Penny Lick Ice Cream Company - Mamaroneck

- 1212 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

When the craving for a truly exceptional sweet treat hits in the New York region, discerning locals in Westchester County often point directly to Penny Lick Ice Cream Company in Mamaroneck. This isn’t just another ice cream shop; it’s a destination built on a mission to bring back old-fashioned, high-quality ice cream—the kind that boasts a short ingredient list, uses local dairy, and is completely free of artificial ingredients. Since its founding in 2013, Penny Lick has grown from a local farmers market cart into a beloved community fixture, offering a great dessert experience in a casual and friendly atmosphere.

The name "Penny Lick" is an homage to a 19th-century style of ice cream vending, connecting the shop to a tradition of simple, accessible frozen delights. However, the modern iteration is anything but rudimentary. Penny Lick focuses intensely on crafting unique and nostalgic flavors while maintaining an unwavering commitment to safety. This dedication is evident in one of its most critical features: the Mamaroneck location is a **100% peanut, tree nut, and sesame-free facility**. For many families in the New York area who navigate severe food allergies, this provides invaluable peace of mind, allowing everyone—including children with allergies—to enjoy a rich, creamy, and worry-free indulgence.

The ice cream itself is made with local dairy and a passion for flavor innovation. Customers rave about how the unique flavors taste "very natural," and even classic choices like Cookies & Cream are noted for their super creamy texture and perfect balance. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick visit or planning a special event, Penny Lick Ice Cream Company has solidified its reputation as a must-visit spot for handmade, bespoke frozen desserts.

Penny Lick Ice Cream Company's Mamaroneck shop is conveniently located along a primary route in Westchester County, making it easily accessible for locals and those passing through the area.

The full address for the ice cream shop is:
1212 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

Accessibility for all customers is a priority, ensuring a hassle-free experience:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance is provided for ease of access into the shop.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot is available on-site, offering convenience for visitors driving to the location.

Its location on West Boston Post Road, a well-known thoroughfare, ensures that whether you’re coming in for an afternoon treat or swinging by after dinner, getting there is straightforward. The casual atmosphere is perfect for a quick stop, and the friendly environment welcomes everyone, including those with furry companions.

Penny Lick Ice Cream Company offers a straightforward yet comprehensive range of services, centered around providing the freshest, highest-quality ice cream products.

• Onsite Services: Enjoying a cup, cone, milkshake, or float right inside the welcoming shop.
• Takeout: Quick and efficient service for grabbing pints, pops, fudge, or sandwiches to enjoy at home.
• Custom & Ready-to-Go Ice Cream Cakes: Offering both immediate-purchase cakes and custom-ordered cakes (which typically require 72-hours notice) for all celebrations.
• Catering & Mobile Carts: The company offers catering services and a fleet of adorable bicycle wheel push carts for private events, including weddings, birthday parties, and corporate functions throughout the lower Hudson Valley and New York City.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts both Credit cards and Debit cards for convenient payment.
• Pet Accommodation: Dogs are allowed both inside and outside the premises, making it a friendly stop for dog owners.

Penny Lick Ice Cream Company distinguishes itself in the highly competitive dessert market through its core values, product quality, and community focus.

• 100% Nut-Free Facility: This is a major highlight, as the entire shop is certified peanut, tree nut, and sesame free, offering a safe environment for customers with severe allergies—a rare and treasured find in the New York area.
• Old-Fashioned, All-Natural Ingredients: The ice cream is made with a commitment to old-fashioned methods, using local dairy and entirely avoiding artificial ingredients, flavors, and colors.
• Unique and Creative Flavors: Known for offering a rotating selection of imaginative flavors alongside classics. Customers highlight unique items like Grapenut ice cream and creative seasonal sorbets, showcasing the company's commitment to flavor experimentation.
• Small-Batch, Homemade Quality: The business is a dedicated ice cream maker, meaning they pasteurize and make all the ice cream base themselves, ensuring a higher standard of freshness and control over the final product.
• Community Focus and Friendly Staff: Reviews consistently praise the employees for being "super kind" and "always happy to see a customer," fostering a genuinely local and welcoming atmosphere.
• Great Dessert Destination: Recognized as a highlight for great desserts, it is a perfect spot for children (Good for kids) and solo diners alike who crave a high-quality, memorable sweet treat.

For custom cake orders, flavor inquiries, or general information, the Mamaroneck location of Penny Lick Ice Cream Company can be reached here:

• Address: 1212 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA
• Phone: (914) 839-2840 or +1 914-839-2840

For New York residents, choosing Penny Lick Ice Cream Company is most definitely worth it, primarily because of the **unmatched assurance of a nut-free environment** coupled with truly superior ice cream quality. In a region where finding safe food options for allergies can be a challenge, Penny Lick provides a much-needed haven where families can relax and simply enjoy a treat.

Beyond the safety aspect, what sets Penny Lick apart is the commitment to **flavor purity and authenticity**. Their custard-based ice cream is made with local dairy and a short, recognizable ingredient list, resulting in unique and intense flavors that taste genuinely natural. If you appreciate traditional techniques and fresh, quality components over mass-produced novelty, this is your ideal ice cream shop. The rave reviews for both classic and imaginative flavors—like the "super creamy" Cookies & Cream and the nostalgic Grapenut—testify to the consistent execution of their mission.

Whether you're celebrating a milestone with a bespoke **Ice Cream Cake** or simply need a moment of pure, safe indulgence, Penny Lick provides a high-quality, friendly, and community-focused experience that makes it a standout destination in Westchester County's dessert scene.

Penny Lick Ice Cream Company - Mamaroneck

1212 W Boston Post Rd, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA