliselectionbaconegg sandwichesnutelladukecutlet

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

This deli is PHENOMENAL! From the customer service to the food, top notch! I’m Italian and I’m SUPER picky about when it comes to Italian food from ANYWHERE, Pantanos hits the mark EVERY TIME! The owner and the workers are super kind! Best deli on Long Island!!
July 30 · fitnessmomm
We get their daily menu specials at my office to our fax and we order once a month from them to deliver. The food is always good and the daily specials can be very interesting. I love the twice fried chicken parm ala vodka. The delivery is fast. They always want to rush you off the phone so mistakes happen and it is a little annoying for the person whose order was messed up. Some of the portions are huge and most sandwiches and meals are definitely 2 day meals.
October 08 · Cory Sussman
Got the crazy rich wrap and a Cajun burger… literally the best!!! Wanted to go back in and commend everyone in there for this incredible food! 100/10. Definitely recommend!
May 24 · Faheem Esau
Got to be the WORST MADE grill cheese bacon and catchup (yeah, wheres the catchup?) I have ever had . Barely any cheese, hardly warm , barely toasted bread and 1 slice of tomato. I mean you shouldnt be able to open a grill cheese this easy . No effort made and rushed. I will try again maybe catch a different cook that day. Gotta say i do love the Hewlett one and the one across from Nassau Colosseum.
November 03 · Anime 38
Still the best lunch and breakfast spot in Plainview. Perfect chicken cutlets. Always fresh food. Love this place! Love the staff. Keep going guys
February 25 · s j