Mr. Phil's Pizza

- 7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228

In the landscape of Brooklyn pizza, a borough where competition is fierce and standards are exceptionally high, Mr. Phil's Pizza stands out as a consistently reliable pillar of classic Italian-American comfort food. Operating as both a traditional Pizza restaurant and a dedicated Delivery Restaurant, Mr. Phil’s ensures that quality, satisfying meals are always within reach of the local community. Located strategically on New Utrecht Avenue, this spot is a go-to for residents seeking dependability, as attested by frequent patrons who praise the pie as "a reliable pie every time. Consistent as it gets."

The menu transcends simple pizza, offering a truly comprehensive selection that positions Mr. Phil’s as a full Italian kitchen. From extensive baked pastas and specialized Italian entrees like Veal Marsala and Chicken Francese to a massive roster of Hot Heroes, the offerings are designed to satisfy every craving. The atmosphere is refreshingly Casual, welcoming Family-friendly crowds and Groups alike, making it an excellent destination for both a planned dinner and an impromptu Quick bite.

Popular throughout the week, Mr. Phil’s is a preferred choice for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining. The commitment to variety and service flexibility—including five different ways to get your food—is what keeps this establishment a staple in the demanding Brooklyn food scene. For those who value a spot that always delivers on its promise of classic, hearty Italian fare, Mr. Phil's Pizza is an established local champion.

Location and Accessibility

Mr. Phil's Pizza is centrally located at 7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA. The New Utrecht Avenue corridor provides easy access for patrons in the surrounding neighborhoods, making it a convenient stop for takeout and a prime location for quick delivery service.

Accessibility is a key consideration for this Brooklyn establishment, both physically and operationally. The premises include a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that all members of the community can access the restaurant with ease. Operationally, Mr. Phil’s is designed around customer convenience, offering an unparalleled range of service options:

• Traditional Dine-in seating for a relaxed meal.
• Standard Takeout service for fast pickup.
• Full Delivery service, cementing its dual role as a dedicated delivery restaurant.
• Modern Curbside pickup for maximum convenience.
• No-contact delivery, prioritizing safety and customer preference.

This multi-channel approach ensures that whether you’re passing by, hosting a party, or staying in, Mr. Phil's pizza and extensive Italian menu are always readily available. Furthermore, the inclusion of Dogs allowed outside is a thoughtful amenity for local pet owners who wish to enjoy their meal at the exterior seating area.

Services Offered

The service and menu at Mr. Phil's Pizza are defined by their immense breadth, covering nearly every aspect of Italian-American cuisine and catering needs:

• The Pizza Core: The foundational offering is the pizza, with options including classic Neapolitan Cheese Pizza (available in 14", 16", and 18", starting at $13.00), the thick-crusted Sicilian Neapolitan Cheese Pizza ($21.00), and specialty styles like the popular Old Fashioned Grandma Pizza ($22.00). The Specialty Pizza menu is vast, featuring unique pies such as the Buffalo Chicken Pizza and the signature Mr. Phil's Special Pizza (up to $27.00).
• Extensive Italian Entrees: The Italian Specialties section offers full plates including classics like Chicken Parmigiana ($16.50), Veal Parmigiana ($18.50), and Eggplant Rollatini ($16.95). The menu also features a full range of seafood dishes, such as Shrimp Scampi and Fried Calamari (starting at $16.75).
• Pasta and Baked Dishes: The menu boasts a comprehensive list of Pasta Dishes with various sauces (Marinara, Vodka, Clam, Bolognese), along with comforting Baked Dishes like Homemade Lasagna ($12.95), Baked Ziti ($11.95), and Stuffed Shells ($11.95).
• Hot and Cold Heroes: A significant part of the menu is dedicated to Hot Heroes, featuring nearly 20 different selections, from staples like the Chicken Parmigiana Hero ($10.50) and Philly Steak & Cheese Hero ($10.95) to unique options like the Sausage & Eggs Hero ($9.75). There is also a concise selection of classic Cold Heroes.
• Catering Service: A defining service is the comprehensive Catering menu, covering all categories: Appetizers Catering (e.g., Fried Calamari Catering - $87.00), Salads Catering, Baked Pasta Catering (e.g., Meat Lasagna Catering - $82.00), and Entrées Catering (e.g., Chicken Francese Catering - $82.00). This full-service approach makes Mr. Phil's the perfect choice for large group events in Brooklyn.

Features / Highlights

Mr. Phil's Pizza offers specific highlights that solidify its position as a reliable local eatery:

• Service Reliability: The most compelling highlight, as cited by consistent patrons, is the Consistency of the food. It is recognized as a spot that is reliable "time and time again" for a good, standard pizza pie, which is invaluable in the highly competitive NYC market.
• Family and Group Focus: The restaurant is highly suited for group dining, listed under Crowd for both Family-friendly and Groups. The menu supports this focus with Family Calzone options ($15.95) and dedicated Specials (2 Family Special - $29.95).
• Amenities: For dine-in comfort, the restaurant provides a clean Restroom. The atmosphere is perfectly Casual, ensuring a low-key, comfortable setting for every meal.
• Payment Technology: The acceptance of modern NFC mobile payments alongside Debit cards provides customers with rapid and flexible transaction options, speeding up both takeout and delivery processes.
• Offerings and Cuisine: The extensive menu is defined by Comfort food and generous portions, offering everything from Small plates (Appetizers like Garlic Knots) to a selection of Wine for pairing with dinner entrees.

Contact Information

For all orders, including large catering requests or simple takeout, please use the following contact information.

Address: 7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA

Phone: (718) 234-4106

Mobile Phone: +1 718-234-4106

What is worth choosing

Choosing Mr. Phil's Pizza is choosing the ultimate in Italian-American convenience and reliable quality in Brooklyn. What sets this establishment apart is its incredible scope of service: it is not just a pizza shop, but a full-scale Italian eatery with dedicated Catering that can handle large events, from corporate gatherings to family celebrations. The menu depth, spanning from classic Neapolitan pies to a wide array of Veal and Chicken specialties, ensures that every member of a group will find a satisfying option.

The highest praise from the community points to its Consistency; Mr. Phil’s is recognized as a reliable performer, a key factor in a neighborhood with many hit-or-miss options. While acknowledging the isolated service issue noted by one customer, the majority experience emphasizes dependable quality. This reliability, combined with five convenient ways to get your food (including Curbside pickup and No-contact delivery), easy NFC mobile payments, and a Family-friendly atmosphere, makes Mr. Phil's Pizza a high-value, low-stress option for authentic, comforting Italian food on New Utrecht Avenue. For a reliable pie and a vast menu of Comfort food, look no further.

Mr. Phil's Pizza

7212 New Utrecht Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228, USA