Teglia Pizza Bar Montclair NJ: Scratch-Made Roman Pan Pizza & Catering

Teglia Pizza Bar Introduce

New Jersey's culinary landscape is renowned for its diverse and authentic Italian offerings, and in the heart of Montclair, a true gem shines brightly for local food enthusiasts: the Teglia Pizza Bar. This isn't just another pizzeria; it's a dedicated craft kitchen focused on delivering the highest quality Italian comfort food, specializing in a distinct style of pizza that sets it apart. The name itself, "Teglia," is Italian for "roasting pan," a nod to their signature rectangular, pan-baked pizza known as teglia Romana pan pizza or "pizza in a baking tin."

For those in the North Jersey area looking for a truly elevated, fresh dining experience, Teglia Pizza Bar is a must-visit destination. The philosophy here is simple but profound: everything possible is made from scratch, a commitment that translates directly into the remarkable flavor and texture of every dish. From the hand-crafted pizza dough, focaccia, and dressings to the in-house-made fresh mozzarella and ricotta, quality is the absolute priority.

The core of the menu revolves around their spectacular Roman pan pizzas. Their dough is created using a "mother dough" and a slow rise and fermentation process, resulting in a crust that is crispy and chewy yet wonderfully light and airy—a texture that many customers rave about, saying it is a phenomenal experience, far exceeding the typical New Jersey slice. Their dedication extends to sourcing ingredients locally whenever possible, partnering with local farmers and purveyors to ensure freshness, while importing only the finest items from Italy to complete their authentic flavor profiles. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or planning a family dinner, this spot promises a memorable taste of Italian artistry.

Location and Accessibility

Teglia Pizza Bar is conveniently situated right in the vibrant downtown area of Montclair, making it an easy stop for locals, students, and tourists exploring the town.

The restaurant's physical address is:

438 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA

Its central location in Montclair provides easy access whether you're coming from a nearby neighborhood or passing through the area. When you step inside, you’ll find a casual and inviting atmosphere, often described as having the look and feel of an old Italian coffee bar. While seating is cozy—it’s designed as a pizza bar where you can grab a delicious counter meal to eat in or take home—the focus remains on the high quality of the food and the craft. Accessibility is a consideration for all guests, as the location includes a wheelchair-accessible restroom.

Services Offered

Teglia Pizza Bar offers a variety of services to accommodate all dining preferences, whether you prefer to enjoy a fresh slice on-site or feed a large gathering at home.

UL:

Dine-in and Takeout: Enjoy a casual meal inside the pizza bar or take your handcrafted pizza home.

Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Order online and have your favorite pizza and Italian specialties brought right to your door.

Full-Service Catering: Comprehensive catering options are available for local pickup or delivery in Montclair, NJ, suitable for corporate luncheons, family gatherings, or special celebrations. Note that a minimum of 24 hours' notice is required for all catering orders to ensure the freshest ingredients.

Gift Cards: Purchase gift cards for a friend or family member to share the authentic taste of Roman pan pizza.

Events: The restaurant has future plans to host events such as pizza pop-ups, pizza tastings, and more.

VIP Program: Customers can join a free VIP program to receive updates on exclusive events, secret menus, special offers, and loyalty rewards.

Dessert Options: The popular Cannoli Bar is a highlight, offering phenomenal Italian cheese cake Cannoli and other sweet endings.

Features and Highlights

What truly makes Teglia Pizza Bar a standout in the competitive North Jersey food scene are the culinary details and unique offerings driven by a 30-year veteran chef's passion.

UL:

Authentic Roman Pan Pizza: Specializing in rectangular, pan-baked Roman-style pizza with a signature crust that is crispy, chewy, light, and airy thanks to a slow rise and fermentation process.

Scratch-Made Ingredients: A commitment to making essentials in-house, including mozzarella, ricotta, focaccia, pizza dough, all dressings, and roasts. This dedication ensures maximum flavor and freshness.

Locally Sourced and Imported Ingredients: Ingredients are sourced from local farmers and purveyors (such as Vacchiano Farm and Hillcrest Farm) whenever possible, complemented by the finest imported Italian products.

Diverse Pizza Menu: Signature pizza creations include the Classic Jersey, the spicy Sweet Heat, the rich Drunken Nonna (with creamy vodka sauce and whipped ricotta), the crowd-pleasing Roni Cup, and the vegetarian-friendly 7 Vegetable Vegan.

Extensive Catering Menu: Catering options go well beyond pizza, offering half and full trays of appetizers (like Antipasto and Burrata platters), pasta dishes (including Baked Ziti and Lasagna Bolognese), entrees (Roasted Goffles Chicken, Short Ribs), and more.

Dietary Variety: The menu includes many dishes that are good for both vegetarians and those seeking comfort food or a quick bite, with some options for vegans.

Warm and Casual Atmosphere: The interior is designed to evoke an "old Italian coffee bar," providing a comfortable and casual dining experience popular with college students, families, and tourists.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about catering, or learn more, you can reach out using the following details:

Address: 438 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA

Phone: (973) 317-0909

What is Worth Choosing at Teglia Pizza Bar

If you are visiting Teglia Pizza Bar for the first time, your focus should be on their namesake specialty: the teglia Roman pan pizza. The difference in their crust—described by patrons as crunchy on the outside and fluffy on the inside—is the main draw and a testament to their scratch-cooking philosophy. Consider the highly-rated Classic Jersey for a taste of a traditional New Jersey-style pie done perfectly, or the decadent Drunken Nonna if you love a creamy vodka sauce and savory ricotta combination. The option to order Half & Half on a single pie is also a fantastic way to sample two different specialty pizzas in one order.

Beyond the pizza, the commitment to freshness shines in the appetizers and pasta. Customers highly recommend the in-house made Eggplant Parm Appatizer, and for a true taste of scratch-made Italian cooking, any of the pasta trays, such as the Lasagna Bolognese or Penne Vodka, are an excellent choice. Finally, don't miss the dessert; the Cannoli Bar is a perfect way to end the meal with a handmade Italian classic that is reportedly "absolutely phenomenal" with its bright citrus notes.

For those planning an event, the catering menu offers a seamless way to bring genuine Italian food to your guests. With options ranging from full trays of classic dishes like Meatballs Ragu and Eggplant Rollatini to gourmet appetizers like the Burrata Platter and diverse entrees like Braised Leg of Lamb and Porchetta, Teglia Pizza Bar ensures your large-scale event is handled with the same care as their dine-in service. Remember to give them the required 24-hour notice so they can source and prepare your order using the freshest ingredients available. Teglia Pizza Bar stands as a genuine testament to Italian comfort food crafted with heart and expertise right here in New Jersey.

Teglia Pizza Bar Menu

Pizza
Queen Margarita $29.00
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil, EVVO
Classic Jersey $26.00
Mozzarella to the edge, Tomato sauce, Sicilian Oregano
Pomodoro $26.00
Fresh Tomato Sicilian Oregano, Sprinkle of Pecorino and Parmigiana, EVVO
Roni Cup $30.00
Pepperoni , Sauce, Mozzarella
True Sicilian $27.00
Tomato sauce of Capers, onion, Anchovy, Basil, Green Olives, topped with pecorino local Toma cheese, Bread crumb, Finished with EVOO
Sweet Heat $31.00
Cured and fresh Italian sausage, Fontina and mozzarella, Tomato, basil, Calabrian Hot honey
The Dew $31.00
House made sweet sausage, Sweet Peppadews, Caramelized Onion, Tomato, Mozzarella
Butternut $30.00
Roasted butternut and mascarpone puree topped with Oven roasted Tomato and garlic, Baby Kale, Shaved Parmigiana Fresh onions
Artichoke & Spinach $30.00
Artichoke sauce, Garlic confit, mozzarella, fontina, Roman artichokes
Parma $31.00
Fresh sliced Prosciutto, Tomato Sauce,Buratta, Basil
Farmer $30.00
Roasted eggplant, Cherry tomato and spinach, Gorgonzola dolce, Finished with Pickled Onions and Arugula
White Pie $29.00
Fontina, Mozzarella, Parmigiana, Roasted garlic, Whipped Ricotta crema
White Meatball $30.00
Meatballs, Smoky pecorino Garlic and Ricotta sauce, Spinach, Mozzarella
Stracciatella $33.00
Tomato, Creamy Torn Ribbons of Mozzarella, Nduja Spreadable Spicy Salami, Basil
Mushroom Pie $31.00
Medley of Mixed Mushroom, Fontina, Mozzarella, and Ricotta Crema, Truffle Carpaccio and Essence
Taleggio $30.00
Talegio cheese, Guanciale, caramelized onions, Ricotta crema, Honey thyme drizzle
Buffalo Chicken $29.00
Broccoli Rabe Sausage $32.00
Marinated Rabe, Parmigiana and Provolone Crema, Mozzarella, Sweet sausage finished with shaved Parmigiana
Mortadella and Pistacchio $31.00
Pecorino and Pistachio pesto, Ricotta, Mortadella, Stracciatella, Toasted Pistachio crumble
7 Vegetable Vegan $30.00
Roasted: Butternut, Eggplant, Tomato and Garlic,Baby Spinach and Caramelized Onion
Marinara Pie $28.00
Mozzarella Cheese to the edge, Extra tomato sauce, with chopped garlic, basil, Sicilian oregano, Parmigianno & Pecorino cheese
Diavolo $31.00
Mozzarella, Roasted Tomato & Garlic Sauce, Long Hot Peppers, Sausage, Shaves Caciocavalo Cheese, Calabrian chili oil
Drunken Nonna $31.00
Creamy Vodka Sauce, herb and honey whipped ricotta, caramelized shallots ,Mozzarella, Parmigiana finished with crispy Prosciutto and fresh basil
Angry Nonno $32.00
Spicy pizza.Vodka sauce, mozzarella and provolone blend, Sausage, hot sopressata, Hot cherry and calabrian pepper relish, fresh Basil
Half & Half $0.00
Can't decide which signature pizza to get ! just choose 2 and we'll make a we will do the rest!

Primi
Meatballs. $15.00
Tomato Braised meatballs, Fresh Parmigiana
Eggplant Parm Appatizer $15.00
Lightly Sauteed, Egg Batter, Tomato sauce, Mozzarella

Salads
Caprese $15.00
Fresh Mozzarella, Ripe tomato, Roasted Red Peppers, Balsamic
Field Greens $12.00
Field Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Red onions, Shaved Parmiggiano, Italian Dressing
Beet $13.00
Arugula, Pickled Onions, Toasted Pignoli, Goat Cheese, Roasted Garlic Yogurt Dressing
Arugula. $13.00
Candied Pecans, Strawberries, Crispy Prosciutto,Gorgonzola, Aged Balsamic, EVOO
Shepherd $14.00
Cucumber, Tomato, Gaeta Olives, Red onions, Arugula, Ricotta salata, Aged red wine Vinaigrette
Burrata $15.00
Marinated Broccoli Rabe, Pickled onion and Radish salad, Honey-thyme drizzle, Crispy Prosciutto, Arugula & toasted Almond Pesto
Caesar $12.00
Romaine, Croutons, Shaved Parmiggiano, Traditional Dressing

Sandwich
B-L-T $15.00
Smoked Pancetta, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Garlic Aioli
Classic Italain Sub $15.00
Ham, Capicola, Pepperoni, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, tomato, onion, Red Wine Vinaigrette
Fresh Mozzarella. $14.00
Vine ripe Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Aged balsamic drizzle, EVVO
Turkey Sub $14.00
Roasted Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, Balsamic
Mortadella $15.00
Italian Bologna, Buratta, arugula and pistachio pesto
Prosciutto Sandwich $15.00
Di Parma, Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil, Sea-salt EVOO
Chicken Caesar wrap $14.00
Whole wheat wrap filled with fresh crisp Romain, chilled organic chicken, Shaved Parm

Hot Sandwich
Roasted Chicken Sandwich $15.00
Marinated Roasted chicken, Italian citrus Slaw, Pickles, Ndujia aioli
Chicken & Rabe $15.00
Broccoli Rabe, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers Sundri Tomato Pesto, Balsamic Reduction
Parm $14.00
Eggplant or Meatball, Tomato Basil and Mozzarella
Chicken Parm $15.00
Chicken Cutlet, Tomato sauce, Parmigiana and Mozzarella cheese
Long Hot & Cutlet $15.00
Chicken Cutlet, Roasted long Hot Peppers, Fresh Mozzarella, Balsamic Dressing

Pasta
Baked Ziti $14.00
Baked Ricotta, Herbs, tomato sauce, topped with fresh Mozzarella
Lasagna Bolegnese $16.00
Thin Layers of pasta, Sauce, special blend Meat sauce and cheese topped with Mozzarella
Cacio e Pepe Lasagna $15.00
Layers or thin pasta, Ricotta infused Bechamel, Fresh cracked pepper Blend, Smokey fresh pecorino Topped with Toma cheese

Bar Zuppa
Home made selections of soups
Pasta Fagoli $6.00
Lentil soup $6.00
lentils with celery, carrot, onion and herbs. Simmered in our house made chicken bone broth!
Soup Special $5.00
Roasted tomato soup $6.00

NA Beverage
Coke $2.00
Small bottle
Diet Coke $2.00
Small Bottle
Sprite $2.00
Small Bottle
Water btl $2.50

Wings
6 baked wing tossed in house made buffalo sauce , Roasted Garlic Ranch
Buffalo Wings $12.00
Tossed in our scratch Buffalo Sauce, Roasted Garlic Ranch
Hot Honey Wings $12.00
Tossed in our signature Sweet Heat Chili Honey, Roasted Garlic Aioli
Nduja BBQ Wings $14.00
Tossed in our Nduja Spicy soft salami BBQ sauce, Roasted Garlic Ranch
Parmigiana Basil and Garlic Wings $13.00
Finished and coated with Garlic and Herb Salsa Verdi & Parmigiana, Caesar

Store Dressing
Caesar. $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan
Balsamic $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan
Apple Cidar $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan
Aged red wine Vinaigrette $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan
Roasted Garlic Yogurt $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan
Creamy Dijon $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan
Creamy Italian $4.00
House made, All dressings are made with pasteurized egg yolk and Vinaigrettes are vegan

Catering Half Tray Appetizers
Half Tray Field Greens Salad $30.00
Field Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Red onions, Shaved Parmigiana, Italian Dressing
Half Tray Arugula Salad $35.00
Candied Pecans, Strawberries, Crispy Prosciutto, Gorgonzola, Aged Balsamic, EVOO
Half Tray Caesar Salad $30.00
Romaine, Croutons, Shaved Parmigiana, Traditional Dressing
Half Tray Caprese Platter $40.00
Fresh Mozzarella, Ripe tomato, Roasted Red Peppers, Balsamic
Half Tray Antipasto Platter $80.00
Prosciutto, Salami, Capicola, Sharp Provolone, Fontina, Stracciatella, Olives, Roasted peppers
Half Tray Burrata Platter $80.00
Marinated Broccoli Rabe, Pickled onion and Radish salad, Honey-thyme drizzle, Crispy Prosciutto, Arugula & toasted Almond Pesto
Half Tray Focaccia Platter $25.00
Fresh Baked Focaccia, Tomato, Herb, EVOO & Sea-salt
Half Tray Focaccia Crostini Platter $45.00
Fresh crispy, Served with Fresh herbed Ricotta, Caponata Italian sweet and sour Eggplant, Hummus with Tomato Salad, Roasted Artichoke and Mixed Olive Bruschetta
Half Tray Meatballs Ragu $60.00
Tomato Braised meatballs, Fresh Parmigiana
Half Tray Roasted Meatballs Platter $65.00
Special blend of Meat, Sweet and Hot Cherry Peppers, Onions, Potato
Half Tray Eggplant Rollatini $60.00
Lightly battered Eggplant filled with Seasoned Ricotta, Tomato sauce and Fresh Mozzarella
Half Tray Stuff Peppers $60.00
Baked Ripe Red Peppers Stuffed with Four cheese and Roasted Tomato & Herb Risotto

Catering Half Tray Sandwiches
Half Tray Sandwiches - Pick 3 $45.00

Catering Half Tray Pasta
Half Tray Penne Tomato & Basil $40.00
Fresh Tomato sauce, sprinkle of Parmigiana
Half Tray Penne Vodka $60.00
Light tomato sauce with peas and a touch of cream and Parmigiana
Half Tray Baked Ziti $55.00
Baked Ricotta, Herbs, tomato sauce, topped with fresh Mozzarella
Half Tray Lasagna Bolognese $75.00
Thin Layers of pasta, Sauce, special blend Meat sauce and cheese ,topped with Mozzarella
Half Tray Pasta al Forno $75.00
Anelletti Pasta, Three meat Tomato ragu, Mortadella, eggplant, Toma & pecorino cheese, topped with breadcrumb.
Half Tray Cacio e Pepe Lasagna $75.00
Layers or thin pasta, Ricotta infused Bechamel, Fresh cracked pepper Blend, Smokey fresh pecorino Topped with Toma cheese

Catering Half Tray Entree
Half Tray Roasted Goffles Chicken $75.00
Slow roasted with aromatics, Au Jus
Half Tray Short Ribs $135.00
8 Hr slow roasted, Pan Fond, Natural Glace'
Half Tray Braised leg of Lamb $105.00
!4 hour Braised ,port wine and caramelized onion jus
Half Tray Porchetta $95.00
Roasted Loin and Belly Roll with Pancetta Pine nuts and Golden Raisins studded Bread Crumbs, Herb Demi

Catering Half Tray Vegetable
Half Tray Roasted Potatoes $50.00
Red Bliss potatoes, Herbs, Butter
Half Tray Roasted Tricolor Baby Carrots $75.00
Hand Peeled and roasted with EVOO, Sea-Sat and Mediterranean spices
Half Tray Roasted vegetable $75.00
Seasonal Medley Mix of vegetable

Catering Full Tray Appetizers
Full Tray Field Greens Salad $60.00
Field Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Red onions, Shaved Parmigiana, Italian Dressing
Full Tray Arugula Salad $70.00
Candied Pecans, Strawberries, Crispy Prosciutto, Gorgonzola, Aged Balsamic, EVOO
Full Tray Caesar Salad $60.00
Romaine, Croutons, Shaved Parmigiana, Traditional Dressing
Full Tray Caprese Platter $80.00
Fresh Mozzarella, Ripe tomato, Roasted Red Peppers, Balsamic
Full Tray Antipasto Platter $160.00
Prosciutto, Salami, Capicola, Sharp Provolone, Fontina, Stracciatella, Olives, Roasted peppers
Full Tray Burrata Platter $160.00
Marinated Broccoli Rabe, Pickled onion and Radish salad, Honey-thyme drizzle, Crispy Prosciutto, Arugula & toasted Almond Pesto
Full Tray Focaccia Platter $50.00
Fresh Baked Focaccia, Tomato, Herb, EVOO & Sea-salt
Full Tray Focaccia Crostini Platter $90.00
Fresh crispy, Served with Fresh herbed Ricotta, Caponata Italian sweet and sour Eggplant, Hummus with Tomato Salad, Roasted Artichoke and Mixed Olive Bruschetta
Full Tray Meatballs Ragu $120.00
Tomato Braised meatballs, Fresh Parmigiana
Full Tray Roasted Meatballs Platter $130.00
Special blend of Meat, Sweet and Hot Cherry Peppers, Onions, Potato
Full Tray Eggplant Rollatini $120.00
Lightly battered Eggplant filled with Seasoned Ricotta, Tomato sauce and Fresh Mozzarella
Full Tray Stuff Peppers $120.00
Baked Ripe Red Peppers Stuffed with Four cheese and Roasted Tomato & Herb Risotto

Catering Full Tray Sandwiches
Full Tray Sandwiches - Pick 6 $90.00

Catering Full Tray Pasta
Full Tray Penne Tomato & Basil $80.00
Fresh Tomato sauce, sprinkle of Parmigiana
Full Tray Penne Vodka $120.00
Light tomato sauce with peas and a touch of cream and Parmigiana
Full Tray Baked Ziti $110.00
Baked Ricotta, Herbs, tomato sauce, topped with fresh Mozzarella
Full Tray Lasagna Bolognese $150.00
Thin Layers of pasta, Sauce, special blend Meat sauce and cheese ,topped with Mozzarella
Full Tray Pasta al Forno $150.00
Anelletti Pasta, Three meat Tomato ragu, Mortadella, eggplant, Toma & pecorino cheese, topped with breadcrumb.
Full Tray Cacio e Pepe Lasagna $150.00
Layers or thin pasta, Ricotta infused Bechamel, Fresh cracked pepper Blend, Smokey fresh pecorino Topped with Toma cheese

Catering Full Tray Entree
Full Tray Roasted Goffles Chicken $150.00
Slow roasted with aromatics, Au Jus
Full Tray Short Ribs $270.00
8 Hr slow roasted, Pan Fond, Natural Glace'
Full Tray Braised leg of Lamb $210.00
!4 hour Braised ,port wine and caramelized onion jus
Full Tray Porchetta $190.00
Roasted Loin and Belly Roll with Pancetta Pine nuts and Golden Raisins studded Bread Crumbs, Herb Demi

Catering Full Tray Vegetable
Full Tray Roasted Potatoes $98.00
Red Bliss potatoes, Herbs, Butter
Full Tray Roasted Tricolor Baby Carrots $145.00
Hand Peeled and roasted with EVOO, Sea-Sat and Mediterranean spices
Full Tray Roasted vegetable $145.00
Seasonal Medley Mix of vegetable

Catering Pizza
Queen Margarita $29.00
Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato, Basil, EVVO
Classic Jersey $26.00
Mozzarella to the edge, Tomato sauce, Sicilian Oregano
Pomodoro $26.00
Fresh Tomato Sicilian Oregano, Sprinkle of Pecorino and Parmigiana, EVVO
Roni Cup $30.00
Pepperoni , Sauce, Mozzarella
True Sicilian $27.00
Tomato sauce of Capers, onion, Anchovy, Basil, Green Olives, topped with pecorino local Toma cheese, Bread crumb, Finished with EVOO
Sweet Heat $31.00
Cured and fresh Italian sausage, Fontina and mozzarella, Tomato, basil, Calabrian Hot honey
The Dew $31.00
House made sweet sausage, Sweet Peppadews, Caramelized Onion, Tomato, Mozzarella
Butternut $30.00
Roasted butternut and mascarpone puree topped with Oven roasted Tomato and garlic, Baby Kale, Shaved Parmigiana Fresh onions
Artichoke & Spinach $30.00
Artichoke sauce, Garlic confit, mozzarella, fontina, Roman artichokes
Parma $31.00
Fresh sliced Prosciutto, Tomato Sauce,Buratta, Basil
Farmer $30.00
Roasted eggplant, Cherry tomato and spinach, Gorgonzola dolce, Finished with Pickled Onions and Arugula
White Pie $29.00
Fontina, Mozzarella, Parmigiana, Roasted garlic, Whipped Ricotta crema
White Meatball $30.00
Meatballs, Smoky pecorino Garlic and Ricotta sauce, Spinach, Mozzarella
Stracciatella $33.00
Tomato, Creamy Torn Ribbons of Mozzarella, Nduja Spreadable Spicy Salami, Basil
Mushroom Pie $31.00
Medley of Mixed Mushroom, Fontina, Mozzarella, and Ricotta Crema, Truffle Carpaccio and Essence

Teglia Pizza Bar Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible restroom

Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
College students
Family-friendly
Tourists

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Teglia Pizza Bar Photos

Teglia Pizza Bar Location

Teglia Pizza Bar

New Jersey Essex County Montclair Bloomfield Avenue

438 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA

Teglia Pizza Bar Reviews

An average rating of ★4.8 from 214 user reviews.

piepepperoniartichokespinachsicilian pizzaheatcrustsliceitalianfocaccia

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Teglia Pizza Bar in Montclair, NJ is a true gem! They specialize in Roman pan sourdough pizza, crafted with heart right here in Montclair. “Teglia” means roasting pan in Italian, and they absolutely live up to the name with their scratch-made sourdough Roman pan pizzas crispy on the outside, airy on the inside, and packed with flavor. A bonus: you can even go half-and-half to try more of Chef Joseph’s amazing creations. Highly recommend!
September 16 · Lauren S
The pizza was DELICIOUS. I had the pleasure of meeting the owner Joe and we chatted about how he makes his pizza. It feels so great to know the ingredients are fresh, there are no seed oils used, and everything is made in-house. The dough is nice and crunchy on the outside and fluffy in the inside. I used to go to NY to get my fresh pizza al taglio but now I have a place wayyy closer to home 😍 will definitely be coming back! Oh also, I’ve never had artichoke pizza before… but it called my name when I was ordering. I LOVE.
September 17 · Kelly Alfaro
The only bad thing is how tiny the place is. Go GET SOME FOOD HERE!!!! I get the Jersey, and it is such a thick crust that I do request it to be well done. (See picks) It is a beautiful pizza crust, crunchy bottom/sides, and chewy soft everywhere else! The mozzarella is the real mozzarella, no fakes at this pizza place, and you can taste the difference!The caramel canoli are ok, but the pizza will keep you coming back to this tiny little place. Also, it is good to know that they do have lunch special prices!
May 12 · Trish
Teglia Pizza Bar is pizza perfection in Montclair! The crust is unlike anything else in the area — thick, airy, and perfectly crisp, almost like the best focaccia you’ve ever had. I had the spinach artichoke pizza, and it was phenomenal — creamy, cheesy, and full of fresh flavor. My wife had the margherita with pesto, and it was equally outstanding — bright tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and that fragrant hit of basil pesto tying it all together.The service was warm and friendly, making the experience even better. Every bite made it clear this place takes real pride in their craft. A must-visit if you love pizza done right.
August 09 · Taurean McDade
Was in the neighborhood the other day and stopped in and met the owner Joe, he was a fantastic gentleman and I really enjoyed his pizza. Fast-forward to today, I have the opportunity to have it for the first time and it was absolutely fantastic. 10/10 will be back
June 08 · Mike