Mr. Bagels Cafe

- 9419 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209

For New Yorkers, the bagel is not just a food item; it’s an institution. And when a local spot manages to master the core art of the bagel while also providing a complete, all-day menu of breakfast and lunch favorites, it earns a special place in the community. Mr. Bagels Cafe, situated in the bustling Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn, has established itself as that essential neighborhood destination. More than a simple bakery, this cafe functions as a dynamic, full-service eatery catering to every meal, from the earliest morning rush to a late afternoon craving.

Mr. Bagels Cafe offers a truly comprehensive dining experience centered around fresh, quality ingredients and New York deli staples. While their name naturally highlights the foundation of their business—the bagel—their extensive menu extends far beyond, covering breakfast platters, omelets, French toast, specialty wraps, signature sandwiches, and satisfying burgers. This incredible variety ensures that whether you’re looking for a classic

Cream Cheese & Fresh Lox

Philly Cheesesteak

The bakery component of the cafe is where its soul resides. They provide daily-baked goods that serve as the foundation for countless customized meals. From the simple perfection of a

Buttered Bagel

Cream Cheese & Bacon

The environment is designed for speed and convenience, fitting seamlessly into the daily rhythm of life in Bay Ridge. It’s a place where locals can pop in for a quick visit, grab their order for takeout, utilize their in-store pickup service, or even sit down for a casual meal. The sheer volume of menu options means it’s an excellent choice for individuals, families, and offices looking for variety without compromising on the substantial portions and fresh preparation that New Yorkers expect.

Mr. Bagels Cafe understands the diverse dietary needs of its Brooklyn clientele, offering options like

Tofu Cream Cheese

Fat Free Cream Cheese

Location and Accessibility

Mr. Bagels Cafe is conveniently located at 9419 3rd Ave, in the heart of the Bay Ridge neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY 11209. Third Avenue is a major commercial street in the area, ensuring high visibility and easy access for local residents.

Accessibility is a strong point for the cafe. It is a highly practical spot for New Yorkers on the go, offering multiple service options including

Delivery

In-store pickup

Takeout

Dine-in

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Free street parking

Paid street parking

Quick visit

Services Offered

• Full-Service Breakfast: Serving a vast array of breakfast options including multiple Omelets (Western, Veggie, Italian, Greek), Pancakes (Classic, Strawberry Banana), and French Toast.
• Specialty Bagel & Spread Bar: Offering a wide selection of bagels and various spreads, from classic Cream Cheese and

  Lox Spread

  to healthier options like

  Tofu Cream Cheese

  and

  Fat Free Cream Cheese

  , as well as

  Avocado Bagel Toast

  .
• Extensive Sandwich Menu: Featuring

  Breakfast Sandwiches

  (Bacon, Egg and Cheese; Turkey-Bacon, Egg and Cheese; Pastrami Eggs & Cheese) and

  Classic Bagel Sandwiches

  (Nova Lox Cream Cheese; Tuna Salad; Whitefish Salad).
• Gourmet Lunch Options: A substantial selection of hot and cold options including

  Signature Sandwiches

  (The Couple, Amazing Turkey, Cuban), Combo Burger Specials (Angus Beef Burger, Reuben, Philly Cheesesteak), and Cold Salads (Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad, Chef’s Salad).
• Customized Wraps: Offering diverse options with both breakfast and lunch menus, such as the

  Power Protein Wrap

  ,

  Healthy Morning Wrap

  ,

  Chicken Chipotle Wrap

  , and

  Grilled Vegetables And Pesto Assorted Wrap

  .
• Assorted Baked Goods: Providing various non-bagel bakery items like

  Muffins

  ,

  Croissants

  ,

  Turnovers

  , and

  Pound Cakes

  .
• Beverages: Serving

  Coffee

  and other beverages to complement the expansive food menu.
• Dining and Accessibility: Accepting

  Credit cards

  and

  Debit cards

  , and offering multiple service options: Delivery, Takeout, In-store pickup, and Dine-in with a Wheelchair accessible entrance.

Features / Highlights

• The Comprehensive Menu: The most distinctive feature is the vast and versatile menu, offering breakfast staples, deli classics, and full lunch combos, making it a reliable choice for any appetite or time of day.
• The New York Bagel Experience: The foundation of the business, focusing on providing a wide range of bagels with numerous specialty cream cheese and spread options, including lox and various salad fillings.
• Hearty and Healthy Breakfast Wraps: Specialized breakfast wraps like the

  Power Protein Wrap

  (Egg-whites, Turkey breast, Avocado, Cheddar) and the

  Healthy Morning Wrap

  cater to health-conscious commuters looking for a quick, filling, and nutritious start to their day.
• Signature Sandwich Creativity: The menu features unique, substantial sandwiches such as

  The Couple

  (Corned beef, Pastrami, Swiss, Sauerkraut) and

  Texas Chicken

  (Chicken cutlet, Cheddar cheese, Bacon, Ranch dressing), showcasing gourmet deli preparation.
• Quality Bread Preparation: The care and preparation of the baked goods, noted by a customer's review of a perfectly toasted roll that was crispy, well-buttered, and wrapped with attention, suggests a high level of consistency in their core offerings.
• Flexibility for Dietary Needs: Offering alternatives like

  Egg-Whites And Veggie

  sandwiches, Tofu Cream Cheese, and Fat Free Cream Cheese, providing flexibility for different diets.

Contact Information

Address: 9419 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Phone: (718) 836-3000

What is Worth Choosing

For New Yorkers seeking a reliable and varied local spot in Bay Ridge, Mr. Bagels Cafe presents a menu so extensive that a customer is guaranteed to find exactly what they’re craving. When choosing from this Brooklyn institution, there are several key items that embody the cafe’s best qualities.

Start with the heart of the business: the

Bagels & Spreads

Cream Cheese & Fresh Lox

Avocado Bagel Toast

Tofu Cream Cheese Bagel

If you are looking for a satisfying, morning meal with substance, the variety of breakfast items is second to none. The

Breakfast Sandwiches

Bacon, Egg And Cheese

Pastrami Eggs & Cheese

Power Protein Wrap

Build Your Own Omelet

For lunch, the cafe truly transitions into a full-fledged deli. We highly recommend diving into the

Signature Sandwiches

Amazing Turkey

Chicken Chipotle

Reuben

Philly Cheesesteak

In short, what is truly worth choosing at Mr. Bagels Cafe is the ability to select a fresh, generously portioned, and varied meal, expertly prepared to satisfy any local craving, at virtually any time of day. It’s the ultimate one-stop spot for the quintessential Brooklyn breakfast and lunch experience.

Mr. Bagels Cafe

9419 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA