Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

- Staten Island, NY 10306

For New York residents with a craving for authentic, well-crafted Italian cuisine, Rustic Pizza & Pasteria stands out as a true culinary destination right in the heart of Staten Island. This local restaurant goes beyond the typical pizzeria experience, offering a comprehensive menu of flavorful pizzas, rich pasta dishes, and traditional Italian specialties that capture the comforting, rustic essence of Italian cooking. The establishment prides itself on bringing the genuine taste of Italy right to the local community, making it a beloved spot for both a quick slice and a full, satisfying dinner.

The core of Rustic Pizza & Pasteria’s appeal lies in its dedication to quality and variety. The menu is expansive, designed to delight every palate with offerings ranging from classic Italian staples to innovative specialty items. Whether you are looking for a casual weeknight dinner, a satisfying takeout option, or a catered meal for a gathering, this restaurant provides a consistent and high-quality dining experience. Its reputation for providing generous portions and using quality ingredients has made it a regular fixture in the dining rotation for many Staten Island locals, with reviewers often praising the fresh flavors and diverse menu.

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is strategically located in Staten Island, NY 10306, with one prominent address being 1789 Richmond Rd, which is a key commercial corridor. Another address is also mentioned at 97 Lincoln Ave, Staten Island, NY 10306. These locations ensure a broad reach across the borough, making it highly accessible for residents. For New Yorkers who depend on driving, the accessibility of this establishment is significantly enhanced by the provision of on-site parking. This amenity, which can be a rarity in the city, alleviates the typical stress of finding a spot, making a quick pick-up or a leisurely dine-in experience much more convenient. While public transit options may vary, the on-site parking makes it a prime location for those driving from surrounding neighborhoods.

The dual presence of addresses suggests a commitment to serving a wider community in the Staten Island area. The consistent service and quality across its operations are what maintain its standing as a go-to Italian eatery. Knowing that a dependable spot for excellent Italian food, including high-quality pizza and hearty entrees, is easily reachable and offers convenient parking is a major advantage for local users in the New York region.

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is a full-service restaurant that offers multiple ways for New Yorkers to enjoy its authentic Italian fare:

• Ordering Options: The restaurant facilitates all modern ordering preferences, including prompt Delivery services to surrounding areas and convenient Takeout for those who wish to pick up their meal. Online ordering is available for both options.
• Meal Times: They cater to lunch and dinner crowds with extended hours, typically opening mid-day and staying open late on weekends. They also offer dedicated Lunch Specials available during the weekday afternoons, providing great value.
• Menu Breadth: The cuisine focus is robust, featuring Italian and Pizza, but with a wide array of choices including Heroes & Wraps, Baked Pasta, Entrees (like Chicken, Veal, and Seafood dishes), and various Salads.
• Dietary Accommodation: The menu explicitly includes Vegetarian Options and Vegan Options, demonstrating a welcoming approach to various dietary needs and making it easier for diverse groups of friends or family to dine together.
• Special Features: Beyond daily dining, the restaurant offers Catering services, making it an excellent choice for private parties, office lunches, or family events that require authentic Italian food. They also feature a bar area with Happy Hour Specials on weekdays for a relaxed after-work experience.

The commitment to quality ingredients and diverse preparations is what highlights Rustic Pizza & Pasteria among local Italian options:

• Signature Pizzas: They are famous for their specialty pies, offered in multiple styles including Personal Pan, Classic Pan, Small, Large, Grandma Square, and Sicilian Square. Must-try innovative options include the Lobster & Shrimp pizza with lobster bisque sauce, the White Clam pizza with smoked bacon, and the Fig & Prosciutto pie with balsamic reduction.
• Authentic Pasteria Dishes: True to their name, the pasteria selections are exceptional. They offer imported pastas and artisan specialties, such as the Seasonal Agnolotti with roasted pumpkin and creamy pesto sauce. Classic entrees like Sausage & Peppers, Chicken Marsala, and Veal Francaise are served with a choice of pasta, house salad, or vegetable.
• Quality of Bread: Customer reviews specifically highlight the excellent quality of the bread used for their heroes, such as the Meatball Parmigiana Hero, which is described as crunchy and flavorful, a small but important detail that elevates the experience.
• Daily and Family Specials: The restaurant frequently offers value-driven specials, such as the Family Dinner Monday-Thursday Special, which bundles chicken entrees, pasta, a cheese pie, wings, and soda—perfect for local New York families looking for a convenient and complete meal deal.
• Freshness Guarantee: Repeated customer feedback notes the food is “always fresh” and “delicious,” indicating a reliable standard of preparation and ingredients across the board.

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria is worth choosing because it perfectly balances authentic Italian flavor with the convenience and variety demanded by the New York lifestyle. For those in Staten Island, it is a one-stop shop for everything from a high-quality slice of their signature five-cheese Rustic Pizza to a sophisticated entree like Filet of Sole or a hearty hero. The dedication to making everything from the sauces to the bread in-house speaks to a level of quality and care that is rare. Furthermore, the provision of on-site parking and a menu that accommodates both casual bites and full, multi-course meals—including vegetarian and vegan options—ensures that every local user will find a reason to make this Italian gem their new go-to. It is a genuine, reliable, and delicious part of the Staten Island food scene.

Contact Information

Address: 1789 Richmond Rd, Staten Island, NY 10306 (Primary Location)

Phone: (212) 425-2623 (Hotline listed for multiple locations and ordering)

Rustic Pizza & Pasteria

Staten Island, NY 10306, USA