Steve's Sizzling Steaks

- 620 NJ-17, Carlstadt, NJ 07072

When it comes to authentic, time-honored dining in North Jersey, few establishments hold the same legacy and charm as Steve's Sizzling Steaks. Nestled right on Route 17 in Carlstadt, this family-owned restaurant isn't just a place to grab a meal—it's a genuine New Jersey institution that has been perfecting its craft since 1936. For decades, it has served as a go-to spot for locals, families, and even celebrities and sports legends looking for a hearty, perfectly cooked steak in a comfortably classic, old-school atmosphere.

Stepping into Steve's is like taking a delightful trip back in time. The atmosphere is deliberately cozy and casual, reminiscent of an old-school hunting lodge, complete with the warm, inviting scent of sizzling meat and savory sauces that permeates the dining room. It’s the kind of place where the focus is firmly on high-quality food, generous portions, and a welcoming, family-run environment. The restaurant has deep roots in the community and has been continuously operated by the same family since its founding, ensuring that the original recipes and commitment to quality remain central to the experience. From the moment you are seated, whether you are stopping in for a quick bite at lunch or settling in for a satisfying dinner, you feel the weight of its history and the comfort of its dedication to tradition.

The restaurant's signature is, of course, the "sizzling" preparation of its entrees. The steaks arrive on a hot platter, seasoned in their house sauce—a preparation that is distinctive and has cultivated a passionate following over the generations. While the special house sauce, sometimes described as having a salty, savory, Maggi Seasoning-like flavor, is a core part of the experience, the kitchen is accommodating and will happily serve your entree "non-sizzling" or with the house sauce on the side if you prefer. This commitment to customer preference is part of the long-standing tradition of excellent service at Steve's.

Beyond the excellent cuts of beef, like the massive 22-ounce Cowboy Bone-in Ribeye or the tender Filet Mignon, the menu offers a well-rounded selection of starters, other entrees, and famous burgers. All sizzling entrees come complete with a fresh garden salad and a side of their iconic steak fries and signature sautéed mushrooms. It's a satisfying, all-inclusive meal that speaks to the old-fashioned value of a classic steakhouse dinner.

This dedication to the core product has earned Steve's significant accolades over the years. Notably, it was named the Best Steakhouse in Bergen County in 2019, a testament to its enduring quality in a competitive North Jersey dining scene. It is a true landmark that proudly serves its community, attracting multi-generational patrons who appreciate the classic charm and consistently excellent food.

For those who enjoy a side of history with their meal, the original owner, Steve, was a larger-than-life personality whose stories are part of the restaurant’s lore, including surviving two airplane crashes and fishing with icons like Babe Ruth and Ernest Hemingway. The restaurant also has ties to local sports history, being a favorite spot for various New York Giants legends over the years, a tradition that continues with its close proximity to the Meadowlands Sports Complex.

Steve's Sizzling Steaks represents a unique piece of New Jersey history and culinary culture. It's a must-visit destination for anyone in the region seeking an authentic steakhouse experience that prioritizes flavor, heritage, and genuine hospitality.

Location and Accessibility

Steve's Sizzling Steaks is conveniently situated right on Route 17 in Carlstadt, New Jersey, making it highly accessible for drivers across Bergen County and beyond. As a prominent roadside landmark, it is easy to spot and reach. The restaurant is well-prepared to welcome all guests, focusing on making the dining experience stress-free from arrival to departure.

The location on a major highway offers significant ease of access for local residents and travelers passing through the area. Crucially, parking is easy and complimentary, which is a major convenience in this busy region. Patrons can take advantage of the free on-site parking lot or look for free street parking nearby. In terms of accessibility, Steve's Sizzling Steaks ensures that everyone can enjoy their meal comfortably.

The full address and contact information are provided below for easy navigation and planning your visit.

Services Offered

Steve's Sizzling Steaks provides a full range of services to accommodate all dining preferences:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the full, classic steakhouse experience with table service in the cozy, lodge-like dining room or at the popular bar.
• Takeout: Conveniently order your favorite sizzling steaks, burgers, and sides to enjoy at home.
• Lunch Service: Available for those looking for a midday steak, salad, or sandwich.
• Dinner Service: The main dining option, perfect for groups, families, or a satisfying solo meal.
• Full Bar Service: Featuring a bar onsite with a great selection of beer, cocktails, wine, and hard liquor.
• Kids' Menu: Family-friendly options are available to ensure younger guests are happy.
• Dessert Menu: A selection of classic pies and other treats to finish your meal, like New York Cheesecake and Key Lime Pie.
• Private Events/Groups: The establishment is popular for groups and family gatherings.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Steve's Sizzling Steaks apart and keeps patrons coming back time and again are its distinct features and commitment to quality:

• Signature Sizzling Entrees: The famous steaks, including the Filet Mignon and Cowboy Steak, served on a sizzling platter and seasoned with their unique, house-made steak sauce. All entrees include a salad, steak fries, and signature sautéed mushrooms.
• Historic & Family-Owned: Operating continuously since 1936 by the same family, providing a deep sense of history, authenticity, and consistent quality that few restaurants can match.
• Atmosphere: Classic, cozy, and casual "old-school hunting lodge" vibe that promotes a relaxing and comfortable dining experience for all patrons, including families and groups.
• Bar Excellence: Known for having a great selection of beer and well-crafted cocktails. The bar itself is a historic fixture, with the owner's mother being one of the first female bartenders in Bergen County.
• Accessibility: Fully equipped for all guests, offering a wheelchair-accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating.
• Sports Hotspot: Located near the Meadowlands Sports Complex, it’s a popular spot for catching a game, with TVs available and a history of hosting sports legends.
• Menu Variety: While famous for steak, the menu also offers popular starters like Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail and Fried Zucchini Sticks, as well as the 1/2 pound Blaze Burgers and the Mary's Special burger patty.
• Service and Speed: Recognized for fast, friendly, and efficient service, ensuring minimal wait times despite often being crowded.

Contact Information

For reservations, inquiries, or takeout orders, you can reach Steve's Sizzling Steaks at:

Address: 620 NJ-17, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA

Phone: (201) 438-9677

What is worth choosing

If you are visiting Steve's Sizzling Steaks for the first time, you absolutely must experience the dishes that have made this establishment a North Jersey icon for nearly a century. The core of the menu—the "Sizzling Entrees"—is the main draw and the reason for the restaurant's fame.

The Filet Mignon is a perpetually popular choice, prized for its tenderness, while the Cowboy (Bone-in) Ribeye (22 Oz) is the ideal option for those seeking a massive, richly flavored cut of bone-in beef. The unique preparation, where the high-quality steak is served sizzling and coated in the house sauce, is what defines the 'Steve's Style' and is a must-try. Remember, all of these spectacular entrees are comprehensive meals, including a fresh garden salad, generous portions of steak fries, and the restaurant’s signature mushrooms.

Beyond the steaks, consider starting your meal with one of the classic appetizers, such as the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail or the crispy Fried Zucchini Sticks served with a horseradish dijonaise. For those not in the mood for a massive steak, the Mary’s Special—a 10-ounce burger patty with fried onions and mushrooms—is a favorite among regulars. Finish your authentic Jersey dining experience with a slice of New York Cheesecake or another one of their classic desserts. Ultimately, choosing an entree that is served 'sizzling' is the quintessential Steve's experience you won’t want to miss.

Steve's Sizzling Steaks

620 NJ-17, Carlstadt, NJ 07072, USA