Sugar Hill Creamery

- 184 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10026

Sugar Hill Creamery is a genuine neighborhood gem in New York, offering more than just a sweet treat—it provides a true community experience. Located at 184 Malcolm X Blvd, this artisanal ice cream shop is a celebrated Black and women-owned small business that has quickly become a local favorite. The atmosphere is a perfect blend of casual, cozy, and trendy, making it a comfortable spot for everyone, from families with kids to individuals looking for a moment of quiet indulgence. The shop’s decor is charming and adds to the cheerful ambiance, creating a warm and welcoming space. The commitment to community is evident in every detail, from the gender-neutral restrooms to its status as an LGBTQ+ and transgender safe space, ensuring that all customers feel welcome.

What truly sets Sugar Hill Creamery apart is its dedication to crafting unique, small-batch ice cream flavors. The menu is a reflection of the owners' cultural backgrounds, blending Caribbean and Midwestern roots to create innovative and delicious combinations that you won't find anywhere else. Customers rave about the exceptional quality of the ice cream, describing it as smooth, creamy, and rich with flavor. In addition to the delicious frozen treats, the shop also offers a selection of baked goods and beverages, providing a complete dessert experience. The staff is consistently praised for being friendly, helpful, and patient, even offering samples to help you choose from the tempting array of flavors. This combination of a high-quality product, a welcoming environment, and outstanding service makes Sugar Hill Creamery a must-visit destination for anyone with a sweet tooth in New York City.

Sugar Hill Creamery is perfectly positioned at 184 Malcolm X Blvd, a central and easily accessible spot in the heart of Harlem. The location is a significant part of its identity, as it draws on the rich history and vibrant culture of the historic Sugar Hill neighborhood. The shop is conveniently situated for both locals and those exploring the area, making it an ideal stop for a quick visit or a relaxed dessert outing. Parking options in the area include both free street parking and paid street parking, which can be a valuable amenity in a busy urban environment. Its street-level entrance and welcoming ambiance make it an easy place to find and enter.

The shop is committed to ensuring a comfortable experience for all patrons. It is a family-friendly establishment that is also welcoming to groups. The atmosphere is both casual and cozy, and it offers seating for those who wish to sit and enjoy their treats. The availability of Wi-Fi is another convenient feature, perfect for those who want to work or browse while enjoying their ice cream. For pet owners, the shop is a great option as it is dog-friendly outside, so you can bring your furry friend along for your visit. All of these features contribute to a welcoming environment that makes Sugar Hill Creamery a popular and accessible spot for the entire community.

Sugar Hill Creamery offers a comprehensive and convenient range of services designed to meet the diverse needs of its New York City clientele. The restaurant's service model is highly flexible, making it a go-to for any dessert craving.

• Service options: Customers have multiple ways to get their favorite treats. The shop offers dine-in service with seating, takeout for those on the go, and convenient in-store pickup. For ultimate convenience, delivery is also available, bringing the delicious ice cream right to your door.
• Dining options: While it is an ice cream shop, it functions as a dessert destination. Its primary dining option is seating, providing a comfortable space to enjoy your order. It is also well-suited for a quick visit, whether you're dining alone or with a group.
• Payments: For a smooth transaction, the shop accepts all major credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Offerings: Beyond its signature ice cream, the shop offers a selection of baked goods and beverages, including coffee, providing a full range of dessert options.
• Amenities: The shop provides a gender-neutral restroom and a standard restroom. It also offers Wi-Fi, which is a great amenity for customers.
• Special designations: As a small business, Sugar Hill Creamery proudly identifies as Black-owned and women-owned, and maintains a welcoming environment that is LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safespace.

These services demonstrate Sugar Hill Creamery's commitment to customer satisfaction and community inclusion. The variety of ways to purchase, from in-store to delivery, caters to the needs of a busy urban population. The focus on providing a welcoming and inclusive space for all is a key part of the business's identity and is a significant draw for many customers. The availability of amenities like restrooms and Wi-Fi further enhances the overall positive experience.

Sugar Hill Creamery is celebrated for several key features and highlights that make it a standout destination in the New York dessert scene. These elements are a testament to the shop's commitment to quality, creativity, and community.

• Unique and Rotating Flavors: The most significant highlight is the ice cream itself. The shop is known for its inventive and unique flavors that are crafted in small batches. Flavors are inspired by Caribbean and Midwestern culinary traditions, and the menu rotates with the seasons, ensuring there is always something new and exciting to try.
• Homemade Baked Goods: In addition to the ice cream, the shop offers homemade brownies and chocolate chip cookies. These baked goods are often used in specialty items like the Ice Cream Sundae and Ice Cream Sandwich, providing a delicious and complementary treat.
• Specialty Items: The menu features several specialty items that offer a full dessert experience. The Ice Cream Sundae is a popular choice, layered with whipped cream and homemade brownie bits. The Chocolate Bliss is another decadent option, combining a brownie, a cookie, and a scoop of ice cream.
• Welcoming and Inclusive Atmosphere: The shop’s atmosphere is a major highlight. It is described as cozy and friendly, and its designations as a safe and friendly space for various communities create an environment where everyone feels comfortable and welcome.
• Family and Community Focus: As a family-owned business, the shop has a strong connection to the Harlem community. It is good for kids and is a popular spot for groups, fostering a sense of community with every visit.

These highlights are what make Sugar Hill Creamery a beloved local spot. The dedication to unique, high-quality flavors, combined with a focus on creating a welcoming and inclusive space, sets it apart from other dessert shops. The homemade baked goods and specialty items add an extra layer of indulgence, ensuring that every visit is a memorable one. The shop is more than just a place to get ice cream; it's a place to experience the culture and warmth of the community it serves.

For more information, to place an order, or to learn more about their offerings, you can contact Sugar Hill Creamery using the information below. The staff is always happy to help and answer any questions you may have.

Address: 184 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10026, USA

Phone: (212) 634-9004

With a menu full of unique and delicious options, deciding what to choose at Sugar Hill Creamery can be a fun challenge. For a classic experience with an artisanal twist, a Double Scoop is an excellent choice. This allows you to try two different flavors and appreciate the richness and creativity of their ice cream. For those who love a full-on dessert, the Ice Cream Sundae is a perfect pick. It layers your chosen scoops with whipped cream and homemade brownie bits, creating a truly decadent treat. If you're a fan of combining textures, the Ice Cream Sandwich is a fantastic option, featuring a scoop of your choice between two of their freshly baked chocolate chip cookies. For those who want to take a taste of Harlem home, a Pint is a great value, allowing you to enjoy the unique flavors later. Don't forget to ask about their seasonal flavors, which are often the most adventurous and celebrated items on the menu. A recent customer review praised the cookies and cream and a rich, velvety chocolate, so those are always safe bets. No matter what you choose, you can be sure you're getting a handcrafted, high-quality product that is a true testament to the shop’s mission.

Sugar Hill Creamery

184 Malcolm X Blvd, New York, NY 10026, USA