Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant

- 911 Erskine St, Brooklyn, NY 11239

Introduction / Overview: Your Escape to Authentic Caribbean Flavors in Brooklyn, NY

For residents of New York seeking a genuine taste of the islands right here in the city, look no further than Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant. Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, this establishment is celebrated as a local treasure, providing a friendly, cozy, and trendy atmosphere where patrons can enjoy authentic Caribbean cuisine. Sally's is not just a place to eat; it's a culinary escape offering a vast and diverse menu that caters to every craving, from classic Jamaican comfort food to impressive seafood specialties. The restaurant proudly holds a reputation for delivering fantastic food consistently—a place where the flavors are always on point and the presentation is as stunning as the decor. Whether you're craving the tenderness of Oxtail, the smoky heat of Jerk Chicken, or a refreshing homemade juice, Sally's is a must-visit dining destination in the New York region.

The core ethos of Sally's is rooted in generous portions, deeply flavored recipes, and service with a personal touch. Long-time customers and first-time visitors alike often praise the warm, attentive staff and management, like “Ms. Karen,” who ensure every guest feels welcomed and well-tended to. This focus on customer experience, coupled with a menu that ranges from hearty breakfasts to spectacular dinner features, establishes Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant as a cornerstone of the Brooklyn food scene. It’s an ideal spot for a quick bite during a solo outing, a relaxed family dinner, or a lively group gathering, living up to its billing as the "best Jamaican restaurant" by its loyal clientele.

Location and Accessibility: Found in East New York’s Convenient Spot

Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant is conveniently located at 911 Erskine St, Brooklyn, NY 11239, USA. Situated in the East New York area, the restaurant is easily accessible for local patrons and those commuting from other parts of New York City. For those driving, the availability of a dedicated, free parking lot significantly enhances convenience, a notable benefit in the often-challenging parking landscape of Brooklyn. This makes it simple to stop by for a takeout order or to settle in for a relaxed dine-in experience without the typical city parking hassle.

In terms of physical access, Sally's is committed to accommodating all guests. The venue boasts excellent accessibility features, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible seating, and a wheelchair accessible restroom. This commitment ensures that a wide range of customers can comfortably enjoy the welcoming atmosphere and delicious offerings. Whether you're utilizing curbside pickup or planning an extended meal, the location is set up for ease of arrival and comfort for all.

Services Offered

Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant is dedicated to offering a complete and flexible dining experience, catering to various preferences and occasions. The comprehensive range of services includes:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the cozy, casual, and trendy atmosphere with full table service.
• Takeout: Perfect for guests on the go who wish to enjoy their authentic Caribbean meal at home or elsewhere.
• Delivery: Conveniently have your favorite dishes brought right to your door.
• No-Contact Delivery: An option for maximum safety and convenience.
• Curbside Pickup: A hassle-free method to collect your order without leaving your vehicle.
• Full-Service Bar: Offering a wide range of beverages including Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, Wine, and imaginative rum punches, as noted by happy customers.
• Catering: While not explicitly listed, the capacity to serve large groups suggests potential for accommodating event dining needs.

Features / Highlights

The unique blend of offerings and environment at Sally’s sets it apart. Key features and highlights for New York locals include:

• Extensive Menu Variety: Covering all dining times with traditional Caribbean and American fare, including Roti, Main Courses (Chicken, Red Meat, Seafood), Breakfast (Caribbean & American), Pasta, Burgers, Salads, Soups, and Desserts.
• Signature Dishes & Specialties: Renowned for dishes such as “Sally’s Famous Oxtail,” “Curry Goat,” “Jerk Chicken,” and a wide selection of impressive seafood like Escovitch Snapper, Steamed Red Snapper, and various Lobster and Crab Legs preparations (Jerk, Curry, Garlic Butter).
• Homemade Beverages: A refreshing selection of authentic Caribbean homemade juices, including Soursop, Passion Fruit, Sorrel, Pineapple Guava, Seamoss, and Ginger Beer.
• Dining Options for All Day: Serving Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert, accommodating various daily routines.
• Atmosphere and Crowd: Providing a Casual, Cozy, and Trendy environment that is popular among Family-friendly groups, large Groups, and Tourists.
• Speed and Service: Highlighted for its Fast service and praised for friendly, attentive staff and personal touches from management.
• Comfort and Convenience: Amenities include an Bar onsite, Restroom, and convenient Free parking lot.
• Dietary Inclusivity: Menu includes Healthy options, Comfort food, and items suitable for a Quick bite or Small plates.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts modern payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Family-Friendly: Considered Good for kids and offers High chairs for the youngest diners.

Contact Information

For inquiries, reservations, or placing an order, Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant can be reached at the following contact points:

Address: 911 Erskine St, Brooklyn, NY 11239, USA

Phone: (718) 210-2526 (Also listed as +1 718-210-2526)

What is Worth Choosing at Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant

Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant stands out in the highly competitive New York dining scene as a truly authentic and high-quality purveyor of Caribbean cuisine. The restaurant’s comprehensive menu, which masterfully blends traditional island cooking with broader American favorites, ensures there is something for everyone. For the authentic Caribbean food lover in NYC, the Oxtail (often cited as the #1 most liked dish) and the various Roti options—especially the Curry Goat Roti or the Oxtail Roti—are essential choices that showcase deep, traditional flavors. The Curry Chicken and Jerk Chicken are celebrated classics, offering the smoky, spiced, and rich tastes that are the foundation of Jamaican cuisine.

Beyond the classic meat dishes, the seafood selection is expansive and highlights the versatility of Caribbean cooking. Patrons can indulge in everything from a perfectly executed Escovitch Snapper to luxurious preparations like Jerk Crab Legs, Curry Lobster, and Honey Glazed Salmon. This seafood range makes Sally’s an excellent choice for a special occasion or when you're simply craving high-quality, perfectly seasoned fish and shellfish.

The atmosphere is a significant draw, described as an inviting blend of casual comfort and modern trendiness. This environment, combined with the personal, genuinely friendly service, creates a welcoming space—a rarity in a large metropolitan area. The fact that the restaurant is highly “Popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining” speaks to its broad appeal and reliability. Furthermore, the inclusion of a full bar with cocktails (including the highly-praised rum punches) and wine allows for a complete dining and social experience.

In a city full of options, Sally’s commitment to excellent food, fast service, a friendly vibe, and accommodating features (like the free parking lot and full accessibility) makes it an exceptionally worthwhile choice for any New Yorker looking for an authentic, delicious, and deeply satisfying Caribbean meal in Brooklyn.

Sally’s Caribbean Restaurant

911 Erskine St, Brooklyn, NY 11239, USA