Casano's Pizza Parlor

- 8 Highland Cross, Rutherford, NJ 07070

For those of us in New Jersey who know that a truly great pizza is more than just a quick meal—it's an experience, a tradition, and a source of local pride—**Casano's Pizza Parlor** in Rutherford is quickly becoming a must-visit destination. This establishment is not your average pizza shop; it’s a dedicated pizza restaurant channeling the warmth and authenticity of classic Italian-American tradition, delivering pies with an artisan's touch and a menu full of comforting, expertly-crafted dishes. Casano's aims to offer an authentic, nostalgic experience, blending high-quality ingredients with a unique, retro atmosphere that feels less like a business and more like a Sunday dinner at Nonna's house.

This spot has gained significant local attention for its dedication to distinct regional pizza styles often hard to find perfected in North Jersey, such as New Haven and Trenton Tomato Pies. However, it's the attention to detail in every dish—from the perfectly charred crust to the balanced sauces and high-quality cheeses—that truly sets Casano's apart. It’s a place where food is treated with reverence, and every customer is welcomed into a cozy, family-friendly environment.

Casano's Pizza Parlor is conveniently located at **8 Highland Cross, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA**. Rutherford is a charming borough in Bergen County, making Casano's easily accessible for residents across Northern New Jersey. The location on Highland Cross provides a welcoming neighborhood feel, stepping slightly away from the major thoroughfares, which adds to its intimate "hidden gem" appeal.

The restaurant offers practical accessibility for local patrons. Dining options include both **Dine-in** and **Takeout**, although it should be noted that the style of the establishment is focused on full pies, not individual slices, emphasizing quality and freshness. For those driving, the area offers **Free street parking** as well as **Paid street parking** options, which is a great convenience in this bustling region of New Jersey. The atmosphere is generally **Casual and Cozy**, with a **Family-friendly** and inviting vibe that is **Good for kids**, making it an excellent choice for a dinner out with the entire family or a comforting solo dining experience.

Casano's Pizza Parlor provides a tailored range of services focused on delivering an exceptional Italian-American dining experience. Their core offerings are built around quality and convenience for the local New Jersey community.

• **Dine-in Service:** Enjoy your meal in the unique, retro-themed atmosphere. Note: While dine-in is available, the vibe is cozy and informal, designed for a casual, comfortable experience.
• **Takeout:** Convenient service for customers who prefer to enjoy their high-quality pies and shareables at home. Ordering ahead is often recommended, especially during peak hours.
• **Dinner Service:** Casano's is a popular spot for evening meals, offering a full menu of pizzas, shareables, and sandwiches.
• **Catering:** The restaurant offers a full catering menu with full and half trays of Italian-American classics, perfect for local gatherings, parties, and events. A **24-hour notice** is required for all catering orders to ensure the highest quality.
• **Comfort Food and Quick Bites:** The menu is centered on satisfying comfort food, perfect for a quick, delicious dinner.

What truly distinguishes Casano's Pizza Parlor in the highly competitive North Jersey culinary landscape is a blend of authentic culinary artistry and a uniquely memorable ambiance. Customers rave about the following key features:

• **Artisan Pizza Styles:** The menu features notable regional pizza styles, including the crispy, thin-crust **New Haven Style**, the famous **Trenton Style Tomato Pie**, and the classic **Casano's Round**. They are praised for an exceptionally thin crust with a perfect balance of crispness and chew.
• **Specialty Vodka Sauce Pies:** A major highlight is the use of homemade vodka sauce with imported Italian cream in specialty pies like the **Round Vodka Stracciatella** and the decadent **Drunken Tor (Round)**, which also features pepperoni cups, fresh stracciatella, and a drizzle of hot honey.
• **Unique Retro Atmosphere:** The interior is intentionally designed to evoke a nostalgic, old-school feel—like an Italian-American basement from the 1970s or 80s. This includes vintage decor elements such as old-school furniture, arcade machines, and retro TVs, adding a cozy, distinctive charm to the dining experience.
• **Exceptional Shareables and Sandwiches:** Beyond pizza, the menu offers highly-rated Italian-American appetizers and sandwiches, such as the popular **Chicken Parm Stracciatella** (available with tomato or vodka sauce), **Meatballs** (based on a third-generation family recipe), and the **Hot & Ballsy Sandwich**.
• **Commitment to Quality and No Alterations:** The restaurant's policy of offering only full pies and not allowing alterations to the signature pies ensures that every dish is served exactly as intended by the chef, preserving the integrity and balance of the unique, high-quality recipes.
• **Youth Engagement:** Noted by local patrons is the efficient and friendly staff, suggesting the restaurant actively engages and employs younger members of the local community.

For New Jersey locals planning a visit or needing to place an order, here is the essential contact information for Casano's Pizza Parlor:

**Address:** 8 Highland Cross, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

Choosing Casano’s Pizza Parlor is choosing a piece of authentic New Jersey culinary culture, rooted in a deep respect for Italian tradition. It is worth choosing for residents in Rutherford and the wider Bergen County area because it delivers a unique, artisan-level pizza experience that stands out from standard local fare.

The culinary focus on specialty pies—particularly the New Haven and Trenton style tomato pies, which honor specific Italian-American regional styles—makes it a pilgrimage site for NJ pizza enthusiasts. The quality of the crust, described by many as perfectly crisp, airy, and delivering a subtle char, is a testament to skilled craftsmanship.

We highly recommend trying a signature vodka sauce pie, such as the **Round Vodka Stracciatella** or the **Drunken Tor (Round)**, as these are celebrated customer favorites that beautifully blend rich, creamy sauce with premium ingredients. For those seeking non-pizza comfort food, the various chicken parm options and family-recipe meatballs are consistently praised. The unique, nostalgic atmosphere simply enhances the experience, offering a fun, cozy backdrop that transports you back to a simpler time. Casano's provides genuine comfort food in an environment that feels like home, making it an excellent local choice for dinner, quick bites, and catering for your next event in New Jersey.

With a menu that includes both classic favorites like the **Casano's Round** ($21.00) and innovative creations like the **Long Hot And Shal!Ot Pizza** ($28.00), there is a high-quality option for every palate. The mandatory 24-hour notice for large catering orders, such as the **Vodka Chicken Parm Stracciatella** full tray ($130.00), underscores their commitment to preparing every dish with care and attention, ensuring your family gathering or corporate event will be memorable. For an authentic taste of New Jersey's rich Italian heritage in a distinct and friendly setting, Casano's Pizza Parlor is an outstanding choice.

Casano's Pizza Parlor

8 Highland Cross, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA