Mamma Mia Pizza

- 2337 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214

Welcome to Mamma Mia Pizza, a cherished local favorite bringing authentic Italian-American comfort food to the heart of Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. New Yorkers know that finding a reliable, quality neighborhood pizzeria is essential, and this establishment consistently delivers. More than just a pizza shop, Mamma Mia Pizza is a full-service Italian restaurant that has become a staple for quick, delicious bites, family dinners, and feeding a crowd with its extensive catering options. They are a classic example of the quintessential New York local eatery, offering everything from a simple, perfect slice of cheese pizza to gourmet specialty pies, and a wide array of classic Italian platters.

The philosophy here is simple: provide fresh, well-prepared food with quick and friendly service. Whether you’re stopping in for a fast lunch slice or placing a large order for a gathering, the focus remains on delivering a satisfying and enjoyable meal. As a local pizzeria, the restaurant excels at offering a warm, casual, and cozy atmosphere that feels immediately familiar—a perfect spot for solo dining, catching up with a group of friends, or a relaxed family meal. In a city brimming with dining options, Mamma Mia Pizza stands out by keeping things traditional and focusing on the dishes that people love and crave.

The menu is an ode to traditional New York-style Italian fare, featuring numerous specialties beyond their well-known pizzas. Diners can explore hearty pasta dishes, generously portioned parmigiana platters, and a collection of hot heroes that are perfect for a robust lunch. They cater to all ages with a thoughtful children’s menu, ensuring that even the pickiest young diners leave happy. From the very first bite of a freshly made garlic knot to the last forkful of a classic baked ziti, Mamma Mia Pizza delivers on the promise of satisfying comfort food. The combination of an extensive menu, convenient service options, and a commitment to quality makes it a valuable spot for Bensonhurst locals and anyone passing through the Brooklyn neighborhood.

Location and Accessibility

Mamma Mia Pizza is ideally situated at 2337 Bath Ave, in the Bensonhurst neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY 11214. This location places it right in a bustling community area, making it easily accessible for local residents and those working in the vicinity. For New Yorkers who rely on public transportation, the restaurant is conveniently located within reasonable distance of local bus routes and subway lines that service the Bensonhurst area.

For those traveling by car, street parking may be available in the area, though as with any part of Brooklyn, it's wise to plan accordingly. The restaurant has been noted for its accessibility features, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, which is an important amenity that ensures all customers can easily access the dining area.

Its positioning on Bath Avenue makes it a prime takeout and delivery hub. It serves as an excellent lunch or dinner option whether you are dining in, picking up your order, or having a hot meal delivered right to your door.

Services Offered

Mamma Mia Pizza prides itself on providing flexible and convenient service options to meet the busy schedules of Brooklyn residents. The restaurant functions as a modern pizzeria and a traditional Italian dining spot, offering a variety of ways for customers to enjoy their meal.

• Restaurant and Pizzeria: Offers seating for both lunch and dinner, with table service available for a more relaxed dining experience.
• Delivery and Takeout: The restaurant is fully equipped for delivery and takeout, providing a perfect option for a quick meal at home or in the office. This includes no-contact delivery and curbside pickup options for maximum convenience.
• Catering Services: Provides a robust catering menu ideal for parties, business lunches, and family gatherings. Catering options cover appetizers like Buffalo Wings and Fried Calamari, main courses such as Chicken Parmigiana and Lasagna, and large servings of salads.
• Online and Mobile Payments: Accepts a variety of modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy.
• Family-Friendly Dining: The dining environment is casual and good for groups, and they are noted for being good for kids, offering high chairs and a dedicated children’s menu.

Features / Highlights

Mamma Mia Pizza’s reputation in the Bensonhurst area is built on several key features that appeal to the local New York clientele. These highlights reflect their commitment to quality and classic Italian fare.

• Extensive Pizza Selection: The menu features a diverse range of pizzas, including the classic 16" and 18" Cheese Pies, Sicilian, White Pizza (Ricotta and Mozzarella), and gourmet options like the Grandma's Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Sofia Loren Pizza (Fresh Mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, garlic), and the fully loaded Everything Pizza.
• Classic Italian Heroes: They offer a large variety of hot heroes served on soft bread, with highly-rated choices like the Meatball Parm Hero, Chicken Parm Hero, Sausage & Pepper Hero, and the Philly Cheesesteak Wrap, which is also a popular wrap option.
• Full Italian Dinner Platters: Beyond pizza, the menu includes traditional, comforting main dishes like Pollo Parmigiana, Melanzane Parmigiana (Eggplant), Chicken Marsala, and various seafood dishes such as Shrimp Francese and Calamari Marinara, often served with a choice of pasta or a small salad.
• Hearty Pasta Dishes: Classic pasta offerings ensure a satisfying meal, including favorites such as Baked Ziti, Penne Alla Vodka, Tortellini Alfredo, and Lasagna.
• Popular Appetizers and Sides: Customers frequently praise the Garlic Knots and Fried Calamari, which are great for sharing or enjoying solo.
• Friendly Owner and Staff: Customers often note the friendly and helpful demeanor of the staff and the owner, creating a welcoming neighborhood feel.

Contact Information

For ordering, reservations, or general inquiries, you can reach Mamma Mia Pizza using the following information:

• Address: 2337 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA
• Phone: (718) 373-6356

What is Worth Choosing

For a first-time visitor or a long-time resident looking for a guaranteed satisfying meal at Mamma Mia Pizza, several items stand out as particularly noteworthy and exemplify the best of their Italian-American offerings. The sheer variety ensures there is something for every craving, from light salads to deeply rich comfort food.

When it comes to pizza, you cannot go wrong with their White Pizza (Large 18"). It's a standout choice featuring fresh mozzarella and ricotta cheese, garlic, and olive oil, often cited by customers as being well-prepared and exceptionally fresh. The Grandma's Pizza (Large 18") is also a must-try for those who enjoy a thinner, pan-baked crust with a vibrant tomato sauce made from peeled tomatoes, basil, and garlic. For specialty pizza lovers, the Philly Cheesesteak Pizza and the Buffalo Chicken Pizza offer savory, non-traditional options that are packed with flavor.

Beyond pizza, the hero menu is incredibly popular. The Chicken Parm Hero and the Meatball Parm Hero are classic, perfectly constructed sandwiches that showcase the quality of their main dishes. For a complete Italian dinner, the Pollo Parmigiana or Melanzane Parmigiana offer generous portions and rich, comforting flavor. The pasta selection offers crowd-pleasers like Baked Ziti and Penne Alla Vodka, which are perfect for a hearty meal. Finally, don't forget to add an order of their famous Garlic Knots—they are a quintessential pizzeria side dish and a local favorite, described as similar in taste to warm garlic bread.

The accessibility of their menu is one of the strongest features; whether you need to feed an entire family with their comprehensive catering service, which includes items like Chicken Parm Catering and Baked Ziti Catering, or you just want a satisfying individual plate like the Shrimp Francese or a fresh Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad, Mamma Mia Pizza has meticulously curated a menu to cover every need and occasion. It truly is an authentic, friendly, and comprehensive Italian restaurant experience for the Brooklyn community.

Mamma Mia Pizza

2337 Bath Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11214, USA