The Good Witch Coffee Bar

- 134 Southside Ave, Hastings-On-Hudson, NY 10706

Introduction / Overview

For New Yorkers in the Westchester area and beyond, The Good Witch Coffee Bar in Hastings-On-Hudson is much more than a place to grab a caffeine fix—it is a community hub, a celebration of empowerment, and a destination for truly exceptional food and drink. Founded and operated by Hastings-On-Hudson resident, former food writer, and recipe developer Joanna Prisco, this café is proudly identified as women-owned and dedicated to fostering a supportive, inclusive, and family-friendly environment.

The name itself is a nod to The Wizard of Oz, lending a touch of whimsy and charm that is reflected in the "cozy," "casual," and "trendy" atmosphere. This is a place where every detail is considered, from the "superlative coffee" to the indulgent baked goods made in small batches every morning using organic flours and sugars. The menu brilliantly balances familiar comfort with inventive flavor, featuring unique items like the "Scallion-Cheddar Scone," "Seasonal Muffin" varieties (including turmeric blueberry and ube cheddar), and a spicy California-style "Egg Something Something."

Patrons consistently rave about the quality, noting the staff is "super friendly and nice" and the drinks are "fantastic" and "very rich in flavor." The atmosphere is welcoming to all, identifying as "Family-friendly," "LGBTQ+ friendly," and a "Transgender safespace," ensuring everyone feels welcome. The Good Witch is truly a modern café that serves as a community gathering point, frequently hosting "Live music," workshops led by local makers, and other events, transforming a daily routine into an experience. Whether you’re stopping for a quick morning "Cortado" or settling in for a satisfying lunch, The Good Witch is Hastings-On-Hudson's charming gem.

Location and Accessibility

The Good Witch Coffee Bar boasts an incredibly strategic and convenient location at 134 Southside Ave, Hastings-On-Hudson, NY 10706, USA. Its prime positioning is directly above the Hastings-on-Hudson platform on the Metro-North Railroad's Hudson line. This makes it a perfect, essential stop for New York commuters heading to or from Grand Central Terminal, offering them the chance to enjoy a gourmet beverage and breakfast without straying far from the platform.

Beyond its convenience for commuters, the cafe is highly accessible for all local patrons, reflecting its commitment to inclusivity. The premises feature comprehensive accessibility amenities, including a "Wheelchair accessible entrance," "Wheelchair accessible parking lot," "Wheelchair accessible restroom," and "Wheelchair accessible seating." This ensures that the warm and inviting atmosphere can be enjoyed by everyone in the community.

Parking is also readily available for those driving in from other parts of Westchester or the broader New York region, with options that include a "Free parking lot," "Free street parking," a nearby "Paid parking lot," and "Paid street parking." This variety of transport and parking solutions solidifies The Good Witch’s standing as an easy-to-reach destination café.

Services Offered

• Gourmet Coffee and Tea Service: Offers an extensive beverage menu, specializing in "Great coffee" using high-quality roasts for espresso drinks like the "Cortado," lattes, and cold brew, alongside a "Great tea selection" and unique seasonal options like "Orange Hot Chocolate."

• House-Made Baked Goods and Desserts: A bakery focus with small-batch goods baked in-house every morning, featuring signature items like the "Split Scone" with cherry jam, the popular savory "Scallion-Cheddar Scone," "Seasonal Muffins," and phenomenal desserts, including a highly-praised "carrot cake."

• Breakfast and Lunch Fare: Provides a full menu of "Breakfast" and "Lunch" items, catering to all-day dining. Savory options include "inventive savory fare" like the "Egg Something Something" and the Friday-exclusive "Brie Sandwich" on housemade Focaccia, as well as a selection of organic and vegetarian options.

• Community and Entertainment: Serves as a host for the community, providing a platform for "Live music" and "Live performances," with performances often taking place from 10 a.m. to 12 noon on select days, covering various musical styles.

• Flexible Dining Options: Customers can choose from "Takeout" for a "Quick bite," "Dine-in" with ample "Seating," or "Outdoor seating" with "abundant outdoor seating" available, perfect for enjoying the nice weather.

• Alcohol Service and Happy Hour: Offers a selection of "Alcohol," "Beer," and "Wine," with dedicated "Happy hour drinks" and "Happy hour food" options for an enjoyable afternoon or evening experience.

Features / Highlights

• Women-Owned and Community-Focused: A key feature is its identity as a women-owned and operated establishment, founded by a respected food writer with a strong focus on community building, hosting workshops, and empowering women in the local area.

• Prime Commuter Location: Strategically located directly above the Hastings-on-Hudson Metro-North station platform, providing unparalleled convenience for New York commuters seeking gourmet coffee and quick breakfast options.

• Exceptional House-Made Baked Goods: Celebrated for its indulgent, high-quality, and often organic baked goods, including the signature scallion-cheddar scone and unique seasonal muffins, setting it apart from standard coffee shop fare.

• Inclusive and Welcoming Atmosphere: Offers an intentionally "Family-friendly" and "LGBTQ+ friendly" space, complete with a "Gender-neutral restroom," "High chairs," and a "Cozy" atmosphere, ensuring a positive experience for all patrons.

• Versatile Space for Work and Leisure: The café is popular for "Solo dining" and "Good for working on laptop" due to its available "Wi-Fi" and blend of seating options, while also serving as a perfect location for social gatherings with a "Bar onsite."

Contact Information

Address: 134 Southside Ave, Hastings-On-Hudson, NY 10706, USA

Phone: (914) 920-4077

Mobile Phone: +1 914-920-4077

What is worth choosing

The Good Witch Coffee Bar is the optimal choice for New Yorkers who demand superior quality in their coffee and food but also value community and a welcoming, inclusive environment. It’s an ideal blend of New York speed and neighborhood charm.

What makes it uniquely worth choosing is its dual focus: gourmet excellence and social consciousness. You can rely on "Fast service" and "Great coffee" right by the train for an efficient morning ritual, but you're also supporting a women-owned business that actively champions community spirit and offers a safe, modern space for all individuals. The "superlative coffee" and incredibly popular, house-made baked goods—like the savory scones and delicious empanadas praised by customers—guarantee a satisfying gastronomic experience that surpasses typical cafe offerings.

This café is particularly valuable for remote workers, creative professionals, and families, as it provides a comfortable, well-equipped space with Wi-Fi and amenities, contrasting with the often hectic environment of Manhattan cafes. Finally, the added dimension of "Live music" and a full-service bar with "Happy hour drinks" transforms it from a simple coffee shop into a lively, all-day social destination, making The Good Witch Coffee Bar a truly enriching and highly recommended local choice in the New York region.

The Good Witch Coffee Bar

134 Southside Ave, Hastings-On-Hudson, NY 10706, USA